Its reality - take the emotion out of it.
Geoff Whaling
Dale,
I have nothing but respect and admiration for the courage of individuals who share their injury experiences. I respect the rights of others to express their views – so we can all learn from the event and from others who contribute. I also feel deeply the sympathy and empathy for those who suffer an injury and for their families and friends. I, and I guess you too, certainly would not participate in these discussions if we didn’t.
We must face reality - most if not all injuries at the lathe are preventable or the probability of them occurring, and the severity of outcomes can be significantly reduced with some quite easily implemented controls, if we have the knowledge.
Accident research highlights the facts - lathes are the most likely machine in the shop to cause the death of a wood worker! Lathe deaths are relatively rare but are in my belief increasing for various (suspected) reasons. Hand, eye, facial and head injuries are relatively common to turners. Grinders, power carvers, chainsaws, bandsaws, table saws, jointers etc maim but rarely cause deaths. Lathe deaths occur because the injury that causes the death of a wood turner is mostly a severe head injury and is usually associated with a turner working alone, with no means of getting assistance or the injury rendering the turner incapable of raising the alarm. Lathes also maim through entanglement, severing fingers, significant facial and eye injuries etc. Alarmist ? NO! Reality yes – all of us can reduce the risk of becoming another statistic – a statistic that is a person, one who has family and friends who are also deeply affected by any significant injury.
Emotion, experience, knowledge and all sorts of human behaviours cloud our judgement when it comes to turning and all things in life. Objective hazards (speed, blank quality, tenon size etc) can be controlled but overcoming and controlling (in a hazard reduction sense) personal behaviours, known as subjective hazards, can be quite difficult. How do we encourage and promote controls to manage risk associated with the subjective hazards – inexperience, the “challenge”, the “I like working on the edge”, the “I know what I’m doing attitude”, pride, peer group pressures, the desire to turn blanks that we know are questionable, or to continue to follow turning practices that we know or a well known to be high risk?
We can have emotion work both for and against us, but do not continue to let emotions cloud our examination of the circumstances which contributed to this or other such events or how to assess hazards and risk or implementing hazard controls. We must set aside emotion and examine these events in an empirical manner to assess what actually caused the high mass, high speed object to become detached from the lathe and to strike the turner in the head. We can learn a considerable amount from these events and from the very positive actions that most likely saved this gentleman’s life.
He was wearing PPE – The Trend Pro – which most certainly mitigated the severity and extent of the injury.
He was able to contact help – a very very good positive.
Emergency assistance was available.
Most likely other actions that he undertook also helped reduce the severity of the injury.
Knowing other factors, such as blank mounting, lathe speed, tool selection, environment, fatigue level etc would permit a better appreciation of the whole scenario – however it is rare that they are readily available for severe injuries.
Now ask one very big question – what if the turner had been knocked unconscious? How would that scenario have played out? The margin between survivability with no long term physical disability, a severe brain injury, and death from severe head injuries is very dependent upon circumstance. The individual turner sets the scenario up – how much risk are they willing to accept, what controls do they have in place, what back up plans do they have, all play out in the outcome.
I’m not trying to be an alarmist, just a realist and I have no intent to hurt an individuals emotions. We must divorce emotion from the pragmatics of injury prevention. Turning is and can be a very safe pastime but we must treat turning as an art, craft and a trade that requires skill, knowledge and respect to remain a safe pursuit.