Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

in defense of Trend line helmut

Posts

in defense of Trend line helmut

#1

in defense of Trend line helmut

John Lucas

No one has mentioned that it appears as if the small end of the piece hit his helmut. Not like a larger chuck that hits you like a baseball bat, this one appears to have hit like a spear. How many helmuts or face shields on the market would handle that sort of high speed impact. I'm not sure many would have. I think things would have been drastically different if the wood hit more sideways.

Still think speed and bad wood was the culprit but just wanted to bring out the fact that angle of impact was a major factor here and nothing short of lexan face shield and hard had rated helmut would have stopped that. In fact even a catchers mask would not have stopped it if there wasn't a clear shield in between the grids.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#2

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

Geoff Whaling

According to Trends literature both the Original & The Pro are rated as

Eye protection ANSI Z87.1 (low energy impact)

Respiratory protection (for reference only) NPF50 to BS EN 12941 THP2.

Not NIOSH approved.

I believe the Trend performed well in the circumstances and above its low energy impact rating - it is primarily a respiratory protection device and is nor designed or intended for medium / high energy inpact protection.

Turners should really read what "medium" means -

"You always have to remember, these are minimum standards that provide a level of protection. Is it the optimum level of protection for every type of hazard? Absolutely not. The people that use this or the people that recommend this type of protector in their PPE assessment need to have cognizance that the hazard in every task is not going to be met by every protector." - Dan Torgersen, chairman of the Z87 Committee on Eye and Face Protection http://ohsonline.com/articles/2010/06/01/z87.1-2010-takes-a-new-approach.aspx

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#3

Steven Antonucci

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

steven antonucci

(pasted this here from another reply below)

...

"even a catcher's mask" wouldn't work...and he's right because it was designed to stop a baseball, not a flying piece of wood. Think about the number of times that you've seen someone take a foul ball off of their catcher's mask and you know that it WORKS PERFECTLY for the activity it was designed for. I've never heard of someone being killed where a catcher's mask failed, and that is out of a much larger pool of people than woodturners.

Rather than repurposing a riot helmet next, or an arborist chain sawing helmet, football helmet, hockey helmet....why doesn't someone assemble a woodturner's helmet? Purpose built for someone standing at the lathe.

And the argument that "some protection is better than no protection" needs to die. The wrong protection is basically the exact same thing as no protection, only it comes with a false sense of security that impairs judgment. I've had people chastise me for not flipping down my $6 visor because I wasn't "safe" while they stood in the line of fire on the other side of the lathe.

If we could get people to stop parroting rhetoric, maybe something would get done?

Steve

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#4

So what are you proposing?

Dale Bonertz

I get the false sense of security thing. Yes stand out of the line of fire and turn at slower speeds but even that is a false sense of security, to some extent, since there is no guarantee a piece will follow the imaginary line of fire. Yes, some protection is better than none. Can you really say stand out of the line of fire and you are OK to not wear a face shield, talk about a false sense of security. It appears to me , even though not rated for it, that Adrien's Trend performed better than expected. Easy to say since I don't know what the outcome would have been if he was not wearing it. My guess is he would not be here to bravely share his story.

My mentor taught me two most important and appreciated things. How to turn left handed so I can be out of the higher danger zone when roughing any piece. He also said to me if you don't where a face mask you won't turn in his shop. So I learned how to wear one and be comfortable. When I learned of the Bionic I purchased one. We can only purchase the equipment, to help protect ourselves, with what is available today, please don't minimize it. Since we cannot foresee every potential circumstance at the lathe, learning to turn safely is most important but also important is a good face shield.

I really believe we are on the same mission about safety and its importance. Turn sound wood, stand out of the line of fire and turn at slower speeds will help a lot. In addition where safety gear (face shield) as a secondary line of defense.

Can I get an amen. :) :)

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: So what are you proposing?

Alan Zenreich

Dale, amen.

It's the 'I just stand out of the line of fire, choose good wood, and keep my speed down' that gives the false sense of security.

What's the saying? Oh yes, "shit happens"

I know I am in the minority, but I also actively protect my lungs while in the shop. Dust collectors and/or air filters are on whenever I am cutting any wood on any machine, and I wear a PAPR (3m BreatheEasy or Airstream) any time I am turning. I don't want any of the nasties, seen or unseen getting in my nose, lungs or eyes.

It's not just the stuff that will kill you in a second... It's also the stuff that will shorten your life, and make you miserable while doing it.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#6

NOT a helmut (nor helmet)!

mjonesrdg

I cannot find anywhere in Trend Airshield literature or catalog information where the unit is called a helmet. I cannot find any place in that lit. or cat. information that even suggests that it protects the head from impacts, and only a loose interpretation of the standards for ANSI z87.1 would cause one to think that the "headgear" part of the apparatus is even tested.

It is not called a helmet because it does not provide protection for the head.

I think that the same could be said for the "Bionic" and any number of other face shield/headgear units sold (to woodturners) today.

If you buy a face shield to protect your head from flying chunks of wood it should be rated far in excess of the ANSI z87.1 (resists a bb at bb gun velosity).

You, and I, are responsible for our own safety, for gathering useful safety information, and for using due diligence shopping for safety equipment. The efforts we make could be greatly enhanced by an organization (such as the AAW) if such an organization really gave a rats ass about it.

Mike Jones in Redding, Ca.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#7

and, "Amen" to this from Steve A

mjonesrdg

"Rather than repurposing a riot helmet next, or an arborist chain sawing helmet, football helmet, hockey helmet....why doesn't someone assemble a woodturner's helmet? Purpose built for someone standing at the lathe."

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#8

Steven Antonucci

I am proposing change

steven antonucci

There are so many things that are contributory to these types of accidents, it's just a matter of time before the next one happens. I am proposing that EVERYONE, AAW members or not, adopt a culture of changing behavior to reduce risk. Can we eliminate every accident? Absolutely not. Can we avoid most of them altogether? I think so.

Here is a starting point for the discussion:

1.) If AAW is serious about "mandating safety" at AAW events, enforce it. If someone signs a contract that mandates "protection" and then willfully violates that contract, don't pay them. It is breach of contract, and would be supported in any court of law.

2.) If AAW is serious about "protection", it should supply the proper safety equipment to be used at every sanctioned event. You see everything from nothing up to nuisance dust systems being touted as "protection". I realize that they don't want the liability, but the truth of the matter is that they have it anyway. If someone gets hurt at their event, do you think that a court will actually care if the turner did or didn't have a shield on? Or that they turner at 3000 rpm with a marginally protected audience in front of them?

3.) There is an endemic problem that I hear at these events ALL of the time. Two guys will be walking from a session talking about the "class" they just took after sitting in on a demo. A demo is not a class. there are things that I would show and very clearly point out that I am showing, but not teaching. When I teach, I need to take into account what the student knows and what capabilities the student has. When I demo, I am showing how I do something with the intent of making the viewer aware of a process and how I do it to encourage them to grow... but with the caution that just because I can do it, doesn't mean that they can!

Too many people promote these events as a bunch of classes you can cram into 2 days, and that needs to stop.

4.) Reach the influencers. Someone posted about the hole in the ceiling, and all that people were talking about months later was how great that demo was. We all know who these people are, and the fact is that they are in high demand because of the very danger that they expose people to. If they stop getting work because of their habits, you will see that they tailor their material to meet the new safety culture in AAW.

Like Mike Hosaluk says "Wouldn't be no show without an audience"

5.) Find someone to actually purpose build a useful helmet. With the advent of things like KickStarter, and a captive audience like the AAW has, it should be easy to make 10,000 of them and sell them all before you make the first one. It is clear that the things out there today are largely ineffective against the very thing that they are being touted for. We should be starting with a riot helmet/football helmet/motorcycle platform and amending it to whatever the correct spec is.

Is this everything? No, but it is a start...

S

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#9

Steven Antonucci

My headgear is German ;-) 


Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#10

Re: NOT a helmut (nor helmet)!

Geoff Whaling

Mike spot on- if only people would learn & understand what the standards actually mean and say. In my interpretation the Trend is not intended or promoted as a "helmut" and is not assessed against the standards for such. It does offer a measure of "brow protection" ancillary to its intended purpose which is exactly what it did in this event (NOT an accident.)

Even wearers of "medium" & "high impact" rated visors will suffer some injury from an event such as Aiden experienced. HOWEVER the severity of the outcomes will change markedly - which is what PPE is all about - reducing residual risk and lessening the severity of injuries suffered from such an event. The real control measures are in preventing such an event - the high order controls used to eliminate or reduce the risk of being struck by a high energy object comming from the lathe - the speed management, sound blanks, tool control, appropriate mounting methods etc.

It is promoted as a Eye protection ANSI Z87.1 (low energy impact)

Respiratory protection (for reference only) NPF50 to BS EN 12941 THP2. Not NIOSH approved.

Alan Z you are not alone there are a lot of turners about who do value their own safety but peer group pressure is a funny thing! Even amongst "Oldies".

I'm not sure why every one leaps onto the AAW in these instances, why not the AWGB as well?

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#11

Re: I am proposing change

Geoff Whaling

Steve that is a very positive starting list. I agree whole heartedly re your comments "classes" vs "demos". Observers at demos only take away what they think they saw. Good teachers set good examples, assess teaching priorities, set a teaching plan, assess development and correct poor habits as they teach.

I have very similar sentiments and hopefully what I have attempted to raise in a series of articles published in UK Woodturning on hazard and risk management for woodturners will at least have started turners thinking along the lines you propose. Impossibe to cover all in a limited publication space, but hopefully enough to start them on the right track.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#12

Geoff, not sure why

Dale Bonertz

you refuse to call these accidents. By the very definition of accident is 1) an unintended happening 2) a mishap 3) chance. This is exactly what happens in these circumstances. I don't believe anyone goes to their shop and says I am going to do something stupid or dangerous or etc. They go out to make something, learn something, have alone time or etc. No one has a planned accident. It just seems like you are insulting those who have an unintended happening (accident) as being in total control of the mishap (accident) or as having taken an unnecessary chance (some do most don't). Call it what it is an accident so you aren't insulting those who have one.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#13

Steven Antonucci

semantics

Steven Antonucci

People like the work accident because it relieves them of personal responsibility from the result. "It wasn't my fault...the wood just explode...".but the truth is that the wood left alone wouldn't do anything. It would just sit there.

The turner makes choices and decisions that lead up to the point right before the wood comes apart. Sometimes, the first step is the wrong step (bad wood...or more accurately, wood that is not matched to the turner's skill and experience. Sometimes, it is step 9, and the wood separates from a catch.

An accident is not about intent, because the lathe does not care if you meant to run it at 500 rpm if it is set for 3000 rpm. The lathe doesn't know that you are a rookie or on bowl #3000. The lathe only know to start rotating under power. You may have meant something different than what you tell the lathe when you hut the switch, but only one of you has a brain.

If you are not using your brain every time you reach for the switch, you are going to have an "unfortunate eduvative experience". If you've ever seen someone who ran their hand over a jointer or tablesaw, they didn't have an accident either. They had an unfortunate and completely avoidable eduacative experience.

I feel sorry for them, but if you put yourself in danger's way... it is not an accident. It is the laws of probability.

Steve

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#14

Re: Geoff, not sure why

Geoff Whaling

Dale, no insult intended. I agree no turner goes out to their shop expecting to be injured - but they do get injured for a number of reasons which are pretty well understood in the wider turning community.

If we are ever going to reduce the incidence of serious head and other injuries, the wood turning community has to face reality and accept what the cause of such events are - lapses in judgement, poor selection of turning blanks, unnecessarily high turning speeds, fatigue, a combination of such factors ..... not a one in a million "accident."

In the occupational field the term "accident" is not used at all as the belief is that such events can be eliminated or greatly minimised by following a logical process of hazard assessment and risk management. We should be proactive and start teaching new and old turners how to recognize hazards and how to control them.

A simple process such as "The 5 Why's" ... why did it happen? why did the blank fail? why was that blank used? why was the speed so high? etc can help turners understand the injury mechanism.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#15

Steven Antonucci

Do you expect a PAPR "dust mask" to protect you?

steven antonucci

Didn't work for Adrien...


S

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#16

It's not semantics-it's disrespectful

Dale Bonertz

"I deliberately do not use the word “accident” as these are forseeable events that result from well documented hazards, that we either believe we can manage or become complacent about. The well known controls are quite often either ignored or not implemented fully. "

"People like the work accident because it relieves them of personal responsibility from the result. "It wasn't my fault...the wood just explode...".but the truth is that the wood left alone wouldn't do anything. It would just sit there."

Sorry gentlemen,

This is, I hope, the last you will hear from me on this topic. It is comments like above that leads me to believe that you both are looking at things so black and white. We live in a color world where there are so many things that can happen. Does this mean we don't try and put out good information on safety, no we must. Judging and not calling it what it is, is counterproductive and disrespectful. If we want to continue to learn from others accidents let us stay respectful so they continue to be brave enough to post them.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#17

Sure did protect him

Dale Bonertz

Why are you so negative. The trend appears to have saved his life. So it did protect him. In my book alive is better than the alternative.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#18

Steven Antonucci

you have a sad definition of protection

Steven Antonucci

Judging by the fact that the cover blew off and allowed the wood to penetrate his skull, I would suggest that the Trend did nothing...or marginally anything. It would be like if he was wearing a baseball cap and survived...and crediting the baseball cap as being protective.

I am not negative. I am realistic. People are dying because they think they are protected. They are not. If I can get one person to listen, it is worth it. You will never hear about the person who listener, because their dust mask won't have to save their life... because they will not be in the line of fire when their "accident" occurs.

S

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#19

Steven Antonucci

this is why "accidents" continue to happen...

Steven Antonucci

Here is a funny story...

I was at a fair the other day and I was with my carving club. There was turner with his lathe demonstrating behind us. I know him from my turning club, and I would say we are friends. He has a "big lathe" and considers he and I "peers" with respect t to our turning abilities. He is extremely incorrect in that assumption.

As I was carving, I would occasionally watch him, since any accidents would potentially throw his mistakes toward our carving group. To his credit, he kept the speed down as he threw shavings directly into his face shield. I needed a break, so I walked over to show him how to avoid filling his shirt pocket with shavings.

The exchange went something like this:

"Mind if I show you a different stance to get those shavings out of your face?"

He replied, "Do I really have a choice? You're going to show me anyway?"

To which I responded, "Yeah, you're right about that..."

Was I out of line for trying to correct bad technique, even if he wasn't convince it was bad technique? Or was the problem really his over estimation of how good he was? Sometimes, you have to beat a good idea into people to get someone to adopt it. I can tell you that I watched him do it my way the rest of the day.

That's where we are.

It is not disrespectful. It is reality. If you think that there is some emotional aspect of arguing with facts, that's unfortunate. Whatever you choose to believe doesn't change reality. Your odds of being hit are astronomically higher if you are standing in the line of fire. Notice that this fact is independent of whether or not you have any type of protection on? The ideal should be to not get hit first, and then have a secondary risk mitigation plan that protects you if a true "freak accident" occurs ( like power loss with a vacuum chuck).

Steve

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#20

Steven Antonucci

this is why "accidents" continue to happen...

Steven Antonucci

Here is a funny story...

I was at a fair the other day and I was with my carving club. There was turner with his lathe demonstrating behind us. I know him from my turning club, and I would say we are friends. He has a "big lathe" and considers he and I "peers" with respect t to our turning abilities. He is extremely incorrect in that assumption.

As I was carving, I would occasionally watch him, since any accidents would potentially throw his mistakes toward our carving group. To his credit, he kept the speed down as he threw shavings directly into his face shield. I needed a break, so I walked over to show him how to avoid filling his shirt pocket with shavings.

The exchange went something like this:

"Mind if I show you a different stance to get those shavings out of your face?"

He replied, "Do I really have a choice? You're going to show me anyway?"

To which I responded, "Yeah, you're right about that..."

Was I out of line for trying to correct bad technique, even if he wasn't convince it was bad technique? Or was the problem really his over estimation of how good he was? Sometimes, you have to beat a good idea into people to get someone to adopt it. I can tell you that I watched him do it my way the rest of the day.

That's where we are.

It is not disrespectful. It is reality. If you think that there is some emotional aspect of arguing with facts, that's unfortunate. Whatever you choose to believe doesn't change reality. Your odds of being hit are astronomically higher if you are standing in the line of fire. Notice that this fact is independent of whether or not you have any type of protection on? The ideal should be to not get hit first, and then have a secondary risk mitigation plan that protects you if a true "freak accident" occurs ( like power loss with a vacuum chuck).

Steve

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#21

Betty Scarpino

Re: Positive approaches

Betty Scarpino

Thank you, Dale.

It is important for our turning community to share stories of incidents while turning--we all learn. Like most people, my receptors for learning are fully open when I receive positive feedback that is free of judgmental criticism.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#22

Its reality - take the emotion out of it.

Geoff Whaling

Dale,

I have nothing but respect and admiration for the courage of individuals who share their injury experiences. I respect the rights of others to express their views – so we can all learn from the event and from others who contribute. I also feel deeply the sympathy and empathy for those who suffer an injury and for their families and friends. I, and I guess you too, certainly would not participate in these discussions if we didn’t.

We must face reality - most if not all injuries at the lathe are preventable or the probability of them occurring, and the severity of outcomes can be significantly reduced with some quite easily implemented controls, if we have the knowledge.

Accident research highlights the facts - lathes are the most likely machine in the shop to cause the death of a wood worker! Lathe deaths are relatively rare but are in my belief increasing for various (suspected) reasons. Hand, eye, facial and head injuries are relatively common to turners. Grinders, power carvers, chainsaws, bandsaws, table saws, jointers etc maim but rarely cause deaths. Lathe deaths occur because the injury that causes the death of a wood turner is mostly a severe head injury and is usually associated with a turner working alone, with no means of getting assistance or the injury rendering the turner incapable of raising the alarm. Lathes also maim through entanglement, severing fingers, significant facial and eye injuries etc. Alarmist ? NO! Reality yes – all of us can reduce the risk of becoming another statistic – a statistic that is a person, one who has family and friends who are also deeply affected by any significant injury.

Emotion, experience, knowledge and all sorts of human behaviours cloud our judgement when it comes to turning and all things in life. Objective hazards (speed, blank quality, tenon size etc) can be controlled but overcoming and controlling (in a hazard reduction sense) personal behaviours, known as subjective hazards, can be quite difficult. How do we encourage and promote controls to manage risk associated with the subjective hazards – inexperience, the “challenge”, the “I like working on the edge”, the “I know what I’m doing attitude”, pride, peer group pressures, the desire to turn blanks that we know are questionable, or to continue to follow turning practices that we know or a well known to be high risk?

We can have emotion work both for and against us, but do not continue to let emotions cloud our examination of the circumstances which contributed to this or other such events or how to assess hazards and risk or implementing hazard controls. We must set aside emotion and examine these events in an empirical manner to assess what actually caused the high mass, high speed object to become detached from the lathe and to strike the turner in the head. We can learn a considerable amount from these events and from the very positive actions that most likely saved this gentleman’s life.

He was wearing PPE – The Trend Pro – which most certainly mitigated the severity and extent of the injury.

He was able to contact help – a very very good positive.

Emergency assistance was available.

Most likely other actions that he undertook also helped reduce the severity of the injury.

Knowing other factors, such as blank mounting, lathe speed, tool selection, environment, fatigue level etc would permit a better appreciation of the whole scenario – however it is rare that they are readily available for severe injuries.

Now ask one very big question – what if the turner had been knocked unconscious? How would that scenario have played out? The margin between survivability with no long term physical disability, a severe brain injury, and death from severe head injuries is very dependent upon circumstance. The individual turner sets the scenario up – how much risk are they willing to accept, what controls do they have in place, what back up plans do they have, all play out in the outcome.

I’m not trying to be an alarmist, just a realist and I have no intent to hurt an individuals emotions. We must divorce emotion from the pragmatics of injury prevention. Turning is and can be a very safe pastime but we must treat turning as an art, craft and a trade that requires skill, knowledge and respect to remain a safe pursuit.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#23

Re: Its reality - take the emotion out of it.

Geoff Whaling

Just to clarify, lathes are mere machines doing our bidding - we control them and we are responsible for how they perform and what they produce - both intended and unintended.

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#24

Criticism can sting...

mjonesrdg

Criticism can sting, but if we are open to learning, we can learn from that which stings every bit as much as we can from the accolades.

When I learned about the ANSI z87.1 test standards, I was surprised. Maybe a bit shocked, and I couldn't help but wonder why these standards, which can be critical to a woodturners safety and his sense of safety, are not exposed by the organizations that profess to be concerned with woodturners safety.

I was aghast to further learn that the standard is applied by the manufacturer, and no independent lab testing is required.

I would think that the inadequacies of the headgear and face shield configurations that are recommended, by such as AAW, would be stressed over and again. These items of Personal Protection Equipment have serious limitations. I know that I am not alone when I say that I believed that they afforded a great deal more protection than is actual and true.

I will post more regarding my discoveries as time allows. In the mean while, do you not agree that the AAW could be a bit more pro active on behalf of it's members.....that those members may learn what is so... rather than what is inferred....regarding personal protect gear?

Re: in defense of Trend line helmut

#25

Steven Antonucci

The problem doesn't get fixed this way

steven antonucci

The problem with a democracy is that everybody gets a vote. (just look at America...) The reason that safety tends to work in industrial environments is because not everybody gets a vote, but everybody has to follow the protocol or they get fired. Enforcement is via fear and intimidation, but it keeps people alive.

Our issue as woodturners is that we have no ability to enforce, lest there be some sweeping changes within the AAW to stop glorifying dangerous demonstrations (which means changing behavior of some old guard members) and a real commitment to a safety culture. This will mean saying no, firmly, to people who want to do what they want to do... and there will be hurt feelings. That's just too bad.

In the real world, this kind of change is always achieved via strong leadership. In companies where the leadership is strong, there is clear communication that the train is leaving- be on it, or be under it. It is common to lose people in these kinds of change, and completely acceptable. With a bunch of "professional turners" making a sizeable part of their livelihood via their involvement via the AAW sanctioned events, it shouldn't be hard to convince them to change - or lose their livelihood.

If you think that there is a positive way to explain the line of fire to person after the fact, I'd bet you that they probably don't need the talk anymore. The talk is aimed at people who haven't developed that firsthand knowledge of the "imaginary line of fire". Every head strike (or other body part) is directly attributable to where the person was standing, and you can remove 99.9% of the injuries by teaching them not to stand there.

Find a positive way to write an article for the Journal before someone else gets killed.

Steve