VERY happy to hear you're still with us after such a major whack. You sound in good spirits. I hope you can get back to turning soon.
Without knowing much about it, I'll just say that your face shield may have saved you even though some material got through.
I hate to say it, but Robo's point is made once more -- you've got to stay out of the line of fire. Ever since his post and video, a while back, I have been paying a LOT more attention to that. He showed that you CAN turn and make the needed cuts without having your head in the line of fire.
And if I may get on my soap box,
It is crucial for everyone to remember the S.A.F.E.R. mantra every time, BEFORE they turn the lathe -- the "S" is Speed. Sounds like you may have forgotten that one.
I'll be using your experience in my Safety spot at the next MCW meeting, so maybe you will have helped someone else be safe. We'll never know, but we have to keep trying.
I just looked in your gallery, and I saw some extremely lovely work.
I also saw that several of those pieces had bark inclusions a major fraction of the diameter of the piece. Beautiful, but dangerous. With no knowledge, I'm going to jump to the conclusion that maybe the piece that exploded wasn't sound wood throughout. Even if it was, it illustrates a good point -- unless you know what you're doing, AND take proper precautions, it is not a good idea to turn a blank that has major flaws and weak "lines" through it, because they can and will come apart at speed.
Sure am glad you got out with your life. Looks like the helmet may have absorbed quite a bit of the energy of the flying pieces. Can't imagine if you had not been wearing it.
Thanks for posting yet another reminder to be safe.
The human skull is composed of 2 layers of hard bone separated by a softer cancellous (spongy) layer. These are commonly referred to as "tables" of bone-inner and outer tables.
If the piece of wood went through both layers of bone this was a very serious injury, potentially deadly. I think the helmet deflected enough energy to save his life.
In fron of the skull there are two "frontal" sinuses. A hollow space in the skull. Behind the eyebrows. The piece of timber penetrated both front and back of the sinus, exposing brain.
...that face shields are absolutely necessary, than you should not be turning wood!
To all those people at symposia and chapter meetings who complain that they don't need to wear a quality face shield while turning, or that they are experienced enough or "too professional" to not need one, I would ask everyone to please tell them to shut up. (Politely or not, as you please.)
I was informed of Adrian's accident a while back by Steve Antonnucci (although not the level of injury severity of condition), and I am very happy Adrian is still with us on the "able to turn, move, breathe, and think side of human existence" (.....which is considerably better than the alternate condition). Excluding the recent fatalities from wood turning accidents that have gotten limited press, this is about the most serious injury I have heard about, particularly one involving major skull fractures that the victim actually lived to tell about it. The Lynn Yamaguci incident seems to be quite similar involving frontal/facial injury, skull fracture, and serious follow-up treatment needed.
Speculating now, unless more data is available, it seems that both involved excess speed, possibly suspect wood, and most importantly, the turner letting down their guard and not concentrating on the machine set-up, speed setting, and body position. Lynn was not wearing a face shield; Adrian was. Both are lucky to be alive.
Hopefully this will not happen to anyone again, however with the rapidly growing number of woodturners and the relatively high number of beginners/inexperienced turners going it on their own, I am afraid the numbers do not look good for keeping our accident statistics low. It should be incumbent on all turners and turning organizations to teach and promote safe woodturning practices to EVERYONE, experienced turners included.
Thank-you Adrian for posting the images of the personal protection equipment that likely saved your life. I for one will be sharing this story with many turners in the future.
When Gil announced it at the meeting couple of months ago, there was quite the discussion on proper safety at the lathe.
First, I am glad that you are OK.
Secondly, thank you for sharing the sparse details of the accident that you can recall. I am surprise personally that what is considered to be one of the more "safe" helmets on the market was only able to marginally protect you. While it probably saved your life, to hear that the platter penetrated both the helmet and your skull should be a sobering wake-up call to the folks that think that even the most expensive helmets offer them much protection.
I didn't know the details when I posted the original note, and I assumed it was the blunt force trauma that cause most of your injury, but to hear that the helmet was actually breeched is shocking. It appears that the face shield may be polycarbonate, but the rest of the helmet is not? The face shield appears to be intact?
Take your time mending, and I hope to see you at the next NJW meeting.
But I always seem to be hungry for more information that never makes it out to the public. Like, besides the diameter, how high were the rpm's, how was it mounted, what step were you attempting?
Have you or anyone else examined the pieces, and would you mind posting pics of them?
Keith, I've glued the four pieces back together and finished the platter. It ain't
great 'cause I had the lathe at real low speed working mostly with 100 grit. If you draw four parallel lines across a circle you get a sense of what the pieces looked like..
The piece had some rot, which gave it quite a bit of interest.
I have complete amnesia for the first two days of the episode so it is only in retrospect that I assume I'd left the piece mounted on its spigot in a chuck, but
assume the lathe had been left at high speed and really took off as soon as it
was turned on.
I've already suggested that a safety feature on variable speed lathes would be
a switch that automatically reverts to slow when turned off.
That is indeed scary. I'm sure you are well aware that if it went through your sinus you were very lucky not to lose an eye. Amazing that the helmet did not do better but I'm glad you were wearing it and I'm sure you are too. Thanks for sharing your story and I hope you recover completely.
Powermatic had a system on their variable speed machines, I think in the 70's. Personally I would not own one that had that feature. When I get a speed that works, I don't want it going back to 25rpm every time I check the work. Looks like your platter had two pith lines in it, of course, not a good thing. Glad you are back on the lathe.
Firstly I'm sincerely very great full that you are still with us and have not suffered an acquired brain injury or a lasting physical disability. The outcomes for severe head injuries are not good! You are a brave individual for posting this and sharing with the wider wood working/turning community. Thank you!
The occurrence of head injuries to wood turners is in my belief increasing both in frequency and severity for a number of reasons. Firstly we have more "inexperienced" turners who have access to quite powerful lathes, capable of high speeds with amazing specifications re capacity or swing etc and have access to some quite incredible tooling.
Many turners both inexperienced and experienced are taking on seemingly innocuous projects that carry very very high risk! Projects such as yours attract us with the challenge of the project and the beauty of the wood. Quality blanks with such figure are rare items so we accept blanks that carry higher risk. We get involved in the project and we also get complacent! Rarely do wood turners fully consider the hazards, the risks and the potential consequences of what they do – or the effect an injury to them will have on their family and friends.
Your blank is quite typical and presents a number of challenges and hazards, particularly from the imperfection upper LH portion and the crotch figure in mid section. The hazards and our behaviour can be managed but it requires knowledge and skill. Those hazards also present a life threatening risk if not carefully managed. We can implement controls to stabilise the blank; support it on a large face plate as we turn; manage lathe speed, tool presentation and control; manage our own behaviours (complacency); and wear personal protective equipment; to at least eliminate or minimise some risk. However if we do not implement suitable effective controls we run the very real possibility of eventually experiencing an event such as yours. The probability of such an event depends upon the level of risk each of us is prepared to accept! Perhaps the outcome could also be vastly different – as in death, or a permanent injury or an acquired brain injury disability.
I deliberately do not use the word “accident” as these are forseeable events that result from well documented hazards, that we either believe we can manage or become complacent about. The well known controls are quite often either ignored or not implemented fully.
Not knowing your skill level or circumstances it is inappropriate to comment on your event but one thing that is very apparent is the Trend PARP helmet certainly performed to its expected abilities and reduced the severity of the impact to an extent. It is designed for low impact protection not a high energy impact such as you experienced.
Talk of wearing ballistic rated face shields is NOT the sole answer. Risk management and hazard control is! We all need to learn more about the hazards and potential outcomes that they present, then put into place effective controls to eliminate, substitute etc hazards. We need a clear understanding of the energy potential of objects coming off the lathe.
Would you honestly let a major league baseball pitcher strike you in the head with a baseball? The energy of objects coming of the lathe can easily exceed that.
Adrian, I am very sorry to hear about your accident but happy that it was not worse.
My first rule of thumb is to turn the speed selector to zero at the end of each day or before starting a new project. I turn the breaker off at the end of each day. Before turning the breaker on, I again makes sure the speed selector is at zero. Again, before I pull the switch on, I check that the speed selector is at zero.
This helps with those senior moments.
I wear a Lexan Bubble Visor and always try to avoid the line of fire.
I dial the speed up slowly and turn rather slowly by most standards. It is much faster than the pole lathes though.
There seems to be a false impression that the Trend Airshield Pro is a helmet. It's even called that in some of the literature on it, but it is a helmet only in the sense that it's worn on the head. It does not provide head protection from an impact like this, nor is it designed to.
This is a great product for what it's designed for - face protection from flying particles and air filtration. It's probably the finest on the market for those uses. If you go to Trend's website or the website of anyone selling one of these, there is no mention of head protection as provided by a helmet. They all talk about air filtration and face protection against flying debris. These are very precise terms, especially when you get into the OSHA definitions. That's the standard they are trying to meet.
The black part on top is structural. It helps hold the inner workings together and gives attachment points for hearing protection and such, but it's not designed to be impact resistant. While any structure that will collapse on impact can provide some attenuation of impact forces, that's not its purpose. The shape may even help deflect some of the debris to change the impact vector. It may not.
My point is that we need to recognize that this is an outstanding piece of safety equipment for what it's designed to do, but it won't replace staying out of the line of fire. It's not designed to protect us from a pound of wood coming off the lathe at 2000 rpm and hitting us in the head. If we want that type of protection, we'd better start wearing a real hard hat.
Marshall - Could you please elaborate on what you wear for protection?
A "Lexan Bubble Visor" is not a trade name as far as I can tell. What is it and what is it attached to? When I searched I find motorcycle helmet faceshields. Is this what you use?
The above Item # was from my catalog. The website is showing Part# 245-0100. If you View Product Details you will see that it is Lexan. It does seem thicker than most face shields. Luckily, I have not had to test its strength. :-)
I purchased it shortly after Joan Kelly's accident. In over twenty years of turning, I haven't had an accident yet. I try to turn safely.