Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Favorite bow gouge size?

Posts

Favorite bow gouge size?

#1

Favorite bow gouge size?

Mavdad55

Folks,

I have been turning for a little less than a year now and have had a great time turning ornamental bird houses (via Dale Nish) and boxes, pens and 1 small bowl out of bubinga (spelling) which was kiln dried, and turned like granite, but turned out very nice. I now have a large piece of Ash at 15% moisture, the wood is 14 inches wide and 7+ inches deep; so I would like to turn a large bowl. The tree was killed by emerald ash bores a year ago. I have a 1/4 and 3/8 bowl gouges as sized at the flute. Is the 3/8 large enough to turn this; or should I be looking for a 1/2" (again by flute size)? I am just getting over rotator cuff surgery and am looking for something that will cut fast with minimal impact to my shoulder.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#2

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

Dale Gillaspy

I use my 1/2" Thompson BG for almost everything I do. That being said, you CAN use the 3/8. It will take a longer time to rough, and 7" is a long overhang. You are going to want to position your tool rest inside the bowl so you don't have a long overhang. Too much torque on the tool, and in turn, your shoulder.

That being said, on a 14" bowl, I would probably rough it with my 5/8 BG and finish it with my 1/2", but that is just me.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#3

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

david

The choice of gouges is a personal preference depending on how you turn. My go-to gouge is a 1/2" Thompson V-shaped bowl gouge, and have a Jimmy Clewes signature Thompson 3/8" for detail work. I have larger and smaller, but they get infrequent use. My 1" skew is relegated to negative rake scraping and helping to form the tenon for the 4-jaw chucks.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#4

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

robo hippy

That is a pretty good sized bowl. I prefer the heavier gouges for roughing, at least when I use one. Most of the time I use scrapers (1 1/4 by 3/8 thick). If you use the 3/8 inch gouge, it will take a long time to do, less if you core the bowl blank. Having a bowl rest really helps because you can keep the tool close to the wood. If you only have a straight rest, then you have to extend the tool out a ways and a 3/8 inch gouge would be very limited here.

robo hippy

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#5

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

Greg Haugen

First off, to clarify things if you're 3/8" is an English brand tool, it's 1/2" diameter steel (or 3/8" flute as you would said.) Your 3/8" english gouge and a thompson 1/2" gouge are the same size steel. English bowl gouges are sized by the flute and American gouges are sized by the steel. With that said, I would surely rather rough it out with a 1/2" English/5/8" American gouge, than with a 3/8" E. gouge. Especially with that kind of depth, over 6" deep. My bowl turning tool group consists of (going by English/flute sizes) a 1/2" swept back grind of 45 degrees for mass roughing, a 3/8" swept back 40 degrees for finish cuts and under cutting the rim, and a 3/8" stubby traditional grind (varying degree depending on bowl) for finishing the bottom.

Also don't try to be a production turner, just relax and enjoy the process. Take your time and watch the amount of the cut, it will help your shoulder tremendously.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#6

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

John Lucas

I agree with Greg. I use a 1/2" Thompson V gouge for almost everything except roughing large or very out of round bowls. As soon as I get it round I prefer my 1/2". As was stated a 3/8" flute on an English gouge is 1/2" steel.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#7

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

Barry L Elder

You need to be more concerned with doing more damage to your shoulder than the size to the gouge you will use.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#8

More important is to keep the tool sharp!

Galen Vetterick

Some will say size matters. :D I say it is how you use it. :D

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#9

Re: Thank you all

Mavdad55

Dale, David, Robo, Greg, John, Barry, Galen,

Thank you all for the responses. This helps me a lot. Doctor says my shoulder material is destroyed, so I do have to take it easy. Luckily I did purchase a cast iron bowl rest from Craft Supply and it has 2 mount points; so that should help. I will make my own handle for an American 5/8 gouge now. Just have to make up my mind on one from D-Way or Thompson. I Like them both based on all your conversations. D-Way looks like the gouge shape is more round or parabolic which I prefer as my 3/8 is an Artisan from Craft Supply which is a low end HT and is a superflute and I really like how it cuts; my 1/4 is a Robert Sorby. I did get carried away with the Bubinga bowl and knocked it out of the chuck by taking to much material with only a 3/8 foot tennon. That is from a Stronghold cranked as tight as I could get it. I did that with a standard 45% grind, think I'll try something closer to 55% to see if this helps me keep my aggressive cuts down. Again, thank you all for your kind help. Looking forward to future conversations. When I get to turn the bowl I'll let you know how it goes.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#10

Re: Thank you all

robo hippy

That rest from Craft Supplies, is that the blue curved one? I have a couple of them, and love the shape, especially for the inside of the bowl. Only down side is it is cast metal rather than the drill rod on top. Well, with the broad profile, it is difficult to drop your handle for a shear cut on the outside of the bowl. I can't figure out why they used 2 mounting spots on it. I just leave it set up in the 'inside' bowl position. It does come loose when used on the outside of the bowl, which rotates it into the wood, but that isn't much of a problem unless you are roughing a chain sawn blank. Mine are now rusted firmly in place, and it would take a torch and pipe wrenches to get them loose.

robo hippy

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#11

Re: Thank you all

Mavdad55

Yep.., that's the exact one. Luckily mine has not rusted yet. Don't have bad problems with rust in my garage, knock on wood. I have had table, band saw, jointer, etc. out there for over 10 years with no rust to speak of and only minor care to prevent it. I did use the Bowl rest for the small bowl but did not have problem with the width there, I am sure it will be a different story on the large one. The tool rest adapter I purchased with it has flat spots for me to wrench it into the tool rest. Did yours?

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#12

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

Don Stephan

If the tree has been dead a year there may be almost invisible shrinkage cracks in the wood. I've made a number of once turned bowls from just cut dead ash and at least a third started to develop cracks as I was working on the inside. CA glue worked on every one except the last blank, which was showing so many fine cracks I thought it best to stop turning.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#13

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

Mavdad55

Thanks for the info.., I'll have to keep a close eye on it when I start.., if it is bad, then I guess I will have to give up the rest of the tree trunk as firewood.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#14

Re: Thank you all

robo hippy

Yes, it has that slot. There is rust in my turning area because I like really wet wood. The wetter it is, the more it warps, and I love warped bowls.

robo hippy

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#15

A bevel angle of 45 degrees on......

JamieDonaldson

...a bowl gouge is very aggressive, and I much prefer the Ellsworth recommended 60 degrees. That is much less catch prone yet very efficient for removing any masses of wood you can tolerate with a bad "wing!"

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#16

Re: A bevel angle of 45 degrees on......

Mavdad55

Jamie, thanks for the info. Do you know if a V shaped flute like a Thompson BG will take an Elsworth grind? Or does it have to be U shaper or parabolic, like a HT superflute BG?

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#17

Bill Blasic

Re: A bevel angle of 45 degrees on......

Bill Blasic

You would have no problem with any wing grind on the Thompson V but I cannot get a good wing grind on the U, not that I have spent a lot of time with the U. I'm like everybody else that when you find that favorite tool it becomes your go to tool and I'm that way with the Thompson 5/8 V.

Bill

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#18

A Thompson V flute is actually less ......

JamieDonaldson

...of a V than several other brands, and I grind my Thompson V flutes to an Ellsworth style swept wing all the time with a Wolverine jig.

Re: Favorite bow gouge size?

#19

Re: A Thompson V flute is actually less ......

Mavdad55

Thanks, that was exactly The info I was looking for.