What's Best is Contextual
charlie belden
If we were RECORDING video - in a studio - with a 14' celing height, 1000 sf of floor space, a boom camera and one or two cameras on wheeled dollies - with stands for lighting and different kinds of lights (halo, flood, spot, etc.) adjusted for each shot - that would be terrific. In a studio, you usually have scripted out what's to be shot so everyone knows what's coming and what they're after. In a studio you have complete control of the space, the lighting, camera positions, the sound - and you can yell "CUT! Let's do another take, but this time . . ." Oh - and each person on each camera probably should have some experience as a cameraman or camerawoman - and a wireless headset so the director can direct the shots he wants. Since you'd be digitally recording, the "post production" work can assemble the best takes and shots and leave the rest of the bits on the "cutting room floor" during the editing processing. And sound levels can be balanced. Can't do any post production when working LIVE - you'rer in WYSIWYG mode (What You See Is What You Get).
We tried all that - but NOT in a studio - in a temporary meeting site. The boomed camera operator had to avoid overhead lights - and the turner doing the demo - all while looking at his monitor showing what his camera was seeing - zooming in our out to show details - and trying not to step on or run over his camera's power cord and video signal cable on the floor. The floor cameras on dollies had the same power cord and video signal cable issue to deal with - while getting the shot the director was telling them in their wirelss headsets the shot he wanted - all done without obstructing the audience's view of the demonstrator - or getting in the way of the demonstrator. And all the equiptment had only a 10' wide by 10' deepr by 8' tall space to work in. And without a script so everyone operating equiptment AND the demonstrator knew what would happen next - there was a real need for quick clear communication - and experience working "live".
Here's the context we were working in and the equiptment we were using
- one fixed mount camera at the tail stock end looking towards the headstock,remotely zoomed in or our
- one dollied camera with operator wearing wireless headset so the guy operating the boom camera, who acted as the director, could direct his shot
- one industrial strength commercial boom that allowed the camera to be moved up and down, in and out, pan left right, pan up.down and remotely zoomed in or out
- lighting on stands and overhead fluorescent
- demonstrator wearing wireless lapel mic and amplifier and speakers to project his voice
- four video monitors, one for each camera and one showing what was going to the video projector
- not visible is a four in - one out video switcher to select which camera feed went to the video projector
- not shown, a 2500 lumens video projector permanently mounted from the ceiling above the audience
- missing is a black out curtain to block the light from the demonstator's area from getting to the projection screen adjacent to the demonstrator.
http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Turning/AudioVideoSystem/OriginalSetUp1.jpg
http://web.hypersurf.com/~charlie2/Turning/AudioVideoSystem/OriginalSetUp2.jpg
This set up took well over and hour to unpack and set up and and another hour to tear down and pack up. Two hours of set up and tear down - for a 40-60 minute demonstrating during a 3 hour club meeting. That meant the video people had to be at the meeting site for FIVE HOURS since the tear down and pack up couldn't be done during the meeting.
Yes, the demonstrator could have acted as the Director, but that would affect the flow of the demo, and not all demonstrators have experience at directing video cameras. In fact, most club demos are done by club members or by a member of another club in the area, not by professional demonstrators.
If you're NOT in a studio, even if you have semi-pro stuff, but rather in a temporary space that is also used for other purposes, and you're videoing one shot - live action - with no second takes - things get a lot more complicated - and many more problems to deal with. The more complex the system, the more likely something can and likely will go wrong. The more people involved the greater the opportunity for miscommunication and the more difficult it is to coordinate. The fewer people and things have to move - the simpler things get.
In our former club president's shop we have another unique situation. His lathe is in small room - about 10' wide but only about 6' deep and with a 7'6" celiing height, the audience side of the room is open to a space for chairs of about 16' x 14' - with three feet between the front row chairs and the lathe. There's really no room for a boomed camera or dollied cameras, either behind or in front of the lathe, nor on either side of the lathe.
In this situation two fixed celing mounted zoomable cameras - one with a tail stock view, one overhead looking down, an overhead fluorscent and another light on a gooseneck suspended from the ceiling get you most shots needed for an At The Lathe Demo. For Off The Lathe Demos a hand held camera would probably work adequately - what with Image Stabilization built into most cameras today. If not, a dollied tripod camera is available.
If your club meets in a borrowed space, shared with others, the conduit frame system works pretty well. Goes up and comes down quick, one person can operate it, stores in a protective ply box on wheels and is AFFORDABLE - around $800 for everything except a projector.
Are there better video set ups for live action demonstrations? Absolutely.
Is there a One Size Fits All? Probably not.
The set up we put together is pretty good for an affordable and transportable system and any club with 50 or more members can probably afford to put one together and operate it with little experience or special knowledge or skills.
As usual
Your Mileage May Vary
.