Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

National Anthem

Posts

National Anthem

#1

National Anthem

robo hippy

I loved the old Jimmy Hendrix version of the National Anthem. I love this version as well, in part because I am an old rocker....

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8C7i9kdEf8

robo hippy

Re: National Anthem

#2

Re: National Anthem

Harry in Beautiful Downtown Kulpsville

I like to hear it played the way it was written, not as a rock vocal. But that's just me!

Re: National Anthem

#3

Well Done But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

He's got to work on his range. The high note on "Free" is an essential part and he can't reach it with strength and support.

Re: National Anthem

#4

Re: National Anthem

charlie belden

Hendrix put the chaos, the confusion, the fear and horror of war into his versrion of the National Anthem, things left out of the more traditional versions. THAT is what makes his version so special - to me -and why I appreciate more fully what the people who fought in the American Revolution endured in order to create a new nation, independent of Britain.

We celebrate glorious victories, but seldom understand the human cost of attaining them.

Re: National Anthem

#5

Re: National Anthem

Steve Kniffen

I remember the Hendrix version, but unlike everyone else in my generation, I wasn't at Woodstock to hear it live. I was in basic training.

I saw the guys in this video on Fox News the other morning. I enjoyed their rendition. I thought it was very respectful, especially when you hear the story behind the band. We get used to the traditional version of the song and forget that the tune was originally an English drinking song, intended to be sung as fast and as high as possible. I like this version a lot better than some of the ones I hear before ball games.

Steve

Re: National Anthem

#6

Re: National Anthem

Barry L Elder

A lifetime ago, when I was in the Navy, I just about exploded with pride every time I heard the Star Spangled Banner, especially when we were in a foreign port. I saw many "ugly Americans", you know the fat slobby ones from NY, NJ, who throw their money around and who are spit on by the locals, but we wore our uniforms with great pride because we stood for something besides money! So please have respect for those of us who do like the National Anthem that is not given some original twist by some particular type of musician. I still salute our Flag and I honor your right to like things I might not so please do the same. :D

As to how I could tell where those "ugly Americans" were from: even when you can hear them yelling at the help from a block away, the accent is unmistakable!

Re: National Anthem

#7

Re: National Anthem

robo hippy

There are a lot of good versions of the song, and the different interpretations appeal to different groups. Another favorite one was the 11 year old Mexican American boy in his Mariachi outfit singing at a basketball game. Worst version ever, and most will probably agree, was Roseann Barr's version.

robo hippy

Re: National Anthem

#8

I like this version  *LINK*


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QKCVS57j284

Re: National Anthem

#9

Re: National Anthem

Steve Kniffen

I'm a retired Air Force pilot with nearly 25 years in uniform. I too wore my country's uniform at home and abroad with pride. I too still stand and salute the flag. I too enjoy the traditional version of the National Anthem, and understand those who appreciate it this way too. I'd never trade any modern stylized rendition for the original or insist that anyone agree with only my ideas on how the song should be sung. I spent all that time in uniform defending the right of each of us to have our own opinion and expressing it. Thank you for your service, too.

Re: National Anthem

#10

This is really moving  *LINK*


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MaGftxRkgPI

Re: National Anthem

#11

Re: This is really moving

robo hippy

Both of those links are inspiring John, and no I am not going to take up singing. Interesting comments on the link for the 'alter abled' girl. For those of us who are not alter abled, we forget that overcoming obstacles is an every day part of life, and all are capable of figuring out ways around difficulties. I am still trying to figure out a way around the skew though......

robo hippy