Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Posts

OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#1

George Taylor

OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

George Taylor

I am ready (I think) to take the plunge in cooling off the garage before we get into the throws of another South Texas summer. The shop occupies 2 bays of our 3 car garage where the only exterior wall is covered in brick and there is indoor living space above the garage. The exterior wall does have a window and the garage doors point due west which has the afternoon evening sun glaring in. My plan of attack would be to insulate the garage doors (Owens-Corning kits) and then install a window AC unit. I had extra electrical circuits run previously. I was looking at a Frigidaire unit from Lowes since I get a small discount; I thought the 15000 BTU unit would be an appropriate size. My questions are:

1. For part time use is insulating the garage real important to do initially?

2. Is 15,000 BTU too much or even possible too little in capacity?

3. What else am I missing?

Any and all feedback is greatly appreciated.

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#3

Re: Calcs

John Veerkamp

Brick is not a good insulator. If it is a south wall it will act like a heat sink and significantly add to the cooling load.

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#4

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

dick gerard

By all means, INSULATE. Insulate the walls,ceiling and the doors. Add weatherstriping if necessary, to both doors and windows. It will pay for itself many times over. A cool shop is a treat to work in, a hot shop is not ... unless you are blowing glass.

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#5

George Taylor

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

George Taylor

I am reading about the insulation "kits" for metal garage doors and it looks like the reviews are very mixed. The complaints center the tab adhering to the doors as well as the weight of the insulation. Is there a more effective method to insulate a metal garage door without costing an "arm & a leg?"

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#6

Clint Searl

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Clint Searl

Depends on your usage. If you're only gonna be in there a couple hours at a time, I'd forego any insulation, and install a big honkin' unit that will chill and dehumidify the place quickly, and keep it comfortable while you're working. Leave it off the rest of the time.

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#7

Steven Antonucci

For what it is worth...

steven antonucci

My answer is based upon my experience in my house (not shop).

I live in a split level house with a lot of big windows. That glass gives us a lot of passive solar, and one year, it got to be too much. I ran out and bout the biggest 120 AC window unit that I could find (15K BTU's) and installed a ceiling fan in the living room to circulate the cold air in our bedroom.

You can hang meat in our bedroom, and the downstairs is very comfortable. In all, I suspect we're looking at about 1500 s.f. being covered by the window unit, with walls and all sorts of bends to navigate around. if your 2 bay is what I think it is, you'll be fine.

Steve

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#8

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Philip Morris

George,

I have used standard R-11 Fiberglas wall batting to insulate several garage doors. It does require some trimming and handfitting, but it is effective and cheap. My retention system is comprised of six sheet metal screws per panel section (three top and three bottom) with light gauge wire wrapped between the screws in a zig zag pattern. I can post a picture later, if this does not make sense.

Recall using about one and a half rolls to do a double car garage door, which does add a little weight. This is optional, but I went ahead and added some tension to my garage door spring to take the strain off the door opener. However, I would advise getting the assistance of a professional if you are the least bit unsure of what you are doing here. These springs store a lot of energy and can cause significant personal injury if suddenly released.

Philip

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#9

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Barry Irby

I have a one car garage shop with a small window unit (5000 btuh?) and it does a reasonable job. Can't hang meat in there but it completely changes the "feel" of the shop and makes working there pleasant and palatable. My garage door faces east, not nearly as bad as yours.

I would suggest looking at the insulation that looks like bubble wrap made of aluminum foil. I would look at several layers of it or perhaps sandwiching in some foam. I would look at trying to keep it firmly in place to prevent heat seeping around it.

You also might consider looking around for a company that does spray foam insulation. Tell them what you are doing and be sure they guarantee the foam will adhere in spite of the excessive heat. look at Icyene (sp?) and Ureathane. There are code issues about leaving some types of foam exposed so be careful.

We are just past the summer solstice, you should have a very good idea how hot that door gets.

Painting the outside a brilliant reflective white might help a lot.

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#10

Roger in MO

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Roger in MO

My wood shop is 24' x 24' Sheetmetal siding over studs with inslation between and finished with sheet rock. I have a small window AC in one wall and a large ceiling fan. The shop was hot and humid when I went in about 2:30 and in 10 minutes it was comfortable in the area of the AC. By 4:00 the temp had dropped 10 or 15 degrees. I only work about 2 hours at a time.

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#11

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Alan Trout

George,

If it was me I would insulate as well as you can and go for a 24,000BTU mini split. It should cool off the garage reasonable quickly and work well for many years to come. They are not super cheap but not break bank either.

Just my suggestion.

Alan

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#12

Clint Searl

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Clint Searl

Insulation is always a future option.

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#13

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

Ralph Watts

George,

You might consider getting a dual system/heat pump/air conditioner. They are near the same price and the extra heat in winter might be a plus...

Best regards, Ralph

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#14

Brad Vietje

George:  Lots to Look Into...

Brad Vietje

Hey George,

There are a host of things you can do. There are a lot of factors, depending on aesthetic concerns, other garage uses/users, significant others in the family, etc...

In addition to installing solar electric and solar water and air heating systems, I do a lot with passive solar design and helping clients improve the comfort of their buildings, as well as working very closely with thermal envelope specialists, building insulators, etc..., so please forgive me if I ask too many questions!

Mini-splits can be a very efficient way to deliver cool and/or heated air; insulation will reduce the amount of energy required to do both of these jobs.

Here are a few thoughts as they occur to me:

- Insulation of the door will help

- Insulation of the entire space will also help. Insulation of the attic space could help a lot.

- COLOR of the door may help the most (as far as the temp of the door is concerned) -- as Barry mentioned. What color is it now? How about white? There are even special whites that are used for observatories to avoid heat gain, and for weather stations to avoid artificially high measures.

- Color of East-South-West walls?

- Brick wall facing south is an issue -- natural (red) or painted? How would it look if painted white?

- Insulation inside that brick wall? Bricks get HOT and STAY hot due to their thermal mass.

- What is roof shape, orientation, material and color? Is there a ceiling above the shop space, or is it unfinished, with a view up into the roof rafters?

- If a ceiling, what's above it for insulation? Other rooms or uses up there?

- Solar attic fan, with an air intake near the ground on the north side can help a LOT -- even if there is a ceiling and an attic. Once installed uses no additional energy. Works when the sun is out, which is when heat builds up. Cooler attic = cooler building. This is especially true of upstairs bedrooms in homes, which are often unbearably hot due to the heat absorbed by the roof.

- Insulation of walls and ceilings: look at dense pack cellulose, aluminized "bubble wrap" products, foil-faced sheet foam products, or even spray foams (need to have fire retardant applied, too). Avoid fiberglass wherever possible, both batts and blown-in.

- Insulation will pay you back three times -- lowers cooling bills, lowers heating bills, and increases comfort level.

- Are you in a wet/humid part of Texas, or a hot/dry area? Moisture issues are important to think through. Be sure your insulation efforts don't block air flow and ventilation needed for moisture management, or wood structures could rot.

- Night-flush cooling: open all windows at night to cool off interior, then close them each AM. If you live where it cools off a lot at night -- you may not:~( -- you can maximize this effect by increasing thermal mass inside the insulated shell (water tanks, concrete, plaster, etc...). Night flush cooling works well here in the NE, but can also cause condensation on heavy metal tools, so they need protection or a water repellant coating.

- Passive venting: make sure hot air has a way to get out at the highest point, such as attic vents at peaks of gable ends. If cool make-up air is available to replace it, the chimney effect can draw in cool air with no fans, and no increase in the electric bills. Some people install underground cool air intake tubes.

There's my 3 cents,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#15

George Taylor

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

George Taylor

Thanks for all the great suggestions, to answer some of the questions:

- the one exterior brick wall faces north and gets a lot of shade from trees.

- the white garage door (metal) faces due west

- mornings in the South Texas Hill country are quite pleasant, even in the summer

- do not want to make major changes to the garage because we are considering downsizing when I retire in 20 months

With all that said, I will probably proceed with a window air conditioner that I will primarily run in the afternoon/evening when I plan on turning and see how it goes.

Thanks again

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

#16

Re: OT - HVAC in 3 car garage

John Stegall

I live in Kerrville and I needed to use my garage as a guest room so I insulated the stone veneer wall, added extra insulation in the attic and added a vent from my HVAC. I went back to using it as a garage/workshop and just used the thin metallicized material on the metal door. The kind that is often used to block the sun on a windshield. I really have been amazed at how well it works.

John