Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Manufacturers and the Forums

Posts

Manufacturers and the Forums

#1

Manufacturers and the Forums

robo hippy

I posed this question on SMC, and wanted to post it here as well. I was chatting with Brad Packard, owner of Packard Woodturning tools, and he made the comment that he didn't think it was proper for him to comment on the forums. The business people are on both sides of this issue. There are some who don't feel it is proper, and others who do comment, but do try to keep it 'civil'. Maybe a third side who will try to take advantage to promote their own stuff. Mostly, I want 'professionals' to explain things in their areas of expertise, rather than having some one like me try to explain and get the facts wrong. Kind of a 'they forgot more about it than I will ever learn' situation. For sure, ethics come in here, and no free advertising, but what do you think?

robo hippy

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#2

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

Bill Jacksonville, NC

While totally agree with what Brad Packard had to say. Really, have no problem with a business owner expressing his or her opinion on any topic they feel strongly about.

Nothing says have to agree with their opinion.

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

Mike Stafford

Brad is a standup guy and this comment is not directed at him.

Over the years a number of manufacturers of various tools have interjected themselves into this forum and it has caused problems.

Ellis has a good system where manufacturers are able to advertise on WC and stay out of the discussions about tools. We have had far too many heated debates regarding tools among manufacturers.

The Boss can certainly correct me if I am wrong.

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#4

Steven Antonucci

Separating facts from opinions (and marketing)

steven antonucci

No issues with anyone who makes things for sale to the turning community posting facts about their products in the context of answering a question.

Facts sometimes are actually opinions.

Opinions are usually marketing.

As long as you tell me which one it is, I know what to do with it. Just make sure your fact isn't an opinion you hold to market your product...and I am OK with it.

Steve

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#5

I would have no objections to .........

JamieDonaldson

...individuals who are also dealers participating in our online discussions, so long as the sales pitch is not expressed. They are a valuable resource for current info about topics such as new tools, and could express informed personal opinions without it becoming a sales pitch.

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#6

Re: How about this idea...???

jake Niedling

It is pretty hard for a supplier to make a comment without someone thinking there is a sales pitch in just about anything they might say or how they said it. What about giving suppliers/manufacturers an area on the forum, where they can provide information on their products, use, design, limitations, etc. Of course like with anything there would need to be some guidelines. Such as No comments about other suppliers products or forum user comments. No comments by users on this supplier area. Just an idea and perhaps there is a better one.

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#7

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

Bill Howatt

Short answer is that it will be great for some and not for others. Very likely a 2-edged sword. Also, part of the problem will arise not from the vendor but from some obtuse individual who is a form member.

There is a vendor on a Cdn WW forum whose presence I would say benefits the members. He doesn't get involved even if his products are getting generally maligned but if somebody posts a support issue, a design problem or has some wrong information he may well get involved with a resolution or correction. He also makes it very clear who he is and the company he represents.

Bill

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#8

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

Stuart Johnson

If you follow the hand tool board you'll see Rob Lee is very helpful and is more than willing to answer questions but does not make a sales pitch. I guess it all depends on how the manufacturer presents the product or company.

The final word on the subject is whatever Ellis says is okay.

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#9

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

Greg Haugen

This happens at least a couple of times a week, if not every day and it's not a big deal. Manufacturers/suppliers/dealers contribute to the forums on all kinds of levels. Does it matter if John Jordan or Robo Hippy contributes to the forums;they're tool or accessory manufacturers? It shouldn't. They are also turners, first and far most. Their input is sought after and respected. I think the original question about Brad is even less of an issue due to the fact he's a dealer of many products across the whole spectrum of the craft. IF someone asks a question about hollowing tools, why wouldn't you want input from John Jordan, Trent Bosch, or Mike Hunter? If you had a question about coring why wouldn't you want Robo Hippy or Mike Mahoney to chime in? There's always more than one way to do things and the techniques of how they're done can be transferred to other applications. There's a difference in a conversation about why Truck A or Truck B is better being completely opinion driven and are Gas or Diesel engines better for towing power being more of a factual discussion based on experiences. Issues that arose in the past came from more of a "Truck A is better than Truck B" stand point. A civil, respectful answer or response is by far better advertising than a mud slinging onslaught.

I don't think it's an issue and I think too much is made out of it. They are turners too.

Turning Forum Moderator

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#10

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

GaryG in MD

Let's not forget that Doug Thompson also participates here, and his comments are honest, informational, and well received.

My personal feeling is that I would hope that Brad would read these comments and decide to chime in when appropriate. We know he is a man of integrity and an acknowledged pillar of our community. We will accept and evaluate his comments just as we do with all others from those who do so much to aid and promote our vortex.

...GG

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

Jack Guzman from Maine

Manufacturers and vendors/tool suppliers have been participating in these forums for years. They haven't been an issue. They don't come here to sell their products. Some are here because they are also interested in the discussion. Some use them to learn how best to serve their customers.It doesn't much matter,there are rules here and as long as everyone follows them there are no problems.---Jack

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#12

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

Darryl

When you put the question on SMC I was a bit surprised at some of the responses. Giving it more thought I don't see anything wrong with a manufacturer or for that mater sponsor providing input to questions about any topic on the forums. There are several well known turners who have "sponsored" tools like Ellsworth or Raffan and others. I certainly would like to hear their opinions. I think we are all able to sort out a sales pitch if it is offered. I doubt that any pitch would ever be given anyway. Manufacturers do what they do for a reason (it may or may not be valid for me) and I would like to know those reasons before I make decisions.

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#13

Ellis Walentine

There are ground rules

Ellis Walentine

WoodCentral depends on advertising to keep the show on the road, so we have a firm restriction on unsolicited commercial posts, which aren't fair to paying advertisers or to us. That said, as several of you mentioned, manufacturers and vendors, whether advertisers or not, are welcome to participate freely here, as long as they keep their posts informational and non-commercial. They are also welcome to discuss their products *if* it is a reasonable response to something posted by one of our visitors (i.e., solicited). They may also answer questions and rebut complaints about their products, but, again, only in response to others' specific comments.

Ellis

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#14

Chuck Jones - West TN

If I put on my glasses and look closely...

Chuck Jones - West TN

...between the line of Ellis' post I think I can see the words "common sense". I believe he's right on target. Like a lot of things, this can be debated endlessly. It would probably be impossible to write an extensive set of rules that would put it to bed for ever.

From what I've seen in my relatively limited experience with the woodturner community about 99.9% of the manufacturers/vendors/professionals are very upstanding folks and extremely good citizens who don't need a lot of rules. The others can be spotted and shot down fairly quickly if they don't shoot themselves in the foot first.

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#15

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

robo hippy

One reason I posed this question was because of a new product Packard is carrying. A CBN wheel that is being made for Woodcut. The curious part was a 'cleaning' stick for the CBN wheel, which was some thing I had seen only for my matrix type CBN wheels, and not some thing I had ever heard of for the electroplated CBN wheels. If some one else asked about it, I would want Brad to feel comfortable explaining all about it, on any of the forums. I could call him, and get the info, and then try to remember and then post it in the forums, or he, or the maker could post about what it is supposed to do.

I guess as long as any one used some common sense, and good manners, then no problems from any of the forum moderators.

robo hippy

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

#16

Re: Manufacturers and the Forums

hu lowery

Common sense should certainly rule. You post great information and help many people all over the net. However I just watched a D-Way video last night that he should send you a bill for! Prominently featured with many close-ups was a very fine and economical little platform rest called a Robo Rest. He also had some very nice things to say about it.

Are you to be banned from posting all of a sudden because you decided to make or have made these little tool grinding platforms? I want one by the way, I'll be talking to you soon.

The same rules should apply to manufacturers large and small. The real question is are they here to add value or advertise and push their products? Usually very easy to tell in my experience. I would hate to be cut off from some of the most knowledgeable people on the internet because they sell something. I do find extremely annoying the people that manage to find a way to advertise their wares in every post. No matter what the thread is about they manage to find a way to offer something for sale that will help. I think if the people with things to sell are honest they know exactly when they cross the line even if others don't.

Thumbs up to the people with great information that happen to sell something. Thumbs down to the people that twist threads to hawk their wares. Pretty simple really. Also of course only fair to remember the site if someone is deriving a significant cash flow from the site.

Hu