Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

Posts

Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#1

Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

charlie belden

We typically turn pieces to a pleasing profile - in a SIDE VIEW. Yet, when the finished piece is displayed, it's seldom viewed in SIDE VIEW, the piece usually being below "eye level". So, unless the viewer intentionally moves his/her vantage point to SEE the profile in SIDE VIEW, what he/she sees is NOT the single axis profile we created, but rather a distorted by perspective version of it.

I've always been fascinated by Micaelangelo's "The David". Though not obvious, Michelangelo distorted the proportions of The David, a LARGE sculpture, presented on a tall pedestal - and only viewable from below. Because it can only be viewed from below, had he gone with the "normal" proportions of the figure, the effect would be that of seeing a human figure with big feet - and a pin head, the feet being closest to the viewer, the head much farther away and thus foreshortened by perspective.

With his knowledge of perspective, he adjusted the proportions of The David so that, despite being viewed from below, it appears as though the viewer is on the same plane as the piece, seeing it "head on" rather than "looking up" - and the proportions look normal, until you get fairly close to it. It's really amazing that he pulled off this subtle effect so well. This genius paid attention to details.

While we turn to a pleasing SIDE VIEW PROFILE, we normally view a piece, on a shelf or pedestal - viewing from above.

If, while turning, we kept checking the look of the piece, as seen from slightly above it and from two or three feet away - rather than the normal side view we use - how might that change the SIDE VIEW profile?

Just wondering,

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#2

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VI

phillip medghalchi

Charlie, I never thought of that, however, when I turn, I usually take the piece out of the lathe few times and bring it in to my wife who has a degree in art and very good eyes for shapes and get her opinion on the shape or the feel of it. This has served me well and also by not rushing to finish the piece in an evening time I happened to learn about the particular wood's movement and what it does when I bring it in to the house and the air conditioned environment. I used to panic about the cracks as soon as I rough turned a piece and brought it in, however, by being a procrastinator i am learning that with patience the wood will close up somewhat and you can finally bring it to a decent shape and finish it.

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#3

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VI

Dale Bonertz

Charlie,

I think you answered your own question. Michelangelo new the location it would be displayed and the vantage point that people would view it. What we make, that would be an assumption that our pieces are looked down upon. I have seen pieces displayed on tables (down view), in cabinets or wall shelves (standing eye level or up view). Actually that is part of the beauty and excitement of what we make, in my opinion, that it can be displayed at different view points which gives the piece a renewed interest. As I have always heard as I started collecting art was to rehang paintings, move sculptures, vases, carvings and etc. This puts the piece in a different location and in different light so it gives it more or different view/interest. At worse you no longer take the piece for granted where it is located and you start re looking at the pieces with renewed interest. That is what was said to me - do I do it - yes but with only about 30% to 50% of the works I own. Not nearly enough for what I feel I should be doing or not nearly as often.

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#4

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VI

Bob Edwards

I have trouble visualizing a piece in the upright position while turning it in the horizontal. I have taken to photographing the piece with my phone camera while the piece is on the lathe. I can then view it from any position I wand and makie adjustments on the fly.

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#5

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VI

david

Bob:

The situation you describe was pointed out to us by Don Derry in a demo a couple of weeks ago. Not something some of us already knew--the piece, say a bowl, looks different when horizontal on the lathe than when vertical when completed and upright because the frames of reference while horizontal--tool rest, bed of the lathe, even a view of the horizon--are different when the bowl is sitting upright; much less than when viewed at an angle too. Yes, it is a perception thing; the eyes are playing tricks with our brain.

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#6

Don Leydens

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VI

Don Leydens

Charlie, that's a GREAT question you brought up. Of coarse knowing the final position of showing the piece would be great, but I think most work is displayed so the viewer will be looking down, or slightly down on the work.

I just finished a little hollow form that looks top heavy when viewed from above, but looks cute and well proportioned from the side. Something to think about for sure. Thanks for addressing this question and I look forward to hearing other folks input.

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#7

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VI

Wally Dickerman

Charlie, good form is good form as viewed from any angle. I would never change a form because it MIGHT be viewed from a certain angle. Galleries and collectors display art work from all angles. I have a modest collection of other turners work. It is displayed on shelves at various heights.

Re: Design in SIDE VIEW, View in more of an ISO VIEW

#8

Clay Foster's Pedestal Series

charlie belden

Wally:

Re: controlling the viewer's vantage point

Clay Foster's pedestal pieces pretty much set the viewing angle (and carve out space for itself in the process, even when displayed with a lot of other pieces). His low "Ripples" series - a rock or cast concrete, a wood wedge shape balanced on it and a bowl sitting on the wedge pretty much dictate how it will be displayed pretty much by its weight and size. Ain't gonna see one of them displayed in a Curio Cabinet or on a shelf or table.

A lot of Stony Lamar's pieces dictate how they will be viewed.

Lindquist the Elder's big pieces had to stand on the floor.

Re: Good Form is Good Form (regardless of viewing angle - or scale?)

I'm not sure that Good Form Is Good Form is always true - especially near the extremes, miniatures on one end and BIG on the other. I think at the far ends of the scale there's possibly a different set of aesthetic "rules" or norms. If a piece is within the "normal" size range of a particular form it is judged against other similar form and the aesthetics of those form. But at the ends of the scale spectrum, something else seems to happen, in part because we have fewer prior examples at that scale to compare it against.

Miniatures seem to have their own aesthetics. They're seen more like small gems than as a bowl, or vase or hollow form. I think very large pieces are also seen in a different way. Neither seem to be "measured" against familiar "rulers" - small things are measured in fractions of an inch or decimal inches, normal sized turnings are measured in inches, LARGE pieces are measured in feet. That may be just one difference between the scale of the piece.

It could be that it has to do with the viewer's ability to view a piece from multiple vantages points. With a normal sized piece that means moving a bit around the piece. With large pieces you may have to step back to take it all in or walk around it to see a side or back (if single axis turnings have a front, sides and back). With miniatures, you want to hold it between thumb and forefinger or in the palm of your hand - up close - much closer than with a normal sized piece.

I'm doing some SketchUp models of three variations of a hollow form with small opening, with variations of each where only the vertical proportions are changed - stretching the form upward. I'm then taking screen shots of the sets of pieces viewed from the side and then of the same set of pieces viewed from various angles to see how how the apparent proportions change as the viewing angle changes. Will post some illustrated examples, and maybe a link to a YouTube video to show what I find - if anything