Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

best grind for a skew

Posts

best grind for a skew

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

best grind for a skew

Jack Guzman from Maine

My go to skew is a 3/4" oval.It came with a slanted edge and a flat bevel. I have tried other shapes to get better performance and now I'm lost. What is a good grind for optimal performance for spindle turning? I tried a hollow grind and screwed the edge right up. I think my bevel angle is too sharp also but I can't get any definite info on this. All I read is general information and it's all over the place. No definite guidelines.I'm just getting comfortable with the skew.This angle business is holding me back.---Jack

Re: best grind for a skew

#2

Re: best grind for a skew *LINK*

david

This article from Alan Lacer should answer your questions: http://woodturninglearn.net/handouts/ho-skew_chisels.html


Alan lacer article

Re: best grind for a skew

#3

Re: best grind for a skew

Doc Green

Jack, here's an article on how I sharpen a skew:

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/sharpskew.html

Re: best grind for a skew

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: best grind for a skew

Jack Guzman from Maine

That is the kind of stuff I've been reading. He tells me that I have the wrong tool. Also I don't understand his description of the shape of it. I have a rectangular/flat skew but I couldn't get it to work for me and I read that an oval skew was easier to use so I got one. It helped but it needed sharpening and I couldn't get the edge right so here we are. I still have no idea what the shape of the edge should be,just general information.

I was hoping that someone with experience could help me understand how to sharpen and hone my skew.---Jack

Re: best grind for a skew

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

That's it!

Jack Guzman from Maine

That is just what I was looking for. Thanks Doc.---Jack

Re: best grind for a skew

#6

Re: That's it! *LINK*

John Lucas

Doesn't really matter. I worked with 17 different skews for the last 2 years and it's more about being sharp and lots of practice than it is about shape of the grind. I tried hollow grind, flat grind, convex grind, rounded cutting edge, straight cutting edge, flat chisel like angle vs the traditional 45 degree angle and everything from 20 degree included bevel to almost 90 degree included bevel. They all function differently but every one of the is good in the right hands.

My personal choice. A straight edge just because it's easier to sharpen than curved edges. Hollow grind because it's easier to hone accurately, About 35 degree included bevel because it's just a good all around compromise between the really sharp but fragile 20 degree edge and the longer lasting but not as sharp 45 or 60 degree edge.


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFlZyGKYro4

Re: best grind for a skew

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: That's it!

Jack Guzman from Maine

Helpful video. I'm going to do some practice tomorrow armed with all this new info. thanks---Jack

Re: best grind for a skew

#8

Re: best grind for a skew

Greg Haugen

Part of the issue you've had Jack is that 99% of turning is personal preference, aka "opinions". If you read an article from Alan Lacer and then one from Nick Cook, you'll be completely lost and start to turn bowls. :-) I live an hour and a half drive from Alan Lacer, been to his house twice for 1 on 1 instruction during my pursuit of the skew. I have also spent some time with Nick Cook and one of my friends in the turning community is Brian Simmons, who apprenticed under Nick Cook. My three spindle turning mentors, all have a different skew configuration that they prefer, and if you add mine, you'd get four different methods from four turners. Any time you read an article or watch a demo the main thing you should strive to take away is "why". "Why" do they like this angle or grind better than that one, "Why" does it work for this application and not that one. If you understand why the Lacer grind works, you'll understand why the "straight" grinds work. Also "why" doesn't it work? A catch is because the cutting edge past the center like of the skew and the toe self fed into the wood. A skate is because the bevel was lifted and the edge became unsupported and it skated back. Once you understand the "why" you'll be able to translate it to other tools and applications. The key to any of them is "sharp". Everyone basically agrees that you've got to do something to a skew beyond a grinder wheel; be it honing, stroping, or Tormek-ing. I agree with John Lucas, there are several combinations that work well-there's none that are bad. My preference is a straight, hollow grind with the standard included angle of 20 degrees, with the tool measuring 70 degrees toe to heal. I like the heal a little more forward for beads. Oval skews, due to their profile, don't do well with the radius grinds. Having the two points of contact of a hollow grind for honing will aid in the process and makes it more efficient. If you don't have one, I'd recommend one of the safe drives. Either a Stebcenter, a Stebcenter knock off, or Oneway's Safe Driver. They're centers that will let the wood slip in the event of a catch. You'll be able to concentrate more on the turning and not be tensed up waiting for the next catch. The best combination/method for skews is the ONE that is SHARP and that you use. The skew is like a piano. You have to learn the notes and chords before you play a song. Just turn with a skew, and turn, and turn. Don't make anything but shavings starting out. Roll beads from the drive to the live center, then use a planing cut and plane them off. Then do it some more. Once your piece of wood is thin, try using your finger as a steady and challenge yourself to see how thin you can get it before it breaks (and it will just drop, no safety issue). IF you have some one nearby see if you can set up some turning time. A mentor can point out small, slight corrections that will make a big difference much quicker than trying to go at trial and error.

Sharpen, practice, sharpen, practice.

Mainly, Have fun. :-)

Any questions, please ask away.

Re: best grind for a skew

#9

Re: best grind for a skew

George Van Beynen

Well said Greg, I like your why approach.

Re: best grind for a skew

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: best grind for a skew

Jack Guzman from Maine

Unfortunately I'm pretty isolated here in my particular eden/backwoods of Maine.Clubs and such are out of my range so my point of contact is the internet. I am grateful to Ellis for this place.

I'm sure I will get it with practice and help from people like you. Thanks for the input.---Jack

Re: best grind for a skew

#11

Re: best grind for a skew

John Lucas

Jack you can find all of my videos by going to www.youtube.com and typing in john60lucas. I have at least 3 on skew usage. Most are geared toward practicing with the skew to get you over the learning curve.

Re: best grind for a skew

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: best grind for a skew

Mike Stafford

Jack, I am first and foremost not a skew chisel expert but I have benefitted from Alan Lacer's videos, The Skew Chisel: The Dark Side and The Sweet Side and his follow-up video The Son of Skew. He does spend a great deal of time extoling the virtues of a curved skew in his videos and being a faithful learner I shaped my skews accordingly.

His videos show lots of good information on the use of the tool, sharpening, shaping the edge and honing. I continue to practice my skills and try to use my skew more and more. As others have said sharpening and practice are the secrets to this tool.

Re: best grind for a skew

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: best grind for a skew

Jack Guzman from Maine

Actually,links to them come up when you open the link you posted earlier.Good stuff. Class is now in session.---Jack