Re: best grind for a skew
Greg Haugen
Part of the issue you've had Jack is that 99% of turning is personal preference, aka "opinions". If you read an article from Alan Lacer and then one from Nick Cook, you'll be completely lost and start to turn bowls. :-) I live an hour and a half drive from Alan Lacer, been to his house twice for 1 on 1 instruction during my pursuit of the skew. I have also spent some time with Nick Cook and one of my friends in the turning community is Brian Simmons, who apprenticed under Nick Cook. My three spindle turning mentors, all have a different skew configuration that they prefer, and if you add mine, you'd get four different methods from four turners. Any time you read an article or watch a demo the main thing you should strive to take away is "why". "Why" do they like this angle or grind better than that one, "Why" does it work for this application and not that one. If you understand why the Lacer grind works, you'll understand why the "straight" grinds work. Also "why" doesn't it work? A catch is because the cutting edge past the center like of the skew and the toe self fed into the wood. A skate is because the bevel was lifted and the edge became unsupported and it skated back. Once you understand the "why" you'll be able to translate it to other tools and applications. The key to any of them is "sharp". Everyone basically agrees that you've got to do something to a skew beyond a grinder wheel; be it honing, stroping, or Tormek-ing. I agree with John Lucas, there are several combinations that work well-there's none that are bad. My preference is a straight, hollow grind with the standard included angle of 20 degrees, with the tool measuring 70 degrees toe to heal. I like the heal a little more forward for beads. Oval skews, due to their profile, don't do well with the radius grinds. Having the two points of contact of a hollow grind for honing will aid in the process and makes it more efficient. If you don't have one, I'd recommend one of the safe drives. Either a Stebcenter, a Stebcenter knock off, or Oneway's Safe Driver. They're centers that will let the wood slip in the event of a catch. You'll be able to concentrate more on the turning and not be tensed up waiting for the next catch. The best combination/method for skews is the ONE that is SHARP and that you use. The skew is like a piano. You have to learn the notes and chords before you play a song. Just turn with a skew, and turn, and turn. Don't make anything but shavings starting out. Roll beads from the drive to the live center, then use a planing cut and plane them off. Then do it some more. Once your piece of wood is thin, try using your finger as a steady and challenge yourself to see how thin you can get it before it breaks (and it will just drop, no safety issue). IF you have some one nearby see if you can set up some turning time. A mentor can point out small, slight corrections that will make a big difference much quicker than trying to go at trial and error.
Sharpen, practice, sharpen, practice.
Mainly, Have fun. :-)
Any questions, please ask away.