Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Club lifespan?

Posts

Club lifespan?

#1

Steven Antonucci

Club lifespan?

steven antonucci

What do you think is the average lifespan of a woodturning club? Do you see people losing interest over time and attending fewer meetings? Do you think people become more picky as to which meetings they will attend based upon the demonstration or topic for the event?

Steve

Re: Club lifespan?

#2

Re: Club lifespan?

Denis Lalonde

Our club (Durham Woodworking Club) in Oshawa, Ontario has been going for over 26 years and still going strong with lots of interest...

Re: Club lifespan?

#3

Re: Club lifespan?

John Lucas

So far everything just keeps going and even growing. I belong to 3 clubs. The biggest has about 125 members. A lot of members have changed over the last 20 years but it's stayed about the same.

The club in Crossville is roughly 15 years old and has steadily been growing. It's up to about 40 now.

The club in Cookeville is also growing very slowly. It's about 8 years old and had about 25 members.

In Tennessee in general we had 2 clubs 20 years ago. Now there are 10 if I didn't miss any.

So maybe there will be a lifespan in the future but so far at least in this state they just keep growing.

Re: Club lifespan?

#4

Re: Club lifespan?

Dale Gillaspy

I think it's just the opposite. Our club is expanding. We have a ton of interest, keep adding new members and new activities. We just had our most successful symposium ever (Thanks in part to John Lucas) and are getting ready for the AAW Symposium here next year. It may fizzle at some point, but things are looking bright right now.

Re: Club lifespan?

#5

Re: Club lifespan?

David Walser

I think club members may have a lifespan rather than the clubs themselves. That is, new turners likely hope to get different things out of club membership than do more experianced turners. If the club only provides things that are of interest to newbies, members are apt to drift away as they become more experianced turners. The club itself may continue to grow -- more newbies join each year than experianced turners drift away -- it just won't have many long-term members.

I don't think things need to go that way. Our local club provides a healthy mix of demonstrations and other offerings that are attractive to both experianced and new turners. Many of the members have been coming for more than five years. But, several people who welcomed me into the club 10 years ago no longer attend. Some no longer turn. Others turn but no longer find attending club meetings attractive for one reason or another. It's difficult to meet the needs of the spectrum of turners. No doubt some clubs do that better than others. None do it perfectly.

Re: Club lifespan?

#6

Steven Antonucci

Overall, growing...but?

steven antonucci

What I have noticed in my past 5 or 6 years as a very active member is that some of the long time members stay active, some of the active members take a step back, and some of the new members sort of disappear after a couple of years...

I realize that not everyone can make every meeting, but I was just wondering if the "club thing" was mostly interesting to "new members/turners"? I know that we have some people in our club that won't come to a meeting unless it's a big name turner demonstrating.

Just wondered if the luster wore off after a couple of years...

Steve

Re: Club lifespan?

#7

Re: Overall, growing...but?

David Walser

Steve - As I said in a prior post in this thread, I think what a member hopes to get out of club membership changes over time. For most new turners, what they're looking for most is information about how to turn in general and how to make specfic projects. Once one has the basics down, membership has to offer something in addition to information or the member's desires are not going to be met.

For many turners, the opportunity to rub shoulders with other turners and to see what others are doing is enough. Others want still more -- such as the opportunity to give back by mentoring new turners, the chance to demo at public events, the ability to serve in club leadership, etc. To keep these turners active in the club, the club has to proved more than just information.

Re: Club lifespan?

#8

Steven Antonucci

Sort of my fears...?

steven antonucci

What if a club member only has a 3 year life span? What types of things can clubs be proactively doing to get more people more involved?

I can predict within +/- 2 people (and almost by name) who will/will not show for a meeting based upon what the topic is. If it is a paid demonstrator with a name, the crowd will always be larger. If it is a show and tell, we'll struggle to fill the time.

What do you do to keep people engaged?

Steve

Re: Club lifespan?

#9

Re: Sort of my fears...?

Bill Howatt

Our club has been going for in excess of 15 years and membership has increased in general.

There seems to be a core of long-time members and certainly not all the new ones keep attending. It is essential that the club keep bringing in new members or else it will decline to the long-time core. Giving demos at various events such as fairs, woodshows, tool stores helps attract new members. Often people are interested in turning but they don't think of joining a club or even know there is a club in the area.

The club has to offer things to keep the interest up and this isn't easy. How many times do you need to see a demo on turning a bowl from a chunk of tree?

Our meetings start with the business, follow on with a demo by a club member or sometimes a visitor from another club, break with coffee and doughnuts, then a show-and-tell. The show-and-tell really is that as well as a critique table where an experienced turner offers a critique of the pieces submitted. There is a challenge table which is for turnings that members were informed of at the previous meeting or earlier. "Next month's challenge is pepper-mills" for example. Often the next month challenge will be based on the current month's demo. A related challenge with this is to keep the member's talk about their piece limited in time.

All well and good but it is obvious that about 1/3 of the members leave after the demo which indicates people want to learn something that will aid their turning quest. The club is now increasing the time allocated to the demo phase so more information can be imparted.

The club also offers beginning turning classes, library of DVDs and books and brings in pro turners for demos and hands-on session for a limited number usually the next day.

And yes, like most, if not all clubs, there is a handful of members who do most of the work!

Bill

Re: Club lifespan?

#10

Re: Club lifespan?

robo hippy

Well, a few of my observations.

One, you need to bring in outside turners for demonstrations. Having club members only gets boring. This is more difficult with smaller clubs that have smaller budgets.

Two, you need workshops/saw dust sessions for improving basic skills. This is perhaps the most important for the newer turners who are trying to develop skills. Seeing a demo is one thing, but remembering what you learned by the time you get back out to the shop is another, general memory problems excluded. This would be a hands on workshop.

You need club projects. Pens for the troops is one. Empty bowls is another, Maybe even Toys for Tots, I think there is an Eagle Cane project for veterans, where cane shafts are turned by the turning club, and the carvers make eagle head handles for our wounded vets. Many non profit organizations need and want items for auction.

Other than that, some just drift away if there isn't some learning and recruiting efforts. I have seen our club, now 12 years old or so, can't remember, grow, then shrink, then grow and shrink. Still going fairly strong though.

robo hippy

Re: Club lifespan?

#11

Re: Club lifespan?

Fred Holder

I have belonged to two woodturning clubs since early 1996: The Seattle Woodturners (in 1995) and the Northwest Washington Woodturners (started in February 1996). The Seattle group was going fairly strong when I joined it. There were a number of members who lived North of Seattle and had to drive 50 to 70 miles to get to the meetings. Many of those people complained about the driving distance. I had to drive 50 miles.

So one day in February 1996, I rented a room at the Mount Vernon, Washington Senior Center and sent letters to everyone North of Everett, Washington inviting them to a meeting to form a club. 19 people showed up and we formed a club that night. That club is still growing and doing fine. I believe it has over 100+ members today. The Seattle club is still going great and also has about 100+ members.

Both clubs use as many demonstrators from outside of the club as possible. Both have Sawdust Saturday's each month and in my opinion are doing well. They also have periodic all day demonstrations with excellent teachers.

Re: Club lifespan?

#12

Dick Hines

Re: Club lifespan?

Dick Hines

Tidewater Turners in Norfolk just celebrated their 25 year. Richmond Woodturners just started their 17th,.

Re: Club lifespan?

#13

Chuck Jones - West TN

Our local club just turned 4 years old.

Chuck Jones - West TN

Like John, I belong to three Tennessee clubs, two in the big cities of Memphis and Nashville, and a local club that I helped start in Jackson (West Tennessee Woodturners). (btw John I count 11 clubs in TN).

I'm a relatively new turner and I'm most active in the Jackson club so I can't offer much about longevity. But we have 44 paid up members and average 25-30 each meeting. Some turnover; probably about 10 who joined then left.

I must say that when I initiated the start of the West Tennessee club I was not optimistic about attracting a large crowd. Based on the demographics I just couldn't imagine a lot of interest. Glad I was wrong.

We get a lot of help from Memphis and Nashville and John Lucas has been a huge help to us since the outset. He's made the 400 mile round trip more than once for demos etc.

Can't think of much we do that hasn't already been mentioned.

So, bottom line we have grown fast, still have a high level of interest and participation. Don't know where it will go from here.

This is a worthwhile discussion to have.

Re: Club lifespan?

#14

Re: Club lifespan?

Dale Bonertz

I am not sure how old our club is but it is going strong. I joined about eleven or twelve years ago and it was in existence long before that. As a matter a fact the very first AAW symposium was held in Fort Collins at Colorado State University. I feel what holds members interest is having demonstrations by outside turners (professional and others alike). Also think outside the bowl demo. We have had demo's on cutting logs into blanks (not actually using chainsaw), metal spinning for enhancement, gold leafing, a professional arborist came in and spoke about harvesting wood, airbrushing, band saw use and maintenance and etc. There are so many things related to wood turning that it is nice to see how others do those things. You always pick up something out of these demonstrations and even another bowl demonstration.

Re: Club lifespan?

#15

we have a demo every month


Re: Club lifespan?

#16

Rob Wallace

Slight Correction...AAW Symposium

Rob Wallace

The first AAW Symposium was held in 1987 in Lexington, Kentucky, just after the formation of the AAW in 1986.

The AAW Symposium held at Colorado State in Ft. Collins was the 8th Symposium in 1994.

For a brief overview of past AAW symposia see:

http://www.woodturner.org/sym/all_symposia.htm

BTW - there's still "plenty of room in the pool" for anyone still considering attending the 27th annual AAW International Woodturning Symposium in Tampa at the end of June. We were informed at the last telephonic Board meeting that we have over 1,000 registered for the symposium, with additional registrations still coming in. It's being held at a great venue, and is sure to be an excellent woodturning experience.

To borrow from Nike's advertizing: "JUST DO IT!"

See: http://www.woodturner.org/sym/sym2013/index.htm

Rob

Re: Club lifespan?

#17

Re: Club lifespan?

Ralph Lindberg

I've been a member of the local club for a few years now, and an officer for most of those years. I'm the guy scheduling the programs now, and I can certainly see the attendance vary by who I can get.

Something big, gets a great showing, something small, gets a small showing. Due to the insurance "thing" I had to do several "related" events this winter, attendance was soft.

As for club growth, we get about 20 "new" members a year, we lose 18 or 19 a year, so we are gaining one or two a year. Most of our "losses" are new people losing interest. We lose one of our core members or so a year to death, we lose another or so to moving.

But the bottom line, we are gaining one or two members a year (total), every year.

Given the over-all economy, I would expect this trend to either continue or improve (if you haven't heard recreational sales, boats, RVs, etc are recovering strongly, so I expect hobby spending to be strong also)

Re: Club lifespan?

#18

Steven Antonucci

interesting stats

steven antonucci

Not sure what our mix is (new/left/moved/departed), but I suspect that it is about right alongside yours...

The one thing I notice is that we never seem to do anything "new" to change the retention issue. With dues only being $25, it is a pretty easy investment to walk away from. if 20% of the membership is walking away, you'd think that might be worth figuring out?

Steve

Re: Club lifespan?

#19

Re: Club lifespan?

Jeff Brockett

The Tennessee Association of Woodturners has been around for 26 years and continues to grow with right at 150 or so paid members. We do a monthly demonstration, have a monthly Saturday workshop and host an annual symposium every year. Our membership is rather "gray" but I am starting to see a nice mix of younger people getting involved.

Re: Club lifespan?

#20

I wasn't gray when I joined

John Lucas

Hanging out with guys like Jeff Brockett, Mike Zinzer, Brian Clary, John Jordan and Pat Matranga (not a guy :) is what made me gray.

Re: Club lifespan?

#21

Malcolm Ray

Re: Club lifespan?

Malcolm Ray

Our club here in Maine is twenty something years old.....we were the only club in this large (landwise) state until about four or five years ago and averaged about 70 to 100 members most of the time....we have had four new clubs branch out from our membership in the last few years for a total of five in the state now.....this shortens the driving distances for many of the members,and I think is the main reason for the new ones.....they are spread all over the state now and all seem to be thriving,while we still maintain our fairly large number of members......many still come back to our club often as well as supporting their local clubs......we try to have well known turners once or twice a year and are able to get some of them when they are in the area to teach week long courses at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship nearby.....this is a bonus for us having nationally known turners in the area all summer long.......and we have several very good turners in our area who demo for us...we have a demo at every meeting,and try to have something for all levels of experience during the year......we are still going strong and enjoying every minute of it.....