Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

OSHA nightmare *LINK*

Posts

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: OSHA nightmare

Mike Stafford

What am I missing here? The link is to an ONDU Wooden Pinhole Camera..... :(

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#3

Steven Antonucci

Watch the video on the bottom


Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#4

Well -----

Galen Vetterick

Send him a monitary contribution to buy or make and send him some pushblocks of your favorite design. :D Like I've never done the same thing. ;)

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: OSHA nightmare

Mike Stafford

I am having nightmares but so far so good. At the time the video was made he still had all 10 digits.

Let me tell you something; Big Mike does not push anything through a table saw with his hands except full sheets of plywood where he is able to be more a foot away from the blade and even then I am likely to use a push block.

I am the original chicken after a woodworking friend of mine lost his thumb and 2 1/2 fingers on the table saw while ripping some oak for cabinets.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#6

Re: OSHA nightmare

John Lucas

Same here MIke. No hands anywhere near the blade. I use the table saw insert as my no hands zone but actually most of the time I don't even get close to that. I have push sticks everywhere.

Nice cameras but I never go into pinhole work. I tried but the images are just too fuzzy for my style of photography

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#7

Steven Antonucci

Am I the only one that saw...

steven antonucci

him ripping the natural edge board without a fence?

I've been too close to the blade before, and now use pushsticks and sleds for everything. I have never considered freehand ripping, though. Looks like a great way to bleed.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#8

Hands Free

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I've met 4-5 trim carpenters who think nothing of striking a chalk line and ripping a board with no fence. One of them I know had fingers broken in a kick-back, but he persists. Another resaws on a portable ts with out a fence. When asked they have all told me "That's the way I learned, been doin' it for 20 years. Field work is different from you woodworking guys."

Riiiiight . . . . .

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#9

Re: Ah, it ain't so bad ...

Doc Green

You can do freehand ripping on a tablesaw safely as long as ...

1. There is adequate set in the blade;

2. The lumber is not stressed so that it tends to close up on the blade;

3. The lumber is flat - no warp, cup, or twist;

4. You don't tend to "over-steer" the cut.

5. You keep the wood pressed down against the table.

You can get in big trouble with a tablesaw, even when using a fence and all the push sticks in the shop by ...

1. Trying to cut a warped or twisted board;

2. Failing to keep the board pressed down flat against the table, as in pushing with a stick against the side of the board to keep it against the fence, and pushing against the end to move it through the cut;

3. Cutting a small piece of wood that is almost square - if it gets trapped between the blade and the fence, it will come at you in a hurry. You can get the same effect by trying to push a rectangular piece between the blade and the fence if there is insufficient bearing surface against the fence.

4. Not paying attention to what you're doing.

5. Having a bowl blank roll off the table onto your foot.

Push sticks ... ? I've heard an argument that it's better to work with fewer push sticks so you can maintain a better grip on the wood.

Just my thoughts. Comments, anyone?

~Doc

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#10

Comment?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You cut bowl blanks on a table saw?

Reeeely?

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Ah, it ain't so bad ...

Mike Stafford

All of the things you said are true but it is the responsibility of the user to make sure he/she is not doing those things.

I have never had any of those things happen. I am a big chicken and after my friend lost his fingers I learned everything I could about how to set up my table saw and operate it safely.

I did have a 3 ounce box blank fall over on my hand one time..... That was pretty scary. :b

I have seen my father rip a board free handed but I never did it and never would.

I built a carrier for my "crooked" boards to get straight edges. Running a warped board through a table saw is a no-no. You are supposed to get the faces flat and parallel before ripping. If neither of the edges are straight you can joint one or use a carrier to rip a straight edge. There is a sequence to preparing a board for use and it was developed by people smarter than me to ensure that the operations were as safe as possible.

Practically everything in your list are things that you are not supposed to do in the first place.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#12

Re: No Way ...  !!!

Doc Green

No way would I try cutting a bowl blank on a tablesaw. However, I have been known to pile a few, and sometimes a few too many, on top of it.

Heck, using a bandsaw to cut a bowl blank gives me a little bit of a fright. But give me a good-cuttin' chain saw, and I'll rip that thing right out for you.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#13

Re: OSHA nightmare

robo hippy

I would pass on most of his 'tool technique'. Maybe that is why I still have all my fingers, and minor scars. He is obviously self taught. Probably hasn't read much either.

robo hippy

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#14

Re: Ah, it ain't so bad ...

Dale Bonertz

OK I am one of those field guys with all ten digits that rips without a fence whenever I have to. It is hard to use a sled with a bench type table saw on the job and maintain a production flow. You don't have to often rip things at angles but it is nice to have that skill. Push sticks can be one of those false sense of security things so be careful. I have seen them break while in use, slip off the wood being pushed and other issues as Doc mentioned. In my opinion you are better off what I term as the finger rule. If the blade can be touch with your index finger after clamping two fingers over the fence then use a push stick (this is usually about 2" to 2 1/2" from the blade). If you cannot touch the blade then it is safe to push the wood through with your fingers as long as the blade does not protude more than 1/8" over the piece being cut and you use two fingers over the fence to lock them from moving sideways into the blade. Kick back can be just as bad with a push stick as it can be holding the piece sometimes worse. You have more control holding the piece than with a push stick. If you feel tension, when holding the piece, stop feeding the wood and turn the machine off.

What I noticed as the biggest no no in the video was having the table saw blade running about 1/2" over the piece being cut. You only need that blade just high enough to cut through the piece and nothing more.

Just my 2c.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#15

Mike Stafford

Re: Ah, it ain't so bad ...

Mike Stafford

Dale, all true but I have been woodworking for almost 50 years. I have been well served by my rules of never using my hands.

Never had any incidents like those you described. But then again I am particularly careful as a woodworker or at least try to be.

I will say this, you professionals possess more skill and experience than the average weekend warrior which is how I would classify myself. You can do things, much like my father who made his living at carpentry, that the average Joe should not try.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#16

Rob Wallace

That unguarded jointer....

Rob Wallace

....would scare the bajeezus out of me, let alone his table saw "technique".

No way would I ever allow this guy to "instruct" anyone..... Good thing there are only two guys in the shop - OSHA would have a field day if this place was in the USA and had sufficient number of employees to mandate compliance.

Maybe we'll read about these guys some day in the future as winners of Darwin Awards?

Rob

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#17

Re: OSHA nightmare

Jim Breeden

When I was in the seventh grade, somewhere in the neighborhood of 50 years ago, my shop teacher taught me well, as he only had an index finger and thumb on his right hand. Never lost that thought. :b

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#18

Rob Wallace

Re: OSHA nightmare

Rob Wallace

Jim:

When I moved to my present location 23 years ago, I joined the local woodworking club within a few months of arriving. At the first meeting I attended as a new member, a long-time member walked up to me and extended his right hand to shake mine - it was devoid of an index finger and half of a middle finger - he then said, "Welcome to the Ames Woodworkers Club!".

After shaking his partial hand and smiling, I thought to myself, "What have I gotten myself into?". That too has always served as a subliminal reminder - a little fear is a good thing, especially when it pumps the adrenaline and causes you to focus and think out what you are about to do!

Rob Wallace

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#19

Leo Cuellar

I draw the line at

Leo Cuellar

freehand ripping. While I wouldn't be worried about my fingers, as much as the nasty headache from having the board smack me in the face, if it decided to bind or my footing faltered. Having seen a table saw punch a piece of wood through a cinder block, I try not to stand behind narrow stock. :D

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#20

Re: Ah, it ain't so bad ...

Dale Bonertz

Totally agree with you there. Weekend warriors should not try some techniques. Please keep in mind someones background in experience. When I speak about such things it serves the reader to know that I spent 11 years working in a wood window and door manufacturing facility and about 20 years as a remodeling contractor. I have seen so many more bad accidents in the manufacturing field than the remodeling field. In manufacturing they are taught push sticks and many other techniques but do to the volume of time spent on equipment things happen, even things you could not imagine should happen. In remodeling believe it or not they're generally small accidents like utility knife cuts, hammer on thumb, twist an ankle, backs and etc.

In conclusion I am not saying push sticks should not be used but in general it is safer to hold a piece by hand if you can. You need to learn when you can and for some that will be 6 inches from the blade or more distance. BTW the safest method is use good feather boards to hold the piece down and in and use a good push stick. When sawing they are not always feasible.

Play/work safe everyone.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#21

You hit the perverbial nail on the head

Dale Bonertz

STAY FOCUSED

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#22

Safety Culture

Steve Kniffen

When OSHA was founded in 1970, what we see in this video was common in this country, too. If a machine had a guard on it, it was removed because it was just in the way. Even after OSHA came along, because so many woodworking businesses were small operations, they were not regulated. This was not unusual, even 20 years ago.

As a safety professional, it's nice to see the shift from "this is the way we've always done it" to "are you kidding me?" It shows we are developing a safety culture where we expect an employee to come to work 5 days a week for 30 years and go home with all his fingers and toes, still able to see and hear. We no longer are willing to accept common accidents as the cost of doing business. Culture change generally takes about a generation and a half, so we're just about there since the foundation of OSHA.

A very wise instructor pilot once taught me that there are times in our careers when have or will take a short cut or violate a safety procedure either because we need to so we can get the job done or because we want to for some other reason. His advice to me was to use those times as opportunities to remember why the rules were there in the first place and to increase our sense of caution while we're taking that short cut. That advice stood me well in my flying career and in my woodworking, too.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#23

Re: OSHA nightmare

Steve Kniffen

Just proves that one one's totally worthless, he can always serve as a bad example.

In many areas, I've learned more from the bad examples I've encountered than from the good ones.

Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#24

Ellis Walentine

Missing from this conversation

Ellis Walentine

... is the definition of pushstick. I have been using tablesaws safely for almost 50 years, and I now use a "boot style" push stick exclusively. It elevates your hand above the blade, but, most importantly, it applies pressure downward onto the leading edge of the workpiece at the same time as it pushes the back of the piece down. Made from any scrap of plywood, it can be run right through the blade, as when ripping very thin slivers off a board, supporting both the main piece and the cutoff. By making the notch very shallow, you can rip very thin stock, too.

I have them in all sizes and shapes for any ripping job that might come along. The old birds-mouth style push sticks have always scared me, so I just don't use them anymore.

Ellis


Re: OSHA nightmare *LINK*

#25

Mike Stafford

Me too!

Mike Stafford

I have push sticks in lots of sizes and lengths. Like I said before I don't use my hands except to load the wood on the table.