Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Posts

Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#1

Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Craig Daymon

I was working on the finial for a lidded bowl today. Here's a pic of the unfinished piece.


The finial has a recessed bead in the center of it. It was pretty challenging/frustrating to turn. I really like the look of this finial, so I'd like to figure out the best way to turn a recessed bead in end grain. Any help would be welcome.

Thanks,

Craig

I'll post pics of the completed box later. I've recessed a Saueracker shell (see Darlow's 2nd book) turning in the center of the base and plan to flock the inside so it can be used by its intended owner for jewelry. The box is Purpleheart, the shell is Camphor Burl, the lid is Masur Birch and the finial is Bois de Rose.

Critiques are welcome.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#2

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

John Lucas

Not sure what you mean by recessed bead. Are you talking about a cove?

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#3

Brad Vietje

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Brad Vietje

Craig,

Like John, I wondered just what you meant. If you can be sure we understand the question, I'm sure you can get good advice here at WC.

Are you referring to a bead like the one shown, essentially at the bottom of a cove or "recess"? Also, you used the phrase "end grain"... Is the finial oriented with the wood fibers running along its length, as most spindle pieces are, so a cut across the top surface of the finial is a cut across all end grain?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#4

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Doug

If you look closely at the top of the finial you can see what he is referring to. It is a small bead in the center of the finial. It looks like a BB in the center with a groove around it. I imagine it's hard to cut the groove around the bead because you are cutting end grain.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#5

Mike Stafford

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Mike Stafford

Craig, there are several ways to cut that recessed bead in the end of your handle. You can scrape it out very nicely with sharp pointed skew; you can use a small detail or spindle gouge ground to a small point and cut it; or you can use a point tool to cut/scrape it out.

As small as your bead appears to be I imagine a 1/4" point tool or a finely pointed and sharpened skew might be your best bets. I usually use a finely pointed detail gouge to form most of the beads in handles for boxes I turn but your handle appears to be smaller in diameter than the handle I turn which is usually not an additional piece of wood but formed from the original blank.

I am sure others can offer other suggestions as there are many ways to skin a cat....I am told.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#6

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

david

Like Mike said, there are many ways to do this. I would, using the tools others have suggested, saturate the area with CA glue and when it hardens turn up the speed of the lathe. In the very center where the bead is, the rotation is at its slowest.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#7

Exactly.


Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#8

Finial is about 1/2" at top and 3/4" at bottom

Craig Daymon

The lidded bowl is about 6" in diameter. It's not that small a finial, just looks like it if you think of it as a Mike Stafford sized box. Probably close to what Mike might put on a box.

Scraping didn't work all that well with the rosewood. Cuts great, though challenging going into the recess around the bead (half sphere). Caught a couple times at the base of the bead, forcing a re-turn.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Brad Vietje

Craig,

Of course, Mike and David are right -- there are different ways to accomplish the same end result.

I would probably try turning it with a long-bevel detail gouge, and might mess it up, and then would probably end up doing the following:

1. Turn the finial with all your best creativity;

2. Turn a recess in the tip;

3. Drill a small hole at center of the recess;

4. Sand, finish, polish, and set aside.

5. Turn a perfect little bead on a small tenon in standard spindle orientation, sizing the tenon to fit the drilled hole -- same wood or a contrasting species;

6. Sand, finish, polish, and part off.

7. Carefully glue the bead's little tenon into the drilled hole.

Maybe that's not all all what you had in mind, but it might work very well. YMMV ;~)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Finial is about 1/2" at top and 3/4" at bottom

Mike Stafford

Sometimes you can form little details like this bead with a finely sharpened thin parting tool. If you think of the edge of the parting tool like the edge of the skew you can roll a small bead pretty nicely in end grain.

If scraping a rosewood didn't work you might try increasing the speed. I find dense exotics respond well to speed.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#11

Steven Antonucci

Also... do it first!

steven antonucci

If I wanted to make any element in the top of the knob, I'd do it while I still had all of the support of the wood thickness. It will likely cut cleaner if you di it first.

Steve

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#12

Re: Also... do it first!

Craig Daymon

Already took that into consideration. That's why I was able to recover from the early mistakes.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#13

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Craig Daymon

That may very well be the optimal approach. I had contemplated it as I was thinking about a contrasting bead. Though I would like to be able to do it just using good tool control (and the right tool).

Maybe that narrow point tool from Cindy Drozda? Pretty much the same as the one sold for the Elf tool. Either would be easy to make.

Thanks all for the input.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#14

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

eliot feldman

I believe Steven Antonucci has it exactly right: you shouldn't have the slightest problem turning this little bead if you start with lots of wood support. I'll bet dollars to doughnuts that any problems you had came about because you waited until the finial was near finished before you started to cut the bead , and you ran into vibration problems.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#15

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Craig Daymon

And you'd lose. The issue I had was getting the point of the turning tool caught in the bottom of the recess around the bead, cutting into end grain.

It was rosewood, nice and oily, and was very easy to use 2 fingers to steady for any final adjustments made. Basically in the area of the bead on the stem, not the end grain bead. The bead on the end grain was the first thing turned.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#16

D-Way beader

Jim Sebring

You might take a look at the unique beading tools Dave Schweizer has for sale. I've been pleased the last couple of weeks with the 1/16, 1/8, and 3/16 inch tools he sells. www.d-waytools.com .

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#17

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

matt overton

I have found Cindy Drozda's vortex tool to be my go to tool in this type of detail situation.

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#18

Re: D-Way beader

Craig Daymon

They're not unique. I already have a similar set. Had them for years, though I haven't put handles on them yet. (They came unhandled.) I thought they were Henry Taylor, but I may be wrong. Ashley Iles makes some of the same type as well. (May have been the maker of mine, but I don't think so. Think I got them from Craft Supplies several years back.) Craft Supplies sells the Ashley Iles ones (handled).

I've also seen jobber bits (drill bits) ground to be used this way. You can get those in very small sizes to make very fine beads.

These probably wouldn't work for my use as the right side of the bead is not turning in the correct direction. Though it could be done carefully. Like using a divider compass to mark a diameter in end grain. Touch the left side to cut and use the right side to visually align. (Though I've managed to catch the compass doing that more than a few times.)

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#19

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

elit feldman

Well, win some, loose some. I still can't see why there would be much trouble using a small skew to get around the far side of the bead; perhaps a better picture pointed into that bead would have made things clearer. Sure is a nice bowl, though. Is it purple heart?

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

#20

Re: Recessed bead in end grain - best way to cut?

Craig Daymon

Yep. I listed all the woods in the first post.. I'll post better pics when it's done. (Maybe even in-focus pics.)