Very new to turning, and to shaping or sharpening turning tools. How good will my old Tormek be for this, and are any particular jigs good nough to warrant their cost?
I'm considering just rigging a substantial platform to allow a tool to be manipulated, to get radius grinds.
Thanks for any insight. (I searched on Tormek, and looked at grinds in Odds&Ends.)
The tormek (any version) is great for sharpening. It is a bit slow if you want to change the geometry of your tools. the jig depend on what you are going to sharpen. If a skew or scraper and good flat surface will suffice. For a bowl gouge with swept wings you need the jig I belive it is or was 185.
1.) Buy the jigs (yeah they are expensive, but the work is done)
2.) Find the jigs and make your own or something really close to it. Drilling a hole that is the size of the cross bar will likely be the hardest thing you have to do.
I have the turning set, and I use them all of the time to sharpen. You will find that you don't need a lot of variety and adjustability, as using a Tormek to regrind a shape is not something most people commonly do. I am averaging about 5 years on my wheels, which equates to a million miles in my shop (I turn a lot, and sharpen more than most people do.)
I have worked with a Tormek many times and prefer to use a standard bench grinder for turning tools. The Tormek is too slow, takes too long to set up, needs special jigs, I prefer the burr off a CBN or standard grinding wheel. On the plus side the Tormek gives a sharper tool off the grinder but the sharpness advantage is short lived when you have thousands of feet of wood going by the edge every minute. If you get into turning you need a fast, repeatable, easy, and accurate grinding system. In my opinion the Tormek does none of these things well. You need to sharpen often, we must keep the tools sharp.
You will get opposing views then mine I,m sure. When you have purchased an expensive tool like the Tormek you have to justify its use. It was not designed to sharpen turning tools.
...you could buy a Woodcraft 8" low speed grinder and a 180 CBN wheel. This will accomodate any grinding of your turning tools without the damage and significant wear to your Tormek stone. Been there, done that!
I am kind of dumbfounded here in this post, Steve, as I have been in previous posts regarding your number of replacement wheels for your Tormek. Sincerely, I wonder if you may be exceptionally aggressive with your dressing stone??, or, how could someone wear out a 10" slow, wet wheel? Are you aware of other Tormek users with similar results? What diameter are those wheels when you feel that they must be replaced? Do you sharpen other than turning tools?
I ask, because I had always thought that when my "wet-Jet" wore out, I'd bite the bullet and step up to a Tormek. But...my current (and still original) wheel has only lost about 1/4" of diameter....in 6 years! (And yes, I turn nearly every day and keep my tools sharp) I am not sure, but I think today, the cost of a 2" wide, 10" diameter wheel would be more than I paid for my whole Jet set-up!
My post here is not intended to be critical in any way, of any thing that you are doing....rather, I am truly curious now, whether I would replace my Jet knock-off or not.
I agree with Jamie. The CBN wheel is a dream to use and works with any jigs on the market. It cuts fast as well as leaving a good edge. As someone else said in a post a few weeks ago. BAsed on what other owners have said it will last a very long time, never needs dressing and doesn't change size. If it does wear out it's cheaper than the Tormek stones to replace.
My stones are usually "done" at about 7". I do not dress them all that often, and I flatten them when they are about 1/8" low in the middle.
They are much softer than high speed grinder wheels, but not as soft as Japanese waterstones. They do wear considerably with the newer steels (at least my first two have?)
I may get the black wheel this time around to see if it helps any.
Using a Tormek takes no more time than a standard grinder. I'm always confused by the perception that it does?
To sharpen a tool, you put it in a jig just like any other grinder and make 2-3 passes across the wheel. Not only is the result better, but you also don't end up with all of the little black dots in your wood from your grinder burr getting embedded. And there is no heat, so no burns or damage to the structure of the steel.
The only thing a bench grinder is good for is making metal blue and go away quickly, which makes a bench grinder the worst thing for sharpening turning tools.
I have been reading all the reviews and reports on the CBN wheels and the performance sounds convincing and enticing.
But I am having a lot of trouble spending that kind of money for a sharpening stone. I can buy 4 good quality Norton 3X stones for a little more than the cost of one CBN wheel.
Does anyone have long term usage information that the CBN wheel will outlast those 4 stones? Have these CBN wheels been around long enough for that kind of wheel wear life to be established.
I am not a production turner and therefore I do not constantly sharpen my tools like they might. If I am lucky I get to turn 8-10 hours each week. However I do sharpen my tools whenever they are being used as needed and almost always after a turning session. I keep my tools very sharp. My normal stones have lasted a long time. I have been turning for almost 10 years now and have only replaced my stones twice. The set on my grinder now is almost new and I would expect to get 2-3 more years of use. Four replacements would probably give me 15-16 years of grinding at the current rate of wear.
Will the CBN wheels last that long i.e. 15-16 years? I don't have a problem buying something better than what I have as long as the "better" is cost efficient. I have not seen any information that would suggest the overall longevity is better when cost is taken into consideration.
$400 is a lot of money to this hobbyist turner which I would rather spend on wood. Shoot I might not live another 15-16 years......
....heavy CBN users is Dave Schweitzer, and he states that he has been using them in production sharpening of his tools for several years. I also have a set of Norton SG wheels in reserve, but when I had used the CBN wheels others had purchased I was especially impressed with the results. As a phrugal guy I easily understood the advantages vs the cost benefits over the old composition AO wheels for my own use, and haven't regretted the cost for a 180 grit wheel for a second, and will eventually "justify" purchase of an 80 grit wheel.
Mike in my opinion there are 2 great advantages other than life. One is never having to true it up. The second is it never changes size. I got a lot of like out of my Aluminum Oxide wheels but those were the two frustrating things. Also you need a dust mask of some kind because the AO dust is not good for you. The CBN doesn't make that kind of dust. There is a metal dust but it seems to just fall straight down and doesn't form a cloud like the AO wheels do.
I don't have to supply water and/or wait for the wheel to soak it up like the Tormek. Granted it isn't as sharp a tool as the tormek will do but the 180 grit CBN sure does put a nice cutting edge on the tool.
I agree with everything John has said. I just started using mine about 2 to 3 weeks ago. I just ordered my second wheel yesterday. I'll keep my 3x (80 grit) wheel and a 120 grit AO on my second grinder.
I was pretty sure that the wear was normal. I do a lot of turning tools, and they tend to bow the middle of the wheel. Flattening it to do chisels or plane irons happens 2x per year give or take...
i use a7 inch Baldor grinder for the initial shapimg of the tools usind a Tornek jig for dry grynding. zfrom them I use a Tormek T 7 for the final sharpening and all the following sharpenings. The sharpenongs on the Tormek take no more than 20 seconds and the edge is fantastic. repetitive and axtremely easy but you need two grinders with the Tormeck universal support. Another big advantage is that if you do need to sharpen seriously woodworkink or carving chisels or plane blades no dry grinder will compete with the water lubricated Tormek.
I got a Tormek when they first came out some ten years ago and am also on a third wheel. In addition to the Tormek I have an 8" slow-speed grinder with a CBN wheel and a Wolverine set. I find grinder to be perfectly adequate alone, but with the Tormek you must have some sort of additional grinder for shaping - that's how I wore out my first stone - shaping on the Tormek.
I have managed to get the Wolverine and the Tormek jigs set so that they create (nearly) identical profiles so I use the Wolverine and CBN to sharpen, and the Tormek to hone. Of course that is not technically true - you cannot hone on a grinding stone - but it's a good image of what I am doing. Since the CBM puts an 8" arc on the tool and the Tormek follows the same profile, but with a 10" arc, when I sharpen (about twice or three times a day on a busy day) on the CBN I get the shape I want and when I touch it up or "hone" on the Tormek (about once every 30 minutes), I create a natural micro-bevel on the tool. From the time I walk away from the lathe until I return to turning takes roughly 30 seconds to hone, which I don't find too terribly wasteful of time. Of course I touch the tool with a diamond hone every little bit between any trips to a sharpening tool.
If I were to have just one, I would likely go with the CBN with the Wolverine jig and the hand-held diamond hone. However I carve a bit and the Tormek can't be beat for carving chisels.
I originally made up one mounting for my dry grinder. Then I got a second mounting for the other side of the grinder. I can rough to size with the left grinding wheel which is about 80 grit diamond or cbn. I use this one for rough shaping. Then I go to the right wheel which is a 360 grit diamond and finish grinding. I use the Tormek when I want it really sharp.
Originally, I had to purchase a piece to hold the Tormek tool rest bar. I reported on that in More Woodturning Magazine and the next thing I knew Tormek had put together a kit to do this. So I got one of those for the other side of the grinder.
Thanks, everyone. These have been very informative replies. I hope I'll get as good a set of responses when I can come back and ask about the lathe I'd like to buy.