Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

Posts

Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#1

Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

david

It has been a while since I had an air compressor in my shop with significant air output. I had a Dynabride with a 3" pad, but it was put aside and now I can't find it. If you saw my shop you would understand. I do have a capable air compressor now, and am considering getting either the Grex or the Apprentice unit. The prices are similar, but the Apprentice unit slightly cheaper and is specified to run on less air output. I have the capability of delivering 90 psi at 8 cfm for the Grex unit, and am having trouble deciding between the two. More torque presumably with the Grex, or less air demand for the Apprentice (less cycling on with the air compressor). Anyone use both systems and can offer a comparison? Thanks in advance.

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#2

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

Peter Hyde

The Grex has no balls. Stalls easily with 80 grit and needs a very delicate touch even on 220. Went back to electric

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#3

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

mjonesrdg

I have an apprentice that continues to serve me well now into it's eight year of service. The 2" backing pad broke some time ago, leaving me with just the 3 inch. I have not been able to find a replacement, and would like to find one. Anyone have a suggestion for this?

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#4

Replacement pads *LINK*

david

Don't know how the collet works for the Apprentice ROS, but pads are available in 1", 2" and 3" sizes.


Apprentice replacement pads

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#5

D.A. vs. ROS

mjonesrdg

David, The term "Random Orbital Sander" is often used when speaking of a "Dual Action" sander (and vice versa). The Apprentice Pneumatic sander that has served me so well is a D.A. sander, and the backing pad(s) screw into the nose of the sander....not held by collet or chuck. But, thanks anyway.

Mike Jones

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#6

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

Donna Banfield

Those Pneumatic, or random orbital air (ROA) sanders are not intended to replace your electric sanders completely. You should consider them finish sanders. That's why the sander stalled at 80 grit for you. Most turners using ROA sanders start at around 220 grit. And when you sand with them, the disc should 'kiss' the wood (to quote Steve Worcester).

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#7

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS? *LINK*

John Lucas

My friend Brad Sells would argue with that. He has 2 employees who sand all day long using pneumatic sanders. They are high end sanders and he has a compressor off a Naval ship to handle that kind of volume. Can't remember the name but I'll try to go by next week and ask. He is also a firm believer in pneumatic grinders for his carving. He feels they are safer because when you let go of the switch they shut down. If you drop an electric grinder it will chase you around the shop until you get the cord pulled.


http://bradsells.com/?page_id=42

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#8

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

Donna Banfield

I'm familiar with Brad's work, John, (love it :-) ) and maybe the larger or higher end ROA sanders can run efficiently with lower grit abrasives. I can only speak from experience with the ROA sanders that I've used in woodturning, and that would be the Grex and the Sioux. Both of them would stall using an aggressive, or lower grit abrasive, regardless of how much air my 80 gallon 11CFM Husky tank was pushing. I can use them now even with 180, but not ALL 180 grits, nor even all higher grit abrasives. For example, I could stall the sanders (both Sioux and Grex) trying to use the Industrial Abrasive sheets (1 meter by 1 yard), no matter what grit I used. Switching to Vince's blue discs made a big difference - no stalling and a better finish. Maybe it matters the abrasives that you're using with ROA sanders? Not sure - but you're just the guy who would get to the bottom of this, aren't you :-)

That said, I agree with you and Brad Sells with respect to the air powered angle grinders. I have two; one purchased used, from Jack Grube (the former and still highly respected wood shop instructor) at Pinkerton Academy in Derry, NH several years ago, and the Harbor Freight mini angle grinder. I use them for fast removal of a lot of wood, (well, not so much the Harbor Freight one...) running the large Kutzall burrs, and they don't stall at all running off the same compressor. And they stop immediately when you release the squeeze triggers.

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#9

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

John Lucas

Donna I don't have a lot of experience myself with air power grinders and sander. I just don't have the compressor. I have played with a few. The cheaper ones that I have used or purchased don't have much power. When I played with Brad's, and one of them looked identical to the HF pencil grinder I bought, his would just hog off wood and mine stalled easily.

I have a Grex. I don't use it. It stall fairly easily and my compressor runs constantly. I hope to use it more when I get my big used compressor installed. It will have enough volume to handle that tool.

I want to say what Brad uses is dynabrade but you know how an old mans memory is. :)

Re: Grex vs. Apprentice air powered ROS?

#10

Thanks for the input, all!!

david

And I am going to find that Dynabride ROS, wherever it is...