Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Kiln drying walnut

Posts

Kiln drying walnut

#1

Kiln drying walnut

Dale Bonertz

I have some walnut logs that I am trying to kiln dry - bowl blanks. We don't get much walnut around here so my experience with it is limited to processing around ten logs over as many years. When I dry it I am very careful with even 10% wall thickness, stacking it low in the kiln (slightly cooler lower and less air movement) and I slow the kiln (temperature and dehumidifier) down as low as I can go. Note, I have tried drying it like I would regular bowl blanks with disaster as a result. In this last kiln load I even wrapped the walnut in a old blanket on one row and on the other row I wrapped them in a landscape fabric type material in an effort to slow it down even more. The smaller bowl blanks I can save around 60% without cracks (6" to 11"). The larger the blanks are otherwise dictates the success - 12" I lose about 50%, 13" I lose about 60%, 14" I lose at least 70% and 15" and larger I am lucking to save any at all. My kiln holds around 150 bowl blanks so I have to mix these in with other species which ideally I would dry them in their own kiln with their own species.

Do any of you who have experience with kilns have any ideas or what do you do in your refrigerator kilns to save this wood (oak and walnut are the worse for what I process in native timbers - neither comes up very often). When they come up I would like to dry and save it for something different but maybe I should just stop processing it since it seems to be a waste of time.

BTW I completely anchorseal all blanks in the kiln.

Thanks in advance for any ideas,

Dale

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#2

Re: Kiln drying walnut

robo hippy

If you are losing that many blanks, then you are drying them too fast. I have found walnut to be very stable and easy to dry. Do make sure to round over your rims, this is huge.

I did a few experiments with 'forced drying' and found it easier/less work and got better results with patience and letting them dry on their own.

robo hippy

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#3

Re: Kiln drying walnut

Dale Bonertz

Thanks for the reply Robo. I don't have the luxury of air drying the blanks. Visit roughoutbowls.com and you'll understand. What I don't understand and why I pose the question here is why the walnut and why the bigger blanks and not the smaller blanks. This last kiln had maple, elm, ash and walnut in it. Outside of the walnut I lost one maple blank (16"). I suppose an argument could be made it is the log's but over the years it is always the walnut and oak that give us fits. Oak I get since even the pro commercial drying companies will tell you oak is difficult to dry without honeycombing or checking. But I just don't hear that about walnut and again why I ask the question here. Maybe you answered my question simply by air drying it rather than trying to force (kiln) dry walnut. It just seems that I must be missing something since commercial guys dry walnut planks without much problems - so it appears.

BTW I do ease the outer edge not so much because I have ever noticed a loss ratio difference between doing so and not but more so I don't cut myself on the outer edge of the large blank. To clarify I did for awhile do both the inner and outer edge but have noticed no difference in losses from those that I did not ease edges.

Any and all thoughts are appreciated since I don't have a big enough ego to think that I might be missing something simple or even technical. When I say that I have slowed the kiln down as far as I can that is because that kiln uses light bulbs for a heat source (once the kiln is loaded I have no access to the bulbs) and thus I can't control the temperature and the timer for the dehumidifier only goes so low. I could run the dehumidifier only once a day rather than four times but then I potentially introduce fungus growth due to not pulling enough moisture from the kiln - I think.

Anymore thoughts?

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#4

Re: Kiln drying walnut

robo hippy

I have noticed over the years that with small blanks, maybe from 10 inches down, even with madrone, they dry with distortion, but little cracking. Most likely is bigger size = more drying stress. I have no idea why the walnut would be prone to cracking. Oak, yea, it just likes to do that. What puzzles me is why the problems with the black walnut, as I have found it to be one of the easier woods to dry. Rule of thumb that I use is if it cracks, it is drying too quickly. If it is molding, it is drying too slowly.

The idea of rounding over the rims, I also do for safety reasons. Got sliced once. Dale Larson planted the idea of rounding over the edges in my head. He does that with all of his stock, including cylinder blanks. One theory is that the sharp/fine edge will dry a lot more quickly creating stress. My theory, kind of related is the 'even wall thickness' part. The square edge changes the thickness part of that area, and by rounding it over, then you kind of keep a more even thickness at that part of the wall. I have found it to really help on difficult woods.

Since I never use the twice turned bowl method, I don't really know beyond this. I think Vacuum kilns are interesting, but not much used. I have done flat work with lumber from one, and loved it, worked like air dried rather than 'kill' dried lumber. I could rip a 2 by 10 inch board, and got 0 spring to the board in any direction. Boiling is a pain, but steaming before putting in the dehumidifying kiln might really help all the blanks, and probably wouldn't take as much energy as boiling. I have used solar kiln dried lumber as well, and found it similar to vacuum dried lumber.

robo hippy

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#5

Re: Kiln drying walnut

Greg Haugen

Dale,

I have experience with a freezer kiln. What bulb wattages are your using, for how long, and what is your ambient CONSISTENT temperature outside of the kiln? What size holes do you have in the top and bottom and what is the spacing? Are the splits/crack straight or jagged?

I've never had an issue with Walnut, there's got to be something that is correctable going on.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#6

Re: Kiln drying walnut

robo hippy

Just had a flash back (no, not the ones they promised me I would have) about a post on another forum. A relative newbie was having cracking issues as well. He had a clear water stream out back, and was sinking his rough outs in it for about 2 weeks. Almost no problems after the drownings. I do remember hearing some old timers talking about rain barrel soakings to do the same thing. Not sure why it works unless it is like steaming or boiling, but without the heat.

robo hippy

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#7

Re: Kiln drying walnut

Barry Irby

Several times someone has posted a YouTube video about the Holland Bowl mill (Or maybe the New Holland Bowl Mill) and how they crank out bowls. There is a statement in the video about them steaming the blanks and how it reduces the loses and warping. I want to know more about that. How complicated is steaming them? How long?

I agree that you are doing something wrong. Walnut is not that hard and nothing compared to oak.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#8

You're going to need better controls

Dick Coers

Just because you can't get at the bulbs is no reason to accept the temperature you are getting. Don't you have them on a switch? Do you have a separate fan from the dehumidifier? How close do you get to the pith on walnut on these big bowls? Maybe you are stretching the material to get those big bowls.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#9

Re: You're going to need better controls

Dale Bonertz

I do need better controls and that is why I built a new kiln so I can control things. I have not used the new kiln yet since i just finished it about a week ago. However that does not explain why I can dry ash, box elder, cherry, elm, hack berry, locust, maple, mormon popular, osage orange, russian olive, sasafras, sycamore, willow and cottonwood without issue. Does walnut just resent being kiln dried. I do cut away from the pith at least one inch and in most cases 1 1/2". You are probably correct that the controls are the answer but I will need to learn what is best in the way of temperature versus humidity level with walnut to be able to dry it successfully. The new kiln has a controllable heat source, three fans which I can unplug any of the three at anytime and a timed dehumidifier which can go as low as 1/2 hour each cycle and I can run it one cycle or 24 hours if I choose.

What would you suggest for a start temperature and dehumidifier run time for walnut and for how long (weeks)?

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#10

Re: Kiln drying walnut

Dale Bonertz

Greg,

The kiln is about 4' x 4' x 8' or about 128 square feet. This takes three 100 watt light bulbs to bring it to about 85 degrees in two to three days. I then start the dehumidifier and it comes on four times a day for 1/2 hour each cycle. It will raise the temperature in the kiln 5 to 10 degrees depending how cold it is outside. The kiln sets in an unheated shed. As I turn the dehumidifier up it raises the interior temperature more. the final week of operation the interior temperature is about 110 degrees and goes to about 120 when the dehumidifier runs and then back down as all cycles do throughout the process. In a dehumidifier there are no holes for air exchange such as freezer kilns. It does have wear on the kiln so some air exchange is inevitable. The kiln has two fans that run 24/7 and the light bulbs also need to run 24/7 to hold the temperature. The principle behind the kiln is what was taken off the forestry service site on dehumidifier kilns section of their handbook. There was also another written article about smaller kilns done for the forestry service by some folks so it follows their specs also.

I am beginning to wonder if it is just trying to force dry walnut that is a problem. Maybe air drying walnut is the answer. I just read an article where some commercial driers air dry some species before kiln drying them to final dryness to alleviate the types of problems that I am experiencing. However they don't specifically mention walnut.

BTW I put about 2 gallons of water in a pan for each kiln to try and equalize all the blanks within the kiln to roughly the same moisture content before starting the dehumidifier.

Now that you have more information on what I am doing can you offer any insight. Please, it is very frustrating to go through all the work from log to kiln and end up with bad blanks.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#11

Re: Kiln drying walnut

Dale Bonertz

Sorry forgot to answer that they are the normal straight type cracks. The worst go through the blank and are split an 1/8" wide. Some down across the bottom and some 1/2 way up the sides. Very few if any are from rim down. Obviously stress related checks but why the walnut and not the rest? This is driving a crazy guy even crazier :)

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#12

Steven Antonucci

NJ walnut doesn't crack or warp?

steven antonucci

I usually turn them to less than 10% at that diameter because it just doesn't move that much here in NJ? If I had a 15" bowl, it would probably be 1" in rough?

I would only put it in a brown paper bag... nothing else.

Steve

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#13

Re: Kiln drying walnut

Greg Haugen

ok.

I asked about the cracks because I once had a couple of logs that I couldn't get a single bowl from. They also cracked jaggedly-very odd. Talked to the logger after going nuts to find out they came from a urban parking lot and were felled onto concrete. No matter what I did, it would have mattered they had the compression fractures.

Secondly, to me, it seems a little rushed (force drying). When I use a freezer kiln, (in a consistent temperature basement, only a light bulb, and a dehumidifier that just in the basement and usually shut off) I don't want the temps much past 90 at the hottest (week 4 with a higher watt bulb) I can dry 40-50 bowl in 4-5 weeks. The first week, I use a 40 watt bulb and make sure everything in any area of the basement is shut off (no fans any where or the dehumidifier). The first week and part of the second week the kiln is dripping with water from the humidity that is stuck in it. Similar to the Holland Bowl Company misting their bowl before drying. Each week the bulb is replaced with a larger bulb. The temp never gets more than 90.

To me it sounds like the temps are a high and I'd try to move the air before taking the moisture with the dehumidifier. Your kiln sounds like the one Trent Bosch uses/used to. In his video on Utility Bowls, I do believe he walks through how it's set up and the cycles. May be worth an email his way.

Try an experiment....turn a bowl thinner. Like Steven said. Turn a 13-15" bowl to about an inch thick. Balance the grain in it. If the thinner bowl does ok, the thicker bowls are drying too fast.

I struggled for a couple of years trying to figure out drying bowls. I followed Mike Mahoney's tips from his DVDs. Didn't work too well for me. He's in a desert and I'm in Wisconsin. I came across a description of a kiln used by a Hawaiian turner named Kelly Dunn. I thought if he can dry bowl in Hawaii this way, surely it will work in Wisconsin. It did. What works in one region doesn't work in the next. The wood is different moisture rating, the climate is different etc. Once the WAY wood dries is understood, it's easier to adapt your situation to a solution.

Slow it down, even out the grain's moisture (so it's not shocked so quickly-either by soaking or slowly the process at the start to maintain the humidity), and possibly going thinner.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#14

Brad Vietje

Toss The Kiln (?)

Brad Vietje

Dale,

I have processed around 50 Black Walnut bowl blanks, but all from two old slow-grown trees*. I don't believe I have ever lost one. I have found Walnut to be one of the more stable woods, and much less likely to crack than Apple, Black Cherry, or other fruit woods.

I have never used a kiln, and only occasionally seal the end grain with Anchorseal -- I use it to slow down drying while awaiting processing and rough turning, but usually not after the rough turning. I either rough turn them in batches and toss a number of rough-outs into a cardboard box, or place individual bowls in paper bags. No shavings, no sealants, just the bag or box.

I am only rarely in a hurry to process wood any faster than the typical sequence of rough turn and wait 6 months+, though that schedule might simply not work for your needs. Last night I finished the bottom of an 11 x 4" Bl. Walnut bowl I had rough turned in 2003, though I don't purposely wait that long -- I just pull out air-dried bowl blanks as I need them. I love rough turning, and don't like sanding, so I end up doing more rough turning than finish turning, so I end up with a lot of air-dried blanks to choose from! My climate is pretty forgiving because it tends to be pretty damp during the warmer months -- I have to worry more about excessive spalting than rapid drying.

So, from my limited experience, I could only conclude that you are simply drying them too fast. Maybe you'd be best to just air-dry the Walnut and Oak, and kiln dry the others (?) Are you drying the solid blanks, or rough-turned bowls?

*While I'm farther north than the native range for Black Walnut, it does fine around here when planted in a warmer south-facing valley location or other warm micro-climate. My dad and I ended up harvesting two big Black Walnuts in 2002 that split apart after a big heavy spring snow storm around 2000. These were planted by a soldier when he returned from the Civil War, so they were pretty old and pretty big -- 3.5 x 4' at the base. Since they grew further north than usual, they grew more slowly than many, so the growth rings are pretty closely spaced -- very nice wood. Maybe growing slowly makes these trees more stable than most?

So I think you have 3 choices:

1. Don't mess with Black Walnut at all :\

2. Don't kiln dry Black Walnut ;)

3. Ship all your Black Walnut to me, and let me worry about it :b

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#15

sapwood on the bowl?

Dick Coers

There is more shrinkage in walnut sapwood compared to heart wood. Wondering if you have sapwood in the base of the bowl.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#16

Steve Kubien

Re: sapwood on the bowl?

Steve Kubien

My only issue drying black walnut in the kiln is when I have had excessive sapwood in the base. The only solution I have found for these is to let them air dry after anchor sealing them.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#17

Re: Kiln drying walnut

Dale Bonertz

Thanks Greg,

Some of things you brought up I'll give a try. You are right about the Trent Bosch style kiln since these are Trent's old kilns. Dan bought them from him years ago. I have talked to Trent about this a few weeks ago when we had a meeting on our symposium. After we discussed everything he did not know what was happening. Thanks again.

Dale

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#18

Re: Toss The Kiln (?)

Dale Bonertz

Thanks Brad,

I rough turn the bowls prior to putting them in the kiln. I will core them to maximize the yield per round/blank.

I am considering no longer processing walnut for it does not seem to be cost effective for my purposes.

I may rough turn them and air dry them rather than waste the energy and space in my kilns. I live in a pretty dry climate so air drying is not all that great either but if I lose them that way then oh well.

I am not sure the shipping costs from Colorado to New Jersey would be cost effective for you but then again :) .

Dale

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#19

What I am going to try

Dale Bonertz

Good point Dick and Steve,

I do know that some have what I would call a skim coat of sap wood. Meaning there is maybe a 1/8" thick to 1/4" thick bit of sapwood on them. These logs have a fairly wide band of sapwood in them. I try to cut it all out on the base but I know that a couple have a thin skim across the bottom. Mostly on the sides is where you would find the sapwood. I think with what I have learned from everyone's input has convinced me to alter what I am doing a bit. I am going to try one more batch in the new kiln where I can slow it down a bit more. I am also going to make sure that all sapwood is cut off. I am going to double coat the end grain areas with anchorseal. I am going to wait to start the dehumidifier until the kiln has held a consistent humidity level for 24 hours (I already do this but I have a better hygrometer than I used to). I am going to be even more careful on the wall thickness with this wood. I'll round the edges of 3/4 of the blanks and 1/4 without to see if it makes a difference with walnut.

I about 6 to 8 weeks I'll report back if it worked. Who knows I may even through in some oak and see how it dries.

Any last minute thoughts from anyone. Thanks to all for your thoughts. It really has helped me consider new options in my processes with this timber. I hope I can come back with good news.

Dale

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#20

Re: What I am going to try

Dick Coers

The downside to making all those changes at once will be that you won't know which one fixed the problem. But, who would want to keep loosing big blanks while you extend the experimenting. Good luck!

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#21

Re: What I am going to try

Don Orr

One of the professional turners our club had in for demonstrations in the past year said something thar made some sense to me. He turns the bottom of his roughouts a little thinner than the walls before drying. I think he said it allows the bottom to be more flexible during the stress of drying. I just don't remember whether it was Glenn Lucas or Liam O'Neill. I'm sure either of them would be happy to dicsuss your situation should you so desire.

Good luck!

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#22

Re: What I am going to try

Dale Bonertz

Thanks Don

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#23

Re: What I am going to try

Dale Bonertz

I thought about that Dick but came to the same conclusion. Who cares as long as the blanks stop cracking. The one thing I am testing is the rounding of edges. If I have 10 big blanks I'll round 7 and keep 3 with a sharp edge. If 2 of the 3 sharp edge crack then I need to rethink but if none of the sharp edge crack and a couple of the rounded do then I don't think rounding matters that much. I do know that rounding isn't going to hurt anything that is why I am going to error on the 70/30 split. All of the other things are easy and harmless enough to do as a normal course of processing. The only thing I will need to careful with is finding the balance between running the kiln to slow and fungus growing and running it to fast for cracking. I know how we have been running the kilns in the past work fine on all woods I mentioned earlier but it does not work on walnut and oak. So time to adjust for hopefully a better balance.

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#24

Brad Vietje

Rounding Edges

Brad Vietje

This is a very good idea.

I lost a few rough-outs years ago that started cracking right at the outer edge of the rim on the end grain, and then started routinely putting a small bevel on every exposed edge-- even the tenon for the chuck. That alone made a big difference, and nowadays I rarely lose a rough-out to cracking while air drying.

I treat the end grain of a few, like an irreplaceable piece, or a blank from a particular tree for a commission, but usually just a paper bag or cardboard box.

For high-movement woods like Beech and Apple, I started rubbing Butcher's Paste Wax on them before removing from the lathe a la Wally Dickerman. I figure if it works in bone-dry Arizona, it will work in much more humid Vermont!

We have warm, humid Summers, wet Springs, pretty normal in Fall, and very dry air in Winter (but things are frozen, so it doesn't matter much if you dry in an un-heated spot). I also stay away from forced hot air heating (REALLY bad for drying blanks w/out checking), keep them away from the woodstove until they are quite dry, and generally dry them in cool or even cold conditions. Not very fast, but very consistent.

I think beveling the exposed edges is the way to go.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Kiln drying walnut

#25

Brad Vietje

Re: What I am going to try

Brad Vietje

I would concur.

The bottoms of side-grain bowls are all side grain, so they lose moisture more slowly than the walls, which are ~2/3 end grain. There's also the added thickness of any tenon to consider, if you mount bowls that way, so the bottoms can be a bit thinner to compensate.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT