We had a few guys here in town some years back that were associated with the Chippendale School of woodworking over there in the UK. A couple of the guest turners used scrapers. Seemed like their scrapers were ground to about 40 degrees.
Me, I was curious about scrapers. I knew that they used to be a 'go to' tool, and seeing finished product, they didn't look any better than my gouge turned bowls, so I started using them. As far as I am concerned, they are a far more efficient tool for bowl roughing than a gouge. Most don't know how to use them properly.
I was taught by Guilio Marcolongo and Brendan Stemp how to use a Shear scraper
All their chisels and know mine are sharpened like a skew Weather round oval or square.Even my small scrapers that fit onto my Rollie or woodcut hollower s are sharpened like this.
I would like to add that we have also developed a cut that has the handle down at 45degrees so we need the angle on the tool.
Takes a lot of practice before you stop gritting your teeth.But the cut is so clean you can see through the shavings
A conventional square scraper with handle high will if you hit the end grain and have a dig in will pull the tool into the work and force the handle down ( a big bang usually occurs.
With a double grind the fibers come down onto the top bevel and force the cutting edge down onto the bevel forcing the tool handle to rise pushing the cutting face clear.
A common mistake made by people scraping is they draw the tool across the work from center to the left when they should rotate the handle in a curve and draw out.
Steve Russel quote One of the most useful techniques you will ever learn as a woodturner is shear scraping. Often confused with traditional scraping (which is a totally different technique), shear scraping is a woodturner's best friend. It's your go-to technique for fairing the curves on your projects, eliminating torn grain and refining the surface prior to sanding.
Shear scraping is one of the simplest and easiest ways to clean up tear out and bruised grain areas on your woodturnings, instead of using your 60-grit gouge. Shear scraping is an elegant process that sweetens the surface and reduces the total amount of sanding required on your projects. Although it's used primarily with bowls, platters and hollow forms, shear scraping can also be adapted to certain spindle turning projects
That was good John. Now, you have to try a burr from the CBN wheel.
The term 'shear scrape' has always confused me. I think the reason for calling it a scrape is because the bevel is not rubbing. I agree that it is a cut, and not a scrape. I do consider scraping to be a cut as well, as I get shavings, and long ones when the wood is wet. It just does not leave a clean surface on bowls. I don't think I have any scrapers with a square nose profile. I have a couple that are round nose, or more ) shaped, and most of them are swept back, like half of a swept back gouge. With those, I can rough with the nose, and shear cut with the edge.
Not sure if Lyle Jaimeson is following this one or not. He calls it a 'sheer' scrape. Can't remember, but I think that is a reference to how fine the cut is as in so sheer, you can see through them. To me, the shear is a reference to the angle of the cut. It would be too confusing if we called it a skewed cut because people think of skew chisels. Flat on the tool rest is a scrape, where the cutter is at a 90 degree angle to the rotation of the wood. Gouge or scrapers both will do this cut. Problem with the scraping cut, is that it tends to pull on the fibers more than lifting and cutting, so you tend to get more tear out. I compare it to speed bumps in the parking lot. If you hit them square on (scraping cut) you get a big bump. If you hit it at a 45 degree angle (shear cut) the bump is extended out and is way smoother. Higher than 45 degrees, it is smoother yet.
I don't understand why scrapers are not sold with rounded over edges like the skews are. Maybe I need a signature Thompson scraper.....
I think it got labeled as a shear scrape because you were using a scraper to do it. I'm sure this came out before bowl gouges were introduced. Maybe we should call it a skewed burr cut. Of course then what do you call the shear scrape using a bowl gouge wing. This doesn't have a burr.
I did a test last year for an article Betty was editing on the differences between a scrape, bevel rubbing cut with a scraper, and a scrape without a burr. As you can imagine the scrape without a burr gave the worst cut, the bevel rubbing cut was OK but since I just polished off the burr and was using an included angle of about 70 degrees the cut wasn't that clean. The scrape with burr was the best.
I need to do the same test as above but have an included angle that's closer to that of a skew. This would be similar to Stewart Batty's new tools. do one with a burr, one without a burr and then a bevel rubbing cut. Maybe in the next month or so I'll have time to do that.
I do remember experimenting with a scraper where I had honed the burr off. I think it was for finish cuts, bevel rubbing and shear scrape. I don't remember any specifics, but do remember it wasn't worth the effort. I do remember some one stating flat out that a scraper with no burr would not cut. Well it will cut, but not as well as a scraper with a burr.
Reed I think it depends on the included angle of the edge. A skew with a really sharp edge cuts very clean when used as a scraper and doesn't have a burr. Blunter edged tool on the other hand won't cut well and must have the burr. It's actually a very complicated subject as you can see by all the different responses.
I do use a skew as a negative rake scraper, and saw Stuart do that some years back. I use mine to adjust the shoulder on threaded boxes. It doesn't seem to cut if I hone the burr off, and if I flip it over so the burr is down, it doesn't cut at all.
Yes, I am following this. I don't use scrapers much. My take on it is, the slicing action of a bevel supported cut will leave a superior surface on the wood then a scraper. But I do sheer scrape everything I do accept the inside of a bowl where the grain would have to be sheer scrapped up hill the wrong way to the grain. Grain orientation is the most important element no matter what tool you are using. When sheer scraping, it is not so much the direction the tool moves across the tool rest, but the direction of the tilt or angle of the handle. The angle, right or left, must be angled to be slicing downhill to the fibers. I have found the benefit of this rather recently (10 years ago). On my old Hollow Forms DVD I'm sheer scraping the wrong direction.
I use the spelling "sheer" because it is scrapping in a very steep angle, a very steep slope, a sheer slope. Sheer scraping means scraping on a sheer angle to the rotation of the wood. The steeper the angle the cleaner the wood surface will be. Shear means cutting as in shearing sheep or cutting hair. It implies a scissor action of two apposing blades. And of course we are not referring to shear as in lingerie. :-) The shavings we get from sheer scraping are more like angel hair then that of lingerie.
Russ Fairfield - article on scrapers - AAW v18, #1
Craig Daymon
I took an old issue of the AAW Journal into my "reading room" last night and stumbled upon an article fitting with this part of the scraper discussion.
Russ Fairfield wrote an article, "Real Turners DO Use Scrapers!", (not about negative rake scrapers) in the Spring 2003 issue of the AAW Journal, page 20. (Volume 18, Number 1) He discusses and compares the different burrs, including no burr.
After digging out the dictionary (yes, I am old school) sheer as in a sheer cliff. Makes more sense now. I thought of it in terms of wind shear like inside the thermal, air is moving up, and out side thermal, wind is moving down, and the boundary line is the shear, and with wind shear, both sides are moving. Perhaps skewed is the proper term, but that one seems to be taken already. Probably too late to introduce a more accurate term, if we can find one.