Ok thinking of giving those negative rake scapers a go, But have a few questions,
What is the included angle I should use?
And also how should I present the scraper to the work, should I use the tool horizontal or trailing down (like a normal scaper)
Also will the burr left from grinding be enough or would it benefit from ticketing/burnishing to leave a more resilient burr or would this be too grabby/snatchy ???
A negative rake scraper is the same as a regular scraper, except there is a very slight bevel ground on the top. Grind that bevel first, then sharpen the scraper as you normally would. If you normally draw a burr, for example using the Veritas jig, then do so.
I've seen the negative rakes that Stuart Batty sells and I really don't understand why he grinds away so much steel on the top. Looks like he's got a line of skews that he sells as scrapers. (Which is pretty much where this whole idea came from.) I don't see it as necessary. I grind away a bevel, maybe a quarter inch wide, like the white at the end of the fingernail. (Though on my nails it's shorter than 1/4".) This way there is still as much steel as possible under the cutting edge, helping to minimize vibration.
Presentation is best to use horizontal or below. I find it much easier to control than a regular scraper for the simple reason that it is a bit more forgiving when you do present it (slightly) incorrectly. You can still get a catch with a negative rake scraper, but I can't remember when the last time it happened to me.
You can use it for shear scraping, hollowing, etc. Anything that you would use a normal scraper.
The first ones were skew chisels. So, the bevel was pretty much the same on either side. Most of the time, just the grinder burr is used. It is gone in seconds. The burr from the CBN wheels lasts longer, but isn't very sturdy either. They are used like standard scrapers. I have seen them with steep bevels on the bottom, say 60 to 70 degrees, and about a 45 on top. You grind the bottom bevel to create the burr. The one I use is about 40, on both top and bottom, and has kind of ) shaped nose profile, with a little sweep on one side. I have found that some times it is necessary to sharpen from the other side to get into some places, so keeping the same bevel on each side makes creating the burr pretty simple. I did try to burnish a burr. Do this by hand only, keeping the burnishing rod close to same angle as the bevel, and very light. Not really much of an improvement. They can be used for shear scraping/cutting, but standard scrapers work better.
My main negative rake scraper is actually a Raffen spear point scraper about 1 inch wide and 1/4 inch thick. Didn't like the spear, and made it into a scraper.
All that being said, about the only time I use them is on end grain. Just don't work that well for me on bowls. If you see Stuart use them, he does make it work really well.
I will say up front that I seldom use scrapers anymore. I'll touch up a bad spot on a piece using a shear scraper but that's about it. I have been playing with negative rake scrapers trying to see what all the fuss is about. I had my scrapers ground fairly blunt, maybe 70 degrees on the front and no top rake. lifted them up so the handle was higher than the cutting edge and that's how i used them if I wasn't shear scraping.
I now have them ground with a negative rake and have been playing with much sharper angles. They seem to cut with less force which I think helps you take a lighter cut and therefore getting a cleaner cut.
The burr does not last anytime at all. I have played with burrs off the grinder, burrs off the diamond hone and burr raised with a Ticketer or bar. On my scrapers it depends on the brand and the metal. John Jordan's shear scraper raises a beautiful burr using his very fine ceramic hone. Not as good with my diamond hones. My Sorby scraper works great off the grinder and pretty good with diamond hones. My homemade scraper made from a planer blade will not raise a burr off the grinder I have to use the diamond hones.
Is a negative rake necessary. Well you can hold the handle of your tool up higher than normal and have a negative rake presented to the wood. Lets assume both tools have the same included angle ground on the top and bottom. The tool is going down hill on the tool rest and probably pushing into the wood. With a negative rake scraper the tool is held flat (the negative rake makes it appear tilted down to the wood). For this reason I think than you apply less forward force onto the wood which lets you take a more gentle cut.
Now here's the interesting part. If I use a skew with not burr I get a very clean cut. It is essentially a negative rake scraper but of course sharpened much sharper. I will have to run a test some day and put a burr on it to see if it cuts better. It will just really hurt to run a diamond hone across the that good sharp edge to raise the burr.
What I've found so far it that I still get a better surface off the bowl gouge. If I have tool marks or bumps then I use a shear scraper and it doesn't seem to matter what the sharpening angle is or if it's negative rake, only that it has a good burr. Since I almost never use a scraper flat I can't really answer the question of whether a negative rake helps although in my limited experiments it seems like it does. I've never really compared 2 tools with the same included angle in my tests however so that may not be accurate.
If you think about it a bit, you will realize that you can do exactly the same thing with a regular scraper, but you just have to hold handle higher to achieve the desired negative rake. The bevel on the top just allows you to work with the handle approximately level.
If you get a chance to see Benoit Averly demonstrate how he hollows his flat bottomed boxes with a skew, you should. Very fast and very impressive. Also lets him get into that bottom corner.
Most of his turning appears to be done with a skew.
His skews appear to be thicker than most. Probably a 3/8" thick scraper he ground to be a skew.
That being said, I find being able to present the tool more horizontal is more comfortable and for that reason I've ground a small bevel on the tops of my scrapers. About 1/4" wide at maybe a 10 degree angle at most. That way I still have a nice fat scraper to absorb vibration and I don't have to tilt the handle up (which would make reaching the bottom of a deep, narrow vessel harder).
Having had a chance to spend some time with Richard Raffan and take a few lessons watching him use scrapers, not negative rake by the way, I am using them more and more.
They work great in lots of situations when properly sharpened and kept sharp. If you have not seen the videos of Reed Gray (Robohippy) using a scraper you should look him up on YouTube. He really knows how to make them sing. I use them primarily for finish cuts and precision cuts on boxes, bowls and scoops.
I keep mine well honed with a diamond paddle and cut away.
The topic about 'if you just raise the handle of a regular scraper, it will work like a negative rake scraper' continues to come up. As some one who uses scrapers as my primary weapon for bowl roughing, they do not cut the same way. Yes, it is still a scraping cut, as in 90 degrees to the rotation of the wood, but the way it cuts is really different. Not sure why, but the top bevel angle is what makes it cut differently. For sure, the grinder burr from my CBN wheels is really aggressive, and very durable, far more so than the NR scraper burr. I have about a 70 degree bevel on them. That top bevel does some thing, and I haven't figured it out yet.
I do use a skew as a negative rake scraper when I am adjusting the shoulder on threaded boxes so the grain can line up. With 16 tpi, I can adjust down to pretty much perfect, so I don't have to take it down to 220 or 320 grit abrasives to get tie final perfect fit. I could never do that with a standard scraper no matter what I did to the edge.
...a number of years ago I ground a copy of his NR scraper out of an old square scraper blank. I probably used it a few times then retired it to my "inactive" toolbox, and don't recall the last time it saw the light of day. NR scrapers are not aggressive at all, and the profile of a skew is very close to the dimensions of a NG scraper. They seem to work best on hardwood, and require frequently renewing the fine burr edge.
In regard to a negative rake scraper, if the included angle between the bevels is more than 90 degrees, grinding Does Not produce a burr. None. Not with HSS anyway, and none that is visible under a stereo microscope at 7X.
I grind my scrapers at a bevel angle of about 75 degrees (up from 70 I listed in the articles), remove the burr from the grinder with a hone on the top surface, and then reform the burr with a diamond hone parallel to the bevel. The resulting burr is very fine, but it cuts remarkably well. And, it lasts for a long time, not just a few seconds.
I point out in the articles that pointing the tool down (to achieve a negative rake?) actually makes the cut more aggressive. I demonstrated this effect earlier today at a friends shop.
Doc, Your articles are right on. They are very descriptive and contain a ton of excellent information. I recommend that everyone read all three, even if you (think you) know it all already. Thanks, Gary
Being a big fan of scrapers, I read your articles on them. Most of it I agree with, but two points I differ on.
One is the burr from the grinder. This has come about with the coming of the CBN wheels. The burr created by a CBN wheel is far superior to one created by using standard grinding wheels. Stuart Batty also has commented that the burr on the negative rake scraper lasts much longer when done with a CBN wheel. If you haven't tried one of the D Way wheels, you owe it to yourself to get one. They outperform standard wheels in EVERY conceivable way. Really!
The other point is that scrapers aren't that great for heavy removal of stock. The right click on my mouse quit working tonight for some reason, but if you go to You Tube and type in robo hippy, I have a clip up where I turn a bowl using nothing but scrapers. I routinely use a scraper 3/8 thick by 1 to 1 1/4 inch wide, for all of my heavy roughing on bowls. The burr from the CBN wheels will hold up at least as long as the cutting edge on any of my gouges.
The CBN wheel is not changing the type of steel the scraper is made from. Possibly, it is drawing a larger/heavier burr. It would not be reasonable to think that the CBN wheel imparts some special quality beyond this.
This may suggest that the Veritas jig for putting a heavier burr on your scraper is a good investment as well. The Veritas jig is $46.50, a CBN wheel is $185 (8").
If the only advantage you get is being able rough out an entire bowl, why bother sharpening at all? We are talking "roughing" out. I would think carbide would be the most efficient approach to take.
I've also seen Richard Raffan rough out a bowl very fast and efficiently using a scraper ground on a conventional wheel, without going to the grinder.
Though, the CBN wheels are reported to last a very long time and they don't change in size, which is a big advantage and important consideration when choosing a wheel.
Cindy Drozda had a link up here a month or so ago about how the CBN cuts the V10 metals much better than the standard grinding wheels. I would think that the CBN wheels, when the grit is attached is like the newer abrasives, which are electrostatically charged, rather than just sifted so you get the grains to align better, and the grit is much more consistent is size.
As for burnishing a burr, I use one of the triangle burnisher sticks intended for the card scrapers. Making a bigger burr isn't as important as making a consistent curve, and not having it break over like a wave. I heard one demonstrator state flat out that you couldn't turn a burr by hand on high speed steel. Well, I tried it out, and with the round burnisher, it wasn't too good, but with the triangle one, it was easy. Just don't over do it.
You do have to keep all tools sharp. When they get dull, you have to work a lot harder to get them to cut. While 'hard work never hurt nobody', 'ain't no point in working harder than you have to'.
CBN wheels will be the standard for woodturners in a few years. The conventional matrix wheels absolutely no advantages over them, other than cost, but the CBN wheels, while more expensive, are a far better value.
So if I grind my scrapers on the grinder, upside down, will that still not give me a sufficient burr? I was shown to do this once and since have always got a very very good light cut on the bowl with my scraper. I can actually feel a bur as well, but am I getting a "false" burr?!
Gary, thank you for your comments and endorsement. Much appreciated!
Randy, when I tried grinding a scraper upside down, I found that I still got a burr on the cutting edge, but it was not as pronounced as the burr produced with the tool right side up. The nature of the burr was the same: not uniform; easy to remove. I concluded that grinding upside down had no advantages other than producing a smaller burr.
Robo, I watched your video on turning a bowl with scrapers only, and it was impressive to see the shavings come out of the bowl. But, I think you are not the average turner who may be having difficulties with a scraper. I also watched your video on sharpening using the Robo rest ... very good, Sir.
Some day I hope to own a CBN wheel, but as for now, my well-worn diamond wheel is still doing the job. I think of it as a power hone, and it produces a good, but very small, burr on my scrapers.
Since I wrote the articles more than a year ago, my opinions have firmed up a bit, based on my own experience and from talking to other turners. Here is a quick summary:
(1) The smoothness of the top surface and of the bevel has a lot to do with the strength of the burr - the smoother the better. Smooth surfaces give a burr that's straighter and more uniform. A fine grit AlO wheel (120 grit) or a diamond wheel gives a smoother surface than an 80-grit AlO wheel.
(2) I now grind the bevel angle a bit steeper, at about 75 or maybe even 80 degrees. This steeper angle makes the scraper immune to catches. I can start a cut with the handle held high (tool pointing down across the rest) and gradually lower the handle until the tool is horizontal, then pointing up, and then pointing up so much the bevel begins to rub, and finally until the cutting edge is lifted from the wood ... and I don't get a catch. You know what will happen if you do this with a scraper where the bevel angle is ground to about 60 degrees (which gives a much longer bevel).
(3) I now seldom use the burnisher because it gives too much of a burr, and if I'm not careful, it will turn the burr back over the top surface (too much curl).
(4) The way I sharpen a scraper now, in a nutshell is, (a) Grind the bevel to the proper angle (75 or so) on a grinder. Touch it up on a diamond wheel if one is available.
(b) Use a 600-grit diamond hone to remove the burr by giving a few strokes
( 3 or 4) with the hone flat on the top surface. In reflected light, a very fine bright line will appear where the burr was removed.
(c) With the tool on a horizontal surface and the cutting edge sticking out into the air, I then place the hone parallel to the bevel and use a swirling motion to form the final burr. This step takes no more than about 10 seconds.
The resulting burr will be very fine, but it will be strong. It may even be hard to feel, but if you run a finger across the top and off the edge, and then up the bevel and off the edge, you should feel a difference. When you go across the top, you should feel just the slightest hint of a burr.
When it's right, the tool will produce "shavings so fine they float in the air, and if you touch them, they disappear." And, of course, the surface left on the wood is nothing but slick - in most cases.
The burr will last a long time. Reform the burr about as often and with as much use as you do with a bowl gouge.
After more thought, I realize that there IS a difference between a negative rake scraper and a regular one tilted down. The difference is that in the latter case the outward (horizontal) push of the wood against the tool forces the scraper against the rest and causes sliding friction between the scraper and the rest. In the case of the NR scraper, the outward force does not do this. The effect of the vertical component of force of wood against the tool is the same in both cases. Therefore, the negative rake scraper is slightly more free to slide back in response to minor catches.
Just wanted to thank everyone who posted/responded to my questions regarding neg rake scrapers,
You guys are a great bunch of people, in a world where so many people couldn't give a damn about anyone other than themselves it's refreshing to know that there are still people out there that will give you the time of day and are willing to help others !!!
Robo, just watched your video of you turning the bowl with just a scaper and want to congratulate you on your technique, man you can make that scaper sing!
I don't know what it's like in the USA but over here in the UK there are many turners who think scrapers are the devils tool (especially the older end turners) but me personally I think if it works then why not use it!!!
The world would be a very boring place if we all did the same thing, and all turners would only own two tools, a bowl gouge and a skew!
Well done Robo, just because you turn them in a different way does not make it the wronge way!!!