Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

"Flame" Box Elder

Posts

"Flame" Box Elder

#1

"Flame" Box Elder

Jim Breeden

I've heard a lot of stories about the red in Box Elder will eventually turn brown. Doesn't matter if it's exposed to sunlight, or not. One turner I know uses Krylon UV Fixitive and has "never" had a problem with the color going away. I have several turned pieces with the red and, I do keep them out of the direct sun in anticipation the red will not turn to brown. So far this has not happened. Anybody else had this problem of color change ?

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#2

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Don in Central Illinois

I read somewhere recently a turner that uses a lot of color rubs SPF 90 or a real high number to block uv rays. Haven't tried it,but interesting thought.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#3

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Dale Bonertz

I have heard this also. I just looked at the bowl sitting on my desk, in basement with big window so must get some sunlight and it has a date of 2004. No change in color thus far and I was just using Walnut oil for a finish back then. I can't say for sure but it probably will change slowly over time. How long still to be determined.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#4

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Dick Coers

Made a pen for my son out of some spectacular bright red. Saw it 2 years latter and it was barely salmon colored. Didn't even look like the same pen. It was a daily user for him.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#5

Roger in MO

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Roger in MO

It might be interesting to try that on hedge.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#6

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

phillip medghalchi

Jim, I just rough turned my first S. Texas (just to clarify) box elder bowl. when I got the pre-cut to a bowl blank piece form this friend of mine I noticed that it had big crack at each side of the top of the blank. I asked him what to do and he said that put it in a bed of shavings. Anyways, I have a barrel that I bury my fresh blanks and rough turned bowl blanks in it. so, I got to rough turn it and left it in the garage on the shelf so I can finish it. Last night i was checking it to see what happened to those cracks and noticed that they are closing up on their own and I also remembered the problem with the red color turning brown. I was asking that if this is a valid claim? From the posts above, it appears that we have mixed answers.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#7

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

phillip medghalchi

I wonder if the body and oil from hand caused it to discolor?

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#8

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

phillip medghalchi

color buff PFs 90? I wasn't sure that such a thing exist for paiting? I have to look this one up.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#9

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Dick Coers

Lots of layers of CA glue for the finish. I'm sure no body oils got through that protective layer.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#10

those cracks may be closing.....

Dick Coers

but they are still there with the structural problems. Be very careful returning!!!!!

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#11

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Jim Breeden

Philip, some of the members from our club brought in several peices, some were brown / tan and, some had not lost the color. There were two boxes, the insides were still full of color, the outsides were tan where the red used to be. All had sealer, wax, laquer, poly, etc. Your guess is as good as mine as to what happened.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#12

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Ralph Lindberg

I can only say that all natural red colors fade. How much and how fast depends on the source.

I've talked to a guy that put a slice of Flamed Box elder in the direct sun and the red was gone in a week

I've also talked to people that have delayed this with coatings, I would bet the Krylon UV is one of the best, and the SPF (sun block) skin coating to be, well, not every effective

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#13

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Bernie Weishapl

I have two with WOP and two with shellac. The shellac pieces have turned a brown color and the WOP are both still red. Don't know why since they are in the same cabinet and not in the sun.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#14

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Jim Breeden

Newbie here - WOP ? :\

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#15

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Don in Central Illinois

Wipeon polyurethane.

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

#16

Re: "Flame" Box Elder

Jim Breeden

Well, DUH on me ! :D