Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Posts

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#26

Harry Robinette

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Harry Robinette

What I was doing in the answer I gave was talking about what was pictured NOT all eccentric chucks.I guess I have to write everything out.

The PSI web site shows only ONE chuck set and it consisted of a aluminum cylinder with 4 or 5 holes. IE the one Ruth Niles sells.

It also showed a offset plate about 4" in Dia with an adjustable plate.

I have both of these unjts plus the Sorby eccentric chuck.

Sorry I didn't spell everything out.

OH ya there are other I believe pen mandrels and maybe some screws that go with the chuck set I saw on PSI web site just to be clear.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#27

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

RCH

I gather from this that you own one of these chucks -- can you comment on using the chuck itself? Putting aside use of pen mandrels, how is the chuck to work with?

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#28

Acceptably well.

Ralph Lindberg

As I noted, there are fit and finish issues, but they do not impact the use of this system.

The four offset holder is, obviously limited to the four offset amounts. The variable unit would be difficult to exactly replicate any particular setup. You could get it close by counting turns on the adjustment, but it would not be exact.

This system is certainly acceptable for the light turnings they show in the instructional video that comes with the unit. That is, pens, pencils, bottle-stops and small candle-stick holders and such.

The unsupported (tail-end) pen mandrels are no more a concern then the ones from a number of different sources.

Just to be clear, I enjoy playing with off-set, non-circular and oval turning. In addition to this system I have the Sorby and the Vicmarc VOD. I have also built a oval chuck for my (foot) treadle lathe.

I think that the PSI and the Sorby, together, could give a turner almost the same abilities as the Vicmarc Eccentric #3 system, although the Vicmarc will handle more weight and has a better fit and finish (and a much higher price)