Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Posts

PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#1

PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Craig Daymon

I received the latest Penn State Industries catalog the other day. They have a couple of products I thought about checking out.

I've bought lots of PSI stuff before, so I do have an idea what I'm getting for my money.

One product that looked very interesting was the "Off Center Chuck System", CSC600. Like almost anything off center, it will certainly make a mini lathe shake. I expect that. Has anyone bought/used one of these? Any opinions?

They also have a set (or individuals) of Robust style toolrests ("The EZ Glide Toolrest"), a set of 3 for $44.85, 6", 9" and 12", with 5/8" posts. I know the Robust rests are very well liked. I've also heard that Robust glues on the steel bars as opposed to one manufacturer that welds them on. Anyone use these? Does Penn State glue on the rod? (I'm guessing so, but maybe not.)

Finally, they are advertising a 1" "Long and Strong" spindle gouge. One of my favorite gouges right now is a 5/8" Thompson detail gouge. I use it on almost everything, except maybe going deep in a bowl. Great tool and rarely vibrates. 1" is REALLY big for a spindle gouge (even big for a bowl gouge), but at $26.95 I thought it might have a purpose. Again, big tool, less vibration. (No, it's not a roughing gouge.) These don't seem to be in stock yet, but wondering what the opinion might be.

BTW, "Long and Strong" has more to do with the handle length than the steel.

Thanks in advance for the input,

Craig

P.S. I've found several PSI products that are definitely worth picking up. One is their 1.5" wide round nose scraper. It is 3/8" thick. Makes a great shear scraper or larger bowl scraper. Their live adapter with #2 morse taper and 1"x8tpi thread is useful too.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#2

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Carole Valentine

Did not see the tool rests in their online catalog, but it does not surprise me if they have copied the Robust rests. I wonder if there is any turning accessory that those people have not copied the design, shipped it off to China and had it made at a fraction of the original manufacturers cost, while the original manufacturer absorbs all the cost of R&D. I simply will not buy from them, no matter how broke I am or how bad I might need something.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#3

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Dennis in Southern Oregon

I vote with Carole!

Dennis

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#4

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

robo hippy

I have never purchased any thing from them. Most of what I have seen that they carry is cloned or copied from other woodturner ideas. Quality does not seem to be up to par with the originals.

robo hippy

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#5

Lyle Jamieson

DITTO!!

Lyle Jamieson

Thank you Carol, I totally agree when you patronize these folks and others that copy all our good ideas you help put the originator out of business. Do you really think the $26.95 tool will work the same as a tool that should cost 3 times as much. It will not get sharp and it will not stay sharp. Using these tools ties one hand behind your back. There is no such thing as a free lunch. I have used tools (not mine) that proudly say on them “made in China and HSS” They were not HSS, at least not to the standards we need to turn well.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#6

The eccentric chuck appears to be an original

Craig Daymon

All that political crap aside, the eccentric chuck appears to be a original. I have not seen anyone else making one like this.

I also believe they are the only ones making the live 1"x8tpi threaded adapter.

They're also not alone in selling knock-offs. Woodcraft, Rockler, Craft Supplies, Packard Woodworks and lets not forget Harbor Freight, all sell knock-offs.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#7

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

There are those of us who remember when Made in Japan was a synonym for JUNK. How we laughed when the first Honda automobiles appeared -- "what did they do, bolt a couple of motorcycles together?" And we know how that turned out.

How much R&D goes into making a basic 3/8 bowl gouge? PSI tools are 85% as good as English or American quality tools and for 1/3 the price. Why not learn with PSI tools then upgrade if you stick with woodturning -- if you go back to the golf course, you have not invested as much.

Americans want to expand their markets and one billion Chinese can purchase a lot of our goods and services -- so, we are to boycott their products?

I am interested in answers to the original questions not political opinions. What is the story with that multi-axis chuck?

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#8

I bought some pen kits from Packard......

JamieDonaldson

... in December, and like to support Brad when I can. But when the kits arrived from Packard they still had the PSI stickers on the bags, so PSI must have a strangle hold on those imports. >(

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#9

Harry Robinette

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Harry Robinette

The only eccentric chuck I could find on the net is a copy of the one Ruth Niles

sells for the guy from Fl. With an old I believe it's Sorby's off center plate.Yes everyone is down on the knock off and yes allot of the major companys have them. BUT most of these company's also produce there own quality products also.PSI produces cheap junk they're HSS is the bottom of the barrel with a rocwell around 57 the very lowest there is.I think allot of there stuff is dangerous because of the way it's built or the materiel it's made from.

of coarse thats JMHO

Oh ya I refuse to buy from them also.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#10

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Jim Breeden

As for the steel bars glued on a tool rest, ala Robust (?), I did the same thing. Went down to my local machine shop supplier and bought a hardened 5/16 steel rod (made right here in the good ol' USA), epoxied it to the top of all my tool rests - bingo ! - slide heaven.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#11

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Craig Daymon

Really? The only eccentric chuck? Who makes the copy of Ruth Niles' (which looks similar to the Axminster eccentric, which Axminster has made for years)? There's also the Sorby. I thnk Kelton has one. And, of course, the one from Jean Francois Escoulen. None of which appear to be the same as the PSI eccentric.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#12

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

John Lucas

The offcenter chuck looks interesting but the off center pen mandrel is an accident waiting to happen. You should never never leave a piece of metal extended out like that. If it should start some vibration it will bend itself 90 degrees almost instantly and will hurt you.

We just had an accident in our shop when a gentleman left the long end of a threaded rod used as a drawbar hanging out of the back. When the lathe was turned on it bent 90 degrees and hit his arm. Fortunately it did little damage.

I've seen a video of a guy cut in half by a larger metal rod hanging out the back of a metal lathe. Quite gruesome but an effective warning.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#13

Re: DITTO!!

Craig Daymon

So I guess you're saying that nobody can turn well using carbon steel tools either? Even though people have been doing so for a long, long time. I guess I'll have to throw out all those Craftsman tools I have now that I know they are worthless. Along with all the ones that aren't cryo or micro grain.

Wonder if David Ellsworth was using HSS when he turned his first hollowforms? I don't think so because he wasn't using replaceable tips when he started and bending hardened HSS is not easy to do. How about Palmer Sharpless? What about when Del Stubs used an ax to turn? Was that a HSS ax?

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#14

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Ralph Lindberg

Carol, I can only state what I heard one time... "Yup, that is a copy of my design for a duplicator, but they pay me a small license fee for every one"

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#15

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Craig Daymon

Yeah, I didn't have any real interest in the add-ons. The main chuck was the thing of real interest to me. Unfortunately, it is all sold as one kit.

Truth is, it is very similar to a design I had, but never made. I made a wooden faceplate that can be offset using T-track and I had considered using a threaded rod to more precisely set the offset. The one I made had the T-track going in 2 directions, which isn't really useful. Rotation, which mine didn't support, and 1 axis linear placement covers most of the positions. Tilt would be the other thing to add to it. The wooden faceplate I created has lots of holes that would accommodate attaching a tilting platform or counter weights. It worked for my 3520, but I only have the mini now and it's a bit big for that.

Being able to attach a chuck, like with this one, I feel would have some additional advantages, so this is still looking interesting.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#16

Opinions are well, like......

Ralph Lindberg

It appears not one of the people posting to this thread actually own one.

However I do, here is my review (which Penn State has posted)

-------------------

Could be useful

As is common with PSI products, the fit and finish is not perfection. It is probably enough for most peoples turning needs however.

Some points that are not in either the video or documentation.

* The cross screw in the chuck, the one that moves the 1x8 drive spindle, measures out at approximately 20 turns per inch; so I assume the drive bolt is a 1/4x20.

* The offset holes in the Multi-Port Holder measure out at approximately 9/16, 11/16, 13/16 and 15/16 of an inch. So those are the default offsets.

* The holes in the Multi-Port Holder appear to be close to 3/8 x 16 (UNC). However the machining on mine appears to be a little off as some of my 3/8 x 16 hardware does not fit.

* Putting a standard size chuck on the Chuck Body is probably not a good idea, a mini-chuck would be a better choice.

--------

If you read the other reviews, you will note that some find it acceptable, others don't.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#17

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Ralph Lindberg

John, you can certainly have your opinion, but speaking as an owner of one of these, I have yet to have any such problem was you allude to.

Nor have I had those problems with the closed end pen mandrels I bought from a different source (and a different design )

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#18

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Ralph Lindberg

Harry, I suggest that your searching missed a few. I know of, what...5 different firms selling several different designs of Eccentric chucking systems, not counting the Vicmarc VOD.

Probably the best, is the one from Vicmarc Eccentric, but it is also the most expensive.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#19

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Ralph Lindberg

Ya, I've got a Sorby, completely different design and concept.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#20

Re: Opinions are well, like......

Craig Daymon

Hey Ralph,

Thanks for the input. I did read your review on the site. It is nice to know that the bolt is 20tpi.

I have a small Nova chuck that should work nice with this as it's direct threaded and uses jimmy bars rather than a key, so I think it's about as small as I can get.

Have you turned much using the chuck?

Thanks again,

Craig

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#21

Pens kits

Ralph Lindberg

There are only about 4 different importers of Pen Kits. Obviously Pen State is one, I can tell you that all the pen kits that Packard, Rockler and Woodcraft sell are from importers, they import none.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#22

Re: Opinions are well, like......

Ralph Lindberg

I tried using a Nova SN2, frankly it was too heavy. The Nova G3 might be OK, we don't have one so I haven't tried that one.

PSI uses the little Barracuda in their video. I just ordered one from Amazon (as they were cheaper then direct from PSI)

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#23

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

Carole Valentine

I suspect that if there is a patent, or if rights to the product are sold, that might be the case. I think that most of the time it is not, however. Anyway, this has nothing to do with the OP's original post...just one of my peeves.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#24

The eccentric unit is pretty nice

Dick Coers

for use with a face plate, or little Barracuda 3 chuck. I also use the little bottle stopper adapter, with a custom face plate, to do pendants. The adjustable offset stud on the chuck seems like it is a little loose, but once the faceplate is snugged up, all is locked and tight. I used it on my Delta 46-460. and at lower speed, no issues. I've only experimented with it a little, but I think it's going to be a lot of fun. So far, I think it's a bargain.

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

#25

Re: PSI Eccentric chuck, other products - opinions

John Lucas

As long as you run the slow running a piece of steel like that without the other end supported is going to be a problem some day. Glad it's working for you, just be careful.