Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Frustrating Situation

Posts

Re: Frustrating Situation

#26

Steven Antonucci

I don't have a title for it

Steven Antonucci

The demo was on the making of a hook tool, handling it, and then turning something with it. During the demo, I lay out a fairly specific process that I use, with EVERYTHING someone would need to know to be successful at making the tool. I repeatedly encourage people to take notes and ask questions with the intent of "teaching them" how to make hooks for themselves and their friends.

Turning a tool handle next just shows how to make a tool handle, but more importantly, leaves the club with a finished tool for their auction/raffle/fundraising. Lastly, I demo how a hook cuts and how to maintain them. I usually ask for volunteers to come out of the audience to get a little bit of hands on... and typically turn either a goblet or a small end grain box... all in 90 minutes.

There is nothing "proprietary" about any of the things that I do, and I was never upset by the fact that someone was making hooks. I had been told that they were actually going to be repeating MY demo (verbatim), which was incorrect and unfortunately relayed to me with the best of intentions. (I had asked a friend to give me the program chair's contact information to volunteer to do this demo for their club)

I usually charge a small fee to cover travel expenses like gas and tolls, and I bring a handful of premade hooks that I offer to anyone that wants them (and will not take the 15 minutes it takes to make one). I am really a cheap date and I share openly, so when I was told that someone would be repeating my demo, I felt pretty violated.

As I have explained, it turned out that they had no intention of repeating my demo, but they were inspired enough by what they saw to demo hook tools to their own club in their own way. I am good with that.

Steve

Re: Frustrating Situation

#27

Steven Antonucci

See my repsonse to Jake


Re: Frustrating Situation

#28

Steven Antonucci

Honor Among Men(and Women)

Steven Antonucci

Without calling anyone out for who got there first, I completely agree with you.

It is certainly one thing to see something commercially, and make one for yourself. It is completely another thing to see something commercially and knock it off cheaper than the original. There are dozens of people doing this, and I do not patronize them... and I often alert the originals to their presence.

I think people have a fundamental disconnect between physical and intellectual property. If you ask most people if copying something you can put your hands on is wrong, they would say yes, but not as many people would agree to an idea. We saw this early on in the music business with the whole RIAA thing and song pirates, and today, openness has meant more music is bought.

In retrospect, I think if the other turner had intended to copy my demo, and just asked me if I would be OK with it... I would have probably said yes. By being open about it, it becomes more about sharing than about protecting. I never meant to protect the knowledge, only the content of the demo (and the "performance" of it).

But as I've said, I was misinformed, and all is well.

Steve

Re: Frustrating Situation

#29

Brad Vietje

Re: Frustrating Situation

Brad Vietje

While we're out on this tangent...

Many of us here are club officers, or active in our local clubs, and it is typical that the same 6-8 people do almost all the work -- the board meetings, arranging fundraisers, group displays and public events, and yes -- the demo's, too.

For those smaller clubs that rely heavily upon inside talent for demonstrators, one positive benefit can be getting more people involved by asking them to be involved in demo's or take on a demonstration themselves. I keep reminding fellow tuners that they need not be an expert at something to demonstrate it or lead the discussion. If they do their homework, learn the key facts, prepare a handout or a list of web links, and are willing to get up in front of people to lead the discussion, they'll get a lot of help and good tips from others in the room, even if they are not an expert turner.

Doesn't address Steve's original point, but a benefit to getting more club menbers involved.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Frustrating Situation

#30

Brad Vietje

Interesting Discussion

Brad Vietje

Hey Steve,

This is an interesting topic. You have touched upon proper citation or attribution when discussing something that was learned from another person, and even intellectual property and professionalism.

I've done lots of demonstrations on hollow form turning, natural edge bowls, hollow ornaments, and a host of other topics. You can imagine how David Ellsworth, John Jordan or Stewart Mortimer feel when hundreds of their students go forth and demonstrate, and I've learned a good deal from all three. Like you, I give credit to my sources all the time, hold up their book or DVD, and tell people to buy it to support them, or at least borrow it from the club library.

The intellectual property question is a delicate one. If you patent a new tool, the hope is that you have legal protection against copy-cats. But if you popularize a form, or a process (like the sequence used in your demo), and teach this publicly, you don't have much to rely upon unless you either become very well known, or publish a book that explains your technique. JoHannes Michelsen, as an example, is well known for his turned wooden hats. Yet a number of his former students have gone out and offered demonstrations that show most of his methods and techniques at their local clubs after seeing him at a symposium.

These hats -- along with Peter Bloch's turned lampshades, and a few other very distinctive designs are possibly in a different category from more general objects like hollow forms, natural edge bowls, fancy pens, or other objects, simply because these are unique designs, while there are thousands of people making fine bowls, ornaments and hollow forms.

The real problem arises when someone starts making the same design or a very close knock-off (say the Range Rider hat), and offering them for sale in a gallery. I know someone who studied with Hannes, and has gotten quite good at making these hats. He has offered his very well-made hats at galleries, and I feel that is crossing the line. I have made and sold hollow forms that are similar in appearance to those made by David Ellsworth, but mine sell for a lot less than his! To a serious collector of wood art, they want the original, with the Ellsworth signature on it, so I'm not really affecting his market at all -- my customers are just not in the same price range as Ellsworth's, Jordan's or Mortimer's. Put another way, I've hit a home run or two, but my autograph just isn't Babe Ruth's!

These are all very interesting questions, and ones I would imagine the Professional Outreach Program of the AAW has taken up, and will continue to discuss. That would seem to be a good forum for a continuation of the discussion.

Best wishes and Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Frustrating Situation

#31

Steven Antonucci

Competing in a world market...

Steven Antonucci

So one of the things that you'll see if your horizons are broad enough is that there are places like China where intellectual capital simply doesn't exist. Their culture is basically completely void of the concept, so they see nothing wrong with copying (and fundamentally believe that there is nothing wrong with it). They have a completely different value system than the Western world. (please notice that I didn't ascribe write or wrong morality to it.)

Hannes' hats are a perfect example of where my consternation lied. If I had taken a class with Hannes or attended a demo with him, I would certainly expect that he would expect that it was with the intent of making a hat. I would also think that most people might agree that it would be bad form to start selling hats to the same galleries he sells through (hey, mine are cheaper!) or potentially market my "Hannes hat making demo" to a bunch of clubs in New England. I would find it most offensive (if I was Hannes) if I was doing "his demo", using all of his fixtures, and every step that he taught without any changes or additional steps or processes. Aside from the work produced, many people also overlook the fact that the demo itself is a "work product".

The lines are always moving as to what is or isn't acceptible, and we're seeing a huge change introduction (via things like YouTube) to the way content is distributed and shared. If you remember music 15 years ago, people were suing over sampling 4 or 5 notes of a melody. Today, bands are covering songs while they are still on Top 40 rotation! Do they ask for permission? Should they ask for permission? I don't know the answer to that one...?

I am all for the demo mash-up, and I have been know to use St. Leger's tongue oil, Mocho's tighten all four jaws, and a few of my own. I always jokingly tell the audience that you can tell who a turner has seen by the jokes they use, and cite all of my sources accordingly.

As the world gets smaller and cultural differences become more prevalent, I think well see much more of it than we do today. If you have seen most clubs recording the demonstrators they bring in, a very simple question arises... who owns the content of the DVD they recorded? And what is fair use? Nobody has tested the waters yet, but I can see someone going to the club library and publishing a "10 Great Turners DVD set" for $50 and undercutting the entire DVD market...someday. (it won't be me)

Steve

Re: Frustrating Situation

#32

Re: Frustrating Situation

Derek Dix

Hi Steven,

I find the direction of this topic fascinating.

I think you are correct with being disappointed with somebody being paid to do a demo that was rumoured to be so similar to your own. A verbatim demo would not be cool.

However as some have pointed out, if we are to broaden our abilities we need to learn it from anywhere we can. Some clubs can't afford to always pay to have the best demonstrators come to their club. Or members to afford to go to an AAW symposium (Fingers crossed it comes to Canada one day). This doesn't mean they should copy you exactly.

As to the direction Brad is going with this thread...

The other day when I grabbed the latest issue of Wood Turning Design and flipped thru the pages, I saw a very nice Binh Pho'esk vessel. Upon further inspection I noticed it was made by Graeme Mcintyre. Graemes work is very well made and he cites his influence and training directly from Binh. Which was obvious due to the colouring and dragon flies. He has submitted his work to galleries and competitions in his native New Zealand. So I ask. "Is this crossing the line". My gut reaction was "yes". Then after some time to think about it I decided (albeit very close) "no".

I have been struggling with getting my own designs from paper to lathe recently for the exact reason of not wanting to copy Binh. The other day I heard a saying. The first person to do something is unique. The second to do the same thing is a copy. The third is a trend.

An interesting way of looking at it.

So is Graeme copying Binh or trending Frank Sudol? What about Joey Richardson who's work is also heavily influenced by Binh.

After considerable thought and time to this subject I can only liken it to Impressionist painting. Most people associate impressionist painting With Monet. But what about Renoit, Pissarro and the American painter Whistler. Not to mention the many other painters that influenced that style of painting in the mid to late 1800's.

Eddie VanHalen used to play guitar with his back to the crowd because he didn't want anybody copying his style.

I am now in the process of getting my designs to my lathe. My influences are Binh primarily and others that interest me. Now it includes Graeme Mcintyre.

By the way do you have any plans to come to Canada? I have seen the video that AAW produced with André Martel demonstrating the hook tool and it has always intrigued me. I've considered trying to make one, or by one of Andrés.

Derek Dix

Re: Frustrating Situation

#33

Re: Frustrating Situation

John Lucas

Binh and Frank Sudol both had one thing in common when they are(were) teaching. Find your own voice. You can take their styles and work with them but if you turn enough of them you will find your own way of using these techniques. Joey Richardson is an excellent example. You would not confuse her work for Binh's (if you know the work) however you can easily see the influence. I have never seen her earlier work but I'll bet it was closer to Binh's and or Franks.

If you turn enough, or simply design enough, you will add a little of yourself into the pieces.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#34

Steven Antonucci

Andre Martel started me on hooks

Steven Antonucci

and I usually open with that in my demo... and that hooks have been around for a number of years prior to Andre or my discovery (Robin Wood was the FIRST guy I saw... Darrell Feltmate had a YouTube video very early on...)

Influence is very difficult thing to manage. I think there are some things that you can be influenced by and "copy" without having to attribute anyone specifically because there is a "trend". A simple example is a calabash shaped bowl or a Grecian urn shaped vessel. I don't care what turner might get known for either, they cannot own the shape- even if their work becomes known for it.

Specific touches become harder to separate from the individual. If you see Binh's work and his protege's work, there is influence (obviously), but they are far from copies. Binh cannot own the shape, or piercing, or color... but the assembly of the three in a specific manner... I'd give him that. It becomes up to the protege to find something else to do that makes it their own.

I stopped reading Turning magazines because I found that all of my great ideas were someone else's first. For me, I prefer the journey over the execution. The process of maturing an idea into a workable solution is far more interesting than the finished result. If you truly want to learn something, you have to take the journey.

The beauty is, the more miles you've walked, the easier the next journey becomes.

Steve

P.S. Andre Martel is a better turner than I am, but our hook tool demos are VERY different. I cannot make his hook, which is how I arrived at my own.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#35

You must be copying Alan Lacer ;-)

Don Orr

He has done a hook-making demo for many years. Just sayin. :D ;)

Re: Frustrating Situation

#36

Re: Frustrating Situation

George Guadiane

I haven't read any of the other opinions, but my answer is:

It depends...

If the person doing your demo is giving you adequate credit and NOT showing your content in a dangerous or inauthentic way, you could probably be a Little over sensitive.

I had a similar situation a couple of years ago. I did a demo at Totally Turning (for free) and 5/6 months later, someone in New Hampshire was doing something like it without acknowledging me AND CHARGING for the class.

The only reason I found out about it is that one of the people who saw what the guy was doing told me about it.

I got over it.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#37

Re: Frustrating Situation

bill Crommett

A slightly different take. Has anyone seen an automobile lately, one that is built for the mass market, that does not have a competitors design built into the end product ? When i was a kid you could tell a Caddy from a Chevy, or a Plymouth from a Ford just by a glance. Now the only telltale differences are the color or the designation as SUV, Convertible, two door, or icky. And now they are copying ICKY>

Re: Frustrating Situation

#38

Steven Antonucci

Can't copy what you haven't seen.


Re: Frustrating Situation

#39

Jim Barbour

Re: Frustrating Situation

Jim Barbour

In the interest of full disclosure, recognize that I am a University Professor and everything we do is in the realm of intellectual rather than physical property so this debate is not new to me at all, and I have a particular take on it.

I find myself in a (slightly) similar situation at the moment, only from the other side. I am off to do a demo this Saturday and a class on Sunday. In one of the Saturday demos I am using turning a gavel to demonstrate the fundamentals of spindle turning. My first gavel was from the excellent instructions provided by Larry Hancock and, of course I will be giving him credit. I suspect any of us who might demonstrate a gavel would use very similar techniques since gavels are pretty much ubiquitous. The gavel is in the public domain and showing how to turn one does not violate anyone's proprietary rights to gavel turning. Using the same script as someone else for the demo is quit a different matter, which is, as I understand it, Steve's objection.

My real problem is a bit different and I ask your assistance. Some years ago I saw an article about turning a round-bottomed vessel that sat at an angle when it was placed on a table. The angle was determined by the placement of a ring inside the vessel (an interior bead) up a ways from the bottom. The location of the bead gave the vessel the tilt. Much later I had the pleasure of spending time with Mark St Leger at Arrowmont and, influenced by his (then new) round-bottomed boxes, I was led back to the original idea and made one without reference to the article other than memory. Now I have made lots of them and I really have no idea how close I am to the one in the original article.

This vessel is what we are doing on Sunday for the class. The problem is that I cannot find the article (did I dream it?). If you know of such a piece please let me know so I can make attribution; otherwise I will just tell the story I have recounted here.

A second issue is what to call them. I have called them Rockie Boxes for some time, but have never been comfortable with the name since it is so close to Mark's Rocka-Bye-Boxes. The object is quite different with no possibility of confusing the one for the other, but does the same "too close to call your own" notion apply to the names we hang on our work? I have decided yes, and mine are now called "Tipply Boxes", to avoid harming Mark or creating confusion.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#40

Steven Antonucci

I think you are handling it well

steven antonucci

I think it's important to have the following approach:

1.) Cite references when you have them.

2.) When you cannot cite a specific reference, be open about it ("I don't recall exactly where I saw this, but it spawned this idea in my head...)

3.) Credit "non-turning" references if you are using outside influence

4.) Avoid conflicts in names at all costs

I'm 99% sure it is almost impossible to be original anymore (you can be obscure)

In a technology optimized world, there will also be subliminal aspects of what we do. For instance, while it might be possible to cite the influences in work, tooling or content on your website, doing so makes it easier for search engines to find you. By giving credit, you may actually be competing with the people you are trying to protect.

On the other hand, tagging can also be done with this exact intent. Go to Ebay and search for your favorite tools and see what shows up. Is it attribution/credit, or an intent to redirect?

Sorry I cannot help you with your question. I sort of remember the article, but I am more familiar with Sigfried Schrieber's work for the same effect.

Steve

Re: Frustrating Situation

#41

Re: Frustrating Situation

Craig Daymon

Just a suggestion, as I haven't put too much thought into the idea, but maybe consider treating it like an open source software license has been applied to the idea?

If you are using the idea as-is, then acknowledge where it came from.

If you do something that adds to it, not so much the design, but improving the process to create it, then make an effort to inform the originator of your improvement. (Whether they believe it to be so is up to them.)

If it's a new design, somewhat hard to determine when it comes to turning since we are just making/combining circles in wood, try to document your process.

In software, having seen/read an article about Larry Hancock's or Mark St. Leger's designs, would in and of itself invalidate any attempt by you to create the, functionally same, item. (Software being functional.) An open source license would allow you to branch off your own version of the design as long as you give credit to those contributing up to the point of the branch.

Of course, all this means documenting all your work, which is somewhat tedious. On the plus side, open source licensing does allow for advancement of an idea and for the development of new ideas based on combining pieces. (Unlike software patents, which tend to stifle technological advancement and foster the growth of patent trolls.)

With respect to the name idea, how about, "Wobble Boxes"? Not sure if it fits with your boxes, but if they are meant to rock/tip back and forth, it might make a good name. I'm taking it from Weebles (wobble but they don't fall down), but I'm certain "Weebles" is copyrighted.

-Craig

Re: Frustrating Situation

#42

Jim Barbour

Re: Frustrating Situation

Jim Barbour

Thanks Craig ~

Yes, open source is an excellent model, as is a creative commons license. As far as Wobble Box goes, that's where I went first and, on searching, found that "Wobbly Box" is new urban slang for a decrepit dwelling. As in, "man, when the storm came through Mack's wobbly box was blown clean away and he is now living on the street."

There is even a website, wobblybox.com for a realtor who is helping people purchase condemned and otherwise falling down property to flip it. That's not an association I wanted.

This just gets more and more tangled, doesn't it.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#43

Re: Frustrating Situation

Lan Brady

Good Luck with the demo and Workshop

Lan

Re: Frustrating Situation

#44

Re: Frustrating Situation

Craig Daymon

Too bad, I liked the Weebles tie-in.

Speaking of wobbling turnings, several years ago I went with the Bucks (County, PA) turners to the Woodturning Center in Philly. (It has a different name and location now, which escapes me.) There was a featured turner from Germany whose pieces were very large and very precisely turned. He had one that was a large maple bowl (maybe 24" in diameter or more) with a round bottom, an in-turned rim and a smooth, round groove track about 1.5" to 2" down from the rim. In the groove he had a large steel bearing.

You would start the bearing around the track and then watch as the bowl began to slowly rock more and more aggressively, reaching a peek when the bearing would stop (transfer of momentum). Then it would progress back to the point where the bearing was moving and the bowl was still, continuing until all momentum was lost.

Neat piece to see. I think I have a short video I shot of it around somewhere.

Found the videos. Two bowls, one with 3 tracks that you would start bearings rolling in opposing directions (2 in the same, one opposed). The other just very round that had a bearing to roll in it. Videos don't quite show it come to a stop. Let's see if I can embed one. Nope.

-Craig

Re: Frustrating Situation

#45

Jim Barbour

Re: Frustrating Situation *LINK*

Jim Barbour

Sigfried Schrieber is his name. Absolutely stunning. Steve mentions him above. Here's a link


http://www.siegfriedschreiber.de/en/

Re: Frustrating Situation

#46

Bob Moffett

Re: Frustrating Situation

Bob Moffett

Jim, I'm sure you will handle it diplomatically. They are fortunate to have you do a demonstration and workshop for them.