Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Frustrating Situation

Posts

Frustrating Situation

#1

Steven Antonucci

Frustrating Situation

Steven Antonucci

What do you guys thinks about this?

I do a very specific demo that nobody else does. I'm pretty proud of the content, and I enjoy presenting it. I worked hard at developing it, and it is geared towards club meetings (90 minutes or so).

I reached out to a club to see if they'd be interested in scheduling the demo when I was going to be in their area, and I found out that one of their members is a member at a club where I demonstrated last year... and he's actually going to be doing my demo in April?

Am I being oversensitive?

Steven

Re: Frustrating Situation

#2

Re: Frustrating Situation

John Lucas

Well when we teach, others will use our lessons. What we have to do is teach better. They may be able to teach the project but they actually help the members learn to be better turners. That's what I try to do. Anyone can teach how to make a hand mirror. I teach how to make a hand mirror with the proper cuts to improve your skills for other projects.

Imagine how people like John Jordan and David Ellsworth might feel. I'm sure over the years many many people are teaching their techniques and even copying their work.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#3

Alan Zenreich

Re: Frustrating Situation

Alan Zenreich

Steve,

When you teach, consider it flattering that others think enough of what you taught to help spread the word.

Hopefully, the new teachers put their own spin on the topic.

The challenge is to keep innovating and be entertaining enough so that people want to hear YOU speak, not just because of the topic that you present.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#4

Steven Antonucci

Your hand mirror demo is a great example...

Steven Antonucci

It is entirely unique, and pretty much the only one out there.

So how would you feel if someone started making hand mirrors? You wouldn't care, right? (because you showed them how to make hand mirrors...that's kind of the purpose of the demo)

But what if they decided to do the demo? Your demo. Using your methods, showing your techniques and most likely a majority of your content? Most clubs record demonstators, so there is ample opportunity to review what the presenter shows.

I see the parallel to Ellsworth, as there are many people doing hollowing demos (I am one), but I have never seen the same hollowing demo twice from the various people I have seen. We all add our own content and hopefully improve the techniques.

I have helped people build a Priddle vaporizer, but I would never demo it.

I have turned Michael Hosaluk throw tops, but I would never demo it.

I have demonstrated Ellsworth style hollowing, but I use a hook tool and a bowl gouge.

It just seems like this is on the other side of what's acceptible.

Steve

Re: Frustrating Situation

#5

Re: Your hand mirror demo is a great example...

Dick Coers

Consider the number of people (many famous too) demonstrating how to make boxes. Wasn't Raffan the first? I think I've seen 5 or 6 people over the years do that same demo, same techniques.

Look at the number of clubs that have libraries, and the number of guys that watch a single copy of the DVD.

It's just the way it works. Bad or good.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#6

Re: Frustrating Situation

Guy Bratt

I'm confused. If you don't want people to do what you do. Why do you teach them? If you have secret techniques you shouldn't tell any one. ????

Re: Frustrating Situation

#7

Re: Frustrating Situation

robo hippy

I guess my first reaction would be ruffled feathers, then they would go down. I love to teach, and would be honored that I presented it well enough so that others could pass it on.

robo hippy

Re: Frustrating Situation

#8

Jim Evans

Re: Frustrating Situation

Jim Evans

Do you know if the other guy is giving you credit for what he is teaching? If so it should take a lot of the sting out of it.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#9

Jesper, Denmark

Re: I think so......

Jesper, Denmark

Take it as a compliment to your technique and ability - and move on.

This is an open community, and we all share knowledge here on forum and in demo's. If you have not copyrighted or otherwise protected your intellectual property, it's out there for all to use.

Experts generally need have no fear of copyists. Ellsworth has demonstrated for years - but it has not generated a true copy of Ellsworth.

On the other hand, if one would demonstrate how to hit a nail with a hammer, many would get the technique and be able to duplicate the skill - and demonstrate it.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#10

Steven Antonucci

Not doing what I do, but showing what I show

Steven Antonucci

I start my demo with "If you intend to learn to use this, you will need to know how to make them... because at some point, you will break one and it should only take you a few minutes to fix it and get back into turning"

I have no issue showing people how to make things so they can do it. I have issues with other people "pirating" my demo while I am actively doing the demo. I found out about it when someone I showed the demo to decided "hey, I can do that demo too" because it was rated as "one of the best demos that they had ever seen".

I want people to make the thing I make and use it freely. I don't want someone to view my demo as "their demo" because they saw it. Imagine going to see Star Wars and then reshooting it because you felt it gave you the right.

It's kind of like that.

Steve

Re: Frustrating Situation

#11

Steven Antonucci

eventually will get there


Re: Frustrating Situation

#12

Re: Your hand mirror demo is a great example...

John Lucas

Steve I'm guessing it probably has happened. Maybe not locally but I've had articles on how to make the mirrors published in England as well as here. I'm sure someone has done the demo. I do see mirrors displayed at the instant galleries from time to time. I don't know if it came directly from my demo's or articles but I'm honored if they are. Besides that mirrors have been done before. I started by copying the mirrors in Woodsmith magazine and then took them in another direction.

Have you seen Bill Grumbine do a bowl. Gosh how many people have done that same demo. Bill does it mildly differently and adds some humor. Mike Mahoney does a bowl and coring, how many other do that.

Stewart Batty just turns a bowl, and I've seen the same techniques Jimmy Clewes uses many times.

However each one of those adds their own personality to it, and their own teaching style. Raffen was mentioned. When we had him at our club I didn't see a single thing that hadn't been taught before often by our local turners. He was fun, interesting, and enjoyable to watch. I guess that's what makes the difference.

We have an interesting thing happening in woodturning and it's carrying over into the flat work. That is the sharing aspect. Many years ago when I got into wood working other artists would not share their techniques especially in finishing. When I got into turning everyone readily shared what they did. It made a much closer community. I do see copies of others work. Usually not sold in the same market and rarely done as well.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#13

Re: Frustrating Situation

richie c

Did you ever hear a really funny joke,and couldn't wait to tell someone else the same joke!

Its just human nature.You like the way the joke made you feel so you spread it with good intentions. Most people credit the source ;if they are asked!

Thats why most comedians wont listen to another comics act. They dont want to subconiously steal a joke thats already been told.Not quite the same for wood turners.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Frustrating Situation

Keith Tompkins

Good analogy Richie...I don't go to very many demo's for the same reason!

Re: Frustrating Situation

#15

Re: Frustrating Situation

John Lucas

Actually I go to other peoples demos to learn how to make mine better. A good example, and I wish I could remember who said it, was to glide the bevel, not ride the bevel. This is a much better description of how it should be done.

I love to see how other turners approach the wood with their tools. It might be very subtly different than what I do . I will go home and try it to see if it works for me and might work for others. I'll give credit when I can remember. I certainly don't claim to know or invent all this stuff myself. I'm like a sponge. I collect data, use what works and then try to teach others what has worked for me.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#16

Alan Zenreich

Re: Frustrating Situation

Alan Zenreich

John, I agree. I attend people's demos, lectures, etc. in a variety of fields and interests, not so much to learn new techniques, but instead to see how they are imparting the information.

Being able to do something well, doesn't necessarily mean that one can teach or inspire others to try what they see in the demo.

One thing I forgot to mention before is that some clubs draw only upon their own membership for demos. One of the clubs I belong to is this way... they simply don't invite (and pay) other turners to demonstrate. Whether it's a matter of finances for smaller clubs, or just the nature of the inbreeding, these clubs depend on their members attending demos, conferences, and symposia... and then showing the club what they've learned.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#17

Re: Frustrating Situation

John Lucas

Ditto Alan I meant to mention that also. Our local clubs don't have the resources to bring in outside people. Several of our members go to various symposiums or attend other club meetings. If they see a demo they think the members might like and have the skills to present it then they do. I'm sure it's meant as more of a compliment to the other demonstrator, that they thought enough about it to try it themselves.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Frustrating Situation

Keith Tompkins

Steve, I do demo's on turning finials, which instantly brings to people's minds that I'm either taking away from Cindy Drozda's work, or simply copying what she does. But finials have been turned for hundreds of years; mine are based on classical forms introduced to me in part by Steve Sherman, who I always give credit to for turning me on to turning them.

Re: Frustrating Situation

#19

Re: Frustrating Situation

robo hippy

That brings up a good point. I owe most of my skills to what I have seen others do. I always try to mention who I learned things from. They may not have been the 'original' but I feel I owe it to them to say it.

From Pat's fan over at Woodnet, "When sphincter tightening exceeds chuck tightening, you have a problem". It always gets a laugh, and most understand.

robo hippy

Re: Frustrating Situation

#20

Steven Antonucci

Heresay and misunderstanding

Steven Antonucci

As it turns out, the whole situation was unwarranted. I was told something by someone who inadvertantly had the nature of the demo incorrect. The other demonstrator assured me that they were not doing my demo, but something very different.

I am more than comfortable with this result, and I wish him luck with his demo.

Steve

Re: Frustrating Situation

#21

Re: Frustrating Situation

Don Stephan

Imagine how an individual or company feels who invests time and money in developing a new tool, only to see others make a knockoff for less because they could skip the research and development. But I often see recommendations to buy such and such from this other company, that doesn't develop new products, because their version sells for less. Why should we expect individuals and companies to try to make new and better products?

Re: Frustrating Situation

#22

Re: Heresay and misunderstanding

Mike Gibson

So you don't want us to knee cap him after all..... :)

Re: Frustrating Situation

#23

Ok - What's the Title of this Special Demo?

jake Niedling

You got my curoisity up to know what the demo is all about. So let us know!

Re: Frustrating Situation

#24

You need to ask yourself why......

Nick Todd

Steve,

You have to ask why you are doing demo's in the first place? To teach?, To share info with others? To show your secret?

Our chapter has challenged our members you have attended a symposium or demo to demo a topic they saw at chapter meets. The best you can ask for is for them to give you proper credit.

If you are using a new technique you need to charge enough to compensate yourself for developing it. People are paying demo & symposium fees to learn new techniques in their work.

If you don't want people to use what you have demoed for/taught them commercially, you need to get releases before they sign up.

Nick

Re: Frustrating Situation

#25

Re: You need to ask yourself why......

g clarke

When I was in medical school we had a saying " see one, do one, teach one". It has worked well for many years. You want knowledge to be passed on to the generations. If it bothers you to have your work copied then you should not teach others to do what you do. Be generous with your technique and help others to learn. Please do not get your knickers in a knot. If your are upset about it, do not do it. my 2 cents.