Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Tool Steel

Posts

Re: Tool Steel

#26

Re: Tool Steel

robo hippy

I have talked to Dave about the wheels if you happen to load them up (brass, aluminum, or other softer metals). He said to just take a heavy scraper to the wheel and sharpen the scraper, and that generally cleans them up.

How long? Well, I don't know. My older matrix type CBN wheels, the 80 grit wheel with 3/16 inch of matrix bonded to the aluminum hub went strong for 6 plus years of turning maybe 700 bowls and many other things, and still had half the matrix left when I switched to the D Way wheels.

I never knew that the Optigrind had more than one grit. I have thought that having a really coarse wheel might help for when I want to shape things. That, or Stuart Batty's Omni Grinder if it ever makes it to market. It would be easier to round over the bottom edges of my scrapers with as well.

robo hippy

Re: Tool Steel

#27

Thanks, Jerry, and . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Your detail is actually about what I expected to see if I had a SEM bolted to my bench. Unfortunately, my reading glasses are a rather poor substitute. :D

Coincidentally, you also provided a great reason to discard hollow grinding in favor of convex bevels.

As a young sculptor, I was trained to use a shallow convex bevel on all my wood carving tools because it provides a much higher degree of control over the cutting edge and a more durable edge that is "supported" by the extra metal behind it. That has carried over into how I do my turning tools. Turners who hollow grind and then speak about "riding the bevel" are, for the most part, talking about 2-point contact by the sharp edge and the heel as a fulcrum. With a convex bevel we have an infinite number of fulcrum points along that bevel's curved surface, and which one we use for a particular cut depends on how heavy or light a slice we choose to take.

Consider as well that with a bevel ground with an 80 grit scratch pattern riding the cut surface behind that nicely honed cutting edge, the effect can be much the same as 80 sandpaper.

Not to hijack Cindy's thread, but your micrographs make a good case for polished convex bevels on all our turning tools, eh what? ;)

Re: Tool Steel

#28

Re: Thanks, Jerry, and . .

jerryw

Curious - how do you control the consistency of your convex bevel shape, especially on a gouge?

Re: Tool Steel

#29

Making Convex Bevels

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

As the bevels are short, 1/4" on gouges to 1/2" on a skew, it's easy to shape the bevel by holding the tool at 90° and rocking it on the fine wheel then use that honing board to polish it up a bit if you don't have or want to use a leather strop. It's even easier if you use a narrow belt sander/grinder such as John Lucas just pictured. I redo the bevel once for every 10 sharpenings, but then when I sharpen, I'm only lightly kissing the edge to the wheel to remove the least metal possible rather than trying to remake the new-tool factory grind that we've been told to love. I find it's less a matter of a precisely consistent curve as it is keeping a shallow convex going. Pretty easy to do just by eye.

Good Example: Look at Ellsworth's grind of a detail gouge in the WC Tool Grinds Library.

PS: Also the very same idea, a convex bevel supporting the cutting edge, with his parting tool grind that follows the detail gouge.

Re: Tool Steel

#30

Re: Thanks, Jerry, and . .

John Lucas

That's why I'm not a current fan of the convex grinds. I found my self sort of searching for the bevel when I turn beads. that's using my skew. I'm still playing with them a little on bowl gouges to try and learn more.

Mark when I am cutting with the skew with a concave grind I am really just riding the initial bevel. The bevel at the bottom of the concave probably does come into play. You can tell this when cutting a bead. The rear or bottom of the hollow ground bevel never even touches the wood.

Re: Tool Steel

#31

Skewing  Around - The MicroBevel

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I would agree with the assessment, John, when you're rolling a bead or other convex form; less so, I think, when you're cutting a cove or doing a peel. That said, the skew's bevel, if convex at all, has to be very slight. That said, using a hollow grind on a skew will make it easier to hone the cutting edge's mini-bevel (see Jerry's pix) as you can use the heel as a 1-point fulcrum for the abrasive block.

For comparison, I put a convex grind on my 1/2" spindle gouge and it will leave a near-polished surface when cutting end grain.

Re: Tool Steel

#32

Re: Hunter tools

Peter Lamb

Johannes Michelsen sells the optigrind made in Austria. 6"and 8" wheels with side grind. Grits 80, 180, 240. There is also a 45 grit at least in 8"