In case anyone wants to start a discussion about the merits and disadvantages of CPM 10V (A11) turning tools vs M2 HSS tools, here is my opinion on the subject.....
http://cindydrozda.blogspot.com/
I quite like the performance of 10V (Thompson Tools), now that I am sharpening them properly.
If you read her whole article she thinks that you get a better edge on HSS that the Thompsons if you use a white wheel. Granted I have not tried the CBN. I don't seem to have any trouble getting a very sharp edge on my Thompson tools with the White wheel. My tools are getting shorter so it must be removing metal.
I do use diamond hones on my skew but it's because I like it sharper than my 100 grit white wheels will do. My diamond hones go to 1200 grit. Don't know if a 1200 grit white wheel would do that since I don't have one.
I am getting ready to run a test on 3 different sharpening systems. If I can find a local turner who has a CBN wheel I will try it out.
I found your blog on the differences between M2 and 10V to be very well written and extremely interesting.
Chuck Engstrom just did a demo at Chesapeake in which he showed sharpening with the CBN wheel.
I had not given serious consideration to buying one, before reading your article, but I am now. I have a lot of Doug's tools and want to do them full justice.
General rule in a tool room is that every edge that leaves a given abrasive will by as sharp, but only as sharp, as that abrasive's grit size.
It takes CBN (which I use) or diamond (preferably diamond) to sharpen carbide, but we cannot "sharpen" a carbide granule of 3000+ grit size (in the powder steel matrix) with a 180 or 200 grit size abrasive. The far larger granules of the abrasive cannot do so when the scratch pattern left by the abrasive is larger than the particle structure of the steel being abraded. IIRC the particle size in powdered metal tools is an order of magnitude smaller than the CBN granules bonded to my wheel.
This is not, however, to take issue with the OP premise that harder abrasives do a better job of sharpening the higher alloys. I use an 80 grit 3x Norton wheel to shape my tools, most of which are 2060 or V11 alloy, but I use a 180 size CBN for sharpening and then may touch up an edge with a 1000 grit diamond hone. The CBN does a great job and there's no aluminum oxide dust to contend with in the shop air.
Mark, Take a relook at the two articles Alan Lacer and I wrote for the AAW journal and the article we wrote for Woodturning, recently. In them you will see visually the impact of various sharpening methods on gouge and scraper edges. Shown are high magnification edge photos as well as cut wood surfaces from same edges. Clearly, the finer the grind (hone is best) the sharper the tool.
I have some 2030 gouges from Packard and a lot more gouges from Doug. I have never had a problem sharpening them with any wheel, white or blue or green. The green wheel I bought from Wood Workers Supply did not cost a fortune and does a very good job at sharpening. I promise not to show any of my wood a magnified picture of the edge of my gouges as I do not want any of my wood to feel a monstrous amount of pain!
In fact, that's why I went to a 180 CBN from a 120 AlO for sharpening. It's also why I hone my skews with a diamond board and use a ceramic slip on the inside of the fluted tools. I would be very surprised, however, to see a micrograph showing me that I've put a cutting edge on the carbide particles in my powdered alloy steels.
I have had CBN wheels for 8 or so years, can't really remember, but had some of the matrix type made locally. I haven't touched standard wheels in so long, I can't remember what they are like.
Back when I had some standard wheels, my turning tools were a set from Craft Supplies of M2HSS, a signature Ellsworth M2HSS, and one of the Packard 'cuts 5 times longer' gouges. When I first got the Packard gouge, I used it non stop for a month. One day I went back to the Ellsworth gouge, and it cut with a lot less effort.
I have a friend, Larry Karlin, who has been turning small myrtle trays, about 700 a year for the last 17 or so years. He can forecast the weather for a week by how the myrtle is cutting (seriously). He got one of the CBN wheels, and didn't like it at first because it didn't cut as well. After it broke in, he liked it enough so that he got another one. He does use the Thompson gouges as well.
I use mostly the Thompson gouges, and still have a couple of the Oneway harder steel ones, and a couple of D Way. I have gone back and forth between sharpening them on the 80 and 180, and can't really feel any difference. I have sharpened on my Tormek, and again can't really feel any difference. This might be different if I used one gouge for a week or two and then switched to another steel and sharpening set up. I don't really know. I have honed, and again, don't notice any difference.
I am thinking that most turners agree that skews cut better when honed (I seldom use the skew). I don't think that bowl gouges do, and most bowl turners don't hone. The difference is most likely in grain orientation. When cutting in spindle orientation, the grain all goes in the same direction, so the honed edge works better. When turning bowls, you are going with the grain, then against it. Here the more serrated edge seems to have an advantage, I guess because it is easier to saw through than it is to slice. Kind of like the table saw. You might get burning, but almost no tear out due to grain orientation.
One turner made the comment about the serrated edges. Think of it as a comb. If you look at it side ways you see lots of fingers sticking up. If you rotate it 45 or more degrees, the fingers disappear, leaving a more even edge. So, maybe if you cut at a shear angle, the coarsness of the edge might not be a big factor.
I did have a 320 grit CBN wheel, and didn't like it. It felt that when I sharpened with it, the edge did not totally refresh. Kind of like when it is time to stop honing and go back to the grinder.
What does all this mean???? Well, I still have to figure that out.
I willl do an interesting test today. I have some walnut that will not cut clean on the uphill grain direction. Turning my mirrors you always get that a little but most of the time I can go to a more acute bevel tool and take care of the problem. this stuff won't. I'm going to sharpen a gouge on my course gray stone, then on my green stone, and then back to my 100 grit white stone and maybe the 120 grit belt and see if makes any difference. By the way the green one is for carbide so no doubt about it cutting the carbide.
At the GA symposium last year l purchased a Thompson scraper, back home l wanted to shape it on a Detla grinder with the wheels it came with and it took me a very long time to get the shape l desired. At the TAW last month l needed another with an opposite grind so l asked Doug if he could show me with what and how he does it. He uses a Norton 46 grit K series and after a very aggressive dressing of the wheel it took him no time at all, the serrated edge from his wheel was far too much for my liking to make fine cuts, but after a trip to my grinder and a hone it works fine. l also bought one of his new parting tools and have nothing but praise after using a cheap diamond shaped one since l started turning l will never go back. Great blog by the way Cindy. Michael.
I know that Craft Supplies now carries CBN wheels, as does Johannes Michelson, and D- Way tools. Any thoughts or preferences? The Craft supplies version is from Vienna I think, and the recommend a slow speed grinder. What do you think?
D Way for sure. Mostly I like the extra width of 1 1/2 inches. I did get a Cutter Master wheel from up in Canada that has a side grind option (about 1/4 inch) and is 1 inch wide. After using the wider D Way wheel for almost 2 years, I really like the extra width. I have never slid off the edge of this wheel. The side grind option is used by the wood carvers more than the turners.
Interesting thread. I'm a big Benjamin's Best fan. Cheap, plain ol' HSS but they sure do cut nicely with very little effort. Managed to find a Crown 2030 5/8" bowl gouge that certainly lasts longer between sharpenings, and cut almost as easily. Then I finally got 2 Thompsons, a V and a Round flute 5/8" Must admit they keep their edge BUT need a lot more effort on my part plus tear out a lot more on difficult grain. I have tried different grinds and also honing but they don't come close to the finish and ease of use that I get from HSS. I've done side by side evaluations using the exact same grind set up on the same grinding wheels in front of independent witnesses and apart from the longer use between sharpening can find no benefit at all from using the more exotic Thompson tools. I'm an arthritis sufferer and ease of use is a big thing for me. Plus I also find picking up a cut is far easier with the HSS.
I decided it was time to do some sort of sharpening test. I took my Thompson 1/2" V gouge and sharpened on lots of different stones and belts. My normal sharpening is on a 100 grit white wheel slow speed grinder. I made a cut on my really hard to cut clean walnut. I think this actually may be some sort of foreign wood and not american walnut. It looks very similar but is darker. It has a bad streak that will not cut clean.
I sharpened the gouge on my 100 grit white wheel, 120 grit Zirconia sanding belt, My Sheppac wet wheel grinder (with the Green leather strop), My very course Gray wheel ( don't know the grit but about 40 to 60) at 3450 rpm, and my Green wheel that is about 60 grit at 3450 rpm.
what did I learn. Well duh, the course wheel left the roughest cut and the finest left the cleanest cut. None of them cleaned up the bad area in the wood although the finer ones got closer. The green wheel is for sharpening carbide and the gray wheel is not. I could not tell the difference in those two.
So I pulled out my 2 HSS gouges. Now they don't have the same grind. They are a little it more acute so I thought they would cut cleaner. I really couldn't tell the difference. Of course I'm feeding the tool by hand and feed rate can make a difference. The highly polished steel does cut easier.
Since that didn't seem to prove anything I pulled out a carbon steel fish tail carving tool with 35 degree bevel (finer than the gouges) freshly polished it on the green strop and tried it. It was cleaner. so I pulled out my Henry taylor 1" spindle gouge with a 35 degree bevel and my Thompson 1/2" spindle gouge with a 35 degree bevel. I polished them on my wet wheel grinder and leather hone and got pretty much the same cut. Again it's hard to tell because ever one of the tools except the 2 ground on the gray wheel and green wheel left a cut that could easily be sanded with 400 grit.
what did I learn from this. Presentation angle of the cutting edge and the angle of the cutting tip seem to have as much or more to do with how clean the cuts are than the sharpening stones. Beyond a certain point anyway. I thought maybe the serrated edge from the Gray stone might have some advantages so I tried changing the angle of approach of the cutting edge and saw no improvement of the cut.
Don't have a CBN or diamond wheel to test the cuts. I do occasionally hone my tools with a 1200 grit diamond hone and see some improvement in the cut. I have done a test on my skews sharpening all of them to 1200 grit and then polishing the edge with a strop. On those I cannot tell the difference in the Thompson tools, HSS tools or Carbon steel. They all cut hair it big swaths across my arm and cut paper with no effort.
So what I'm going to do is continue to turn and not worry too much about how I sharpen, as long as it seems to be doing the job.
I forgot to mention that I did a few passes with my Hunter Osrpey tool. It cut as clean if not more so than the 35 degree spindle gouges and carving tool. I don't have a good way to measure the edge angle on that but it looks to be more acute than 35 degrees.
I've done the same cutting test on some Cocobolo using the Hunter vs the spindle gouges and the Hunter leaves a cleaner finish. But again any of these tools use properly will leave a finish that is easily cleaned up with 400 grit. I've had instances where I was going to stain the wood for a customer and had to actually rough the wood up with courser paper so it would take the stain properly.
John, After reading about your (excellent) test, I would love to hear how you react to the same tools sharpened with a fine grit CBN wheel. Just out of curiosity.
I first bought both the coarse and fine D-Way wheels (older ones without the side grit), and can say nothing but good things about using them.
I have had the D-Way wheels for over a year, and love the way they grind cool, are already balanced (run very smooth), never get smaller, always true, always square, cut fast. Those things can be said about any of the metal-core-abrasive-particle type wheels, not just D-Way.
My biggest question is "how long will they last?" I don't have a perfect answer yet. After almost a year and a half, I don't see any noticeable wear from sharpening turning tools. There was a break-in period, though. At first the wheels were "coarser" than they are now after use. That break in happened fast, and since then they haven't seemed to deteriorate or dull.
Except for me having done something (apparently) stupid! I used my fine grit wheel to shape a malachite cabochon. That dulled a spot in the middle of the wheel. So I now have a 1 1/2" wide wheel with 2 different "grits" on it!
I wanted a coarser "coarse" wheel for shaping tools, so I got an extra coarse wheel from Opti-Grind. They are made in Austria, but ship from Michigan. The Opti-Grind has side grit, which I think would be good for some things (like sharpening router bits?), but hasn't been useful yet. I do love the coarse grit.
I have only had the Opti-Grind for a few months, so, even less data about longevity there.
The Craft Supplies wheel looks a lot like an Opti-Grind wheel. Made in Vienna, makes sense. Opti-Grind makes wheels in 6" or 8" diameter, and 1" or 1 1/2" wide.
Ok, that's basically the sum of my experience with CBN wheels.
Anyone have any data on how long they last? Anyone worn one out yet? I think I heard that Trent Bosch did, but I don't have the details. Are you out there, Trent?
All of these CBN wheels are comparable/close in price, and it's high compared to a Norton 3X. The convenience of never changing in size or shape is worth it to me. If they last 4 times as long, it will prove to have been a bargain. If they last only just as long as my 3X wheels, I will still buy another for the advantages they give.
Cindy I hope you know I love your work and highly respect you so my intent was not of undermine what you said. I'm just confused by all the sharpening methods out there. Being a non scientific test I could only use what I had available. Wish I had a D way or Glaser gouge that I could sharpen the same way as my Thompson and then have the various sharpening tools to test.
Then of course you would also need to turn a variety of woods and hopefully use the same feed rates and rpms so the tests would be as equal as possible. Probably not going to happen.
It is fun playing with the various techniques to learn from them so I can pass them on to others.
Maybe someday we'll be at the same venue and I can try out your techniques. Did you use the CBN wheels to sharpen the tools you used to turn the salad. I saw that video.
Of course, CBN wheels do a much better job turning vegetables
John, I think your test was exceptionally good as a comparison because you didn't use different kinds of wood. You used the same wood, so the different ways to prepare the edge could really be compared. Just curious how the CBN sharpened Glaser and/or Thompson would fit in.
I didn't really like my Thompson tools when I was sharpening with Aluminum Oxide. Or the Glaser 15V, either. I preferred the Hamlet 2060 or Sorby M2. Now I like 'em all
No worries, I don't feel like you are undermining me in any way (nor I, you). We can't all agree, and I don't think we really disagree on anything anyway. Let's keep on sharing our experiences so we can all learn more. That's what makes the world go "round"!
You will see carbides with an edge on a cutting tool – whether they were cut or fractured is the question. The carbides are only a portion of the edge as the steel matrix is also there. We are aware that tools with very hard carbides can be sharpened with softer wheels – witness sandstone wheels on farm tools and gray wheels on HSS. However, a lot of time and lost wheel -material are involved. The advent of advanced grinding wheels, whether white, blue or CBN has allowed a faster approach to a better edge. Just as wheel performance and wheel life is a function of the abrasive type (Alumina, Silicon carbide, or CBN) and binders (vitrified, silica gel, steel) used, the performance of a cutting tool is determined by its matrix and embedded carbides. The relevant wear, hardness, and toughness properties of the cutting tool materials tend to not only control its performance during use, but also its ability to be sharpened to a keen edge. Carbon steel tools have moderately high hardness, very high toughness, but very poor wear resistance. Carbide inserts are very wear resistant and have incredible high hardness, but suffer with poor toughness (improving with advent of micro-grain carbide). The advanced PM alloys (CPM 10V&15V, PM M4, 2030, 2060…) offer a range of properties that allow highly wear resistant and hard alloys to also have reasonable toughness. Advanced PM materials (or for that matter, M2 HSS vs. carbon steel) require more sophisticated grinding media to achieve the same keen edge as a simpler material. Finer wheel grits or honing will certainly produce a finer edge.
The formation of a cutting edge during grinding, as well as its wear during use, is a multi-faceted (no pun intended!) issue. That is why there is an entire engineering field call Tribology. However, to answer some of the speculations and to hopefully replace some urban legends with facts, I offer the following points:
• In HSS and PM cutting tool materials, the carbides act as a wear resistant component in concert with the hardened steel matrix. In simplistic terms, the carbides play a role similar to the crushed stone component of asphalt.
• Carbides, no matter the type, are very brittle and hard compared to the hardened steel matrix.
• Grinding actually removes the matrix along with the carbides similar to a bulldozer scraping rock filled clay. Some carbides are pushed along, while others are fractured during the action. So, a ground face will show evidence of shearing carbides as well as pulling out of carbides.
• The fineness of a cutting edge is primarily formed by the relative fineness of the grinding wheel. The formed edge is preserved during use by the carbides (type, size) around that edge. (the role of the formed burr used in woodturning is an additional component).
• The protective carbides tend to stand proud of the surface, as the matrix is eroded by the cutting wear. At some point, they are tall enough to be pulled out of the matrix leaving a jagged area. The larger the carbide, the easier to pull out and the poorer the remaining edge.
• During metal cutting, tools wear to the point where the load on the cutting edge builds and the tool fails. In wood cutting, the tool wears to the point where an undesirable finish results.
Following are some images of cutting edges at very high magnification illustrating the role of carbides around cutting edges.