Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

A wood-drying conundrum

Posts

A wood-drying conundrum

#1

A wood-drying conundrum

Mike Foster

Here is a problem we don't often face in turning, and one that I anticipated as I started down this journey with one of my weird math based pieces. I am working with wet cherry, but rather than the normal bowl/vessel dimensions or wall thicknesses, this piece wants to be on the order of 2-3" in cross section and is turned from a block of face grain cherry about 12" in diameter. I want to carve the outside surface of the form with a pattern, then use some techniques I learned from Jacques Vesery to do some dry brush painting on the result. The real glitch is that carving the cherry is soooo much easier if the wood is wet. As you may guess, the problem is that wood that thick wants to check on the end grain, as the surface dries much faster than the interior. I actually have the piece shaped, and have started the surface carving, but tonight got my first check. I have been storing the piece in the pile of wet shavings (from the turning) while it is not being worked on, and that seemed to work pretty well. I think that the time I have spent working on shape and beginning the surface carving has now been enough to give me problems on the sides with the end grain.

So I hit the one check with some CA, and then sealed the rest of the endgrain with some shellac. I think this will keep things in check (pun intended) while doing the surface carving, but wonder about how the piece will behave later in life after carving and painting are done.

So now I am wondering if the microwave drying thing may work for me to help get the piece to a point where it won't check. Now I realize most wont have tried microwaving something this thick, but maybe someone has. I also wonder if I kept the endgrain sealed while microwaving if that may be a better idea. Perhaps it is better to just seal the piece well and hope for the best. I really hate to do that though, because if it checks badly, the piece would become worthless and I would hate to put a huge amount of work into a worthless piece of firewood. I really considered using a piece of kiln dried, or air dried (if I could find either) 12/4 cherry for this piece, but carving kiln dried wood is a whole different, less pleasant, experience than carving wet cherry. I may end up resorting to this if I have to.

Any thoughts? Anyone try anything like that? Just for your interests sake, the piece I'm attempting would be similar to the one shown below. This piece was turned and carved from a very well air dried burl (I've had the wood for at least 15 years). Wet, face grain cherry is a whole different ball game.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#2

Yet another weird thought

Mike Foster

So what do you suppose might happen if I did a piece like this from piece of the tree with the end grain running up and down through the piece. Ie. the center of the tree is in the center of the piece. No pith left, so no problem with that. I think this may compound the problem, as now there is end grain exposed around the whole piece, rather than just in 2 spot (well 4 really) . It may even out the drying some though. Sure would be nice if I could just figure out a way to hollow these things out and leave a 1/4" wall.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#3

I recommend...

GaryG in MD

that you ask Eugen Schlaak.

He does microwave drying. ...Gary

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#4

Ellis Walentine

Try something

Ellis Walentine

When I get to a head-scratcher like this, Mike, I usually have to run some experiments, because none of my theories are a sure thing. My hunch on this one is that you'll have trouble unless you use a block of wood without any pith in it. I don't know much about microwave drying, so that could be a workable method. So could, I imagine, Dave Smith's alcohol drying technique. But you may need to actually run some tests to find out.

On another note, I have found that, for some reason, pear wood doesn't check as much as most other woods. Pear looks and works a lot like cherry, so it might be a good substitute.

Sorry, not much help here.

Ellis

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#5

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

John Lucas

Mike Cherry has always been my nemesis so I've experimented with it with mixed results but I'm getting better.

First, while carving keep it in a plastic bag. This keeps it green and doesn't let it dry at all. The shavings trick helps but it still tries to dry although it does slow it down. Once your finished carving you will really need to watch the thin areas since they dry faster. Also end grain areas of course. I've had great success drying things completely covered with wax although it takes a long time. When I want it to dry a little faster I coat all thin areas and all end grain areas and leave the rest uncoated. I use 2 coats of Anchorseal for things that I must paint it on, I dip them in hot parrafin wax for things that I completelly cover.

Now let me say that I have not tried carving to completion before doing all of this so I'm kind of doing a guess based on my experiments with other work.

Microwaving. I have dried 3" square blocks of cherry and roughed out bowl blanks but never something larger. Patience is the key here. I start out on high heat with short times. I have not experimented with defrost cycles because I don't really know what the machine is doing. Is it just doing short bursts of high power or something else. I didn't think you could actually change the power of a microwave transmitter so I just assume it's doing something on high. Anyway. On smaller pieces I gradually increase the time from 30 seconds to a minute letting it cool completely between cycles. If I think it might crack I leave it in the microwave so stop air movement and slow it down. It takes many many cycles. The 3" block took about 20 to 25 cycles to dry. I kept a list of weights on a piece of paper so I could see how many. I wasn't on a rigid schedule. Everytime I came in the house for a day and a half I would run a cycle. During lunch I got several cycles, etc. Even then I had a very slight crack that closed up when it completely dried.

I turned my Cardiac lamp out of green cherry. I turned the outside with the pith centered. Then turned the inside to 3/16" wall thickness so the pith and everything else was completely gone. Surpisingly it stayed within .015" of completely round so the aluminum accents I added worked out well. I did put band clamps around both ends to try and keep it round but I'm really not sure it they worked or the wood just did it's own thing.

I know the wax will work but it might take 8 or 10 months to completely dry a blank that is 3" thick. In a year and half an 8" blank had just started to crack but I think that was because the wax was peeling off. It had lost a tremendous amount of weight but I didn't record the weight. When turned it moved just a little so it must not have been completely dry or the wood had some tension. I'm guessing it was not totally dry based on other experiments of other species.

Hope this helps. Above all else take it slow whatever you do. Cherry cracks when you look at it wrong. Wish I knew John Jordan's secret he turns a lot of the stuff but I don't think he leaves it thicker than about 1/2 to 5/8". I could be wrong.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#6

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Bill Jacksonvill, NC

Have you thought about putting your carving in a brown grocery bag with some shavings or without and store for that way for couple, weeks? Wrapping in newspaper works about same. After couple, weeks let air dry for month or two.

Feel ambitious make a beer cooler kiln equipped with light bulb and computer fan.

If in real hurry try other procedures mentioned.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#7

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

John Lucas

Putting it in a bag with shavings will promote mold. Been there done that. The bag alone will block the air movement and will also absorb the moisture and release it which slows the drying similar to shavings but since the bag will tend to dry out it doesn't cause mold as bad. Since he's planning on doing the finish carving on it before drying I would think mold would be the last thing he wants.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#8

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Joe Meirhaeghe

Mike, I've turned end grain vessels from green cherry logs that I will store in a chest freezer if I can't get them completed in a day. There have been times that I've worked on several pieces at different stages the same day, so I'd only hollow for a little while then put them back in the freezer. I've took a cherry piece in & out of the freezer 3 or 4 times over the course of several weeks before I finished roughing it out . I never got a check on them. I did seal the end grain with anchorseal before freezing them.

Only thing is I don't know how it would be to carve while frozen. But they turn just fine frozen.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#9

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Mike Foster

Thanks for all the suggestions. I think I will have to do as Ellis suggested and do some test pieces. I wonder about microwaving with shellac as an end grain sealer, vs just microwaving with no sealer. I think I will test a couple of pieces to see what happens one with shellac and one without. Ellis, the piece I am working on does not have any pith. It was a face grain slab taken from just off the pith to one side. If I had some pear, I would give it a try, but it is not so common here in VT.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#10

Re: A different approach

Peter Hyde

Wood checks as it dries because of different drying rates. The rate of evaporation from the exterior is higher than from the interior because of different surface area. So covering the whole piece, either partially or completely with shavings, paper bags etc. just makes everything equal as far as the rate is concerned but does nothing to correct the area difference. So if you intend to use an oil base finish on the piece use oil to seal the OUTSIDE SURFACE ONLY. Leave the inside to allow drying. As the inside dries faster or at the same rate there will be less or zero checking. I have done this on all green turnings for several years and have almost 100% success.

HTH

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#11

Re: A different approach

Mike Foster

Peter, thanks for your advice and I understand what you are saying, however, this is not the same situation as a hollow form or a bowl. There is no inside. Like I said in my original post, if I could hollow it I would. Take a look at the picture I posted of a similar piece and you will get an idea of what I'm attempting. The piece I am working on is a very similar sculpture 12" in diameter that started out as a solid torus. So the wood that will be left after shaping and carving will still be about 2.5-3" thick, solid, but with alternating end grain and side grain like a bowl.

Mike

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#12

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Mike Foster

I thought about that Joe, but I'm not sure it would carve well, and I have a problem with Reynauds where funny exposure to cold things can shut down the arteries to my hands and make them go white and numb. Not going to handle a piece of frozen wood and risk that. Thanks for the thought though.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#13

Re: I recommend...

Mike Foster

Thanks Gary, I just emailed Eugen and asked him to chime in here if he has some thoughts or experience with this.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Brad Vietje

Interesting challenge, Mike.

I've been thinking on this since last night (early this AM) when I first saw it... Initially I thought of the microwave, with a large number of short sessions at 50% power. I have done this with success on thick bowl blanks, but never anything as thick as your piece. Like John, I also think altering the power output of most microwaves is really a timer function that uses 100% power for X% of the time, but I can't be sure of that.

Seems turning the doughnut torus first would be the way to start; turning one from an end-grain slice would probably work well, as you'd have a consistent amount of end grain all the way around, but for aesthetics, the two presentation sides (largest exposure in one plane) would be ALL endgrain, which may not be the look you want at all!

I guess I'd turn a torus from side grain and one from end grain, and try both approaches. I think experimenting with the nuker will probably yield acceptable results in the end.

Then again, you could abandon the smooth sides entirely, and turn this from some really curly stuff, coat it or bag it to slow down the drying, and allow it to wrinkle up as the curly wood dries... A different look, for sure.

I have a good friend from high school days with a custom kiln drying business nearby, if that helps. How about Mesquite? I hear it barely moves at all, and almost never cracks.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#15

Re: A different approach

Peter Hyde

Mike I understood what you are doing and it still means there is an inside and an outside of different surface areas. That's what causes the cracking problems. So if you slow down the moisture loss on the outside biggest area you can achieve equilibrium in the rate of evaporation and eliminate stresses caused by shrinkage. Also keep in mind wood shrinks the most along the growth ring and that can be used as a criteria when cutting the blank from the log.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#16

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Cherry cracks. Why torture yourself? Use some other wood or just wait for a large piece of cherry to finish cracking then use the part that did not crack. Bradford pear is almost crackless and that plentiful wood can be very attractive.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#17

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Peter Rand

Mike; Bill Neddow boiled his large roughed-out pieces, often bowls up to 2" thick. I think the process and principle applies to any configuration of wood. He believed that the process of boiling relieved internal stresses in the wood and prevented checking, and he had very good success. He had large kettles outdoors that he heated with propane and he boiled the wood for some part of a day. The wood still took the same long time to dry, and the wood might move, but it did so check-free. The boiling required a long time, presumably to get even the interior up to the boiling point for some time. This is as I understand his successful process. Certainly worth a try. It has worked for me for smaller pieces.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#18

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Don in Central Illinois

I use a lot of cherry and when I rough turn I put them in a plastic bag, then turn the bag inside out every couple of days. Takes quite awhile but don't lose many to checking. I have also had success with boiling but not much luck packing in wet shavings and storing in paper bags.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#19

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

John Lucas

I did that with dogwood limb sections that were flat and included the pith. They all dried crack free. Can't remember how long it took but I went down each night and turned the bag inside out.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#20

Re: A different approach

John Lucas

That's why the microwave works. It heats the wood from the inside and even out the drying. The problem is we don't have any scientific specs to look at and say this is how long to heat such and such wood that is this thick. We are all guessing with some help from practical experience.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#21

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Don in Central Illinois

I had some rough turned bowls, 12 to 14" in diameter and abou 1 1/4 to 1 1/2" thick took about 4 months. The dryer it gets the less often you have to turn it inside out less often.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#22

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

John Jordan

My cherry doesn't crack, so I wouldn't say it always cracks, I would say it never cracks. :D

This shouldn't be hard, Mike. First, if you glue checks, you are wedging them open-small checks will close up when the wood equalizes, but its best not to get them in the first place.

Keep the surface dampened as you carve, that's all that's needed to prevent checks while you are working, and put it in a bag at night-no shavings which will promote mold as already pointed out. When the carving is complete, I would spend 10 minutes with an air hose, and blow through the end grain and get out as much of any free water that may be there-cherry heartwood doesn't have much. Then, put it in a paper bag or box and give it a little time, it will dry quicker than you think.

FWIW, cherry sapwood moves more than cherry heartwood, so if one leaves a lot of sapwood, you may get more than expected movement, or a crack caused by the diiference in rates of movement.

John

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#23

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Mike Foster

Thanks John. I didn't really consider the effect of wedging open a crack, but that should have been a no brainer. I will start just keeping the piece in plastic as I get it carved.

I have started in a little experiment of drying some cherry in the microwave (see the post below), and may actually do this if the experiment seems to work. I should probably be more patient, but I would like to move this along as I am working under a bit of a time crunch, and if it fails, I would like to have the chance to do another to recover.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#24

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

Mike Foster

I cut a couple blocks of wet cherry about the same cross section as the eventual piece and actually sanded them smooth on all sides (quickly so no heat buildup).

I sealed the end grain on one block with shellac and left the other bare.

I have put them few a few cycles (30 seconds at full power) of the microwave now. Definitely moist to the touch when they come out. I have not heated them to the point that they are actually hot to handle, just a little warm.

Both blocks started at 9 3/8 ounces and are both down to 9 1/8 ounce already. There is some minor checking already on the bare block, but none on the sealed block. I will continue with cycles and keep you all posted.

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

#25

Re: A wood-drying conundrum

John Lucas

Mike I forgot to mention spraying it with water while you carve. John is probably the one that taught me that and it works fantastic at keeping the cracks from opening up in the first place. I keep a spray bottle handy when I'm working with woods that tend to check and I'm having to go slow or take much longer than normal.