Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

finial proportions

Posts

finial proportions

#1

Keith Tompkins

finial proportions

Keith Tompkins

My finial demos and classes have been very well received, classes are usually filled up with a waiting list. However, there's been one question I haven't been able to answer, and it's asked without fail every session...."what is the proper proportion of finial height/width in relation to the main form?" I will be doing this demo in Tampa next June, so I better come up with a suitable answer. In an attempt to figure things out, I layed out lines to see how close I came to the "rule of thirds". I also drew rectangles around some of the key elements within the form...Interesting (even thought the shot isn't head-on)..The finial is the same height as the form. The emphasis point of the main form and the bulb in the finial falls on a 1/3 point of the total height. The collar is approx. 1/3 of the main form, and the diameter of the bulb is 1/3 of the collar. Can I draw any conclusions from this image..seems I like, and instinctively use the rule of thirds. I would welcome any comments or thoughts!

Re: finial proportions

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: finial proportions

Keith Tompkins

Oh yeah...the bulb is 1/3 the height of the finial, as well as being at 2/3 of the combined height of the finial and the form.

Re: finial proportions

#3

Ellis Walentine

Couple opinions

Ellis Walentine

I'm a more organic kinda design guy, Keith, and I'm always suspicious of rules of thirds and other numerical rationales for proportions. I believe that it is much more important how the finial interacts with the form to make a unified impression. This gives the finial much more freedom to complement the shape and color and mood of the piece. It's a squishy way of looking at it, and harder to teach, but there it is.

Ellis

Re: finial proportions

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Couple opinions

Keith Tompkins

Ellis, I agree completely...you know it's right...or it's not. It's so hard to put a formula to it. A tall form would require a completely different finial than a short, squat one. Yet, everyone seems to want a formula. I had no formulas in mind when I turned this, yet the rule of 3rds seems to fit almost perfectly. My answer has always been...I don't know the perfect rule...I just know when I'm happy with it. Yes, that's a hard one to teach.

Re: finial proportions

#5

Re: finial proportions

Philip Duffy

Why do you need a formula? Seems to me that when you do different pieces, in different styles, the rules of "what looks good" would change. Let you mind's eye be the judge and if you do not like the result, turn a new finial. That's what I do. Somehow you should let your "art side of the brain" work the problem and let your hands do the work. Philip

Re: finial proportions

#6

Re: finial proportions

Hal Taylor

Kieth makes a good point - even though most of us don't use a formula when we turn our pieces, the pleasing end result will most likely be in a one third, two thirds porportion.

Re: finial proportions

#7

Re: finial proportions

Mike Gibson

If l make a piece that is pleasing to the eye when l measure it l find that it nearly always fits those rules. l am always conscious of the golden rule while turning although l never measure at any time and rely on my eye.

Michael

Re: finial proportions

#8

Chuck Jones - West TN

I'm too new at finials to have an opinion...

Chuck Jones - West TN

...but there is one reason I like to have some sort of "guideline". I still have trouble visualizing the end result before I've even made the initial cuts on the finial. A few rules and some rough measurements help me work up the nerve to put the tool to the wood. Beyond that I agree that the eye is the best assessment tool... or maybe the camera and the eye.

A really useful aid is to post a finial here and pay attention to the constructive criticisms. I posted a bad one here a few weeks ago and the help I got from Ellis, Keith, Charlie, and some others was more than I'd expect from a two day class.

Re: finial proportions

#9

Ditto!

Jorge

I don't like rules, just work at it until my eyes like it.