Kind of long.....
robo hippy
Me to my dad a few years back, "Opinions are like rear ends, every body has one." To which my dad responded with out any pause, "Yea, and some of them stink!" After some thought, I thought, "Yea, and some are pretty hot". The following are my opinions....
There was an extended thread about 2 years ago about the McNaughton. For sure, every one who has tried to use the tool swears at it (even if you didn't say it out loud), and every one who figures it out swears by it as the most efficient tool to use for coring.
First, and Kel does not agree with me on this one, and the last time I talked to Mike Mahoney about it, he commented some thing like "you might be on to some thing". Part of the aiming problem is the bends of the blades. They are not totally accurate. The newer Mark 8 blades are far better than the older ones, but there is one tiny problem that persists. The blades can be fine tuned to make the cut go in a perfect arc of a circle. For fine tuning, you need the clear plastic circle template. Hand cut plywood templates or compass drawn templates are not accurate enough. You need to lay it over the top of your blades to check the curves. The main problem I have found is that the tips will go straight for the last inch or so of the blade. When cutting, the blade will follow the tip. If the tip is going straight rather than following the exact curve of the blade, it will drift to the outside of the cut. If the tip deviates by even 1/16 of an inch, it makes a difference. Not much on a short/small core, but a lot on the end of a deeper core. The tips need to be tweaked in just a hair. This solves most of the drifting to the outside of the cut/core problem. If you tweak it too far, it will drift to the inside of the core. I did buy 2 new blades after the last thread, and one, the standard/medium curve was pretty close. The other, the flatter curve on the jumbo set, the last 2 inches of the blade went straight with the tip being off the curve by 1/4 inch. If the entire blade is a perfect arc of a circle, all the way to the tip of the blade, you can aim by keeping the blade centered in the kerf. Correcting an arc that is flatter than the curve of your blade is doable, and some have learned to correct it without thinking about it. It does cause some problems for beginners.
Cutting tip height: All coring tools are scrapers. When using a scraper on the inside of the bowl, you need to be at center height, or slightly above. Never below center height. I like Dale's demo with using the largest blade, fully extended, to set your tool rest height. One other factor, that needs to be considered is that when cutting, the downward pressure/load of cutting will push that tip down even more. Try cutting off the stub that is left when the core is popped off and you will see how much flex there is in the blade and the tool rest. Again, not much of a problem on smaller cores, but a bigger problem if you are fully extended on a big core and trying to cut it all the way off so you don't rip through the bottom when you remove the core like can happen when coring crotch wood, burl, or end grain. If your blade is too high, the vertical blade does not fit well into the round kerf. If it isn't high enough, your tip is below center when you get near the end. You can raise the tool rest a bit to compensate. 'PROFESSIONAL DRIVER ON CLOSED COURSE DO NOT ATTEMPT' method is, with full set of handles on, drop the handle just a bit. You can learn to feel when the cutter is below center, but this is only for very accomplished masters of this tool. I think most of the catching problems and chattering are from the tip being below center. Having a collar under the tool rest is essential to keep it from vibrating down as you core. I use an end grain turned piece of wood, not a collar with bolts/set screws through it. No chance of it ever getting loose and moving.
The tool gate: I prefer mine locked into place. I found out early on when lining the tool up for the cut, with the gate loose, first thing it did when you engage the tip into the wood was twist, which kind of binds the blade in the tool rest, and moved my pivot/aiming point. By locking it in place, it eliminated this. It also provides me with a handy 'bending' jig for fine tuning my blades.
Aiming: The most difficult thing to learn. Since the tool is not on a fixed pivot point, you have to do the aiming. Dale's explanation is a good one, and I think fairly similar to mine. Simply, the curve of the blade never seems to exactly match the outside curve of the bowl. Rule of thumb, if the blade curve is tighter than the bowl curve, aim more parallel to the outside shape of the bowl. If the blade curve is flatter than the bowl curve, aim more towards the center of the bowl (we called this 'toe nailing' when driving nails). McNaughton has a laser system, and Monster tools also makes one that goes on the McNaughton. They really help tell you where you are. I never could figure out the 'straight line from blade shaft to tip' thing. Just did not compute for me. I have the McNaughton set up, and had it welded to the top of my handle as that was more efficient than using the same bolts that lock the blade in place. I can use the same handle for free hand hollow form cutting with the laser.
Blade tips: I grind mine square. The spear point makes a wider shaving, and with the square tip, I get way better shaving ejection. Both Woodcut and Oneway have square tips. I will be retipping some of my old blades with Tantung steel, 3/8 wide by 1/8 inch thick, and slightly tapered. It should work fine, and is an excellent cutting material for wood, silver soldered on, and almost as hard as the carbide tips, but easily sharpened with standard hones (coarser is better, a point that Dale also makes). Mike Hunter did retip one for me a few years back. He tried a very pointy one which I did not like, and he did another one for me that was 3/8 inch square. It worked fine, but again, I prefer a square cutter, not pointed.
This tool is not for every one.
Betty, I am looking forward to some one else's opinion of the 3 different coring systems. I have commented about it many times in the past.
Dale, in your demo, you made the comment about me being fairly new to the tool. I am curious about that comment. Not offended, but curious. I had, at the time turned some 10,000 bowls, and a lot of them were cored.
robo hippy