Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

Posts

Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#1

Steven Antonucci

Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

steven antonucci

With my Kelton coring rig...

I am pretty sure that I have done everything I can to get "good" at coring. I have asked questions. I have watched videos. I have purchased the mother-of-all-jaw-sets for my Nova chuck (3 1/4" tenon)!

I have all but given up on using the most bent knife. Aside from its penchant for dismounting a bowl, aiming it requires voodoo and other black magic that I do not understand. In the end, my largest cores show the battering and bruising of being slammed to the floor and 1/4" of wood left in the foot of the tenon.

So I will ask the following questions:

1.) Are you supposed to lock the round gate in the toolrest firm, or should it be able to pivot a little bit?

2.) Can someone please explain (again) any reliable means for aiming the dang thing?

I did manage to make two cores from 15" x5" bowls. Two bowls are better than one, but not as good as three or four. Help!

Steve

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#2

Rob Wallace

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Rob Wallace

Steve asked:

So I will ask the following questions:

1.) Are you supposed to lock the round gate in the toolrest firm, or should it be able to pivot a little bit?

The pivot should not be locked-down, and should be able to pivot freely, but without "play" (vertically). The tool should be captured by the turret, and held up on the handle end as it enters the work so that the cutting end does not rock-down when it meets the rotational force of the blank. You should be able to re-position and pivot the tool throughout the cutting process.

2.) Can someone please explain (again) any reliable means for aiming the dang thing?

You probably already know there is a laser guide available for this tool set. This addition might help a little, but you'll still need to visualize where the tip is (I guess it's part of the learning curve), given that it should be in line with the tool shank. If it is not in line, the curved portion of the tool should be carefully bent back so that the cutter is in alignment.

I find that the most important thing is to continually clear accumulating chips from the cut, and make some additional "kerf" room (I usually take it off of the bottom surface of the 'inner' or smaller bowl) for the blade width, particularly when using the tighter diameter curved blade. This kerf-widening can be done by the "rocking" approach that I've seen Bill Grumbine and Mike Mahoney do, or in some cases I simply back the blade out and take another half-wide kerf cut to create extra room for the blade and for chips to come out.

I have used sprayed-on WD-40 on the cutter in some cases, but I really don't think it helps very much - YMMV. I have done enough of these cores, that the kerf widening seems to always work for the most part. I have both the old and new turret formats, and the new ( Mark 8 ) has some subtle advantages, specifically with the need to hold the handle end up and the adjustment for the capturing of the tool within the turret itself.

You should also periodically check that the cutter is in line with the shank of the tool shaft - occasionally the curved tools get bent if they get stuck in a cut and are bent off-line. It is easy to bend them back into alignment if needed.

I've been enjoying coring bowls with the Kel McNaughton system for at least 7 or more years. (I can't really remember when I got mine....)

Hope this helps,

Rob

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#3

Harry Robinette

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Harry Robinette

One major thing I've found is don't hold the tool really tight,I hold the tool up against the turret and just hard enough to keep control if you try to force the tool it will kick your_ _ _. The direction the tool moves is the shape of the steel you can not change this.

I stand on a step box and line the tool up with the turret slot and eye it as I move it in the arc of the tool,this lets you find where to start your cut and where it's going to end. You just start where you were shown from looking down on the tool and push the tool forward and pull the handle just slightly towards yourself and the tool will cut the arc you seen from the top.

I do like most everyone and over cut the kerf also wax the tool and the turret before you start.

Everyone says just push forward but I find a gentle pull on the handle also helps,just don't pull very hard or it will stop cutting.

I do spray the kerf with lubricant I use PG2000 a tool lube for metal to metal lube but seams to work for this rather well.

Hope this helps.

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#4

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Dale Bonertz

Steven,

I did a demonstration for the Rocky Mountain Wood Turners which they videoed. That video was put on youtube and I have received a lot of positive feed back on how it has helped folks with using the tool. Type in McNaughton Center saver and several videos come up and the one I am referring to is Bonertz does McNaughton demo. You could also go to Kelton tools site and click on the link that Kel has put in the videos or instruction tab. It should answer most the questions you have regarding the tool. You can email me if you should have any further questions if you like. It is an hour and half video so be prepared with your time if you want to get the full benefit of the demonstration.

Good luck,

Dale

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#5

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Carole Valentine

Steve,

You have had a couple of good answers here from Rob, Harry and Dale. Dale's demo is excellent.

I have been coring for several years with that system. There are a couple of additional areas we could look at to hopefully solve your problem, not the least of which might be the expectation that you just cannot do it! ;) That leads to tension, and probably a death grip on the tool, which in itself can cause problems.

I have found that the whole process requires a bit of finesse and a feel for the wood, the grain and the tool. You have to learn when to let the tool run, when to wiggle or push it a bit to encourage it, and most importantly when to hold it back. If you are getting catches severe enough to bend the blade, especially on a DVR, then I suspect that one of two things is probably happening: you have a piece of wood with a small but very hard, gnarly section adjacent to softer wood, shavings are compacting, or (and in my mind this is more likely) you are are pushing the tool to take too big a cut OR you are letting it run instead of holding it back a bit when it hits easier grain. If you let it take off on you instead of controlling it's advance, you are asking for a catch. Once you have had a catch, there is a technique to getting past it...it's a bit like taking the ripple out of a bowl bottom. You have to take very, very light cuts until you have completely removed the dig in that resulted from the catch. Otherwise the tool will just dig in all over again in that same place and may do so even more violently than during the original catch.

On difficult wood, I spray WD-40 directly into the kerf with a tube while turning the piece by hand.

The screw should NOT lock down the assembly - it needs to turn freely. I lost mine and have never missed it.

Aiming...I use the visualization method described by a previous poster. Not only does this tell you which blade to use, but also where and at what angle the blade should enter the wood. It takes some practice. It takes a lot of practice if you are taking thin cores like Mike does!

Guess I have said enough...there are lots of folks who are probably more well versed in the use of the system and I am sure they will be willing to help. Coring is fun and very satisfying...don't give up on it!

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#6

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Josh Bowman

Steven,

I had watched all the videos, talked to all the right people, even Mahoney and Grey. Someone on another forum got me going right. I knew she had a weak lathe and had no problems. Me having a Jet 1642-2 then a PM 3520 seemed to be the difference. So here's what I think for what it's worth. Both of my lathes could power though anything I could throw at them and would bind the blades. When she told me she had to pull the tool out often, and re-visualize the path and clear chips, I got thinking that I was getting the tool in a bind by allowing/pushing it into the cut. So I took the laser off (now I feel like Luke Skywalker! "use the force") and would insure the tool could feed through the gate and turn toward the bottom center with some wood left for the bottom, before starting. Then starting to cut, this required just barely holding the tool and feeling the inside of the blank with the tip as the tool cut, pulling back to insure no binding. Before long I was making reliable cores! One BIG mistake I was also making by not extending the tool out to the final length to get to the bottom and insuring the cutter tip was on center line before starting the cut. I was setting center with the tool pulled back into the turret, I hope this makes since. But I have found that the tool no longer makes smoke or other bad things. As a matter of fact, it the tool will not pull back out easily, you are getting into a bind, which means the tool is being pushed forward. Now watching the pros do it, I find I just hold the thing and at first even have to hold back. The tool will progress until the turn at the bottom then require a little....very little pressure to make the grain change.

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#7

Steve Kubien

I hate it.

Steve Kubien

I'm not going to lie, I don't like the McNaughton. I have owned it twice. The 1st time I was spending too much time and money washing/replacing my short. On the 2nd go around was better and I attribute it to a stronger, smoother lathe (DVR vs 1624-44) and larger tenons (#3 jaws on my SN2 chuck). I was still launching timber all over the place and I was sick of the threatening letters from NASA's lawyers.

I had a woodcut for a while & really liked it. It just wasn't big enough capacity-wise. Nowadays I use the he Oneway rig. It's alright but I preferred the Woodcut. I'm not certain but the Oneway cutting may be made of recycled beer cans.

In my version of a perfect world, either Woodcut would finally release the larger edition they've been working on or Oneway would come up with cutters that are good for more than one or two cores before grinding (which is a PITA).

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#8

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Barry Irby

I have had one for years, but only use it occasionally, usually in heavy bursts. Early on I discovered that my knives were not properly shaped. They Must be a section of a circle. I suggest you take a poster board and draw a bunch of concentric circles about half and inch apart. Lay your knives on them and they should nicely fit between two of the lines. Mine were not even close.

Another thing, the tip or cutter should be in a straight line with the shank. Put a straight edge on yours and check.

Sharpen them. I loaned mine to a "friend" who ground the hard metal off the top of the knives and that was the end of that. Mike Hunter rescued me by installing some of his cutters on them for a tidy sum.

I made an "Aimer". Its a piece of plexiglass about 15" by 6". I mount it in the chuck, sandwiched between two of the jaws so that the center of the 15" side is centered in the chuck. Then draw a line on it Parallel to the long edge at the face of the jaws. This is the exterior bottom of the bowl. then with a dry erase type marker you can sketch on the shape of your blank. I use blue tape on mine. Then you can slide the knife under the plexi and actually watch where is goes. You can set the post. I lock mine in such a way that it tends to truly guide the knife. I set the angle of the banjo and mark its position on the ways. I use a black marker for this. Then I slide the banjo out of the way, remove the plexi and install the blank, and move the banjo back into position and core away.

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#9

LINK *LINK*

Ralph Lindberg

CLICK


YouTube

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#10

Dale Jablonski

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Dale Jablonski

I gave up on these a long time ago for similiar reasons.

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#11

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Doug Turner

Steve, Something the Utah woodturner's association demoed a few years ago to tech coring tool control was to remove the handle and core with the blade only in the tool rest. It sounds scary as hell, but you don't need or want a lot of forward pressure, and you hold the back of the the blade up as if the handle were in place only it is not as heavy. bowls up to 16 inches were cored in this manner. I have seen Mike Mahoney demonstrate this a few times and each member of the club was able to core a bowl in this fashion if they wanted to. It also helps to get over the fear and anxiety.

The advice to clear the chips frequently and widen the kerf are spot on. I lubricate the blade and the tool rest for easy sliding motion. I am assuming you are coring green wood which cuts much easier. Oversharpening the blade will cause too agressive a feed rate and tend toward catches. Good luck

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#12

Betty Scarpino

Upcoming article February issue

Betty Scarpino

Steve, there will be a major article on bowl-coring systems in the February issue, written by John Giem, that I think will help answer your questions, especially question #3 on how to aim this system. Send me an email in early January and I'll send you an advance e-copy of the article (it's not ready yet).

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#13

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Dale Bonertz

Steve,

I did not catch the 15" x 5" bowl size when I first read your post. That is a pretty large blank when trying to get proficient with any coring tool. I know you are an accomplished turner and coring is like learning any other skill. What I mean is get 10 to 12 bowl blanks ready to core (rough turn the outside and then put them in garbage bags - you can stack these on the floor 4 to 5 per bag. Make sure they are turned out of good coring wood like elm or box elder - as a second choice maple or walnut. Also make sure these blanks are no larger than 12" diameter and no deeper than 5" deep. Now just like if you want to learn how to turn a bowl do all ten of them in a row one after the other. You will make some mistakes but by the time you get to number 10 or 12 you will have a very good feel for what you are doing. You will only need two blades in this exercise. The tightest curve from either the mini or standard set -preferably the mini if you own it. The other blade is the middle curve from the standard set. Just use those two blades on all 10 blanks.

I am going to stick my neck out here but watch that youtube video and then go directly to your shop and start coring those ten blanks. I have all the confidence in the world that you will be comfortable with the tool at the end of this session.

Coring with the McNaughton center saver is so fun, rewarding and relaxing once you gain the confidence in yourself to use the tool. Relax and have fun and laugh at any mistakes you make because you are learning and the next one will be better. BTW my email address is in the video if you need any further assistance I am generally available if you need any help whatsoever. I receive my email through my mobile phone which is usually always with me.

Good luck Steven,

Dale

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#14

Alan Zenreich

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Alan Zenreich

For those not familiar with the coring tool, this is how it looks at its best.

I recorded Bill Grumbine doing this 16" black cherry blank about two years ago during a free seminar he held at his shop to address techniques using the coring system.

He cores largest size to smallest, with a mortise in the center of the blank facilitating creating new tenons on the opposite side.

It is worth noting that in this video everything went very very smoothly. It was his first core of the day, and pretty much picture perfect. A short while later, he cored another blank, and struggled a bit, not nearly as easily done.

I've only cored a few blanks... having bought Steve K's Woodcut from him, and I know he now prefers it to his current OneWay rig. I have granted him visitation rights should he come to my area. < veg >

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SQTt5GfSyyA

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#15

Steven Antonucci

Just watched your video... AWESOME!

steven antonucci

Explained it very clearly and easily. I should be all set to go.

What I was doing wrong was mostly around the aiming of the tool, and your method and explanation seems pretty straightforward. Having the entry angle described the way you did was the missing link.

I have to wait until the weekend to cut up some more cherry, unless I decide to saw in the dark... but I have every confidence that you've shown me the 2 or three subtle things I was doing wrong. I will hopefully be posting a 4 core cherry set next Monday!

Thanks

Steve

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relation

Dick Hines

Steven, when you set up your coring system the thing you have to remember is to keep the tip of the knife a little above center. If you don't the cutting edge will below center when you get to the bottom of the core and the bowl will "climb" the knife and try to kiss you. Since you can't keep the tool post close to the piece like in using a bowl gouge the knife will bend down. Think of using your gouge to far over the tool rest.

The next thing is you have to keep the knife up under the support post. If it drops then the knife center is below the center of the bowl.

I don't use the long handle when coring. I made one that is only 6" long and lets me bring the tail stock up for support.

Good luck

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#17

Steven Antonucci

Like the short handle for tailstock support idea!


Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#18

Kind of long.....

robo hippy

Me to my dad a few years back, "Opinions are like rear ends, every body has one." To which my dad responded with out any pause, "Yea, and some of them stink!" After some thought, I thought, "Yea, and some are pretty hot". The following are my opinions....

There was an extended thread about 2 years ago about the McNaughton. For sure, every one who has tried to use the tool swears at it (even if you didn't say it out loud), and every one who figures it out swears by it as the most efficient tool to use for coring.

First, and Kel does not agree with me on this one, and the last time I talked to Mike Mahoney about it, he commented some thing like "you might be on to some thing". Part of the aiming problem is the bends of the blades. They are not totally accurate. The newer Mark 8 blades are far better than the older ones, but there is one tiny problem that persists. The blades can be fine tuned to make the cut go in a perfect arc of a circle. For fine tuning, you need the clear plastic circle template. Hand cut plywood templates or compass drawn templates are not accurate enough. You need to lay it over the top of your blades to check the curves. The main problem I have found is that the tips will go straight for the last inch or so of the blade. When cutting, the blade will follow the tip. If the tip is going straight rather than following the exact curve of the blade, it will drift to the outside of the cut. If the tip deviates by even 1/16 of an inch, it makes a difference. Not much on a short/small core, but a lot on the end of a deeper core. The tips need to be tweaked in just a hair. This solves most of the drifting to the outside of the cut/core problem. If you tweak it too far, it will drift to the inside of the core. I did buy 2 new blades after the last thread, and one, the standard/medium curve was pretty close. The other, the flatter curve on the jumbo set, the last 2 inches of the blade went straight with the tip being off the curve by 1/4 inch. If the entire blade is a perfect arc of a circle, all the way to the tip of the blade, you can aim by keeping the blade centered in the kerf. Correcting an arc that is flatter than the curve of your blade is doable, and some have learned to correct it without thinking about it. It does cause some problems for beginners.

Cutting tip height: All coring tools are scrapers. When using a scraper on the inside of the bowl, you need to be at center height, or slightly above. Never below center height. I like Dale's demo with using the largest blade, fully extended, to set your tool rest height. One other factor, that needs to be considered is that when cutting, the downward pressure/load of cutting will push that tip down even more. Try cutting off the stub that is left when the core is popped off and you will see how much flex there is in the blade and the tool rest. Again, not much of a problem on smaller cores, but a bigger problem if you are fully extended on a big core and trying to cut it all the way off so you don't rip through the bottom when you remove the core like can happen when coring crotch wood, burl, or end grain. If your blade is too high, the vertical blade does not fit well into the round kerf. If it isn't high enough, your tip is below center when you get near the end. You can raise the tool rest a bit to compensate. 'PROFESSIONAL DRIVER ON CLOSED COURSE DO NOT ATTEMPT' method is, with full set of handles on, drop the handle just a bit. You can learn to feel when the cutter is below center, but this is only for very accomplished masters of this tool. I think most of the catching problems and chattering are from the tip being below center. Having a collar under the tool rest is essential to keep it from vibrating down as you core. I use an end grain turned piece of wood, not a collar with bolts/set screws through it. No chance of it ever getting loose and moving.

The tool gate: I prefer mine locked into place. I found out early on when lining the tool up for the cut, with the gate loose, first thing it did when you engage the tip into the wood was twist, which kind of binds the blade in the tool rest, and moved my pivot/aiming point. By locking it in place, it eliminated this. It also provides me with a handy 'bending' jig for fine tuning my blades.

Aiming: The most difficult thing to learn. Since the tool is not on a fixed pivot point, you have to do the aiming. Dale's explanation is a good one, and I think fairly similar to mine. Simply, the curve of the blade never seems to exactly match the outside curve of the bowl. Rule of thumb, if the blade curve is tighter than the bowl curve, aim more parallel to the outside shape of the bowl. If the blade curve is flatter than the bowl curve, aim more towards the center of the bowl (we called this 'toe nailing' when driving nails). McNaughton has a laser system, and Monster tools also makes one that goes on the McNaughton. They really help tell you where you are. I never could figure out the 'straight line from blade shaft to tip' thing. Just did not compute for me. I have the McNaughton set up, and had it welded to the top of my handle as that was more efficient than using the same bolts that lock the blade in place. I can use the same handle for free hand hollow form cutting with the laser.

Blade tips: I grind mine square. The spear point makes a wider shaving, and with the square tip, I get way better shaving ejection. Both Woodcut and Oneway have square tips. I will be retipping some of my old blades with Tantung steel, 3/8 wide by 1/8 inch thick, and slightly tapered. It should work fine, and is an excellent cutting material for wood, silver soldered on, and almost as hard as the carbide tips, but easily sharpened with standard hones (coarser is better, a point that Dale also makes). Mike Hunter did retip one for me a few years back. He tried a very pointy one which I did not like, and he did another one for me that was 3/8 inch square. It worked fine, but again, I prefer a square cutter, not pointed.

This tool is not for every one.

Betty, I am looking forward to some one else's opinion of the 3 different coring systems. I have commented about it many times in the past.

Dale, in your demo, you made the comment about me being fairly new to the tool. I am curious about that comment. Not offended, but curious. I had, at the time turned some 10,000 bowls, and a lot of them were cored.

robo hippy

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#19

Steven Antonucci

I'm usually the guy who starts the thread 


Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#20

Re: Like the short handle for tailstock support id

Jorge

Steve, I am not as experienced as reed but hitting 1k.

Years ago I stopped using the handle and always use the tail stock. My gate is the old one and I prefer using the left slot. I never use the blade with the most bend, (shorter radius) and very occasionally use the straight one. Hold it with my fingers in a very relaxed manner

Besides of truing the shape to an arc of a circle, keep it clean and smooth, I file mine just as we file the tool rests, to have a clean smooth action, nobody has mentioned it, but some woods have more sugar than others, like cherry, and the blade body, by friction, gets carbonized, so after every core, clean it with steel wood and wet an dry as needed.

I never spray wd40 straight into the wood, it can cause problems at finishing time; but after cleaning the blade, I spray it with, senior moment... a stuff from the kitchen to prevent food sticking to the frying pan

About visualizing, after having the experience of making the interior diameter bigger than the exterior, I figured out to, without the bowl blank on the chuck,

position the gate and swing in the blade until you find the setting that will leave enough wood at the bottom, I leave 1/2" for blanks 12" 0r less and 3/4" for blanks above 12" Once you establish that, mount your blank and make shavings.

Probably your problem is you don't use it often enough, that is no problem now that you have a big stash of wood, keep using it very often and when you emerge on the other side of the logs you will be a master...

happy and safe turning!

Forgot to mention that I core out the smallest first and progress to the bigger...

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#21

Re: Just watched your video... AWESOME!

Dale Bonertz

I hope it helps you. Can't wait to see the set.

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#22

Re: Kind of long.....

Dale Bonertz

Don't take offense Robo. The video was edited and there was something said, if I remember correctly, that referenced you from many years ago. I have your video and Mike's which both have good points in them. As with everything we all have our own tweaks to someones methods thus we won't always agree with them on their way of using tools. In retrospect I am not sure why the whole end question and answer thing wasn't edited out. I did not do the editing, another club member did the editing and posting to youtube.

Dale

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#23

Re: Kind of long.....

robo hippy

Dale,

Not offended at all, just curious. I am wondering if you have ever experimented with tweaking the tips of your blades.

robo hippy

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#24

Re: Kind of long.....

Dale Bonertz

I have not tweaked the tips. I have not found it necessary in the way I use the tool. Maybe someday I will, out of curiosity, to see if it makes any noticeable difference.

Have a great day,

Dale

Re: Continuing my love/hate (mostly hate) relationship

#25

Steven Antonucci

almost glory...

Steven Antonucci

I ran out in the dark and a light rain to make a quick application of my new found knowledge and I almost saw greatness. I lost the middle core to a funnel when the shavings jammed and it broke off the remaining thin section. I think the banjo worked loose a little and re-aimed the knife, or i would have had it.

Dale's video was the clearest explanation I have ever seen, and i expect that i will post many piles of bowls pictures this weekend. Thanks for the video and the link guys!

Btw- coring wet apple was perhaps the most nauseating smell I have ever encountered turning wood.