Keith Tompkins' recent post motivated me to try something I gave up on back when I first started turning. My wife is a lampworker and makes lots of glass beads, marbles, flowers, and such. My earlier attempts to integrate them into wood pieces didn't turn out so good. This one didn't either, but after looking at the pictures, I think I see some things that I could change to improve it. Maybe I should take the pictures before I make the piece... hmmmm is that possible.
The piece is ash and black walnut. About 8" x 8". One coat of poly/oil at this point.
Your comments and suggestions greatly appreciated.
I like the piece a lot and it makes me wish I had some beads to play with.
I do have a couple of suggestions. The lower part of the finial does not flow into the lid. Changing what looks like a straight line on the base of the finial to a slight cove would make the flow together better. Under cutting the coves the bead fits into would make it nest better. And the base of the vase in the should be smaller.
Here's a different thought. How about turning the base of the finial as a part of the lid? That would eliminate one piece out of the project and the process of fitting the finial to the lid. Then the top part of the finial could either match or contrast.
Your comment about seeing the finished piece in advance is exactly what is known as previsualization. It's one of the backbones of photography, but also of woodturning. We all practice it to some extent when we conceive a piece.
In this case, you might have tried drawing the piece in advance with some degree of accuracy. I don't try to draw both halves unless I'm using a computer to duplicate the curves from one side to the other. Try out combinations of curves and quirks and angles until you get a combination that works and you know why it works. Then, replicate the curves on the lathe.
On this piece, I love the shape of the ash vessel and the concept of that colorful bead, but I think the lines of the walnut parts need to stand out a little more, and possibly be articulated differently. I hesitate to tell you how to do it, because there are a million possibilities and it's your piece. Also, I would try using a larger bead in relation to the finial, maybe with a shape that echoes the shape of the pot.
Overall, though, I like it a lot. Can't wait to see where you go with this concept. Maybe your wife will find a new outlet for her beads.
Some of the faults I also noticed, but I had not seen the possible solutions.
Turning the lid and base of the finial together would most likely have avoided the break in the curve as well as the unsightly joint from the lid to the base. Not sure why I didn't think of that; I was working with a piece of 1 1/2" thick wood.
I definitely should have undercut the wood more where it joins the glass. However that is going to be a little tricky because most of these beads are not perfect in shape. I believe Keith mentioned that earlier also. They are hand "turned" on a mandrel using molten glass. Bead makers are concentrating more on colors and other challenges than on perfection in the circumference, which is not really noticeable in most of their uses. My wife also concentrates on not dropping it into her lap.
So far I have only worked with what she calls her reject bucket. She has not tried to make any shaped specifically for combining with wood... because I haven't yet figured out what I want her to make.
I'm going to try a few more. It's a good break from turning bowls and such.
Hi Chuck, I agree with Barry....the lid is crossgrain while the finial is spindle grain orientation. The joint will move with weather changes. I would make it one piece, the lid and finial. Your finial stock grain doesn't run straight up and down...if you try to turn it thin, it will probably break. Don't be afraid to make your turning thin where elements meet..it will add visual interest. Still, it's a very cool finial...glad I could help!!
The ash component is pretty nice. But its upper portion flattens out a little too much. That makes a flowing transition to the walnut lid difficult. It's the transitions from component to component, tying them all together as a cohesive whole, that is one of the things that is missing.
The proportions - bowl and lid to the finial, to me, looks a bit squat. A bit more heighy can visually "lift" the piece. A little slimming down of the finial will also add to the lift effect.
I don't know how this image will appear (too small?) but I drew lines to show how slimming down the finial and removing straight lines would improve the flow.