Re: DIY Video System for Demonstrations
charlie belden
John wrote:
>Charlie I still think this system works well. I can put the camera anywhere it needs to be to best see the action. <
The problem is that not every club has a John Lucas available to operate the camera - and who shows up to every demonstration and operates the camera.
>The downsides are, storage and needing a camera that has remote zoom, and the operator needs to see the big screen to be able to position the camera accurately. It doesn't require any switching. It does require a camera operator who actually cares about operating the camera. Most of the problems we encounter is still the camera operator watching the demo instead of trying to position the camera.<
The video system we've put together has the Operator sitting behind the demonstrator - watching all three camera feeds in separate flat screen displays, each labeled and color coded (ie. overhead view, end view and front view) AND a separate flat screen labeled projector (what the audience is seeing). The operator also has three separate labeled and color coded remotes that he or she uses to zoom individuall cameras in or out to get the best shot of the action.
With a display of what each of the three cameras is seeing, the operator has The Best Seat In The House, being able to see three views of what the demonstrator is doing and thus concentrating on the video displays, not on the actual demonstrator.
>I think a redesign of the basic system and you could make it so it can be broken down into a smaller space for storage.<
I'm sure that could be done. But there's still the GOOD CAMERA OPERATOR requirement.
>How many times have you seen a turners shoulder in the video camera when hollow bowls or vessels. You switch to a camera that has a less that best position.<
Even with a three camera system, there's always the possibilitiy of the demonstrator obstructing the view of the Best Shot Camera. One solution would be an additional flat screen display where the demonstrator can see what's being sent to the audience's display (big flat screen or projector screen). The other possibility is to have the "director" inform the demonstrator that his head/should is in the way.
Will add that to our To Do List.
>With this [ boom camera ] system you can simply move the camera above the shoulder, even right next to their head if necesssary<
Again, this requires a good camera operator. And I'm not sure the demonstrator wants anything moving around his head when making a critical cut ; )
> This isn't the whole arm. We add weights to the rear to make it easier to balance the camera. The whole assembly is mounted on a rolling chair bottom so you can roll the camera to help get it into the perfect position. The camera operator is seldom in the way of the audience but it doesn't really matter because you can fill the frame with the tool doing the cutting and everyone is watching that.>
We have and tried a professional Boom Camera system on wheels. But moving it around when there are lights hung over the demonstrator was limited. You don't want to hit the overhead lights - or the demonstrator when moving to get The Best Shot.


> It also has the advantage that if the demonstrator needs to step over to a table to do texturing, painting etc, you simply roll the camera over that position.<
You must have attended one of Jacques Vesery's demos at the San Jose 2012 Symposium. This was exactly the problem with his demo. A possible solution might be to have a small table top that could be quickly and easily placed on the bed of the lathe - in the field of view of the three fixed position cameras - and removed and place on a folding table behind or beside the lathe when not being used.
(another thing to add to our To Do List
>In my demos I do a section where I walk to the front of the lathe to show how much easier it is to control the tool when cutting a platter (or mirror) downhill with the grain from the center out. The metal "cage" gets in the way of this.<
The FRAME we've come up with has the headstock end open. Lookking down on the FRAME, it's an "L". The top of the "L" is over the headstock, the foot of the "L" around the tailstock end. The "L" is about 4' long and only 2' wide. If it were wider, say by a foot or so, you could do what you described without the FRAME getting in your way.
Yet another thing to perhaps add to our To Do List.
Thanks for raising all these points!