Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

looking for a beefier face shield.

Posts

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#26

Re: I bought one of those.

phillip medghalchi

John, are trying to kill yourself, or what? supposed you found this helmet/face shield, what guarantees that the piece will not fly and hit you in the shoulder, which few months back that's exactly what happened to me. fortunately, I was lucky and dodged it, which only caught me on hit me in the left shoulder. We recently, had a good friend here who got hit with the mesquite round which hit the ground and bounced off the ground and hit his face in the right side and now he has titanium in the right side of the face and he already had at least 5 surgery to correct his face. However, the piece hit the ground first and then hit him off the ground. the point I am trying to make is that first of all do not stand in the direct line of fire until maybe when you are done with all shaping and ready to do sanding and final light cuts. Even at this point I try to keep the tail stock on the piece until very last part of the work. I honestly don't think that there is anything that would protect us %100, maybe, take some impact away.

Then, again how are you going to protect the rib cage form getting hit or your collar bone or even stomach?

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#27

Re: I bought one of those.

John Lucas

Phil Well first of all I've never been hit in the face by flying wood and rarely been hit anywhere at all. I've had some bark come off and hit my hand. I have had a few pieces explode over the years. I was out of the line of fire and nothing happened.

I don't turn many bowls or hollow vessels. That seems to be where the troubles are. When I do turn bowls most are under 8" and they are good sound wood. Not that I haven't turned a fair number of the years, I probably have 20 under the cabinet for sale and another 2 dozen or so roughed out on the shelf.

I turn mostly small items like my mirrors, ornaments and boxes. I think I've had maybe one mirror come apart in the several hundred that I've done over the years. I've turned bowls up to 20" but do so out of good wood. I do have some now that cracked badly while drying. They are still sitting. I may fill the voids with epoxy and turn them someday, or I may just toss them.

I started this thread because I don't believe your average face shield would stop a large piece of wood that hits you directly. It might reduce the damage and with luck redirect the blow. I just wondered if there was something that would really protect you.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#28

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

RCH

They also come standard with the Jet 1642. I quickly removed it -- it caught shavings so that I couldn't see what I was doing, which is dangerous. It now lives in the garage, 50' from the lathe.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#29

Re: I bought one of those.

phillip medghalchi

John, I am glad you have been safe and may God always protect you form anything like that happen. I thought long and hard about this and the problem is complicated. First of all you need to have a dust mask of some sort to make sure that you are not inhaling the dust, then some of you good folks need to have hearing protection since the sound of the cutting tool and lathe motor can be harsh. Then you need the eye and the head protection. Combine all of this we don't have any thing yet that would accommodate all in one + give you the protection we the turners need. Maybe this is a good time to invent something who knows? Alltogether, I think we all need to exercise good judgment and practice safety at all times.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#30

Re: I bought one of those.

David Walser

First of all you need to have a dust mask of some sort to make sure that you are not inhaling the dust, then some of you good folks need to have hearing protection since the sound of the cutting tool and lathe motor can be harsh. Then you need the eye and the head protection. Combine all of this we don't have any thing yet that would accommodate all in one + give you the protection we the turners need. Maybe this is a good time to invent something who knows?
[Emphasis added.]

But, we do have something that combines hearing protection and dust protection with a substantial face shield. The 3M Airstream is one example. The Triton Powered Respirator is another. Neither solution is cheap -- close to $1,000 for the 3M (with hearing protection) and about $250 for the Triton (if you can find one). Nothing will protect us from everything, but solutions exist that provide substantially more protection than what most turners are using.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#31

Re: that's cool-but kind of funny too

Craig Daymon

Don't those jackets have that high, tight collar like most turning smocks? This could be the new look of the woodturner. Besides, you really think it's that funny looking compared to wearing a Trend Airshield Pro, or similar mask? I'll bet these are fairly comfortable too. (Though no dust collection and I don't see magnifiers in the Lexan.)

-Craig

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#33

A story with a moral..for John Lucas

mjonesrdg

A non-turner friend of mine (also named John), diagnosed with sleep apnea, and in the first few weeks at home with his CPAP, was not adjusting to the contraption on his face. He often woke in the morning to find it on the floor, draped over the bedside table, or in a ball under his pillow.

One night late, John Friend woke up with the CPAP mask mooshed against his face, closing off his nose, and blowing into his ear. He ripped it off his head and with his best backhand, slung the thing across the darkned room. The flying mask/hose pulled the attached machine off the nightstand and onto "Spike", the family dog sleeping there on John Friend's side of the bed.

Now Spike comes up kiiii-Yiiii-ing like he's mortally wounded, doing circles from one side of the bed to the other. Missus John friend wakes with a start, reaches under the mattress, pulls out the Ruger Nighthawk, and, screaming,"I'm armed, I'm armed" she fires a shot that strikes the ceiling fan above. Now, the dog is squealing, John is cussing, the ceiling fan is going,,"clinkety-clank...clinkety-clank....and someone calls 911.

After that event, the CPAP stayed in the bottom drawer until shortly after John's Scary (asleep while driving) Accident. A couple of black eyes from the impact, and the insurance deductible were the longest-lasting effects, aside from the scare. But, my friend John made a vow to learn to get along with that CPAP...and he has. (Even brought it to fish camp with him last season). John Friend realized that it could have been worse...a lot worse...and now he says, to all that will listen, that some things are made to protect, and sometimes you've just got to learn to love 'em.

The moral? John Lucas, use that "beefy" face shield that came with your Powermatic. Sure it can be a pain in the patootie, and you don't have to use it all the time. But like my friend, you can learn to love it...and you can teach others to love it too. As we have learned recently, the alternatives can be downright scary.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#34

Re: A story with a moral..for John Lucas

John Lucas

I tried to use it. It sucks, was in the way and you simply couldn't turn effectively with it in place. Some things are designed by turners and maybe engineers. Some things are designed by lawyers who have no idea how it should work. That's the protective cage over the powermatic. I have yet to find anyone who has used the thing.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#35

Re: A story with a moral..for John Lucas

phillip medghalchi

John, I wonder if this qsn. was ever raised by turning community to Powermatic company when they first intrudecd it to the market with that cage? Or, the qsn. was raised and powermatic never took time to listen to it or show the turners why they invented it in the first palce or how it shoud be best used so it would be used all the time. has anyone ever seen the demo of this cage. Like it was mentioned above I too have seen that turners remove it all together and sits on a wall or shelf collecting dust, however, the poor turner gets charged for the idea and the metal and pay shipping and all that on this piece of eqpnmt.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#36

Re: A story with a moral..for John Lucas

John Lucas

Wish I knew the answer to that. As far as I know (and I certainly could be wrong here) Powermatic and Jet are the only company that ships a guard with their lathes. Now whether it was for the turners safety or protection from lawsuits I don't know but at least they tried. It's just not a very good device.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#37

Re: A story with a moral..for John Lucas

Lan Brady

Can you imagine the public outcry against Powermatic if they quit providing a free safety device?????

The press would crucify them just to have a story!!!!!

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#38

Jesper, Denmark

Re: It's probably most effective hanging on the wa

Jesper, Denmark

In case of accident, the corporate lawyer claims the safety device provided was not used, and therefore the company has no liability.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#39

Re: I bought one of those.

Martin S.

Phillip:

What do you use for face, hearing, and lung protection?

What about body protection?

Serious questions. I bought one of these, too. Did I buy something too light?

I need to know what would be best to protect me and my son as we learn to turn.

Thanks in advance,

Martin

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#40

Re: I bought one of those.

phillip medghalchi

Martin, I suggest you read all of these responses which are given by some of the very professionals here as we all have had our own versions of these mishaps. Most of all do not stand in the direct line of fire when roughing out and when your instinct tells you that something may go wrong.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#41

You didn't answer my question.

Martin S.

Phillip,

I don't understand. You slammed John for his choice of face shields, which happened to be my choice, too.

I asked you what you used. Your answer was that I should read everyone else's answers. I have.

If you use something better, I'd like to hear about it. If not, why did you slam John for his choice?

Perhaps you don't use anything, and you were being facetious in slamming John?

This is about safety, it is not a joke. I'd like to know what, if anything, you use to protect your face.

Is that a secret?

I am new to turning, and I am just trying to learn.

If you use a better face shield, please tell me the brand. If you don't use anything, and are embarrassed to admit it, you can send me a private email and tell me so.

I thought these boards were to share useful information. Maybe I was wrong?

Respectfully,

Martin

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#42

Re: You didn't answer my question.

phillip medghalchi

First, I didn't slam John for using his choice of face shield. I was just trying to agree with him that some of the face shields in the market do not do the job. Secondly I thought that I mentioned and I checked which I didn't. I use Bionic Shield

http://www.amazon.com/Uvex-S8510-Polycarbonate-Anti-Fog-Hardcoat/dp/B001VY3ACE/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1349715685&sr=8-2&keywords=bionic+faceshield

I don't need to use hearing protection since I have severe hearing loss and I wear hearing aids so I can turn them down when hollowing or roughing which cause the loud noise, I wear totobobo mask that is pretty efficient.

My main line of defense is not being in the direct line of fire. I stop frequently and check to see how the wood is acting under the tool and go from there, however, there is still no %100 proof that nothing will happen.

I wasn't sure that if you asked me what I was using, and I am not taking this as a joke.

Next time I appreciate that you ask directly and not jump the gun too fast so you get your answer. If you are new to this hobby and going about it like this you will insult some of the professional turners here and you will not be to happy with thier responses.

Hope this will help you and get you to calm down.

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#43

Thank you

Martin S.

Phillip,

Here's the recap as I see it:

I did ask directly, and quite clearly, in my first post. Perhaps you just missed it.

Your answer was "read everyone else's posts if you want to find out the answers to your questions".

I asked again, explaining that I didn't understand why you didn't answer my first post.

I irritated you, but you did answer, and I appreciate that. Thank you for the information.

I may be relatively new to turning, but I have been on WC, WN, and SMC for quite a while.

I have made many friends, and irritated very few people.

I am sorry I offended you. I won't do it again.

Very respectfully,

Martin

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#44

Re: Thank you

phillip medghalchi

You can tell some one to sit down, or get your b..t in the chair, sit the h.....l down and many many more. It will all achieve same goal, but with different reaction. However, if you say please take a seat and feel comfortable then you really now have that persons attention too. That's all I was trying to get across. I also have mentioned your answer in a different post that I used that bionic face shiled, maybe not directly quoting the name, how ever, it was answered. I had chat with john and I respect his techniques and his knowledge, besides I don't think that I have slammed his selection of face shield. after what had happened to my local friend with his face this issue of face protection has a different place on my mind and has high priority on my list when in the shop.

I also researched something about this, it appears that General tools has a shield that attaches to the lathe and it shields the whole object being turned i will further investigate it to see if it is universal, and can be mounted on any lathe. however, it looked promising.

Here is the link:

# 25-160 Wood Lathe Guard

This Wood Lathe Guard is easily installed on the lathe bed and the height of its support column can be adjusted to suit the clearance needed for the shield depending on the size of your lathe.

This device ensures complete safety against the following risks: wood chips, broken tools, dust, or any other object.

FITS MOST WOOD TURNING LATHES. DOES NOT INTERFERE WITH NORMAL LATHE USE


Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#45

Re: Thank you

Jim Breeden

Phillip - Where did you find the Wood Lathe Guard, #25-160, in the Grizzly cat? I have their cat and can't find it ennywhere. Even went to their web site and asked for that number - no deal. :\

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#46

Re: Thank you

phillip medghalchi

Jim, my applology. I didn't realize that the way I typed their name and you google it brings out different result. I correct that mistake with the bellow link. I know that their tool color confuses one with grizzly. however, if you go to this link and slect the accessories and look under the lathe youwill seee it.

http://www.general.ca/site_general/accessories/lathe.html

Re: looking for a beefier face shield.

#47

Re: Thank you

Jim Breeden

Phillip - MY apologies ! My dyslexia, plus I can't read, got me into trouble. :b I looked at the color, not General, and thought it was Grizzly. No wonder Grizzly thought I was wierd. I will now proceed to the General site.