Re: looking for a beefier face shield.
David Walser
If you're serious about getting protection from impact injuries (as opposed to keeping small, sharp, items from being flung into your face), I would look at something like the 3M Airstream. It's face shield is supported around the edges by a rigid plastic frame. This should divert much of the energy from an impact to the Airstream's helmet and away from your nose. The UVEX Bionic face shield should provide similar protection (without the hardhat and powered respirator of the Airstream). Another option, if you can find one, would be the Triton powered respirator.
These products keep the plastic face shield (and flying objects) away from your face. In comparison, a typical face shield provides little impact protection. Prove this to yourself by using your hand to see how much pressure it takes to press the plastic of a typical face shield against your face. The answer is that it takes hardly any pressure at all. I cannot get the plastic shield of my Triton to touch my face without breaking it.
None of this means that a typical face shield provides no impact protection. It does. It spreads the energy from an impact over a larger area, it might deflect the object, making the event more of a glancing blow than a direct hit, and it should prevent an object from penetrating your skin. Nor does it mean that an Airstream or other beefier face shield will protect you from any impact. If you try to stop a speeding 57 Chevy with your face, you will die -- with or without a 3M Airstream. All this means is that these beefier face shields provide substantially more protection than do typical face shields.