Ok, I have read the posts from past and I am not sure if I get that "turn the can of finish upside down". then I have heard about the bloxygen too.
Here is what happened to me. I bought a can of General finish salad bowl finish. I used a lots of it since I made few utilitarian bowls, but, we had heck of hot a summer and very warm and humid. About a week ago I wanted to put it on a new bowl so when I tried to open the can i had heck of a hard time to open it at first then when I also read in the threads that to turn the can upside down when storing, so what happens to the sticky lid?
Dose bolxygen work like they way they claim it, or is it something that they just wanted to sell another product?
An evaporative finish (such as polyurethane, shellac, etc.) essentially is a "solution" of finish in a suitable solvent. So the finish is deposited on the object and that's pretty much that.
If you minimize the head space in your container (marbles, squeezing the sides or whatever) there is less space for which the solvent to evaporate.
A finish which cures due to a reaction such as oxidation or polymerization is different. The finish is applied to the object and reacts with the air, moisture, a catalyst or whatever. Time passes and you have a finish.
If you minimize the head space in your container, you minimize the exposure of the finish to oxygen, moisture, etc. It might react a little, but not too much. If you add Bloxygen (or something similar such as argon, nitrogen, etc.) - you are displacing the air in the head space from the container making the finish less likely to react. Some caveats here - stir, don't shake - the atmosphere can "dissolve" in your finish.
Some other things of which to be aware - propane and carbon dioxide can work - but they do have a solubility in the finish - so you may want to use more.
So - in answer to your question - Bloxygen works. Of course if you were to go to an industrial gas supplier and get a small tank of nitrogen or argon, that would work as well and be less expensive over the long run - but you'd have to using a lot of finish.
Waterlox is my main go-to finish and it's one of the most infamous finishes for going bad, and it's not cheap. The additives to me just make an expensive finish even more expensive. They may help awhile. No matter what you do, additives or not, you'll never use every drop of a finish. Why not make the amount that will eventually go bad be smaller? I like to decant finishes into smaller containers. When I buy a new container of finish I'll decant the entire container into smaller containers. Once a container starts to gain some air space, it goes into a smaller container, and so on.
Jerome, thank youfor that explanation. I'll try it. I guess i have to invest in few small very airtight containers in the future as to minimize the air space and also buy some bloxygen.
Waterlox doesn't really go bad. A gel forms on the surface, but the fluid below the gel layer is still good. All you need to do is use a pipette to stick through the gel layer, and draw the good fluid up from below. Don't throw away all of that good Waterlox. I've been using the same can for over two years via the pipette process with no problems. I bought 100 pipettes on eBay for 50 cents.
I use plain old CO2 from a 20oz paintball bottle, filled at the local paintball place. The valve from a refill adapter (ebay), a small hose barb, and a length of vinyl hose is used dispense it into finish containers. Initially I got too much gas, so I added an orifice to the hose barb by soldering in a short length of brass tubing and squeezing it down around a small steel wire (from a wire brush) which I then pulled out. This arrangement has worked well for over 7 years now. Three or four cans of Bloxygen will pay for this setup.
I also run brad nailers off paintball bottles with an appropriate adapter and regulator when I need to do work away from the workshop. Very handy.
If you have a MIG or TIG welder that will release gas without being turned on, just use your Argon or Argon/CO2 right out of the welding torch.
On the contrary, it all can go bad as well. Usually you'll get the surface gel, but it will also all go bad eventually. The surface gel is usually the warning it's time to change containers. I used to have a picture of Waterlox "gel" in shape of the can after it was cut away around it. The gel was then sliced like a cake. A pipette wouldn't have done a thing.
It would be interesting to know what the different circumstances are in our experiences. All I can say is I've been using the pipette process for about 14 years, with temperature extremes in my garage with no problems at all. I do use a glass jar with a lid instead of the can, but that is the only extra step I take. I buy a new can of Waterlox about every three years or so.
A couple of points, I think the glass jars are better than "cans". I use jars as well. I think can are at times a weak link. The opening or cap gets dented or damage and it's a matter of time. Most people that have had colossal failures were involved with cans/containers that were damaged. Glass in a shop has it's own set backs but in my opinion they're a lot more reliable for storage. A quart of finish lasts me about a year. That's not due to loss, but usage. 3-4 baluster jobs a year and the production turning I do, uses it up. I'll lose less than a 1/4 cup, basically the skim from the smallest baby food jars.
The pipette technique is a good one and pipettes are handy to have in the shop for other things as well.
Scott, I tried to send you PM, but you are not set up, could you send me PM, please. I'd like to see a pic. of this tank so maybe I can make one if you don't mind, thank you.
I use a cheap and simple alternative that works well for me. As the can contents decreases I fill the can with small rocks. This displaces the enemy (air).
This makes sense from physics point of view, but what about introducing very fine dust that come from the surface of rock into the finish solution which in a long run will make small bumps on the article you are applying the finish on? Unless, I am guessing that you wash those rocks very hard and make sure they are tumbled rocks?
Haven't read all the other replies, so forgive me if this repeats information already provided. I got Bloxygen to help me get a longer pot life on a quart of Waterlox. I was averaging about a third of the container before it gelled up on me. The Bloxygen seemed to help, but I abandoned its use after learning how you can add water to any decanted container so the water sits on the bottom and the finish rises to the top of the rim. It is the air layer that when absorbed into the finish causes it to gel. To help with a sticky threaded lid, I put some oil or light grease on the threaded part of the lid and that helps.