Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

Posts

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#26

Re: Turning fast?

John Lucas

Mike had to stop making videos. My neighbor is cutting down a pine tree and chain saw noise is noticeable. Of course chain saw noises on a turning tape would not necessarily be a bad thing but I need to get a bike ride in so will do that.

I turned one more demo piece. This was after turning an entire 6" x 3" deep walnut bowl with the larger Osprey tool.

The section just to the right of the bead was roughed using the Osprey and then sanded from 220 to 600. All the rest was turned with the Osprey only at 2450 rpm. This is just a pine 2x4.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#27

Mike Stafford

Re: Turning fast?

Mike Stafford

That is a fabulous picture John. In all honesty the wood just cut with the Osprey looks smoother than what was sanded. You can tell that the wood was sanded. The other surface looks cut and very smooth.

I generally turn with Osprey at a fairly high rpm. The wood is fairly humming. The Hunter Tools respond well to speed.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#28

Denis Putland

Re: Pine and sand paper

Denis Putland

Mike, John.. In my experience soft woods like pine do not accept sanding worth a hoot.

A sharp gouge will also give pine a smoother looking finish then sand paper.

Not trying to knock the tool that John used, it is just what I know about pine and sanding it.

Denis

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#29

Re: Pine and sand paper

John Lucas

Dennis I agree but since it was on the lathe for another project I thought I would do a quick test to go along with the other woods. It's looking like whatever wood I use the Osprey leaves a finish somewhere between 400 grit or above. The exception of course is if you don't flow with the tool well enough and leave a burnished line or slight bump that must be removed with either shear scraping or sandpaper.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#30

Re: No, it doesn't

John Lucas

Yea wish we could sit down in person and play with the tools. The big difference between the regular Hunter tools and the Osprey is that nose or bevel of the tool is basically the same as the nose or bevel on many bowl gouges. So it has the same problem when you have a steep transition from side to bottom of a bowl.

Even though it functions like a bowl gouge in this respect to top not being flat changes the angle the chip comes off the wood from that of a standard bowl gouge. so it cuts very similar in the way it handles but cuts cleaner. It will not remove wood as fast as a bowl gouge. At least when used in the same flute orientation (if you reference the top of the cutter as the flute) Still haven't quite understood why that is.

Even though the cutter will not remove wood as fast as a bowl gouge in the normal orientation it will come close when you use the tool as a scraper and isn't grabby like a bowl gouge would be if you used it flute up in a scraping motion.

It's not a tool for every occasion but is very easy for a beginner to use, will make some more advanced bevel rubbing cuts, and will make those cuts very clean.

In short you could use a Hunter #4 or #5 and the Osprey and do most anything and never have to sharpen again. The Hercules will do many of the things the Osprey does it's just harder to roll beads however it's much more stable in scraping mode than the Osprey.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#31

Testing

Craig Daymon

Del Stubbs use to demo turning using a sharpened axe. I never saw it, but I think it's on one of his videos. Be interesting to see the finish achieved

With respect to testing, and there might be someone here with the extra cash and interest, MAKE magazine (a really cool magazine, mostly electronic projects) had an article recently on building your own electron scanning microscope. I think the total cost was around $1,000. It was one of the last three issues, but I don't recall.

There are several electron scanning microscope DIY projects on their page, though I'm certain the cost varies widely. Here's a couple.

http://blog.makezine.com/2012/05/11/ben-krasnows-home-made-electron-scanning-microscope-and-liquid-lens-coming-to-maker-faire/

http://makerfaire.com/pub/e/8157

Here's the main magazine site, for those interested. (Especially great if you have kids.)

http://www.makezine.com

Here's another site where they throw, along with many of their readers, different projects.

http://www.makeprojects.com

I keep thinking there is a turning project to post up on their site, but I haven't hit on it yet. Maybe an Arduino controlled etching/engraving system? You can burn wood with the lasers in DVD burners, so there might be something there.

-Craig