Sharpness, materials, and reasoning
steven antonucci
I think it would be practical to consider the following. Whether you can make another tool sharper than a Hunter cutter is not material. Most people take their gouge straight off of whatever wheel and go cut wood with it. I have a Tormek, and while I theoretically could hone my tools on the leather wheel to a mirror finish, I do not because it is not practical.
So the limits of the material do not match the situation. Just because high carbon steel CAN get sharper, it does not mean that it is. The Hunter cutters have been polished to a very good edge, and it is not an edge that most of us will ever get on our other tools. With the exception of my skew, I rarely go beyond stropping off the burr from my Tormek for finish cuts in wet wood to avoid tanin stains (not the sharpness).
When I do go through the effort on my skew, it is way far and above the Hunter cutter in sharpness. What most of the conversation has overlooked is the geometry of the cutter. In a gouge, the edge is being presented into the wood In the Hunter, it is more like it is cutting like a skew because the edge is "up" and usually rolled over to the right or left giving the skew angle. It is probably more analogous to a hook tool in cutting because the bevel rides against the wood and you aren't as susceptible to fluctuations in movement.
I still haven't figured it all out, but I know for a new turner, there is a much easier learning curve. If you miss the bevel, it just works like a scraper with a big, sharp burr...
It is decidedly an odd bird to deal with in that it does things about 90% as well as 4 or 5 convential tools, but it also can be taught to a beginner who may only be 30% proficient with a gouge, but can pick up a Hunter and get 60% in a day or two. I still don't know what to do with mine... but I know what it can do.
Steve