Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

Posts

Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#1

Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

John Lucas

I'm working on a pen turning video using the Hunter Osprey tool this morning. My voice sucks so I'll probably go on a bike ride to clear it up. Anyway I always wondered how clean the Hunter tools cut. I often cut the inside of boxes and just leave them. Anyway I did a test. In the photo below you will see the left side was sanded to 600 grit. It still has a few sandpaper lines. The Hunter tool was used on the right in bevel rubbing mode to turn the shapes and bead. It looks to me like I need to go to 1200 grit to roughly match the finish off the tool.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

Mike Stafford

It is incredible the finish that comes off the Hunter Osprey. I have been using them extensively on my birdhouse ornaments. Where the roof is end grain down at the bottom and then transitions to long grain along the thin stem is the perfect job for the Osprey. The thin end grain does not like sanding because of the possibility of heat checking.

The Osprey greatly reduces my sanding time on both the body and the roof section of these little birdhouses.

I have also been using the Osprey for finishing cuts on the lids of my boxes. The end grain comes off the tool polished and sanding if needed starts at 600 or higher. Very few woods do I need to sand to higher than 600 grit.

I like the way the tool cuts and responds exactly like a gouge. The learning curve is very short.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#3

Ellis Walentine

Let's talk absolutes

Ellis Walentine

I'm very impressed with the results that you and John are talking about, because I know you wouldn't be saying this if it weren't so. But, I need some kind of closure here. What is it that makes this particular tool give such a smooth surface? Mike talks about how it cuts and responds like a gouge. What are the variables here? Bevel angle? Sharpness? It seems to me that the greatest advantage of carbide cutters is that they are sharper than the edge we normally create on our gouges. Other than that, the only way this tool could work like a gouge is if the effective bevel angle is similar. Does the 45º presentation angle, coupled with the included angle of the carbide cutter, mimic the cutting angle of a typical gouge?

Inquiring minds need to know. :)

Ellis

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's talk absolutes 

Mike Stafford

Ellis,

The carbide cutter is mounted at an angle on the end of a round tool shaft such that the edges mimic the flute of a gouge at the very end. The shaft is ground back under the cutter much like a gouge would be ground so you are riding the bevel just like a gouge.

Now the depth of cut is limited with this tool because we are still talking about one of the Hunter round carbide cutters and although it could be used for turning a bowl it would be slower than if you used a bowl gouge.

The real advantage in the way I use the tool is to make my final cuts. The razor sharpness of the nanograin carbide slices the wood very cleanly leaving behind a polished surface. John's picture showing the finish on a piece of cocobolo in spindle orientation gives an idea of how cleanly the tool cuts.

I use the tool almost exclusively now to cut the final profile on the lids of my boxes and also to finalize the shape of the body of a box when it is reversed. The fine finish that I get from the tool saves me a lot of sanding time and also eliminates most of the opportunities for heat checking of the end grain if a lot of sanding is needed to remove it. The heat checking is also a problem on the thin bottom edges of the roofs on my birdhouses. Not much sanding needed after the Osprey and there is no noticeable difference in the transition from end grain to long grain as you proceed up the roof to the top.

I have used it for my little birdhouses, boxes, and on a couple of bowls but it is reach limited by the shaft diameter for much bowl work.

I don't have a picture showing the bevel on the shaft supporting the carbide cutter but it is a continuation of the bevel on the Hunter cutter. So in use you ride/glide on the bevel just as you would with any other gouge.

The picture shows the #2 Osprey in use forming the roof for a birdhouse from a piece of walnut. The finish behind the tool glistens with smoothness.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#5

Re: Let's talk absolutes

John Lucas

Ellis I think the real advantage is 2 things. The cutter itself has a resessed surface that is polished. This gives an edge that I can't measure but seems to be around 25 to 30 degrees. That and the polished surface means that it simply has a finer cutting edge than most tools we use for turning.

Now this would normally make for a really grabby tools but because of how the cutter is mounted on the shaft you have a front bevel that measured from the center line of the tool is very similar to that of a typical bowl gouge. this makes it easy to use both as a scraper with tool held flat or as a bowl gouge with a bevel rubbing.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Let's talk absolutes

Lyle Jamieson

I use the #1 hunter tool for my hollowing and it is amazing. The finish left behind from my bevel supported cut needs no sanding. Come across the end grain of a lidded box bottom and not have to stick my fingers in there to sand...priceless. To me there are three things at work here. The nanograin carbide is made from such fine particulate that the edge is razor sharp. Much different from other carbides or gouges sharpened on a grinder. The only way to match the sharpness would be to hone the gouge and the sharpness would be so short lived that the advantage would be lost in a few seconds. John, the mirror finish is from the nanograin not any attempt to polish the surface of the carbide. That is how you can tell what grade of carbide you have, is by the matt gray surface of the other carbide cutters. The second issue is the angle of attack, yes, it is some place near 30-45 degree angle. That is the sweet spot for the smooth surface. And the last benefit comes from the slicing or sheering cutting action achieved by the angle and the bevel supported cut. I believe that a slicing cut will always leave a better finish behind on the wood then a scrapping mode can. The bevel support gives you the control of the direction you are cutting as well as support to prevent any grabbiness or catches. The Hunter tool unsupported by the bevel can be very aggressive to the point of uncontrollable for many beginners.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#7

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Let's talk absolutes

Joe Bradshaw

Ellis, I have the smaller Hunter tools and I agree with Mike and Lyle. I can get a 320 finished surface by taking my time and taking light cuts, plus rubbing the bevel. Since I have been using myHunter tools, I rarely sand the interior of my boxes. Now I just have to get the outside to the same level.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#8

Re: Let's talk absolutes

Craig Daymon

Is that accurate to say that carbide cutters have a sharper edge than we can get on gouges? My understanding was that carbon steel blades could be sharpened the finest, HSS next, cryo, micrograin next and finally carbide. I understand these are suppose to be micrograin carbide cutters, but are the really sharper than can ge gotten from steels?

They DO hold their edge MUCH longer than the steels and my sharpening skills are certainly suspect, but I'd like a more concrete comparison.

Was the turning presented dusted before photographed? Sanding would likely need dusting before showing truly how well it compares. The gouge would have cut, throwing off its residue in the process. (Yes, sandpaper is cutting, but it leaves a fine dust.) Also, the angle of the gouge cuts, though not parallel, 45 degrees or closer to the grain direction. If the turning was sanded (and dusted) in the same direction as the grain, how would it compare to the gouge? I always finish my sanding by sanding with the grain, especially in spindle orientation.

Inquiring minds want to know.

-Craig

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#9

Re: Let's talk absolutes

John Lucas

Craig These carbide cutters are as sharp as I can get my HSS cuttters. Maybe in some scale certain steels can get sharper such as a scalpel. I have a lot of carbide tools of various types including some other turning tools. My router bits for example will not get as sharp. I tried just the other day because my 3/4" router bit was not cutting well so I sharpened it as best I could with the same diamond hones I use to sharpen my skews which will shave hairs. The router bit would not.

Is it sharper than steel blades. No. I simply stated that the sharpening angle is narrower than most other turning tools and the surface is polished. this makes it cut cleaner than my typical turning tools which are sharpened to 35 degrees or thicker. I can get very close to this same finish with my 35 degree detail gouge

I did dust the turning. In fact I sanded it twice because I saw the same lines that appear to be left from a courser grit. When I sanded to 1200 the lines were gone and it was in fact shinier than the finish left by the carbide cutter.

I'm open to suggestions on how to test this further. One gentlemand said the fact that I used an oily wood the surface was burnished by the bevel. Possibly but I've had what I think is the same results from Cherry although I have done the actual sanding side by side. I have sanded the cherry after turning with little improvement.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's talk absolutes

Mike Stafford

John, I don't have the capability but it might be interested to see what a cut surface looks like under the microscrope when cut by various tools sharpened as well as they can be.

It only makes sense to me that the sharper a tool is the more smooth the cut wood will be. I mean if you are sharpening a gouge on an 80 grit wheel you cannot expect it to not leave some scratches in the wood. I have no idea to what level of fineness these nanograin carbide cutters are sharpened but they are polished to a mirror finish.

If you rub a fingernail along the edge of freshly sharpened and honed turning tool you can feel the roughness of the edge. If you do the same thing with a carbide cutter I do not feel any roughness. When I do it is time to rotate or replace the cutter. I do know that when I use a Hunter tool and I see a line in the cut surface of the wood that usually means I have a little chip in the edge which I can detect with my fingernail.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#11

Re: Let's talk absolutes

John Lucas

Mike I have a Stereo Microscope but don't know if it's even possible to get an adaptor to photograph through it. It also only magnifies to 20 power as is. I remember trying to learn more about a sharp edge using microscopes as school. It was very difficult getting the tool under the scope at the kind of magnifications you need to see the scratch lines of the abrasives and the Depth of Field was so shallow it also created a problem. I think you need something like 100x or more.

I also tried to measure the angle on the Hunter tools. The inside angle is a cove which makes it harder to measure. That's why my estimate of 25 to 35 degrees. I think the actual first millimeter might be 25 and then feathers out thicker to around 35 toward the bottom but that's as close as I could get using homemade filed angles in an aluminum plate. Even then it was still a rough estimate although probably not off more than a few degrees.

I do no that it is a sharper angle than any of my current turning tools and is polished to a higher level although my stropped skews might be pretty close to that polished.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#12

Re: Let's talk absolutes

Barry L Elder

It has been my experience that you don't need some cutting-edge tool to get a shiney finish on cocobolo. Nothing against carbide or nanocarbide, as I know that Hunter has been working on his tool line for a number of years. :D

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's talk absolutes

Mike Stafford

I bet Mike can supply you with that information regarding angles and whatnot.

I think you may be correct about a stropped skew. I also strop mine on occasion and it is polished and very sharp. You can shave with it.

If I had a Tormek I could probably get a stropped finish on my gouges. I had several of my tools sharpened by a Tormek representative who then went on to power strop them on the machine. They were really sharp.

It would be interesting to see the finish off a Tormek sharpened and stropped tool versus a normally sharpened tool versus a Hunter cutter.

All of this said I still think the main difference in this Hunter Osprey tool and other Hunter tools is that the cutter is presented on round bar stock at such an angle as to mimic a gouge and there is a bevel behind the cutter on the bar stock that lets one pick it up and in very short order use it just like a gouge. The learning curve is almost non-existent if the user knows how to use a gouge. The finish off the tool is very good.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's talk absolutes

Mike Stafford

I tend to agree Barry but when I get a polished finish on end grain walnut, mesquite and some other woods I tend to get excited because that means that I don't have to sand them as much.

On end grain dense woods in the rosewood family I have long loved the Hunter tools because they eliminated almost all of my sanding. If I have good tool control I will have a finish that virtually needs no sanding. And sanding of end grain is best minimized due to the likelihood that the dense exotics (and lots of other woods) do not like to be heated up on the end grain and will heat check.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#15

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#16

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

Mike Stafford

I think I know the difference between a cut surface and burnished surface, Grant. I also know the difference between riding the bevel and gliding along on the bevel. Riding the bevel bruises and burnishes the wood.

I have been using Hunter tools for a long time and I have found them to be useful in a variety of applications. They are not a cure all for everything but they certainly have proven to be problem solvers for some of the things I do.

Grant, do you think this is a burnished surface? Same walnut piece pictured earlier after finishing the turning.


Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#17

Steven Antonucci

Sharpness, materials, and reasoning

steven antonucci

I think it would be practical to consider the following. Whether you can make another tool sharper than a Hunter cutter is not material. Most people take their gouge straight off of whatever wheel and go cut wood with it. I have a Tormek, and while I theoretically could hone my tools on the leather wheel to a mirror finish, I do not because it is not practical.

So the limits of the material do not match the situation. Just because high carbon steel CAN get sharper, it does not mean that it is. The Hunter cutters have been polished to a very good edge, and it is not an edge that most of us will ever get on our other tools. With the exception of my skew, I rarely go beyond stropping off the burr from my Tormek for finish cuts in wet wood to avoid tanin stains (not the sharpness).

When I do go through the effort on my skew, it is way far and above the Hunter cutter in sharpness. What most of the conversation has overlooked is the geometry of the cutter. In a gouge, the edge is being presented into the wood In the Hunter, it is more like it is cutting like a skew because the edge is "up" and usually rolled over to the right or left giving the skew angle. It is probably more analogous to a hook tool in cutting because the bevel rides against the wood and you aren't as susceptible to fluctuations in movement.

I still haven't figured it all out, but I know for a new turner, there is a much easier learning curve. If you miss the bevel, it just works like a scraper with a big, sharp burr...

It is decidedly an odd bird to deal with in that it does things about 90% as well as 4 or 5 convential tools, but it also can be taught to a beginner who may only be 30% proficient with a gouge, but can pick up a Hunter and get 60% in a day or two. I still don't know what to do with mine... but I know what it can do.

Steve

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

Lyle Jamieson

Thats a sweet line, you nailed the curve.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#19

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

Mike Stafford

Well, thank you Lyle. My wife the mathematician says it is a half parabola although she qualifies that statement by saying a parabola can have different shapes.

I remember some of that stuff from long ago and far away but I try not to think about it these days. That's why I married her..... :b to do all my heavy thinking.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#20

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

Joe Bradshaw

Mike, all of us who know Gail will agree that you married up.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#21

Re: Sharpness, materials, and reasoning

John Lucas

Steve If you feed the Hunter Osprey tool down a bowl from lip to bottom with the bevel rubbing and cutter facing to the right it is cutting almost exactly like the nose of a bowl gouge. The wood is skewing across the tip kind of like if you fed a skew in with the toe down. The difference is the bowl gouge probably has a 45 to 60 degree sharpening angle while the Hunter cutter has 35 or less.

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#22

Steven Antonucci

No, it doesn't

steven antonucci

John- you are spot on about the angles and the skew-like properties, but the cutting is not the same.

With a bowl gouge presented in the same manner as the Hunter, the BEVEL of both tools are moved through the same motions in the same manner, but the Hunter cutters are sharp at the TOP and a bowl gouge would be sharp where the two surfaces meet. The bowl houge doesn't have the "hook" on the tip. If you rode the bevel on a scraper, it would be more like using a Hunter Osprey (assuming similar angles and such).

I think there is some plane analogy of bevel up vs. bevel down here, but I don't know enough about planes to explain it. The bottom bevel that rides against the wood is basically a wash when comparing the bowl gouge to the Osprey. They can be the same angles and you can polish them to the same finish. Both can rub against the wood in the same manner to provide support for the chip you are cutting.

What changes is the included angle. If I have my bowl gouge ground at 60 degrees vs. 45 degrees, my handle position changes and it starts to get hard to make the transition from side to bottom without hitting the handle or making a contortionist motion. So, a lot of turner will have a different gouge for each part of the cut. The angle of the tool plus the angle of the presentation give you an effective angle at the cutting point.

I think the Hunter changes this by not relying on the top surface being flat like the flute of the gouge. It starts off much lower than a bowl gouge (aka sharper), and then it is not reliant on the handle being so low to get the bevel rubbing because you can roll it on it's side.

It's hard to explain, but I will see Mike in Wisconsin in a couple of weeks, so perhaps we can figure it out over a couple of Brats and a cold beer or two.

Steve

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#23

quick test on other woods

John Lucas

I did another quick test this morning and used a better quality 600 grit paper. This was maple and walnut. I roughed out the wood using the Osprey as a scraper. the finish was easily sanded out starting with 220. Then as I worked through the grits I wiped it down with a dust rag between grits. My best estimate is the finish off the Osprey in bevel rubbing mode is somewhere between 400 and 600. You can see in the photo that 600 is better. The 400 grit was definitely less shiny than the unsanded version.

I conciously fed the tool faster than normal to avoid any possiblilyt of burning and as Mike said I glide the bevel which simply means I didn't apply any excess force with the bevel onto the wood.


Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#24

Mike Stafford

Turning fast?

Mike Stafford

John, I am curious. I don't normally discuss or ask questions about turning speeds because I hesitate to tell people at what speed they should turn. I believe people should turn at a speed where they feel in control and safe.

However it has been my experience with the relatively small section of the circumference of the Hunter tool in use during turning that a higher speed is better and a better finish is the result. The Osprey utilizes a #2 cutter which is relatively small and somewhat limits the size of the cut you can make and a shearing cut at relatively high speed will yield a wonderful finish with this tool.

So the question is at what speed were you turning?

Re: Hunter Osprey vs 600 grit sandpaper

#25

Re: Turning fast?

John Lucas

Mike I don't know because my Powermatic doesn't read out directly so I never look. I'm up over 2000 for sure and probably closer to 2400 rpm maybe higher. Now that's on small diameter work. I don't do that on bowls although on bowls less than 6" that I know are good and solid I will probably go up towards 2000 or more. Like you I've been turning a while and kind of know what I can get away with.