Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Need your advise to proceed

Posts

Need your advise to proceed

#1

Need your advise to proceed

phillip medghalchi

Last Sunday I ventured to try my hands on a piece of Walnut I won in a drawing which was held at our local AAW meeting. So, I proceed by looking at the piece and trying to figure out what's the best way to get the most beautiful figure out of the log. I then decide to make a hollow form as you'd see in the pictures which follow, the problem is that while I was working with the piece it was late at night and it wasn't one of those crazy S. TX hot nights and therefore, I was tired and left the piece on the lathe to gt to it in the morning. I get back in the shop next morning and find out that it started to crack, so I immediately buried the piece in the shavings and put it in the plastic bag and wrap it tight. So, everyday I checked it and every day I find out it is cracking more and it's opening up. I like to know if you were working in this piece, would you proceed or would you give up on it. I have the option of filling it with fine walnut dust of the pieces I saved for this purpose or I can fill it with turquoise or another stone to complement the design. What would you have done if you had this piece. any help would be greatly appreciated. If you feel that I did something wrong in he process of turning this piece, please point out I don't mind it and this is the only way I can learn.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#2

Cracked wood is "ventilated firewood" in my book

Greg Haugen

Personally, I've be done with this piece. There is an incredible turner that says, "life's too short to turn crappy wood." The large crack is a bit large, if you have a catch - it will be two pieces in orbit.

With that said, if you're set on it. I'd stop, let it dry for a while and stabilize and then re-enforce it with CA, InLace, and other epoxy mixed products before continuing.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#3

Mike Stafford

Turn the pith out of it.....

Mike Stafford

Philip, this piece appears to have the pith in it. You can expect it to have radial cracks and split more times than not when the pith is left in the blank.

As my old friend and instructor Jamie Donaldson once told me, "You have to turn the pith out of it."

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#4

Re: Turn the pith out of it.....

Dale Miner

I didn't know Jamie was old.?

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#5

Re: Turn the pith out of it.....

phillip medghalchi

I realize that the pith needed to come out, and this is no the first time I incorporated the pith in the design. However, the pith and the grain patten of it is part of the design and I thought I can get the attention of the old timer turners to give me some tips. Of course, not the age wise but the experience wise, and no disrespect to any one of you since I have seen pisces like this pattern before that inspired me to this, however, this is my first hollow form of the kind. BTW, I already hollowed out about half of the inside so no turning back now since there is nothing to design from here on out, it would just be sap wood and a big hole, if I cut the pith out of this design.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#6

Steven Antonucci

Some thoughts

steven antonucci

Nice form.

Now burn it.

Seriously. I would consider torching and wirebrushing it. It will crack some more, but that's OK. If it's blackened by the torch, the cracks sort of "go with it".

I cannot tell from the picture, but it looks like it's about 1/2" thick? Two things you need to remember about hollowforms is that the thicker they are, the more they want to move (and will crack). If the wood is thin, it can move, but does so without having the "strength" to crack the wood around it. I suppose that you could have boiled it after you turned it or alcohol soak. I've done it in the past with some success.

Secondly, hollow turning needs to be a start to finish thing. If you don't get to that finished state in one sitting, assuming the piece hasn't cracked, it has likely gone out of round and you can't make it thinner without risking cutting through anyhow. I suck it up and git 'er done...

Short of the torch work, I would suggest you move on...

Steve

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#7

Re: Need your advise to proceed

John Lucas

I know how hard it is to give up on a piece. Believe Me I've hung in there on way to many. The thing is I always disliked them later because they always look like a piece you tried to save. I'd toss it.

The older and more experienced I get the more I take John Jordan's words to heart. Life's to short to turn Crappy wood.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#8

Re: Need your advise to proceed

Don in Central Illinois

If you really want to 'try'to save it, you could tape it and finish hollowing it out thin. Then you try inlace or something like it after it is dry. I might let it sit around and try later, but it looks pretty bad. Keep it around the shop asca reminder.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#9

Re: Need your advise to proceed

phillip medghalchi

John, i appreciate your advise. I realize that my inexperience led me to that design. I looked at the log and I had the chance to cut it right through the pith and make two nice smaller bowls or maybe platters (well plates, not much dia.) somehow I got suckered to the beautiful purple colors of the growth rings and didn't think with my head instead with my eyes heart, therefore, I am paying the dues like many advanced turners before me. I think at least the pic. of this will remind me to think logical instead of esthetically which can get me in this kind of trouble.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#10

Re: Need your advise to proceed

phillip medghalchi

I think I will do the earlier to see if I can proof myself silly. Although I have gotten good at inlaying, which I have to post what I gave to my mom for her birthday this last march. I have to dig it out of the other comp.

Thank you for the tip.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#11

Another "last ditch" option

mjonesrdg

If you soak that form in a bucket of water, the crack will close up...though not likely all the way tight. You'll have to have a plan for holding the re-hydrated piece in shape, or it will just crack open again. There is now a wet application epoxy (West systems, I think) that will hold, and you can have it shipped while the piece is soaking. CA glue will work sometimes. You might also consider wrapping the piece tightly with strapping tape or similar while the glue and the piece dries.

I have re-hydrated some work in the past, and have had some success with it. It has always been a "last ditch attempt" to save something, and when I felt that I had little to lose. If you try this, I hope that you'll share with us your results. You have done a very nice job with turning a sphere and the work has potential beyond firewood. what you are experiencing, we all have gone through at one time or another.

Good Luck with it!

Mike Jones in Redding, California

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#12

Re: Need your advise to proceed *LINK*

Doc Green

Hey Phillip, by my "standards" that is not a large crack, and if I had considerable work and emotion invested in the piece, I would fill the crack with epoxy and coffee grounds without giving it a second thought.

If you are unsure about the technique, see the article on my website:

www.docgreenwoodturner.com

Cut the splinters, chips, etc., out of the crack so the epoxy will bond to solid wood on both sides of the crack. After filling the bulk of the crack, I would apply thin CA to the lower end of it where the gap is too narrow to force the epoxy mixture into the opening. Also, I would wick thin CA into the other cracks around the vessel to restore some strength even where the cracks have not opened up.

Let the epoxy cure fully before the start turning again. That is, for 5-minute epoxy, let it cure for at least a couple of hours.

When you start turning it again, keep the speed of the lathe on the low side. Also, stop the lathe frequently and examine the crack for any signs of it opening up again. Take your time; light cuts, etc.

I would under no circumstance attempt to use CA glue as the binder for filling the crack. However, you can use sawdust or other material as the filler.

Good Luck! ~Doc


Doc's website

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#13

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Need your advise to proceed

Lyle Jamieson

Phillip, I know your question was what to do now, and you have some good suggestions already. Id like to comment on the "crappy wood" issue. I would bet that the cracks were in the log before you started. Leaving it partly done without putting it in a plastic bag was a mistake for good wood or bad, but my guess is the cracking would have happened no matter how you turned it. With the cracks already in the log the stress of the shrinking wood only opened them up to be more visible. In the roughing out stage take a clean cut and bright light to inspect the end grain for cracks before you invest time and energy in it. It was likely firewood before you started. The stress of the drying tries to squeeze inward around the pith and there is no place for the wood to move so it cracks. Doing hollow forms with the pith in it is problematic but can be done with good wood. Yes, it might still bulge out and crack, usually with one or two cracks that can be converted to a design feature. With good/fresh wood the cracking might stay near the pith and not radiate all the way to the outside of the tree or mouth opining. We get sucked into doing the biggest turning project from a piece of wood when the goal might be to turn the best piece(s) I can get from the wood.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#14

barry rockwell

Re: Need your advise to proceed

Barry Rockwell

Phillip,

Looks like a very pretty piece to me. My solution would probably be to wrap it with strapping tape or shrink wrap, complete the hollowing, sand and finish the inside, true up and clean up the rim. Then remove it from the lathe, hand sand the outside and the bottom, put on whatever finish, drill holes along both sides of the cracks, and "stitch" together with rawhide or sinew. I probably wouldn't even remove all of the tool marks on the outside. I like the "rustic" or "primitive look. I might even add to them.

Good luck.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#15

Great response and I agree


Re: Need your advise to proceed

#16

Re: Need your advise to proceed

robo hippy

Okay, let'e see:

When turning green, finish it and don't leave it on the lathe over night without bagging it with wet shavings and some water added. Just adding the shavings, which begin to lose water as they fly through the air is not enough moisture. Check!

Turning with the pith in is a problem guaranteed to cause cracks. Check!

Always examine closely before you turn, and as you turn for those 'invisible' cracks. Some times you can hear them as you turn. Check!

Turn to final thickness and dry. Fine, but you need to at least wrap the outside, and some times I will actually wet sand it and wrap the outside to help it dry without too much cracking. Check!

Cracked badly. Well, for me, it is too much work to fill all the cracks as in, the hours you spend will not add to the price you can get for it. You could fill and fix all the cracks just for the experience if you want. You could experiment with the soak in 1/2 wood glue and 1/2 water which will cause the wood to expand again, and is supposed to fix the cracks. Might be worth the experimental time. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Check.

Try again. Check!

robo hippy

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#17

Re: Need your advise to proceed

phillip medghalchi

I like to thank each and everyone who answered this thread and I am very lucky to have joined this forum. I appreciate all the tips and for now I think i will wrap it tightly in press & seal wrap and give it few days until i can digest all these tips, then proceed to decide which one of the tips I am going to work with. I think most of you are right about my initial mistake, but I like to try with some of the suggestions here and see what I will learn from it and in the process I will post pictures of it to keep you all in the loops, this way perhaps we all learn something from it. I am also going to log all the steps and time it takes me to get to the final result or the decision.

Again, thanks so much.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#18

Re: Need your advise to proceed

adrien

Interesting.

Why the strong caveat against CA glue for crack repair?

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#19

Phillip- I strongly suggest that you ........

JamieDonaldson

...use a paper bag rather than a plastic one for your temporary storage. The paper moderates moisture exchange with surrounding air, and won't enhance growth of mold and fungus like sealing in plastic. Wood will always move with changing humidity levels, a reason I don't condone filling cracks with anything, and CA glue has very little ability to heal or prevent further cracking.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#20

Re: Need your advise to proceed

Fred Holder

It is possible to fill the cracks with various material, such as: Inlace, sawdust (or some other filler) and CA glue, epoxy, etc. However, before you do those things, I recommend a process that Wally Dickerman posted a few years ago. I tried it and it worked for me on several bowls with good success.

Get some white glue and mix it with an equal part of water so that the bowl is completely submerged, use a rock or something to hold the bowl under the solution. Let it sit for a few days and then take it out. With luck the crack will have closed and the glue will keep it from opening up again.

The first time I tried it was with a 14" maple salad bowl I had rough turned as a house warming gift for a friend. The bowl cracked and was open 1/4" at the rim. I decided to try Wally’s process. I let the bowl soak for about three days and took it out. The crack was still open. I said to myself, “Wally your idea didn’t work.” I threw the bowl out on a pile of lumber in the yard.

About a week later after several days of rain, I walked by the bowl and noticed the crack had completely closed up. I put the bowl in the shed to dry for a few weeks and then final turned it. There was a faint line where the crack had been. It has been about three or four years now and the friend is still using it without the crack ever opening up again. I’ve used this process on several other cracked bowls with good success.

I recommend you try this process first. If that doesn’t work, then fill it with one of the things mentioned.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#21

Re: another  idea

jim 9 miles

If the piece is ruined you have nothing to lose with an experiment.... As mentioned soak it in water.

The crack will probably close completely up. take out and put several metal band clamps around it and let it start drying. Tighten the clamps daily. you may be able to get it to dry without the crack.

If not, nothing lost.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#22

Re: another  idea

Ken Ward

Thats why I don't like turning walnut,it just don't like me >(

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#23

Re: Need your advise to proceed

phillip medghalchi

Latest development on this hollow form is that I filled it with lots of shavings in and buried it in the shavings and put the whole thing in a brown shopping bag. Yesterday, I checked on it and it appears that the large crack is closing down on its own. I stopped hollowing form the last time i posted and have not touched the form yet. So, i keep everyone posted on this form to see what will transpire from all this.

Re: Need your advise to proceed

#24

Latest development

phillip medghalchi

Latest pic.s of what happened to this piece.

Well, I buried the piece in shaving s and put in a brown paper bag and set it aside. A week or so passed by and then i checked it again, and Lon be hold the crack was closing. As you can see little Patience paid off.

Here are the pic.s.




Re: Need your advise to proceed

#25

Users beware, as these cracks are not......

JamieDonaldson

...healing and glueing themselves back together, but preparing booby traps for those trusting souls that put these pieces back on a lathe! >( :\ :b :(