Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Very Large Turnings

Posts

Re: Very Large Turnings

#26

Re: Some questions for Steve

Steve Sinner

David, thanks for your very good questions. You are correct in assuming that welding the outrigger to the bar adds strength and stability. We also use nothing but solid steel bars, which add mass. Mass is an excellent tool to fight vibration. The more mass, the more force is required to get it to shake. An example is my wife's latest washing machine. It weighs over 300 pounds. I'm pretty certain the manufacturer could have built it much lighter, but then it would move around the room when it starts into its high speed drying spin!

As for the torque question, if you can load the bar far enough off center and manage to create sufficient torque to bend a 1" steel bar 22" long, you would have exceeded the torque arresting capacity of the system. I have never managed to do it, even though I do very large vessels of hard woods, sometimes with knots, rocks, or steel cored bullets which tend to provide quite a shock when they encounter the cutter at speed. If a client came to me with an extreme example of using a cutter far off center, we would be able to accomodate that situation by strengthening the trap. The concern would then turn to the post itself. Is a 1" post sufficiently strong enough to remain vertical under the load would be the question.

An additional advantage of welding the outrigger to the bar is that you can swing the bar much farther in the trap, giving you a lot more flexibility to steer the cutter where you wish without changing the setup.

The 1 1/4" bar is approximately 78" long and weighs about 50 pounds. It is bored for 5/8" tools and comes with a brass bushing to allow the use of 1/2" tools. A safety pin is included to prevent the accidental pulling of the bar through the trap. The single portion of the bar is about 14" long. These dimensions are nominal, because when we buy the steel, it comes in "random" 12 foot lengths. Instead of cutting off an extra inch or two and scrapping it, we simply incorporate it into the bar, which results in some small variations in length.

I would argue that the two systems - outrigger offset and outrigger close - use the same principle to arrest torque. The only difference is the distance between contact points on the trap.

Re: Very Large Turnings

#27

Physics

Mike Foster

Steve, I don't usually do large HF's, so dont have a large rig. If I were in the market, yours would probably be the one I chose. I've been following the thread, as it's been interesting and a bit enlightening. I would argue that David has a point, but it may not be significant. There is a lever arm set up by the torque. If you had no trap I think it would be far harder to keep the tool from torquing with your setup as opposed to a D handle due only to the lever arm being so much shorter. It's really simple physics and only makes sense. However, it doesn't really matter, as the trap is more than adequate to limit the torque.

I like the fact that you have much more freedom of movement with your rig, and may consider a bar just for that reason alone.

Re: Very Large Turnings

#28

Steven Antonucci

Physics, sort of...

Steven Antonucci

The amount of torque required to arrest the force of an offset cutter in a hollowing system should never be more than your hands could arrest. The problem with torque is so minimal if the cutter is leveled to the ways and the bar is rigid.

If you think about Lyle's points on vibration being the enemy, two things are candidates for vibrating. First the tool can flex, which can quickly get your cutter somewhere off of the centerline of the vessel, making for a dangerous potential situation. The second situation is that the wood itself can vibrate if your cutter isn't sharp or the turner is pushing too hard. I never use a big cutter when hollowing, as it creates more problems than it solves (more to dull, larger chip, more force applied to cut...)

If your cutter is level and sharp, the purpose of the rear support is to keep it there and to keep you from having to hold a 50# bar level. The Sinner system probably enjoys the additional mass dampening, but I bet you could hand hold the round bar with no torque issues. Torque is a function of the distance from an axis, and with a 1" long cutter, you just don't get that far off center.

Now, come up above that centerline, and you are in a whole different conversation...

Steve

Re: Very Large Turnings

#29

Re: Physics, sort of...

Mike Foster

I agree with you on your points Steve, but I was thinking in terms of a cutter assembly which can be assembled using Lyle's rig with the cutter extending beyound the center of the tool. Depending on the setup, that can be an inch or more. In that situation, torque can beome more of a significant factor that is hard to control by hand held tools. I don't do this much as I try to use tools that keep the cutter in line with the tool handle, but the Jamieson system does allow you to extend the reach using off center cutters. It is nice to have the torque arrestor there in those situations.

Re: Very Large Turnings

#30

Steven Antonucci

Yet another, "whole another thread"

Steven Antonucci

I think a lot of people are mistaken about a whole bunch of "hollowing misconceptions".

The only place you need an offset cutter to reach is a greatly undercut vessel with a small opening. For these vessels, I often undercut them with either thinner bars (1/2") with slightly longer cutters. Once you hit the transition point, you can almost use a straight bar with a straight cutter. Because the top of the vessel is not very far away, the bar doesn't need to be very stout, nor does it need to be "one bar fits every cutting situation".

If you remember this vessel:

It was mostly undercut with a 5/8" bar with a 45 degree 3/16" bit (handheld). When I got to the part where I could no longer reach, I could have added a longer cutter or smaller bar to make up the last 3/8" of reach I needed in that corner. I used a 5/16" bar I have for smaller vessels/openings, and finished the cut...and there is almost no torque. This vessel is about 9" in diameter, or 4.5" undercut...

You can make a swan neck, but I think they are much harder to use because you automatically have a longer overhang and you have to manage the bar in and out of the hole.

Perhaps, someday, i'll shoot some pictures to illustrate...

S

Re: Very Large Turnings

#31

Re: Some questions for Steve

David Walser

Steve - Thank you for answering my questions. You've come up with an interesting design and I wish you continued success.

Re: Very Large Turnings

#32

Re: Physics, sort of...

Steve Sinner

We promote the Munro cutting system. I usually use it set off center to the right, almost never on center. I have two extra links, which can bring the offset up to about 3-4 inches. Still no problems with excess torque. Think of all the turners who use Rolly's tool - with the extra links - by hand. With the stability and power of the boring bar, it is duck soup. As I said before, you would need to apply sufficient torque to bend a 1" steel bar 24" long in order to overpower the torque arresting ability of the trap. Imagine how much weight it would take to bend that bar if it were supported on a couple of bricks. You could stand on the center of it and not see any deflection, no matter how heavy you are.

There is a very good reason why we call the system "high efficiency." You have to experience it to appreciate it.

For example, you can move our 1 1/4" bar in any direction in our setup with just one finger. Can't show that in a photo, either.

Re: Very Large Turnings

#33

Steven Antonucci

No, but you can shoot a video for Youtube 


Re: Very Large Turnings

#34

Re: Very Large Turnings

Lyndal Anthony

Sorry about the blocked email address. I have reset my filter to let more addresses through. If you include your email address in a reply, I will gladly send you an email.

Lyle, you have some very good points about the safety. One thing I have found to counter vibration is to use a smaller diameter cutting, smaller cuts/less tool load, and I turn down the RPM's to reduce sympathetic vibration. I have also found that if the doulbe bar/handle end of the captive bar flexes, it adds vibration. A solution here is to make the handle end larger/stiffer. I agree that vibration is a problem and I strive to cut without vibration, but at this point I am experimenting to see just how far I can hollow without vibration, so I have to go to the point it vibrates and see what is happening. Is it the bar, the handle end, is it flexing my tool rest front or rear, or tool itself? Right now it is trial and error. I've spent a bunch of money making bars, but it sure is interesting.

Re: Very Large Turnings

#35

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Very Large Turnings

Lyle Jamieson

Lyndal, You are right on. Even though I am not a self appointed expert and I am not an engineer, but I play one in the shop, I have done the testing. The smaller cutters are much more efficient. Even the difference between the 3/16 HSS I used to use and a 1/4 HHS is huge. Mike hunter and I worked 8 months trading and testing prototypes of the carbide cutters before we got one I was satisfied with and would be versatile enough to do the shapes and scale of turning I expected. The next thing to consider besides the size of the cutter is its application to the wood surface. When it's the boring bar that is bending to start the vibration it's a must to take efficient cuts. There are some things to help dampen the flex but you reach a point that all humanly things can not stop the bar from vibrating. The only solution is to go to a bigger bar.

When hollowing deeply the entire length of the boring bar and handle will bow in an ark. The tool rest in the middle and the force on the cutter pushing down (assuming you are cutting on the centerline and the cutter is parallel to the floor) will lift the bar and handle up behind the tool test. The trick is to not allow the ark to get large enough so it snaps back trying to get back to straight, thus starting the vibration. I have written about putting some mass or weight just behind the tool rest to resist the bowing effect. I lean my forearm on the handle and add some of my body weight when I get really deep.

You are correct too that the twisting forces are intense in there, as Steve explained too. But I doubt that it is of much influence in the turning world. We would have to be extending out away from axis much farther to make the bar twist and bounce back.

I am thrilled to see you understand these principles. My Dad taught me too well as a kid, to NEVER put myself in the danger zone with any tools. To push that envelope is not worth the risk. We had our local turning meeting this morning and a very experienced woodworker we all respect came in with a bandaged thumb. He shared his LBI moment, (Learn By Injury) and was really lucky that he only nicked his thumb with a table saw. Prevention is 99 percent if the solution, don't put yourself in a place to get hurt.