Wayne I'll let others tell you about brands and such because I haven't kept up with them. I do plan to build my own rig and already have the metal just haven't had the time. I've only done a few turnings that deep and nothing that deep and large in the same breath.
However here's my words of advice. Get a really really big bar. Beyond about 12" or so 3/4" bars aren't big enough. I did manage to get one about 15" deep with a 3/4" bar but it's not worth it. I used one of the older bars sold by Frank Sudol and went 18" deep with no problems. It was almost a pleasure to use compared to the drudgery of trying to go deep with a 3/4" bar. I think his was about 1 1 /2" but don't remember for sure. Not sure who sells those now.
I do know that Lyle Jamieson is selling a much larger bar for big turnings. You would have to write him to find out the limits on his bar.
I have Lyle Jamieson's standard boring bar, but I think it would be a little light weight for what you want to do. I just saw Brian McEvoy demonstrate at the Utah Woodturning Symposium this year. His bar is heavy and suitable for what you want to turn.
Of course, you can make your own. I think that Brian's is fairly reasonable.
I don't think there is any advantage in using O1 instead of 1018, especially if the O1 is in the as supplied (annealed) state.
There might be some slight advantage to using a higher strenth steel in a quenched and tempered condition, but I think that advantage will be more of an increase in the natural frequency that the bar vibrates at, as opposed to the length of bar over the rest before vibration occurs.
Perhaps the easiest material to obtain in a quenched and tempered condition in the size needed would be a 4140 prehard. Cost wise, my guess is that a 1.5" bar of 1018 would be less expensive than a 1.125" bar of 4140 prehard, and my guess performance wise is the 1.5" 1018 would vibrate less at the same extension past the rest.
I have been working with Dennis Gooding on the physics that go into a boring bar. I now has a small variety of home built boring bars and a lot of experience. For what you are doing I recommend a bar at least one inch in diameter like Steve Sinners bar sold through the Sanding Glove (http://www.thesandingglove.com/Advanced-Lathe-Tools-Boring-Bar-Systems.asp). I made mine simi9lar to Steves using 5/8" ID x 1 1/4" OD tubing, but you can also use 1 0r 1 1/4" schedule 80 or schedule 160 tubing. It is important to leave the handle end long and heavy enough to give yourself enough leveragbe to keep the bar down on both ends at the same time. I like the "handle" end to be bigger and heavier to keep it planted firmly. (My big bar: front 3" schedule 80 tubing five feet long and the handle end is 3 1/2" schedule 80 tubing eight feet long. With this setup I can bore five feet deep, but the opening has to be 4" in diamter. I am finishing an article for American Woodturning Magazine with more information and charts on this subject.
You are treading into dangerous waters. Some of the hollowing systems available can hurt you. And trial and error of making home built systems could be problematic too when you get that big. If you error with a piece of wood that weighs 100 pounds you can get in trouble in a split second. The system must be strong both in front and behind the tool rest. The system must have the reach capabilities to do the bulbous shapes you describe. If you are going to make your own call me and I can help you choose the correct materials to do it safely. I was at SWAT as a vendor and I had to move away from my booth in fear because a fellow vendor was doing something that I did not want to be in the same room with him. One of the other guys said he was going to trip the breaker and cut the elect to his lathe so nobody gets hurt. Be careful when you get in that scale.
You might look on YouTube for several videos done by the late Elmer Adams, a very well known turner in Hawaii. He did huge pieces in beautiful Hawaiian woods up to 4 ft deep and 2 ft wide. Equipment not real high tech, but every effective.
Might also look up Virgil Leih, a Minnesota turner who does huge work. He needs a fork lift to load logs on an old 16-foot Oliver lathe he uses.
My home made system works very well. It really isn't a matter of high tech, but low tech, common sense and sound welding. Yes, it can be dangerous, but done correctly, it works well. You can call me @ 563-599-8042 or email: ImLyndal@aol.com. I am not out to make any money/profit. I am just finding out what does work. I've talked to some of the people doing deep hollowing and have worked with an engineer on the physics..........
I've hollowed to a dept of 33" over the the rest using the 1 1/4" boring bar from Adavance Lathe Tools and felt completely comfortable & safe, while using the Rolly Munro cutter that has a controlled cutting depth
Here's the bowl that Stuart Mortimer and Steve Blenk turned at our American Woodworker Shows, back in the late 90s. It actually got a Guinness Book of Records listing as the largest turned bowl on record at the time. (I am sure somebody has surpassed it by now.) The bowl is 7'-9" in diameter and over four feet tall. It started as a giant Sitka spruce tree near Gold Beach, OR. The bowl blank alone weighed over 5600 lbs and took two Hysters to get it off the flatbed trailer that carried it from Oregon to Pennsylvania.
Stuart and Steve turned it on a Highlander lathe from Scotland, over the course of three weekend shows. I actually had a brief turn, and what a thrill! The lathe was only spinning at about 20 rpm, but that was plenty to get a feel for the power of that size bowl blank. The main tool was a ring tool with limiter. It had about afive foot handle and a three foot shank about 1 1/2" in diameter, with about a 1" ring. The shavings flew like 20' strands of spaghetti about an inch wide.
In the photo are some well known faces: Andy Rae, Groucho Marx, Stuart Mortimer, Frank Klausz and Steve Shanesy. I am not sure where the bowl is today, but it sure was a fun project.
Sorry Joe but I have to set the record straight. You might feel comfortable and safe doing 33 inches deep using a 1 1/4 bar but there is no boring bar in the world that will do that WITHOUT VIBRATION. A 2 inch diameter bar would be at its limit around 30 inches. The only way to make it work would be to have a internal tool rest so the bar is not dangling out so far off the tool rest. In my opinion I do not want to exceed the limits of my boring bar and have it bend/flex/vibrate. You might get lucky for a while but when you are working with heavy wood something very bad can happen if vibration exists. The Rolly cutter will prevent you from getting a catch but it will contribute to the vibration issue. I know...there are famous turners doing it, but that does not make it safe or smart.
Contact Brian McEvoy in at onegoodturn.ca (email brian@onegoodturn.ca) for advise. He often hollows to 36" with a boring bar rig. Wood choice and condition are another ingredient to the mix.
Lyle, you should be very careful about making comments about something which is outside of your personal experience and knowledge.
When and where did you use my 1 1/4" system?
And would you care to explain exactly what danger you found?
Perhaps yours would be dangerous at 33" (I'll take your word for that - you should know), but mine certainly is not, which has been proven again and again over the years.
Lyle, I agree with Steve. You better be careful about being a self appointed expert.
Do you have an engineering degree? I have been working with an engineer on my boring bar research. I have used my 1 1/4" boring bar and have hollowed to about 30 some inches deep. I do prefer my 2" boring bar when going beyond 24" though. I have gone 48" deep with my 3" bar, and I think it is capable of going about 55" deep, but I haven't quite been able to test it yet because my 16" bed extension on my Powermatic 3520 han't allowed me to test that yet. I do know from experience that the bigger, deeper you go, the smaller cuts you have to take. It is time consuming, but it is a must.
Sorry to step on your toes. But you and Steve are missing two of my words, "without vibration". And I will stand by the statement that there is no way a single 1 1/4" bar will go 33 inches deep unsupported without vibration. Steve has a twin bar welded together that can go deeper and I have not tested that. YOU might be able to force the boring bars beyond the vibration point with your experience and skills but to suggest anybody can do it is a stretch. In my opinion that is dangerous. The vibration can loosen or release the chucking method, loosen the steady rest adjustments, or blow the piece up with a thin wall spot in there for a weak point. And what about the undetected flaw in the wood like a crack or bark inclusion?? I have used boring bars up to 4 inches in diameter and 12 feet long and I have tested every available size and configuration. Life's too short to put yourself in danger. I don't take a 1700 pound piece of wood lightly. I am not suggesting that I am an expert, I want the truth to be known. I have always said there are many ways to skin this cat and there is rarely a right and wrong, just different. They are different for many reasons. I choose to hollow without vibration because it is a safety issue for me. Others can use any method they prefer. There have been some famous turners seriously injured from no fault of their own and our turning family has lost two experienced turners recently to turning accidents. I don't want to read any more obits.
I'll be teaching my method of high efficiency deep hollowing at Marc Adams School of Woodworking in October. We will cover how to deal with vibration that is a part of any hollowing system. And when it is a problem and when it is not. With my system and my tools, there is absolutly no danger from loosening the support system or the mounting. I have completed well over 500 deep hollow vessels, and have never loosened a single part of the setup due to vibration.
Thanks to harmonics, vibration will happen at certain points, and it does not have to be when you are deeply into a vessel. Simply changing the relationships of the supports will correct it.
I've looked at your boring bar system on both your website and on The Sanding Glove's. I cannot tell from the photographs, how long is the 1.25" bar and how far does the single bar extend beyond the double bar?
Yours is an interesting design. The double bar would appear to do a better job of stiffing the boring bar (reducing vibration) compared to the traditional "D-handle" design. On the other hand, the double bar arrangement would appear to do less to combat rotational forces (the desire the bar has to twist in the direction of the lathe's rotation). A traditional D-handle boring has a wider base than does your double bar design. This gives the D-handle the leverage necessary to resist the rotational forces. Your design appears to rely less on leverage and more on the brute force of the two bars being trapped by the rear tool rest's cage.
Of course, these are just theoretical musings on my part. I'd love to be able to test those theories out in practice.