Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Dust collection

Posts

Dust collection

#1

Dust collection

Jeff Brockett

I am getting ready to take the plunge and invest in a cyclone dust collection system for my 900 square foot shop. I figure that 40 feet is the longest run that I will need and there will be 7 drops. After a lot of research I have discovered several things:

1. with dust collection bigger is better

2. lots of opinions about the different systems

3. metal ductwork is the way to go

4. prices are all over the board

One thing that I was surprised about was that one of the bigger players in dust collection systems was not highly rated by several people who had purchased units from them. Interested to see what others thoughts are.

Re: Dust collection

#2

Size & Money

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Size does matter here. The amount of air moved through a 6" system is significant compared to 4". You can have two 4" gates open and still get full flow through both of them, so long as your air handler (the blower) uses a 6" or better intake. Remember to gate each drop.

On the money side, putting metal ducting in a 900 sq/ft shop is, IMHO, a big waste of money. 6" S&D PVC is fine and much quieter to boot. Tape rather than glue your joints to provide easy access in case the shop cat gets sucked up a pipe. Ignore the BS about static charges etm. If your air handler is sized and properly rated, the duct will be clean.

There are those here who have put in system with automatic/remote controlled blast gate. I've never had the need for them.

Can't speak to the cyclones, and I don't have the space for one.

hth

Re: Dust collection

#3

Re: Dust collection

robo hippy

I have Oneida. Excellent tool, and a 3 hp system which will allow me to run 2 machines at once and still have good volume/air flow. Oh yea, I have a 24 X 36 shop. The Clear View was not in existence when I got my Oneida. They deserve a good look as well. Pleated paper filters = much more venting area for the air that comes through your system than cloth bags. Have the remote on/off switches (I think it is Lone Ranger) which uses FM frequency rather than infared where you have to point at the receiver. Have 2 of them. The one in the turning area goes on a hook or other 'permanent' position so it doesn't vanish with the shavings. I think I could have kept all my drop downs at 6 inches rather than stepping down to 5, like was recommended by Oneida, and may change it eventually, but it works fine as is.

robo hippy

Re: Dust collection

#4

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Dust collection

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Jeff, bigger is not necessarily better in the case of the ducts. You need to maintain a minimum air speed in the ducts to keep dust from settling and eventually plugging the ducts. The optimum sizes depend on the airflow capacity of the blower and the length of the runs. It has been several years since I designed my system and I have forgotten the details. Do a Google on dust collector design and you should find design information. Also, one of the dust collector system vendors used to offer free engineering design if you buy some of your materials from them.

Dennis

Re: Dust collection

#5

Bob Moffett

Re: Dust collection

Bob Moffett

I have a 2 hp Onieda cyclone system with metal ducts. My shop is about 15' X 24'. I used the metal ducts because my shop is in my basement and some may think plastic pipe is just as good, and they may be correct, but, since it was under my house, I didn't want to take any chances with sparks and fire. I though it was better to over react than to wish I had as my house was burning. I had Onieda design my ductwork for me and then I added some more ducts. In retrospect, I wish I had added a duct to hook up to a vacuum hose for sweeping the floor.

Re: Dust collection

#6

Re: Dust collection

Tom in Alaska

I am also looking into dust collection systems. I have a question or you: Are you interested in picking up cuttings from machines or are you looking at capturing dust from sanding?

For me it is the latter.

I have a unit on my ceiling by Jet that I run when sanding, however that does not intercept the dust early enough. I still get dust on most other things in the shop (2 car garage that has not seen a car since we moved in). I think I need to install a larger dust collector to get the air close to the back of the lathe when sanding. I really don’t care about the dust from the band saw, drill press or the chips from the lathe, but I suppose I would attach a fitting to the band saw if I got a system.

I had a system about 20 years ago and I found that static electricity was a bigger deal than I imagined. When I finally get around to installing something, I will install a grounding wire if I go with plastic or flex ducting.

Re: Dust collection

#7

Ground

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Tom,

PVC is an insulator. It is physically impossible to ground it. But not to worry.

While the action of charged cellulose dust (it's your saw blades that create the static charge) can impute some charge to PVC (or metal) piping, even enough to cause a spark, the potential of the charge is quite low in a residential setting where the DC is not running continuously for 12-18 hours straight. It will not be nearly enough to cause a spark that is hot enough to ignite wood dust in the right atmospheric density. Not only is the spake not hot enough, but also the amount of fine dust in the air inside your ducts will not be enough to cause a fire. The very few documented dust collector fires have been caused by hot embers coming off the blade or hot metal sparks from nails in the wood being cut getting sucked up the piping, landing in the bag, and being fanned to life in the airflow.

Re: Dust collection

#8

Dick Hines

Re: Ground

dick hines

I have had a Griz for years and it does a fairtley good job of removing sanding dust. I have come to the to understand that you can never collect ALL the dust. The one worse tool in your shop is the bandsaw. I don't care what I do I still can'collect all the dust from it.

Re: Dust collection

#9

Yes, a static explosion in your .......

JamieDonaldson

...PVC ductwork is one of the all time urban shop myths! During some dry weather periods the humidity will be low enough to cause a static build-up sufficient to hold dust in/on the pipe, but there is not the dust concentration, compression, static discharge, etc. to create combustion unless volatile fumes are added to the mixture. Here is the hood that sits right behind the working area of my lathe, made from inexpensive heating/cooling ductwork collector boxes. The Long Ranger remote on/off gadget is one of the all time great inventions!

Re: Dust collection

#10

Chuck Jones - West TN

Re: Dust collection

Chuck Jones - West TN

I have a combination of metal and flexible plastic duct. I used sheet metal screws to fasten the metal sections together. That has been a source of problems. A few times shavings from my planer and lathe have caught on the screws and caused obstruction. There is probably a better solution to fastening the pipe.

When I installed my system several years ago, like a dumbass I fell for the static problem and ran a ground wire inside the entire duct work system. That really caused some obstruction problems until I ripped all the wire out. While I now subscribe to the "Urban Myth" label about static and fire, I must admit a lot of static accumulates in the flexible plastic pipe. Enough to make all 187 hairs on the top of my head stand up when I walk under it.

Actually, I do not use my system much except on a couple tools where it is necessary to clear the shavings (planer and joiner/planer). Mine exhausts out into the woods and really sucks out the cooled or warmed air. Since I haven't been able to eliminate all the dust I find my Air Shield Pro to be better protection for my lungs. My wife keeps an absurdly clean house so I find a dirty shop to be a welcome counter balance.

Re: Dust collection

#11

Re: Ground

waltben

Grounded mine, but not because of fire potential. I just hate getting zapped every time I get use my 'vacuum cleaner' in the winter!

Re: Dust collection

#12

Re: Dust collection

Ray - Middletown, in

I took out metal and put in pvc. I was using an underpowered cyclone and thought the pvc would have fewer leaks. Still underpowered so I doubt it helped much. Just picked up a 3 hp dual bag collector and hooked it up without the cyclone. If you make it up to IndyFest you can check out what I did.

Ray

Re: Dust collection

#13

Brian McKearney

Re: Dust collection

Brian McKearney

At the beginning of the summer, I installed an Oneida 3HP Pro-1500 with 6" metal ductwork. My longest run is approximately 30 feet. I'm very pleased with it and it has very good suction.

Aside from the cyclone and ductwork, you will also need to consider individual tool hookups. I purchased an Excalibur overarm blade guard (ceiling mount version, which is about half the cost of the boom version) for my table saw. I'm still working on my miter saw, but I currently have a homemade collection hood that is collecting the majority of the dust. At the lathe, I'm mostly interested in collecting dust (not shavings), so I use a 2'-3' length of Loc-Line.

Brian