I have a request to make some "dowels" from heart wood pine. These will be between 16 and 24" long. and either 1/2" - 3/4" thick.
Not being a spindle turner (or much of a bowl turner, but at least I have some practice there) - I am seeking the sage advice of WC.
- For a 3/4" finished size dowel - what dimension blank would you want to start with?
- Are there 'rules of thumb' for when material gets "whippy"? If so would you expect these dowels to be whippy?
- My tool rest is the standard part for a Nova 3000 - I would guess 10-12" long. How much difference would a 24" tool rest make - given that I'd expect to need to use a support to control whippy materials (depends on answer to Q2 above)?
- Given that I need to make 40, and that I am not an experienced spindle turner - how many pieces do you think i should plan to start with? I do not know the tolerances but I do know the application; I do not think that the tolerances would be very tight - i.e. +/- 20% in diameter.
- Given a quantity of 40, how long would you expect it to take YOU to turn (per piece), starting with a square blank?
Henry, it is actually easier to make dowels of uniform size by drilling an appropriately sized hole through a steel plate and driving riven/split straight grained stock through the hole with a mallet.
You can actually buy these plates commercially from a variety of sources but I have not seen any offered that were 3/4".
You can also make them on the router table by cutting square stock to the correct size and using a round over bit. Leave part of both ends square and round over one side at a time.
Trying to drive a 24" long 1/2" dowel through a sizing plate would be like the proverbial noodle and wild cat situation. Both of these would be nearly impossible to turn on the lathe as well. A router setup, or the dowel maker from Lee Valley is the way to go. The dowel maker uses two plane blades, one to rough, one to size. Kinda pricey, but works great!
I think you will find it a challenge to turn these on the lathe. Very good spindle turning skills I think would be required to deal with the whip and obtaining uniformity. I would look at the other options mentioned above.
There is a jig that makes it pretty simple. I may still have mine but if not I'll try to find it in one of my router books. I used to make all my dowels for inserting contrasting pins in wood because store bought dowels were often oval and of course don't come in exotic woods.
I should have mentioned it can be done in the shorter lengths but will still be quite a problem with spindle whip as some have mentioned above.
There is also a dowel making plane that you can build if you have those skills. Roy Underhill shows how in one of his books I think. I know he did it on one episode.
What I would do is suck in my gut, throw out my chest, and turn 'em! Doing so would keep me from having to fiddle with a router (which can sometimes produce tearout, which will have to be sanded away) or deal with the uncertainties of trying to drive the blanks through a dowel plate. And it will be good practice. By the time you get 40 of them done, you will be pretty good at it and be much wiser toward the end.
I think one-inch-square blanks would be good for finished 3/4" dowels. The uncertainty here will arise from the difficulty in locating the center and getting a point center to seat at the marked center without being deflected by the grain of the wood. I would cut the blanks about an inch longer than the final length and cut to length after the turning is done.
If it takes between 10 and 15 minutes per dowel, times 40 results in between 7 and 10 hours at the lathe. Once you get into the swing of it, it may go faster. You will be there for a while.
With a 3/4" dowel 24" long, I would hope that whipping would not be a serious problem, or at least would be a problem that could not be dealt with. (that is, slow the speed down to about 2,000 RPM and use your left hand to steady the blank, etc.)
I would use a 3/4" open-end wrench as a gauge for the diameter, being careful not to force it onto the wood.
Chucking: I would do it in two steps. First, mount the blank between centers. Knock off the corners and turn a tenon on one end. Second, mount the blank between a scroll chuck (or collet chuck) and the point center at the tailstock to do the rest of the turning. By using the chuck, you can reduce the pressure exerted by the tail center, which will make the blank less likely to bow in the middle and whip.
Turning tools: First, true up the blank and work toward the final diameter with a spindle roughing gouge. Then, I would use either the bottom wing of a bowl gouge or a scraper, both in the shear-scraping mode, to work closer to the final diameter (check with the wrench) and strive for uniformity along the length.
Sanding: I would depend on sanding with a sanding block (board) to give the final uniform diameter and remove any tool marks. Wrap a sheet (or part of a sheet) of 100-grit paper around a 1x4 board, etc. ... For the final sanding with higher grits, I would not use the board.
Cut to length using whatever saw you prefer: table saw, chop saw, radial arm, bandsaw, etc.
To get started, I would cut only a couple of blanks and go through the procedure to see if any problems arise. I would try turning one all the way between centers (as opposed to using the chuck) to see if whipping is a problem (with the extra compression required to keep the blank firmly seated against the drive center). Once the process is established, I would do the various operations in batches.
I think a 1/2" or 5/8" stebcenter would be ideal for the drive center, as opposed to a spur drive.
And that's about it. Of course, there are at least a thousand possible variations on these suggestions, so you can use the methods you prefer. Good luck! Think of it as "going to school."
You are right Dick. I completely lost sight of the 24" dimension.
Although I have seen Roy Underhill drive pretty long riven splits through his homemade plate. I guess success would depend on how straight grained the wood is....
In my experience a scraper increases the whipping problems. Could just be me. When I taught a class in stool making spindle whip was a major problem for everyone and the thinnest part of the leg was 3/4. It would have been much worse to turn the whole thing 3/4". I may give it a try this morning before I start the cutting of my next ring for the lamp. My students were turning 22" legs and having one heck of a time. We went to 14" legs and even though they still had whip problems it was much less.
I believe you can do the whole spindle with the spindle roughing gouge. Start in the normal fashion and then when you get close to the correct size us one of the "wings" like a skew and clean it up. I'll post my rough out gouge video below.
I still think the router is the way to go. I did lots of dowels this way. It takes one or two to get the size right and you do have to start with wood that is good and square. You would also have to either turn a tenon that would fit your drill or glue in a dowel.
For those not familiar with this technique you take a square piece of wood slightly larger than the dowel you need. One end goes in a hand drill and the other end goes into a hole in the router jig that just fits the square wood. This is pushed through as it spins and goes past the router bit which cuts it to size. There is a 3/4" hole in the other side of the jig that accepts the dowel and hold it steady. There's usually some chatter and/or slightly off size to the first inch or so of the dowel but once it's steadied by the outer guide hole the only thing you have to do is not feed the dowel too fast which produces a screw thread instead of flat dowel.
There is another solution that my dad who is not a good turner uses. He turns them close to size and used a belt sander to get rid of the whip marks. I have tried using a small hand plane with the lathe running to get large flat areas really flat without whip and it does work but if you have some bad grain in the dowel it will tear it out badly.
I just typed a very long response. There was a flicker and it went away. Now I will go for the edited version.
I would try the router set up mentioned above. You don't tell us what these are for and how accurate they must be. Or what tools you have. I think the learning curve and set up time for the lathe would be much steeper than for the router. If I were doing them on the router, I would start with blanks that are about a hundredth of an inch over sized.
If I were doing them on the lathe I would make a "cup" center for the tail stock. The cup would be square and sized to receive the stock. This would avoid all the problems with centering the stock. I think you can do the 3/4 ones pretty easily, but the thinner ones will want a steady rest for the center. I would make one with a "wheel" to fit the stock with the square hole in it. If you do, you might as well do it for both sizes. Drive them with a chuck and you don't have to center that head end either or put any pressure on them that would increase whip.
One more note. I made a piece of furniture out of heart pine. Sand paper life was measured in seconds. Very pitchy and clogged in nothing flat. Use sandpaper that is water proof and you can wash it by soaking it in Simple Green and water. I cleaned some of the belts for my Performax twenty or more times.
I would make them on the router table and spin them on the lathe to lightly sand them.
OK I gave it a try. 18" x 1" maple but square. I tried faster speeds and slower speeds. Here's what I learned (or relearned). The slower speeds work better to a point. You don't burn your fingers as easily but you have to go painfully slow with the gouge which makes it very easy to apply too much pressure and you get a catch. You get a catch because the wood grabs the cutting edge and pulls itself into the wood from the flex. Very hard to avoid in the middle.
The faster speed let me move the tool at a more comfortable and smoother rate but required a very light touch with the tool and my fingers and It was hard not to burn my fingers.
Smaller tools such as my 3/8" detail gouge don't flex the wood as bad (probably because of the smaller cut) and don't cause the chatter as much but it's very difficult to get a long flowing straight line which is of course what your after.
The skew seemed to require more finger pressure to steady. Although the cut is smoother in terms of being a straight line it was more difficult to keep the chatter down than the Spindle Roughing Gouge.
As you can see in the photo below the round nose scraper produced the most chatter (the area to the right of the tearout) It was also the hardest to get a really flat straight area. A flat scraper didn't work very well because the corners would catch but you could grind a slight convex which might help. Still when I tried the Easywoodtool which is convex the chatter was far worse.
Is short, the spindle roughing gouge worked the best for me but when you get to the middle areas you have to go extremely slow with very very light cuts and even then I got 2 catches which basically ruined this dowel.
I could get better after 5 or 6, I haven't done this long and thin in a while but think what a challenge this would be for a turner with less experience.
By the way in my experience the steb centers produce more chatter due to the pressure from the spring in the center point. I prefer a 4 prong center that is either driven in or has saw cut marks for the teeth to grab. It lets you reduce the pressure of the tailstock and still drive the spindle with the least amount of pressure and seems to reduce the flex and chatter.
I think the Steb Center is a wonderful drive center for larger shorter work but not the best for long thin pieces.
I just gave it a try. Ripped a 3/4" square blank off a poplar board, 24" long. Mounted it between centers, then installed it between a chuck and point center.
My first thought: Wow, that is Long! Made an attempt to turn it to a dowel 1/2" in diameter ... to impress John. Didn't work.
When I got the diameter down to about 5/8", the whipping became severe near the center of the piece. I tried a gouge in a traditional cut, a gouge as a shear scraper, a round-nose scraper in the shear-scraping mode, and a skew. Each tool produced a similar result: whipping that gave rise to a rough, spiral pattern near the center of the blank.
I had no problem as long as I was working only 6 to 8" from either end of the blank.
Even though I was trying to take the diameter down to less than 3/4", I now believe that a small steady rest will be required to prevent the whipping, even for a 3/4" dowel. That is, treat the dowel as if it were a trembleur.
I was not able to prevent the whipping by holding my hand/fingers against the piece.
1.) If I had to make that many, I would most likely not turn them, but make a drive plate
2.) If I was bent on turning them, I would make a steady rest at the tailstock end and work back toward the headstock in a chuck. Between centers might seem like a good idea, but it isn't at that diameter. Without boring you to death on the civil engineer of a chucked load point at the headstock vs. a point center, let's just agree that the chuck is better?
3.) If the headstock was hollow and could support the finished diameter passing through it, I might skip the steady rest and make a simple wooden collet in my chuck and just feed the finished diameter into the headstock. You could probably work 6" at a time per dowel.
That's cool I wish he had shown a close up of the various holes in the metal. Obviously the small holes from the cutters and the large hole is the guide.
Lan A chuck on both sides works for larger dowels. I tried them for small dowels and the weight of the free spinning chuck will twist the smaller dowels in half. What is really needed is a way to drive both chucks together and then put a pulling force on the dowel. Haven't tried to do that yet.
Doc I went back out and tried other tools, sharper angled skews and smaller gouges. A more skew angle to the cut seems to help keep the wood from pulling itself into the cutter but it still happens. I don't have a steady rest to try but may see if I can find something around the shop that can be modified.
LOL, I think that is the definition of an Oximoran-- when a man turns captured ring goblets that will stand on the side of a nickel, refers to 3/4" dowels as being small.
Thanks John , I agree that the method does not work on smaller dowels, but it makes great walking sticks for 5 wounded warriors.
That guy is just begging to loose some fingers. Drilling steel with that size of bit, and not holding the steel with a vise is more than an accident waiting to happen. He will soon be called "Lefty" with that kind of safety attitude.