Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Scrapers Revisited.....

Posts

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#26

Let's see now, you're using ........

JamieDonaldson

...left handed scrapers when the lathe is correctly rotating anti-clockwise, so you would need right handed scrapers when the rotation is backwards or clockwise! :b

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#27

Leo Cuellar

Re: Let's see now, you're using ........

Leo Cuellar

It would be easier with a gouge because then you just get to use that other edge that always gets sharpened but never taken to the dance. :)

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#28

Re: Let's see now, you're using ........

robo hippy

I had to think about this for a bit. I never considered inside/outside/swept to the left/swept to the right scrapers. A round nose will do it all.

As for the tiny tear out that you can't see, or can barely see, but can feel, as long as you are turning flat grain/face plate/bowl orientation, if you reverse, then you will get the same tear out, except it will be on the opposite sides from where it was when you reverses. It seems to me that there is always some, even in the cleanest cutting woods, no matter which tool you use, how sharp it is, how light the cut is, or how high of a shear angle you are using. For 2 quarters of the bowl, you are cutting down hill with the grain, and for the other 2 quarters, you are cutting up hill against the grain. Cutting against the grain will always leave some tear out.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#29

Re: Let's see now, you're using ........

robo hippy

I guess I should add bevel rubbing here. I experimented with an old punky piece of Big Leaf Maple. Nasty stuff with grain going every which way, and used every tool in the shop to see which would give the best cuts. High shear angle was best, along with rubbing the bevel. I think the idea is that the bevel actually holds the fibers down while the cutting edge lifts them up. With no bevel rubbing (often called shear scrape), you do not get as clean of a cut.The difference is minimal in wet even grained wood like Madrone. The difference is pretty big in dry wild grained punky wood. The high shear angle helps kind of like hitting speed bumps at an angle. Straight on (scraping cut), it is a big bump. At an angle, the bump stretches way out, so the bump is much more gradual (shear cut).

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#30

Leo Cuellar

Re: Let's see now, you're using ........

Leo Cuellar

I found out pretty much the same thing... with a spalted piece of big leaf maple. The only advantage I've discovered to running something backwards, is if you get a "fringe" on the leading edge of a void, then you can turn that off, but that's about it. Except for a couple of swept edge scrapers most of mine would work either way. Now its back out for lots more practice, I'm almost ready to try working on burls without butchering them.

Thanks for your thoughts!!!