Scrapers Revisited.....
Mike Stafford
The July issue of Woodturning magazine has a very interesting article regarding sharpening scrapers and polishing the top surface of scrapers. The article is by Alan Lacer and Jerry Wright and contains some wonderful close up photographs of surfaces cut by scrapers following various sharpening and polishing regimens.
To directly quote from the articleon page 26:
1. Wheel grit has little effect upon the quality of the burr and the cut wood surface.
2. Heavy or light pressure applied to the tool during grinding has little effect upon the burr formed.
3. Polishing the top of the tool following grinding, then using a burnished burr as an alternative to the ground one has a dramatic effect upon the burr formed and the quality of the cut wood surface.
4. A polished top surface combined with a burnished edge produces a consistent cut wood surface quality.
5. A scraper presented in a shear cut orientation produces a much better cut surface than the same scraper which presented flat.
I think that the polished top of the scraper has much the same effect and for the same reasons a woodworker polishes the back of his plane blade to the same degree of fineness as the edge. The edge will be sharper and more uniform when the two surfaces have equal size scratches. On the 1/2" square scraper I use to cut flanges on my boxes the top and the slightly beveled left side are both polished to a near mirror finish and the intersection between the two is almost razor sharp which allows me to cleanly cut the wood and eliminate sanding and tearout.
My experience has been that the polished scrapers give me better results. I use a Veritas jig to get a uniform burr and touch it up periodically with my fine diamond hone. Both my end grain and cross grain work have dramatically improved since I started polishing the tops of my scrapers.
Not trying to re-ignite the argument but just presenting information that makes the argument better than I did in the first discussion.
As with all other things your experience and opinions may vary. As my dearly departed father-in-law used to say, "That is why they make chocolate and vanilla." 




