Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Scrapers Revisited.....

Posts

Scrapers Revisited.....

#1

Mike Stafford

Scrapers Revisited.....

Mike Stafford

The July issue of Woodturning magazine has a very interesting article regarding sharpening scrapers and polishing the top surface of scrapers. The article is by Alan Lacer and Jerry Wright and contains some wonderful close up photographs of surfaces cut by scrapers following various sharpening and polishing regimens.

To directly quote from the articleon page 26:

1. Wheel grit has little effect upon the quality of the burr and the cut wood surface.

2. Heavy or light pressure applied to the tool during grinding has little effect upon the burr formed.

3. Polishing the top of the tool following grinding, then using a burnished burr as an alternative to the ground one has a dramatic effect upon the burr formed and the quality of the cut wood surface.

4. A polished top surface combined with a burnished edge produces a consistent cut wood surface quality.

5. A scraper presented in a shear cut orientation produces a much better cut surface than the same scraper which presented flat.

I think that the polished top of the scraper has much the same effect and for the same reasons a woodworker polishes the back of his plane blade to the same degree of fineness as the edge. The edge will be sharper and more uniform when the two surfaces have equal size scratches. On the 1/2" square scraper I use to cut flanges on my boxes the top and the slightly beveled left side are both polished to a near mirror finish and the intersection between the two is almost razor sharp which allows me to cleanly cut the wood and eliminate sanding and tearout.

My experience has been that the polished scrapers give me better results. I use a Veritas jig to get a uniform burr and touch it up periodically with my fine diamond hone. Both my end grain and cross grain work have dramatically improved since I started polishing the tops of my scrapers.

Not trying to re-ignite the argument but just presenting information that makes the argument better than I did in the first discussion.

As with all other things your experience and opinions may vary. As my dearly departed father-in-law used to say, "That is why they make chocolate and vanilla." :D

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#2

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

Dale Miner

Wise man that father in law of yours.

I like both. Two scoops more so than one.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#3

The burr created by the grinder.........

JamieDonaldson

....wheel is rolled back, irregular and brittle at the edge, unlike the more uniform burr that is raised by burnishing the edge of a polished surface. As with cabinet scrapers, the aggressiveness of a burnished edge can be more evenly created than a course ground edge rolled by the grinder, and when used in a shearing position a more clean cut results from the sharper edge.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: The burr created by the grinder.........

Mike Stafford

Jamie, the article has pictures which are very telling. In the photos you can see the difference in the edge of a polished scraper vs. the edge of one straight from the manufacturer. There are also photos showing shear scraped vs. conventional scraped wood surfaces for each of the various sharpening techniques.

I thought it was a timely article since we just had a long discussion here on WC about the same thing.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#5

Steven Antonucci

Polishing.

Steven Antonucci

Every tool in your kit will benefit from polishing the two surfaces that make up the cutting edge. I start a discussion on scraping with a piece of automotive wet dry paper on a flat surface to show exactly how easy it is to polish the top of the scraper to a mirror finish. I bet it takes less than 5 minutes to go from 400 to 1200 grit, and you can see your face in it. Makes no sense to do more than an inch of the tool, which should last you 10 years.

One pass on the grinder to from time to time, but most of the time, I lap off the burr with a diamond hone and then use the diamond hone to cut/burnish the new burr. It gives me 2 intersecting, polished surfaces and a very fine hook that lasts a long time (way longer than a grinding burr...)

S

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#6

Aage Rendalen

What about thickness of scraper?

Aage Rendalen

How does the thickness of a scraper affect the grind and the surface of the wood?

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: What about thickness of scraper?

Mike Stafford

I don't know exactly how to answer that question. The scrapers I use most frequently are 1/4" thick but for some operations I use scrapers as thick as 1/2". I treat them all the same with respect to grinds, polishing and burnishing.

It is the edge that is created on the tool regardless of the thickness that matters for me. The thicker steel only allows me to reach deeper into a piece or work farther off the rest without vibration. I polish the tops of all of my scrapers now after sharpening and burnish a slight burr.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#8

Steven Antonucci

I think there is such a thing as "too thick"?

Steven Antonucci

For the way that I use a scraper, I prefer a thinner edge. One of my best tools is a Sorby teardrop cutter mounted on a 5/8" round bar. It gives me the thin edge with the support behind it. I liken it to relieving the heel on a bowl gouge.

I also like the round bar because it moves across the tool rest much easier and it feels the same flat as it does in shear and everywhere between. Frankly, I am surprised that nobody is making a scraper like this except Sorby?

Steve

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#9

Re: Polishing.

dick gerard

IMHO, you should also polish the flute of turning gouges, whether spindle or bowl gouge types. The cutting edge is noticably "sharper".

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#10

They do, but better

Carole Valentine

The Multi-Axis scraper from Kelton Ind. is the only scraper I use any more unless I need a scraper with a very small head to fit into a form with a small opening. I used to use the Sorby multi-tip, but it has lost it's spot on the tool rack to the Multi-Axis.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: Polishing.

Mike Stafford

Dick, I am sure you are right. Good point. I hone the inside of the flute with a slip stone but I don't think that the flute is as polished as the tops of my scrapers.

Before I got a couple of different sizes of slip stones I use to wrap fine wet/dry paper around appropriately sized dowels and touchup that way. Maybe I should go back to that method and polish the flutes.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#12

Leo Cuellar

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

Leo Cuellar

Thank you for posting this, Mike. The input from everybody really made a difference in the quality of my surfaces. The problem that I had, was too much burr & not enough control. Using a scraper that has been burnished with red rouge, top first and then the bevel combined with finally understanding the concept of shear scraping has really got me revved up! Learning to make delicate cuts in that fashion has given me better control of my gouge and skew as well.

Up until last week I routinely had to start sanding at 180#. Now, I begin at 320# to 400#. It is all because all of you are so willing to share what you know & are so patient with my stoopid newbie questions! :D

Leo

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#13

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

robo hippy

Well, a couple of things here, from a dedicated scraper user.

I have always polished the tops of my scrapers. Mostly to remove the old grinder burr before putting a new one on.

There is a big difference between the burr from an aluminum oxide wheel and a CBN wheel, with the CBN being far superior. The burr from honing has no durability at all, and is gone in seconds. The burnished burr is slightly finer than the one from the CBN wheels, but not by much, so I generally don't bother with it.

For thickness, I prefer 3/8. 1/4 inch is too thin, and just doesn't have the mass for heavy roughing, in which the scrapers excel any other tool, IMHO. Any thicker has no benefits that I can see at all, and the one I have is pretty much square, and feels top heavy when using, especially if I am cutting more on one side than the other.

I do not know why all scrapers don't come with the bottom sides rounded for working up on the edge with shear cuts. I round all of mine over so they work better that way.

I have never understood the articulated tip and tear drop scrapers on heavy shafts. I can do all of the same cuts with standard scrapers.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#14

Steven Antonucci

It is true.

Steven Antonucci

The only reason that my gouges aren't polished is because it is harder than polishing the flat.

Steve

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#15

Brad Vietje

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

Brad Vietje

Reed,

I've read many times that you prefer a scraper to a bowl gouge for roughing out a bowl (as well as finishing it).

I'd like to see that demonstrated, but I live really far to the east (northern Vermont). I routinely use scrapers to smooth the profile of a bowl, but still find it hard to believe they are superior to a bowl gouge for removing wood. Or maybe I should use the phrase "removing wood efficiently". Given enough horsepower, I know a scraper can remove wood PDQ, but so can a bowl gouge -- and I'd expect with less resistance, thus less force (or horsepower, in terms of motor torque).

I am not attempting to be argumentative in the least. I'd like to learn more, and I'd love to see an objective treatment of the matter. Have you ever shot a video of your methods?

I'd like to see how you do it, and if there's a source of info on the web, I'll look into it with open eyes and mind (well... with safety glasses, perhaps...).

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#16

Re: Scrapers Reviuosited.....

jerryw

Brad - search YouTube for robohippy and you can see some of his videos. He really gets after it with scrapers!!

Jerry Wright

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#17

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

robo hippy

Brad,

This clip wasn't final edited for sound or light, but shows some of what you can do.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hKdqiAc0jx4&feature=g-upl

Every time I do this as a demo, I get a turner or two who come up to me and comment that they will have to rethink the scraper. How much you can pull off depends on hp/torque, tool sharpness, and how much steel you can put into the wood at one time.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#18

Aage Rendalen

Pure heresy but impressive result

Aage Rendalen

It's hard to argue with a good outcomes, and it looks as if yours are as good as it gets. I wonder if the issue of scraper vs gouge in bowl turning is a turning version of shooting baskets via the backboard as opposed to sinking a swisher. In spindle turning I can see that scrapers are inferior to skews and gouges, but in bowl turning--is it just a question of style? I use gauges, but seeing your video makes me wonder.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#19

Re: Pure heresy but impressive result

robo hippy

Heresy indeed. When I first started turning, I was told to only use a scraper when necessary, but the gouge was the better tool. I didn't know the difference between the two and I could get equally deep catches with either tool. Most of your bowl roughing cuts are pretty much a scrape, especially if the tool is held mostly level, and with the flutes on the side, which is how I hold my gouges most of the time. Dropping the handle a bit does make it slightly more of a shear cut, but that is because the nose gives the shear angle. I just started to experiment with them, and prefer them for roughing and getting the bowl shape, then use a gouge, one pass most of the time for a finish cut.

More heresy: I use them on spindle work as well. They will do an excellent job with a peeling type cut, and when I get tear out because of uneven grain that I can't remove with gouges and skews, I resort to the shear scrape; non bevel rubbing cut, dropped handle, high shear angle. With the properly shaped tip, you can turn beads, coves and delicate finials. I can also do bevel rubbing cuts with them. They are cutting tools, and you can do scraping/peeling cuts with either gouges, skews or scrapers, as well as bevel rubbing cuts and 'shear scrapes'. One of the reasons the carbide tipped tools are so popular is that they are small scrapers that are pretty easy to control.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#20

Steven Antonucci

Not all carbides are scrapers

Steven Antonucci

Some are essentially small hooks...

I wonder if you could do that on a Jet Mini? ;)

Like Brad, I use my scrapers to refine all the little wiggles I get in cutting a bowl. I've got a Chinese horse and a half, and I know I could stall it if I tried to rough out with a scraper.

I've gotten into the habit of saying "I can do this in my own shop, but what you can do in yours is something only you know the answer to"

Good video.

Steve

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#21

Mike Stafford

Re: Pure heresy but impressive result

Mike Stafford

Everyone seems to forget that for most of turning history turnings were accomplished without the plethora of turning tools to which we have access. There are some beautiful turnings created without modern tools. Scrapers dominated the turning tool world.

The only exception I will take with Reed's argument is that regarding the carbide tools being scrapers. The cup shaped cutters on Hunter Tools cut and leave a finish when used in the right application that is hard to beat. I use them extensively inside boxes to refine the hollow and to reduce sanding.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#22

Leo Cuellar

SWEET!

Leo Cuellar

Do you ever reverse direction scrape for twisty/fuzzy grains?

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#23

Re: Not all carbides are scrapers

robo hippy

Okay, there are a two main types of carbide cutters that I have seen. The Easy Rougher type which are flat stock with square or slightly rounded nose profiles, and the cupped type like the discs on the Eliminator, which I have. For sure the Easy Rougher is a scraper, but you can roll it in its edge for a shear cut. The disc type, if used flat are very grabby. Roll it on its side, and you get a nice shear cut. Most of the time, this is not a bevel rubbing cut. Many turners define the difference between a cut and a scrape as being rubbing the bevel, and not rubbing the bevel, with no reference to the angle the cutting edge as it is presented to the wood. No bevel rub = shear scrape. Bevel rub = cut/slice. I guess the cupped discs are in this grey area.

I am not sure what is meant by reverse scraper cut for removing fuzzy grain. I do some times, especially on the inside of the bowl, pull towards the rim to smooth things out, and this is going against the grain. These cuts are so light that grain orientation makes little difference.

robo hippy

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#24

Steven Antonucci

An important distinction

Steven Antonucci

Just because you have a gouge in your hand, it doesn't mean you are cutting. I agree with your definitions of cutting and scraping being separated by bevel contact. I suspect that there are areas where lots of opinions about what was actually taking place might vary.

I have shown a very good turner how I cut with the wings on my gouges. He referred to is as a shear scrape and I corrected him saying that I was actually cutting because I had bevel contact. I believe that you can actually CUT in certain situations with a scraper because you have bevel contact. In your video, there are spots that I think you show it.

So, you can cut with a scraper or scrape with a gouge. The key is knowing how to use your tools.

Steve

P.S. The Hunter's are able to cut or scrape depending upon how they are presented. I think they work WAY more effectively for cutting than scraping, where they tend to be a little grabby because the burr is so large.

Re: Scrapers Revisited.....

#25

Leo Cuellar

Should have been clearer...

Leo Cuellar

My fault, Robo, I meant, do you ever run the lathe in reverse & work from the other side? You know those annoying little prickles that you can't see, but you sure can feel them. I think riding the bevel pushes them back into the wood.

I did some more experimenting just a little bit ago... a very high angle of shear scraping, 75 to 80 degrees makes an even cleaner cut. The amount of pressure applied during the cut definitely seems to make a difference also, especially with a thinner scraper, say 1/4". Too much pressure and its going to chatter even if you can't actually feel it. As Steve told me the other day, angle hairs. I came very close to getting a surface that was ready for 1000# sanding.

Really liked what you showed in the video.