Re: FORM - the key to a nice piece
charlie belden
Ellis wrote:
>. . . it occurs to me that despite the ease of practicing forms in miniature, practice alone won't teach you to either intuit or recognize good form. <
Ah, there’s the rub. Does one have an intuitive sense of good form? Is it built into us? Is it a cultural thing, some forms more appealing to one culture and not others?
>And, what is good form anyway? Is it subjective?<
Some good forms are probably universal, genetically built in, probably a Darwinian thing. Recognizing an edible fruit, vegetable, tubor, nut . . . and when it’s best to eat for its best nutritional value would be a real biological advantage. Recognizing advantageous biological characteristics of a potential mate has a real biological advantage. Many of the forms we find attractive may be subconsciously linked to these two biological imperatives – eat in order to live – and reproduce.
Since early turners were probably males, curves found making up a female of our species could influence what they found attractive.
Then there are environmental factors. The more forms one is exposed to, the more likely there will develop a preference for some forms over others. The more Masters’ Works a painter has seen and studied, the more likely the painter is to paint pleasing paintings. This assumes of course that the painter isn’t painting something like nothing that’s been done before. When you get out beyond the bounds of Done Before, things can get a bit trickier.
>Are there universal shapes that are good/better/best? Are there principles of good form that can be learned and recognized when we produce them?<
There seem to be principles of good design – for what’s already been done before – or that occur in nature a lot – thirds, fifths, Golden Ratio, Fibonacci . . . These can be envelopes in which to work – leaving room for some riffing of course.
> . . .form and surface are about the only things that matter to me when turning. My understanding and appreciation of good form (such as they are) are something I bring with me when I go to the lathe. Occasionally I surprise myself with a shape or a transition or a detail that work -- for me at least -- but does that make them good?<
If you turn soley for yourself, what you like is all that matters. Of, on the other hand, you turn to compete with other turners, or turn to sell – to the public or collectors you’re playing in a different game. Now it’s The Market that probably will dictate Good – or not. Then, aesthetics take a back seat to what sells.
When you surprise yourself while turning, you’re probably tapping into primal stuff, sometimes very subtle primal stuff. That ability to pick out This Is Better Than That is built in us – though a ton of money is spent hiring Ad Agencies to convince us THIS is BETTER THAN EVERYTHING ELSE. The adage “Sex Sells” goes after that biological imperative – reproduction – and has been working pretty well – for a LONG time
>I guess in the end, what I'm willing to settle for becomes my statement of good form, and whether anyone agrees determines whether it actually has merit.<
If YOU like what you’ve turned, and you’re turning for YOU – then YOU are the ultimate aribitor of what is and what isn’t good form – regardless of its size. If, on the other hand, you require external verification that you’re right – then your into that Marketing area.
Dale Miner wrote:
>Is 'Good Form' a dynamic concept? If what you (we) are willing to accept as our statement of good form, then does that change as we refine our capacity to produce smoother and better curves and transitions?<
Certainly what is “good” changes over time. Compare Rubinesque vs Goyaesque paintings of female subjects. And a piece that we turned a while back – and really liked at the time – may look “not quite right” to us now. In part that’s probably due to experience and exposure.
Let me give you a personal example.
I was in Bogota, Columbia, specifically to see Columbia’s Gold Museum (of cast gold pieces of Pre Columbian art) and to buy some raw emerald crystals to use in jewelry pieces I was casting.
The emerald dealer I was working with listened to what I was after – and the price range I could afford. He presented me with four packets of stones, each in a carefully folded “envelope” that could be opened quickly to reveal the content.
I examined the first packet of stones and selected two of the best in the packet and set them aside next to that packet. When I opened the second packet I saw immediately that my previous selection look like Coca Cola bottle glass by comparison. I returned the first selection to their packet and folded it closed, picking out three stones form the second packet. The “those look like coke bottle glass compared to these – so put them back” process repeated when I opened the third packet.
The FOURTH packet had the Muzos, named after the Muzo Mine where this quality of emerald was first discovered. The stones in this packet were instantly recognizable as the definition of Emerald Green. And because they were small, I being on a budget. They were absolutely flawless – clear emerald green, perfectly cut and breathtakingly beautiful. I could only afford one of the smaller stones – but I HAD to have it. I also bought one of each of the other packets so I could show future customers why a Muzo cost more than a lower quality stone. Once educated a bit about emeralds and emerald quality, they’d usually go for the Higher Priced Spread, that also had a higher Mark Up (read profit).
Side By Side Comparisons will usually lead to good, better, best conclusions. And the more there is to compare, the more apt The Best will be recognized – and selected.
>Also, as form relates to woodturning, does the definition of good form change as time goes on?<
For me at least, what I thought was pretty good when I first started turning now look kind of clunky. And as I turn more, and see more works by others, the stuff I’m turning now look way better than earlier pieces. Maybe not as good as the ones turned by well known turners – but hey – if you ain’t stretching you start to lock up and get stuck ; )
>Does that definition change as turners collectivly change what is accepted as good form?<
This gets back to the External Verification thing – it’s only a good piece if others say it is. And who the Others are is different. Turners put a high value on THIN WALLS. The Average Joe and the Collectors – not so much.
=======================================
John Lucas wrote:
>I have to dissagree somewhat. I think it's difficult to really see the small details in good form at that scale. The subtle difference in a curve as it goes toward the bottom or changes from curved to flat is very difficult see on that scale.<
And THAT is where Digital Images & PhotoShop come in. You can take a digital image of a piece while on the lathe – bring it into PhotoShop (or another Digital Image Processing application) an blow it up to whatever size you’d like. The details are in the miniature – and image processing software lets you see details better than looking at the piece with a magnifying glass.
I posted images of a “calabash bowl”, a “flat topped hollow form with finial” and recently an “ornament with finial and icicle – one a pedestal”. A photographer was able to recognize dust in one of the images and determine that the piece was very small. Most others thought the pieces were much larger than they actually are.
>In fact I learned to "feel" curves by running your hands from the lip to the feet. You can feel a bad curve easier than you can see it.<
Anybody who does high end body work will absolutely agree with you. I know a guy who was a high end body work person. He suffered from macular degeneration an was going blind. Without his eyesight fooling him, he could FEEL imperfections nobody in the shop would see – until AFTER the paint was applied. He became the Quality Control Guy for the shop – and got paid more – and earned every penny with his new found skill. (The cup is half empty – or half full – depending on your perspective)
Steven Antonucci wrote:
>Agree with John. Minis are good as maquets (sp?),>
maquett: a sculptor's small preliminary model or sketch.
>but it is really hard not only to see good form at that scale, but I would offer it's hard to control tool movement at that scale too. I submit that you can see form and control it far better at an intermediate scale.<
See above regarding the use of PhotoShop to enable seeing details
Regarding tool control – for me at least, making a nice roll cut is far easier on a miniature than on a normal sized piece – the range of movement required can often be done with finger tips and wrist movement rather than those AND whole body movement. Maybe it’s just that the fine motor skills and techniques for making my hands work together, developed from my jewelry making days are transferable to turning.
>That said, I agree that the idea of practicing and multiple is a good one. I might take a piece of "ordinary" wood and turn a shape. I may recut that piece several times looking for the perfect form. It may not ever become a finished piece. I'm OK with that.<
Practice may not make “perfect” – but it usually makes “better”.
>Even though I can make work at a much higher level of capability that ever before, I find myself discriminating on what I finish. Just because I mounted it on the lathe, doesn't mean it will end up with my name on it.<
Descrimination requires that you have at least two things to compare. So maybe the more things you have to compare, the more discriminating you become?
And BTW – you CAN sand to a better, if not to a “good form” – assuming you start CLOSE to a good form.
Carol Valentine wrote:
>I would have to disagree with part of this. Of course practice on minis (and I have turned many,many of those rascals over my turning career!) can help with skills, especially the fine tool control needed for doing details, finials, etc. However, minis are VERY forgiving when it comes to overall form simply because of their scale.<
Now were into an interesting subject – aesthetics as a function of scale.
Would Durer’s etchings work at 10, 20 or 100 times bigger?
Would the Parthenon work – at 1/10th or 1/1000ths scale?
I know Michaelangelo’s The David at 1/12th the scale of the original full sized piece definitely does not have the same impact – at least on me.
Maybe there is a different aesthetic for different scales.
I do know that if the hole in a hollow form is too small for a turner to get a finger in to get a feel for wall thickness, wall thickness isn’t a criteria for a good piece or a Close But No Cigar piece. With miniatures. “heft” or “lack of heft” isn’t a factor either. Given their size, grain or figure in the wood is usually not all that important – visually (though quite important when you have to turn a delicate finial out of open grained woods or a figured wood). Color may still be important, but it’s The FORM that becomes the dominate criteria with miniatures.
>IMHO, the larger the piece, the harder it is to achieve a continous fair curve, <
That’s been my experience. But with miniatures, often sanding to a continuous fair curve is far easier than “cutting” one.
>and the easier it is for the eye to detect those burps in the curves and any poor proportions in the design<
So visual acuity or lack there of, is a contributing factor when defining the criteria for good form?
If you can visually blow up a photo of a miniature to a “normal size” would you still be able to detects burps in the curves and any poor proportions in the design?
>Most of the time, if you could take a miniature and magically transform it into a 6 or 8 inch piece, it would end up in the burn barrel.<
Better to burn a little wood than to burn a lot more wood?
Is SIZE a criteria for good form or is BIGGER merely more imressive than smaller, at least to turners?
David wrote:
> . . . At one time I aspired to produce large bowls, but what I found was they take so much time to finish--all that surface area to sand, assuming the form was acceptable.<
Well minatures do have the advantage of being quicker to turn and less surface area to sand. And smaller pieces of nice wood – DRY wood – are easier to find – and less expensive, to say nothing for Less Expensive
> I need the pieces I make to eventually sell so I can acquire more tools to play with, and large pieces are 1) more expensive and harder to sell, and 2) take up too much space on the shelf or counter.<
>You forgot to mention packing and unpacking time and storage space at home between shows. You can put a LOT of miniature plates, bowls and hollow forms – in a shoe box ; )
> The thing about miniatures--you need to be a collector or have a dollhouse to furnish, and I don't think there are that many out there in that category.<
I’ve noticed that the miniatures I’ve been turning get more comments and generate more interest among the people I know than my “normal sized” pieces, even if the forms are very similar. Small has its own WOW Factor.
I’ve also noticed that people really really look at small pieces. I think their size shifts their perspective towards seeing the piece as a gem and not an object, functional or not. People really look at small things – examine them more – than regular size stuff. And they notice and comment on things they don’t seem to notice or comment on when presented with a normal sized piece.
As to the lack of a market for miniatures, perhaps we’re back to marketing. The trend in much of modern life is towards Smaller Is Better – the Walky Talky “portable phones replaced by pocket sized, and smaller, cell phones. Now seen as HUGE television sets now can hang on a wall, or fit in your hand – or pocket. Computers that used to take up half a room or more and need their own air conditioner became desktop towers and now are smaller than an old LIFE magazine – with far more computer power and capabilities than their predecessors. Even the American love of BIG cars is changing.
And collectors, even a very well known collector, came around to miniatures – due to space constraints for displaying a collection of larger pieces. She built quite a collection of miniatures – and began educating others to the value of miniatures.
Miniatures may need a bit more marketing. There’s a pretty large lapidary and jewelry market out there to tap into. And the dolls and doll house market is a lucrative market to be tapped.
> . . . now I generally work small and tackle a large piece only when available wood presents the opportunity.<
Ah, the availability of wood or adequate size and condition issue. If you need to turn DRY wood, I dare to venture that you have far more nice dry wood on hand that you can turn a miniature from than you have for normal sized pieces. And all those smaller pieces would probably end up being tossed – or burned.
>The sandpaper gouge can affect form, but in most cases it is easier to turn and cut the wood to the desired shape.<
The sandpaper and grits you use for regular sized pieces may not be the best choice to use on miniatures. Where you start at 100 or 120 grit, maybe even 80 grit, and working your way through to 220 or 320 grit for a full sized piece – begins with 320 or 400 grit for miniatures and goes up to 1500, 1800 or maybe all the way to 12000. I’ve found that a paper coffee filter will put a nice luster on a miniature – but isn’t all that useful on full sized pieces.
Then there’s the type of sandpaper used. I’ve found Wet/Dry sandpaper to be thinner, more flexible, and in a wider range of grits than the paper I use for sanding furniture and regular size turnings. And they can be held to almost automatically create a fair curve on a Close To Right surface.
As for it being easier to cut rather than sand to a desired shape, this assumes that you already have the tools and techniques for using them really well. But those tools and learning those techniques often take years and years to acquire. With miniatures a lot can be turned using only a few tools and they only need to be used to Get Close – the fine tuning being done with sandpaper.
>I find that there are all kinds of people, some of which no amount of practice will give them 'the eye'.<
True, so true. But nothing will probably change that.
Barbara Gill wrote:
> . . . Even for those turners who just can't see the difference between pleasing and not so pleasing forms could take a lesson from the Greeks and get out their ruler to improve the finished product.<
Which gets us back to the fundamentals – the importance of form – a good form – whatever THAT is. If it ain’t there, color, figure, piercing, texturing, pyroing, carving etc. doesn’t matter. You can’t make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear.
Now if there were only some way to make Dog Bowls an aesthetically pleasing form . . .