The long thin finial was turned from a 3/4" poplar dowel. Started from where it fits onto the flat topped hollow form and turned back towards the tip - in short sections - each sanded with 400, 600 and 1500 grit paper as I went. I wanted the "flame" at the top of the long thin one to be longer - but started the final cut and tapered faster than I intended.
The tall thin finial was to be a practice run for doing one in maple - but it turns out poplar is stronger than I'd thought and easier to sand ; )
Charlie, I believe that Cindy Drozda and other finial makers start at the tip and work backward. I am curious as to why you prefer to do it the opposite way.
I agree that the finials for these two pieces should be black rather than white, carrying the red brown - black - red brown color scheme up to the top. A white finial breaks the piece up into two disparate pieces rahter than one integrated piece.
The poplar and maple finials were just practice pieces to get familiar with using a small detail spindle gouge. I'd been using a parting tool and a 1/4" bench chisel as a bedan. The detail gouge let me do better curves transitions and longer sweeping curves.
Will be doing a bunch of miniature bowls and hollow forms over the next few days, experimenting with the little detail gouge - and different finishes. Wnat to play with a graphite finish, the look of graphite is pretty interesting - and subtley different from other colored finishes like dyes or paints or stains. May try black shoe dye.
Nice thing about turning miniatures - you get to try things out that you wouldn't try out on a piece that you had two or three hours invested in.
I do the same as Wally and I'm right handed. I put the thinnest weakest point point out so it's supported by the thicker parts as you move toward the headstock.
Can't answer for Charlie but when you try to make a lid for really small stuff you can't do it in the normal fashion which is to turn the bottom of the lid, fit it in the box and then turn the box and lid with finial. You need to be able to test fit the lid so turning the base of the lid first and working your way backwards just makes sense for turnings of this scale. Been there, done that.
John's exactly right. Getting the final to fit the opening in the hollow form it's for is easy to overshoot. So if you start at the bottom end and overshoot the fit - part that off and try again. It you start at the tip of the finial and work your way back - and overshoot the fit - it's START ALL OVER - and you've wasted the time turning all those details and long delicate onion ( or whatever).
John's exactly right. When trying to get the finial to fit the opening in the hollow form, easy to overshoot and have a very loose fit. And a loose fit can mean that when the piece is picked up to be examined - the little finail will fall off - and onto the floor - then UNDER something heavy. Whiile this may have the benefit of doing some dusting under a piece of furniture - it sort of ruins the impact you intended the piece to have.
So if you start at the bottom end and overshoot the fit - part that off and try again. No other work lost.
If you start at the tip of the finial and work your way back - and overshoot the fit at the very end - it's START ALL OVER - and you've wasted the time turning all those details and long delicate onion ( or whatever).
It you true up your blank before you start the finial it won't contribute any out of round vibration.
And if you turn at a higher speed, 2000 - 2800 rpms, even a long delicate piece will self stabilize pretty well.
And if you Sand & Finish As You Go - NEVER GOING BACK (ok, so you CAN go back - IF YOU'RE VERY, VERY, VERY CAREFUL), the section you turned last will have plenty of wood behind it towards the chuck on the tail stock end. That means it's less likely to snap off - which, as Martha Stewart say "is a GOOD thing."
FWIW. When I took a class from Cindy Drozda we oriented the finial top to the tailstock and turned to the headstock. Then a jam chuck was made that the delicate finial was inserted into so the base could be turned and test fitted to the box as we went along. In fact I inserted my finial into the jam chuck to transport it home so the little bugger wasn't broken in transit.
She chucks the blank in a scroll chuck with the tenon end toward the headstock, using the tailstock center to hold it for roughing the shape. She's pretty unequivocal about starting at the very tip and working backward to the base of the finial, finish sanding each section as she works her way down. She uses an open-end wrench as a caliper for the tenon, and cuts the opening in the box lid for the tenon to fit.
I must say that I've had a hard time when I've tried working upward to the tip. Of course, my tools and techniques probably weren't very good either. I'm sure all you folks are speaking from your successful experiences. More than one way to skin this cat.
Ellis I've tried working toward the tip. You have to be extremely light on the bevel and back the wood with your fingers to cut the vibration. I did it just the other day to settle an argument when someone said it was impossible because you would break the wood. I can do it that way but it just takes way too long. The cuts have to be so delicate. You can be much more aggressive when going the other direction and it really speeds up your production.
You prefer working from the tip down to the tenon, which is exactly what Cindy is saying. Here's a really quick sketch to confirm what we're all saying...
Yep. Now show a picture of reversing the finial to finish fit to the box. I put a jam chuck into duckbill jaws on my Supernova2 and fit the finial into it all the way to the 'cap' and then turn the tenon to fit. Keeps everything centered and predictable.
end wrench to size the tenon. Works pretty much every time by matching the end wrench to the drill used to open the top, however, if you touch the opening with your tool all bets are off. Found out the hard way.
While Cindy's "From Tip Of Finial Back To Tenon Of Finial works quite well - at NORMAL SIZE - and the open end wrench used to size the tenon - it doesn't work so well when you scale things way down - to miniature size. Little iitty bitty open end wrenches aren't that common and they don't fit in tight spaces. And, as noted, if, while hollowing the piece the finial is for, you happen to make the hole a bit wider - it's hard to measure the diameter accurately and pick a corresponding open end wrench to use to check the tenon's diameter. Guess wrong and you'll probably have a problem with the fit.
One of the many things that's different about doing miniatures is tolerances. At normal size, being off by a little isn't super critical - you just push a little harder if the fit is tight - or put a coat or two of shellac or lacquer around the tenon if the fit is too loose. Those "adjustments" aren't available when you start turning little things. Be off just a little bit and - the finial can't be put on the piece - or - the finial falls off the minute you touch the finialed piece (and you spend 10 minutes on your hands and knees trying to find the finial).
So - getting the tenon on the finial to fit the opening in the top of the piece it's intended for is the No. 1 priority. And the best way of doing that is turning the tenon FIRST and getting it to fit just right. Only then will the rest of the finial be turned - assuming you don't mind wasting 15 - 30 minutes turning a nice little finial - THAT DOESN'T FIT THE PIECE.
So - for turning miniature finials - START WITH THE TENON AND GET IT RIGHT FIRST. Then and only then spend the time turning a beautiful delicate little finial.
The attached link is to the first of a two part video showing how I turn these miniature finials. The original video I did was aa bit over 16 minutes - start to finish. Alas, YouTube has a 10 minutes max limit. I've broken the original video into two - each under the 10 minute limit. I put up Part 1 of 2 and am working on Part 2 of 2. I'll post the link to it when it's done.
As always, suggestions for improving this stuff are welcomed/
Hmmm...I've turned more than a few finials, most of them very slim in parts. As I said before, I turn the tenon first, at the tailstock end. I can then easily fit the tenon to my already turned lid. I then proceed to turn the rest of the finial, working toward the headstock. I part it off at the tip. Works very well for me.
The reason it's so easy is that I'm supporting my finial with the tailstock, using a slim extension with a very small, fine point. The point is secured in the finial tenon. The extension is made to fit a Oneway live center.
And....I bought the small extension from Cindy D!. She was using it during a demo.
Guess I just like to be different. Since I was turning before most of you were born, I learned to make things work my way.