Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

Posts

The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#1

The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

Roger Chandler

The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...or is there a way to do both?

Can both be done on the same project? I like art .......a lot.......but most of the folk I interact with seem to want something practical [utilitarian] I have a creative side......wants to do high end stuff.........everybody seems to prefer a bowl!

Where do you fall in this spectrum of choices? Do you just go from artsy on one project to utilitarian on the next, or do you try to accomplish both in the same piece? If so, how do you go about achieving both on the same project?

What do most of the people you interact with prefer........something practical or something artsy?

Is this a can-o-worms this discussion is opening?

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#2

At this point in time, and the current.....

JamieDonaldson

..state of the economy, you can sometimes sell utilitarian items, but you'll have to eat the Artsy stuff! :b

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#3

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian

John Lucas

Depends on how much you need the money. Now that I'm retired I plan to go the artsy root simply because that's what I've wanted to do for a long time. I still plan to do functional things to bring in extra money but it will be with a more artistic flair.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#4

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian

Dick Coers

8 out of 10 items I sell have at least something artsy about it. Decorated rims, color in the decoration, pyro details, fully dyed, etc.... It seems that some type of color is really important. Just a really nice natural bowl, or natural edge stuff, I might as well try and give it away. No sales on those since last Christmas. Wood pendants and earrings have been selling pretty well, but the price is right on that. Nothing over $35 on those.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#5

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian

Nick Todd

My utilitarian items take less time and I get the instant gratification and still selling a few items a month. The artsy stuff are making great wedding gifts. People still appreciate the gift at value before the economy crashed. ;) I can't get myself to sell the artsy time at a deeply discounted price. So I keep them, give them away or donate to non profits.

So the answer is find a way to turn what you enjoy.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#6

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian

charlie belden

Folks go with THE DEFAULT - familiar objects- that have an immediately recognizable function - plate, platter, bowl, weed pot, vase, lidded box. While other turners may be impressed with a Pop Fit lidded box, or a hollow form with what seems like an impossibly small opening in it, ladies don't like Pop Fit boxes - takes two hands to open or close them, most folks would see an Ellsworth HF and think warped bowling ball or a river run rounded smooth rock - with an unexplained hole in it.

If you go with exclusively functional - you compete with Pier One Imports, Pottery Barn and IKEA. THAT is a losing proposition.

If you use interesting woods - well - you have the first step for Product Differenation - "THIS is more expensive than THAT because someone - ME - took the time to get the most out of it and show off just how amazing and beautiful this piece of wood is - and by implication - your backyard tree may be.

And THAT is where most turners who want to sell their turnings fall short. A lot of time and effort is put into techniques and tools - very little into MARKETING. And MARKETING is not only finding what IS selling and what IS NOT SELLING - but also EDUCATING your potential customers (NOT "Consumers"). With knowledge comes appreciation - and usually more income ; )

Imagine what might happen if, in addition to displaying your work that's for sale, you left a copy of "Expressions in Wood, Master Works from The Wornick Collection" and / or a copy of "New Masters of Woodturning". Imagine if you had a portfolio of nice photos of your best pieces out there for people to thumb through - along with a story about each piece. And imagine that some of the pieces were custom pieces - for a specific person - that reflected something important to that person.

Case in point. I did lost wax cast jewelry. What I took to craft faires and shows were mostly silver, often with semi precious stones. But I also put out a three ring binder of color photos of the custom pieces I'd done - in gold, with precious stones - and a short story about each piece.

I did a pair of rings for two young women who'd been best friends since first grade. They were off to colleges a thousand miles apart. One was very self confident and outgoing, the other shy and very intelligent. I did a large sunflower - it's stalk wrapping around to form the band. Around the stalk and rising to the sunflower flower, a morning glory vine, with more delicate, less flashy but still beautiful flowers. The two complimented each other - and these young women got it right away and were pleased with THEIR rings.

A couple saw my work at a show, took a card and - a year and a half later, wrote and asked that I do their wedding rings. He was from eastern Washington state, she from southwestern Nebraska - both raised around wheat fields. They wanted the heads of two wheat plants coming up the sides of their rings from opposite directions and coming togeher side by side at the top. They each sent me a drawing of their idea - on 8 1/2 x 11 line paper. My challenge was to take their ideas, scale them WAY down and then send them actual sized "wax sketches" of what I'd come up with so they could see them actual size - just in red wax - they had to imagine them in yellow gold. The process took some time - but they loved the results. I got Christmas cards from them for the next ten years, including pictures of their kids as they arrived.

Both of these collaborations with the ultimate owners / commissioners lead to over twenty other custom pieces. I didn't make any money on either of these two early commissioned pieces. But I did make money on the referred commisions because the two young women friends and the young couple educated their friends who then commissioned personalized pieces.

I educated four people, who in turn educated twenty people . . . who educated who knows how many more people. I benefitted from some of that - and other jewelers probably did as well. And educated about one craft, leads to an appreciation of other crafts - and that's good for all people doing art or craft.

While the AAW is educating collectors of wood art, it's up to we turners to educate or try to educate the Average Joe and Jolene. It's not that they CAN'T appreciate what we do - it's that they aren't yet aware of what goes into a piece or the stories behind the pieces. Once aware of why YOUR pieces are different from what they see at Ikea or TARGET, they will value your pieces more highly - and perhaps pay more - to possess one of your turnings - embellished or not, artsy or functional or both.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#7

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian

Roger Chandler

Wow, Charlie...........what a great perspective..........thanks for taking the time to share it with us!

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#8

Utiltarian ...

Jorge

Roger,

I decided to go utilitarian, I thought "when I get tired of it I'll try something else" 955 pieces later, I am still learning and have not tried the galleries route, I love to have the direct interaction with the buyers, forever trying to make shapes that please me, and they sell themselves, my best sellers are pieces in the $200 range, and I love to have all my money right back to me, not 50% of it...

just saying...

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#9

Everyone who sells, should read Charlie's post

Greg Haugen

Charlie, you hit the nail on the head. I've been thinking and saying that for years.

For the past few years, it never fails, I go to a show and there's an exhibitor there that shouldn't be. They tired, they've done it for a long time, and they're burned out. They can't muster a smile if they had to. I'm very energetic and responsive with people and ENJOY what I do. Every show, the "grumpy/burned out" exhibitor barely sells anything and those who are having FUN (myself included) usually had an outstanding show. If you can't get excited about your work, no one else will. There's so much more than just the "creativity" at the lathe, and it's everything else that often gets forgotten about.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#10

Steven Antonucci

Charlie and Greg are required reading

Steven Antonucci

Charlie is spot on in his education perspective, but Greg also hit on another point. EVERY show of any type that I have ever attended has booths with vendors that should not be there. They have no chance of success because they sit back and HOPE that someone notices them.

Hope is not a strategy.

It is extremely important to treat every person that walks up to your booth as both a potential customer AND a potential advocate. The last two things you want are a buying customer to get the feeling that you weren't worth their time AND/OR a potential advocate to have a negative opinion of your business. Negative advertising is very hard to overcome and often completely unseen.

I don't directly sell at craft fairs, but I do demonstrate at a very large one every year. I make sure that the gallery store brings a couple of my pieces and I can refer people over to the store area if they are interested.

One last thing that might help is turning simple items like finger tops to give away to children. Having a visual draw to your booth and a freebie for the kids might just pry the occassional wallet from said pocket of mom or dad... Obviously, suckering your wife or kid into the booth to sit with you is require for this (not a solo venture)

Steve

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#11

Make what you ENJOY to make......

Greg Haugen

The short answer? Make what you ENJOY to make. This is my answer to this question, or similar questions. As I previously stated, if you're not into and excited about what you're making no one else will be. There is a market for everything. The challenge is finding it. Example, I used to work for a local guy who makes traditional wood saws out of his basement. HIGH END SAWS, $180 to $300 range. He sells to multiple countries. It's a vastly growing business. With the economy and all of the other factors, one may think it would be struggling. He has gotten into the right market, got his name out there, and is passionate about his craft. The artistic and the functional paths do cross. In my opinion Mike Stafford is one of the best box makers. His boxes have a function, check, and they're incredibly elegant and artistic as well, check. Does artistic have to be unrecognizable and function-less?

Make what you enjoy to make. I've done shows where the cheapest item that was sold was $150 and I've done shows where the most expensive item was $30. If you spend all week making bottle corkers but you enjoy making bowls and hollow forms, and those bottle corkers don't sell. You're out of sales and a weeks worth of enjoyable turning. That show that you're getting ready for may be looking for the higher end items. If you spend the week making bowls and hollow forms they may not sell either. But at least you've enjoyed yourself for the week and you have inventory that you are excited about.

Another thing is the market. Bringing high end artistic turnings to the neighborhood farmers market isn't the best "market tester". Find the market for what you make.

My turning is a business. "I am a woodturner" is my response when asked what I do. Often I hear someone say, "My turning is a hobby" or "Then it would be work, and not fun." I say, what's wrong with loving what you do every day. Make what you enjoy and everything else will work out, it may just take time.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#12

Well said Charlie and Greg!


Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#13

Chuck Jones - West TN

2 thoughtful and well written articles...

Chuck Jones - West TN

... by Charlie and Greg that should be published somewhere.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#14

F/U to Charlie and Greg

John Altberg

I have taken the liberty of copying and pasting Charlie's and Greg's responses (FULLY attributed!) into a word document that I intend to share with the members of my club. Charlie, you fully articulated what for so long has escaped me when trying to convey the "value proposition" to prospective customers. To expand upon your thoughts, it occurs to me that I may make a binder showing photos of the wood acquisition process so that others may understand that their bowl began with me in the trenches wielding a chainsaw and humping large logs into the back of my truck. Or, better yet, the "Life of a Bowl" explaining through photos raw log, rough turn, drying, finish turn, and then finishing. Heck, my prices are going up as I type!

Greg, I met that "grumpy guy" at the last art show that I attended. He, a potter, had made ikebana that had a clever cup and frog set-up. When I attempted to engage him as to where he had sourced them his response was, "They're out there.", as he parked his butt in his tall director's chair at the back of his booth, folded his arms and looked the other way! Further inspection revealed that his set-up was nothing more than plastic ramekins from the restaurant supply house that he had glued the frogs into himself! Needless to say, the ikebana that I had intended to buy went back on the shelf. My dollars THAT day went to a very personable glass blower, instead.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#15

Re: F/U to Charlie and Greg

charlie belden

John:

Don't bother with any attributing. The fact that it's prompted a discussion of the subject - and brought up ideas for how to educate the general public is the type of thing I was after. Who said what isn't important. WHAT ideas and actions came of it are what' are important. Thanks for the offer of attribution - but I'll take a pass on that one.

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#16

One more thing...Smile!!

Jorge

and smile some more, stand tall and don't forget your sexy underwear!!! :o)

Re: The big debate......go artsy, or go utiltarian ...

#17

Charlie, this is very timely...

GaryG in MD

Our next Meeting is titled "Selling Your Work II".

Your exposition is right on.

I'm posting it, with attribution, on our web site as required reading before the meeting.

Thanks for your thoughts, Gary