Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Does it matter what wood species it is?

Posts

Does it matter what wood species it is?

#1

Does it matter what wood species it is?

John Lucas

I ask this for two reasons. Other than trying to learn the woods so that I can understand the movement problems and have some knowledge of the appearance when combining them or buying them I really don't get hung up over what it is.

I'm much more concerned about the Art of the piece. Kind of like it really doesn't matter to me what tool you use or even if it's done on the lathe. I'm interested in the piece and whether or not it's successful.

It's kind of like when segemented turners tell you there are 1900 pieces in this piece. Other than interest sake I don't really care. I'm more interested in the form and whether the feature designs work with the over all piece. Do the wood choices work together etc.

I guess part of it is my memory has gotten so bad I have trouble remembering the wood species. Particularly when it's something I seldom use and then it's laying around the shop for a year or more. I'm much more interested in how it looks and if it fits the project. I'm more interested in the process itself, how to mount it on the lathe, how I'm going to turn it, and can I make the design work.

I know I should be more interested in the wood itself but I guess I'm not.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#2

I'm with you John

Mike Foster

I also just don't remember some of the unusual woods that I come across, but will use them to fit what I'm doing. Problem is that often the customer wants to know what wood it is. I have taken to writing what the wood is on the chunk of wood when I acquire it (and if know what it is). Then, years later when I pull it out of my stash, it's identified for me.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#3

Steven Antonucci

An example of where it might matter?

Steven Antonucci

Over the weekend, I demonstrated in Southern VA and I was given 2 pieces of historic wood. One was from an Ash tree that was planted by George Washington. The other was from a pecan tree that grew on George's estate, but was planted well after his time. In the case of historic trees, I guess it matters.

If the piece is painted, blackened, burned, etc... I tell people it is amboyna burl just to get a rise out of them.

Steve

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

Mike Stafford

You are probably right, John, the wood species does not matter but for me not knowing what I am turning takes half the fun away.

One of the personal challenges I enjoy is turning as many different species as I can. I enjoy chucking up a new species of wood and learning how to turn it. I see it as a challenge to turn something useful and hopefully pretty from a new species the first time I turn it.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#5

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

john lucas

I guess I'm much more interested in the turning process, shape etc than what species of wood it is. Even if I knew in 3 months if someone asks I won't remember. I tell them it's limbus numerous.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

but if I have a choice I'd rather know

Chuck Jones - West TN

After a while all turners gain at least a "feel" for how any one of several species will work, look and feel after it is turned. That turned look and feel can be quite different from how the chunk looks before turning and after it has been lying around a shop for a few years getting dusty, faded, and dry. There are lots of chunks in my pile that I could not identify now if they weren't labeled. There are several times I would rather know.

For the first fifty-sixty years of my life I could tell the difference between a tree and a giraffe, but I didn't know much else about them. One of the fun parts of working with wood has been the process of learning a little about tree species, characteristics, uses, etc.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#7

Two questions about my work when I sell it

Dick Coers

What wood is it, and how long did it take to make? If I have the species on the description card, one of the early questions is covered. I don't burn that on the bottom of my work, but it seems to be important to the customer. It could be that these questions are just conversation starters, but if I didn't know the species, it may appear that I don't know my craft.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#8

does wood species matter?  YES!

Roger Chandler

John..........I understand your point, and agree that the project, how the wood fits together if it is a combo, and the finished product is the most important........that being said,

I think the type wood is important..........folks who get items, whether given to them or purchased, are indeed interested in the species of wood. As regards the historical trees...........identification is crucial.......our clubs project with the Stonewall Jackson prayer tree is an example. Witness trees from a battlefield, or a tree that was well known in a community makes people want a keepsake if they know the wood is genuine.

I always put the species on the bottom of the turning if I know what it is......

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#9

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

Phil Powell

I'm with John, the beauty of the wood, the finished shape, the quality of

Execution, and the exceptance of the finished piece far out weighs the need

To be able to identify the tree the pot came from. For sure I like knowing

Those things but it ain't number one.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#10

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

Bob Macgregor

If the piece is a kitchen implement or bowl, then it might matter more, but it should be less important for a piece where appearance is (nearly) all.

Having said that, I think most owners would like to know the type(s) of wood in the piece in the same way that the owner of a sculpture or painting might like to know whether it was oil, acrylic, bronze, plaster, or whatever medium was used. And, as others have mentioned, for a piece from a "historical" tree the history angle is probably more important than the art.

BOB

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#11

Mike Stafford

P.S. - Collectors

Mike Stafford

P.S. Collectors of my boxes like to know because they like to add a new species to their collection as well. I guess that is the most important reason for me.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#12

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Yes, the species is very important to me. My original interest in woodturning developed because this was a way to see inside those trees I had enjoyed all of my life. I am FAR more interested in the wood colors and grain patterns than I am in whether I generate some item that receives acclaim for a beautiful shape or serves as base material for carving, pyrography, piercing, or other forms of embellishment or disfigurement.

I am finding that there are lots of us weirdos or retarded woodturners out there. I was encouraged by the remarks of Richard Raffan (latest issue of American Woodturner) when he stated that his functional items will still be used when all the wood art has been forgotten. Mother Nature can embellish wood like no man -- why not help reveal that beauty, not paint over it?

Why not use plaster or Styrofoam as a base material if only the shape is of interest?

Now off soap box. The wood is everything to me.

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#13

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

Barry L Elder

Just wait a month or two, John, until all that job-related stress leaves your brain and you'll be able to remember things you forgot to remember from years ago! Um.....I think! :D

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

#14

Re: Does it matter what wood species it is?

bill Crommett

Emmett Manley will appreciate this: When at the Tacoma AAW thing we saw a vase covered completely with beads. My wife who has definite opinions said to me: Does AAW stand for American Association of Whatever ?