Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

salty question

Posts

salty question

#1

salty question

darrin hill

my niece told me (not asked) to make her a salt cellar...

i've learned that once you start making stuff, you get lots of 'requests'.. :)

anyways... question is.. I'm using osage orange cause i had some sitting around... and was wondering if i should put a finish on it that won't be affected by salt.

especially the inside.

Re: salty question

#2

aaannnnndddd

darrin hill

aaanndd... since i looked up osage orange AFTER i made the salt cellar and AFTER i posted that last post, is it safe to use as a food container since the wood fruit expels insects...

Re: salty question

#3

Re: salty question

John Lucas

I've only made a few salt shakers. I haven't found a problem with salt and finishes. Perhaps if you mix it with water and apply it to the finish is might damage it but just laying the salt on the finish hasn't caused problems. However that was quite a while ago and I don't even remember what finish I used. Most likely it was a wipe on varnish because that's what I used to use all the time.

Near as I can tell you can eat of just about any wood. Inhaling the dust of many woods can be bad but haven't heard of any that would cause problems just by eating off them. I've used Osage Orange for a lot things and it at least feels like a stable wood that doesn't seem to have any problems associated with it.

Re: salty question

#4

JL

Re: salty question

JL

I believe in finishing the outside, not the inside. I figure salt shakers and pepper grinders have some pretty abrasive material in them. Why put on a finish that will just wear off?

Re: salty question

#5

Re: salty question

Stuart Johnson

Are you making a salt cellar (small dish used at the table with a little spoon) or salt pig (larger 4 or 5 inch angled bowl used in the kitchen)? If it is a cellar I don't think the finish makes any difference because they are usually emptied after the meal. If it's a pig then you want something that will hold up to normal kitchen use. I would use a good salad bowl finish both inside and outside.

Re: salty question

#6

Chuck Jones - West TN

Salt wells, if used, will delelop natural patina

Chuck Jones - West TN

I've made several salt wells (not shakers, pigs, or cellars) and all I did was give them a good coat of oil and (probably) wax and buff. Several of my family are serious cooks and they've used them so much they have developed a really nice patina.

Re: salty question

#7

Re: salty question

John Veerkamp

Darrin,

The OO does not need to be finished inside. The wood is food safe and takes a nice polish with just good sanding. The fruit is what "repels" insects not the wood. Enjoy.

John

Re: salty question

#8

Re: salty question

Jorge

John,

Yew is poisonous, every part of the tree except the pulp of the berry is poisonous, the seeds are lethal.

I learned this when I made recorders (flutes) for my daughters and the music teacher called me and told me to destroy the, or at the very least make new mouth pieces, out of a safe wood. I ended up making new mouth pieces out of imitation ivory.

Re: salty question

#9

BarbS

Thanks Jorge

BarbS

I have a bowl-size piece of Yew with beautiful grain, and now I'll have to mention using it for non-food use only. I didn't know that; thanks.

Re: salty question

#10

BarbS

One note on 'shakers'

BarbS

Open salt cellars would be different, but just a note of advice I picked up: salt shakers benefit from a few grains of rice added to the contents, so the holes don't clog as readily. I'll be adding that in notes to a customer, though many know it all ready.

Re: salty question

#11

Re: salty question

John Verkamp

Wood in question is Osage Orange, not yew.

Re: salty question

#12

Re: salty question

Jorge

John,

John said: "Near as I can tell you can eat of just about any wood"

thus my comment.

Re: salty question

#13

Re: salty question

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Don't worry about wood toxicity. You could probably eat that bowl without any adverse effects. I don't know how all these toxicity rumors get started and perpetuated.

Let's say there was a wood that was so toxic, that ingesting one teaspoonful of that wood would kill a person. How many years do you think it would take for salt to rub off one teaspoonful of that wood in the process of shaking.

Dose is a critical factor when considering toxicity. Wild cherry wood contains cyanide, an extremely toxic substance but the concentration is so low that we don't have to be concerned about toxicity.

As someone has pointed out, the big danger in working with wood is inhaling the dust over many years, and, in some cases acute allergic reactions caused by inhaling certain woods.

I was a pharmacologist/toxicologist for 30+ years.

Re: salty question

#14

Thanks!

Don Orr

Thanks Emmett for the reality check from someone in-the-know. This site continues to amaze and astound me with the depth and breadth of knowledge and experience. Reasonable caution is a good thing-empahsis on the "resonable".

Re: salty question

#15

Re: salty question

Jorge

Emmett,

The music teacher is a spanish lady and she said in her town every year there are horses, cows, goats, rabbits and children that die from eating parts of the yew.

So better safe than sorry.

A quick search brought up this:

http://www.botanical-online.com/alcaloidestejoangles.htm

Re: salty question

#16

Re: salty question

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

Taxus or yew is widely planted as an ornamental shrub in the United States. It is true that certain yews provide the source chemical for taxol, a cancer chemotherapy agent, but many plants provide source material for useful drugs. Poppies for morphine, May Apple for podophyllium, etc. If you wish to avoid toxic plants -- avoid poison ivy, jimson weed, and pokeweed, as they cause most of the plant toxicities in the United States.

I defer to the music teacher in the field of music. Woodturners seem to be a superstitious bunch and quick to believe any rumor or old wives tale.

If nothing else remember DOSE. Water will kill you if you drink enough of it, and cyanide won't harm you if you only ingest a few molecules. People purchasing a bowl don't eat that bowl, they may just eat from the bowl. How can they be harmed?