I was talking to a friend yesterday and he mentioned ruefully that yet another woodworking program in a local middle school was being phased out. This is a decline that's been going on probably since I took seventh-grade woodshop fifty years ago, but it still resonates with a lot of us. This month, I'd like to hear about your recollections of your high-school or junior-high woodshop days. How did shop class impact your life, if at all? Did it set you on a course for a lifetime interest in woodworking? Do you have any anecdotes about those days that you'd like to share with us? Do you think that the demise of woodshop education bodes ill for our society?
As usual, we'll slice, dice and pureé your replies and serve them up in our next column in Woodworker West magazine. Thanks for participating!
I think it can be summarized in two basic problems:
First, "shop" classes are not promoted towards the honors student. Quite the contrary, it's a place where the lesser students can "go hide out" and not have to think too much. (my opinion) Yet, most successful craft people I know are pretty smart? I think shop is better suited to the creative, intelligent type and poorly suited for "teaching a trade". I think that belongs in the vo-tech, but shop should be available as a creative outlet to the HS masses.
Secondly, my carving club meets in a local HS woodshop. When you walk in, there are lots of tall cases, a canoe, and other large scale projects. Why in the world would any HS shop teacher want to do this? For starters, every tool in the shop needs work. Secondly, the budget for the shop is minimal, and yet the students are using expensive plywood sheets like tissues. Lastly, the skill level is not up to that scale of work and the teacher cannot possibly help 25 people making a highboy in 50 minutes per day.
I think HS woodshop should refocus on craft instead of trade and scale down projects that not only make sense financially, but also work much more quickly for today's attention spans. It would be much more useful to teach patience and quality on an iPod case than a bookcase.
My shop class itself didn't really affect my woodworking. I was building a walnut table and someone stole the top before I got it done so I never actually completed a project. I got much more from the drafting class that the same instructor taught. I was fascinated by Architecture and had I been better at math may have been an Architect today.
My woodworking background came my Grandfather but since he never actually taught me it was purely there as an example. I learned mostly because I was broke in college, needed shelves and a bed for my new wife and I was familiar with the tools having seen what my Grandfather did so I simply started.
I think hands on programs are extremely important in todays schools. Metal working, woodworking, and car repair classes give a sense of accomplishement that no other classes do. They also give you a feeling of self worth.
I have some good memories of woodshop in Jr High, but that is as far as I got. Mr. Grubel was a great guy. We had a choice of a couple of different projects the 1st semester and I chose a wall lamp. Very simple project with a little cutting, drilling, and gluing. I think I still have it somewhere. Second semester we were allowed to choose our own project. I think there were some books and magazines with plans and ideas for us to look through. I chose a telephone stand with a space below for a phone book. Simple construction with a curved top. I still have that also. There was a paddle hanging on the wall with “Board of Education” on it and if you made trouble the Board of Education would meet the Seat of Knowledge. (They could do that back then). When he was showing us around the shop and explaining the different machines I clearly remember him turning on the bandsaw and quickly swiping a board into the blade. It was probably a piece of 1x pine but there was a cut about 1.5” deep into the edge of that board in the blink of an eye. It sure left an impression on me still some 40 odd years later.
As for the decline of “Shop” these days, it is my opinion that this is a huge mistake. There is so much emphasis on college, but not everyone wants to go to college or is really suited for it. Many people learn better by doing. Shop was where you got to try out many different things and find something you liked and were good at and maybe could pursue into a job or career. I have nothing against college, but it seldom teaches you to do an actual job. It mostly teaches you how to learn which is good, but not actual job training. Many of the community colleges in our area have excellent programs that DO teach real life job skills in areas like construction, HVAC, culinary arts, and many other areas. These courses are often filled with adults training for a real job in the real world. Shop also helped the poorer academic performing students succeed at something and again give them skills that could translate to life skills and jobs. So now that everyone is expected to go to college, where are we going to get the auto mechanics, carpenters, electricians, plumbers, masons, welders, maintenance staff, etc? Few trades in this area have any kind of apprentice programs. Many trades have become technology dependant such as auto repair and HVAC. These are all necessary occupations that can earn a good living especially if you get into a union. Jobs are out there if you have training and skills but who is telling our kids that? I saw an article recently that said there are 600, 000 manufacturing jobs unfilled in this country because there are no trained people to fill them. Manufacturers need to step up and cooperate with local schools, including colleges, to develop programs to train people to run these increasingly high tech pieces of equipment and to repair and maintain them. All the technology in the world is worthless if no one can run or repair them. And just maybe you don’t need a fancy college degree to do that. Just some real life training that could have started in high school if they hadn’t cut the whole program.
And just in the interest of full disclosure, I went to college, got a 4 yr. degree, bounced around in different jobs unrelated to my degree, and finally went back to school to learn how to do an actual job and am now working in that field. What a concept! Can you tell this subject strikes a nerve with me?
I'm not sure if woodshop really influenced my current interest. I think I have always been messing around with wood in some way or another. I think I finally have the time and patience to really put in the effort needed to be successful and have fun with it. It sure is a great way to meet interesting people, such as there are here, and learn new things, and maybe even produce somethng useful.
In 1951 fourth grade through seventh we had co-ed "craft class". In eighth grade the boys had shop and the girls homemaking. I hope the girls got more out of their class than I got out of mine. There were no power tools used which is just as well because there was zero real instruction. We continued our craft type stuff like pine bird houses from pre cut pieces until the last six weeks. We were then told to make anything we wanted but we would need to purchase any wood other than pine or cheap plywood.
High school wood and metal shop were both risky for freshmen so I took printing instead. Unfortunately I found out most in the class were those kicked out of the shop classes. It wasn't bad after the first dozen times of being "black balled" by the seniors.
I have seen some outstanding work produced from shop classes. The fact I had zero benefit doesn't mean a thing other than the school and instructors make all the difference.
I never had a chance for wood shop in high school. If I had, it would have been the one class besides PE that I would have made straight A's in. I was destined to work with my hands. Wood is a media that speaks to me, and the lathe is the best Christmas present I ever bought myself.
I can understand budget woes, and the need to cut some programs. Too bad because not every class will reach and inspire every student. If the schools can not have the wood/metal/auto shop classes, then there should be separate schools where students can take off campus classes for credit.
My daughter is not interested in wood shop, but is in auto shop. Go figure.
I seem to recall being in Wood I and spending the first two weeks adding fractions on the blackboard. The teacher, who was also the wrestling coach, and would write two fractions on the board, and we were supposed to add them (adding measurements?). I would do them in my head quickly and he would stare at me (like "why are you in here?") It annoyed him to no end that I could do it in my head faster than he could on paper, but it also shows that 30 years ago, woodshop was not the place for honor students.
I also recall that all of the industrial arts teachers were missing limbs. One armed metal shop teacher. Another couple has missing fingers. If you got the whole department in a room together, you had enough parts to make a full teacher
I also recall there being about 20 kids in the class, but almost no lines for any of the machines. Why? Because all of the kids would hang out outside the shop smoking. Sometimes with the teachers.
I didn't get my love of wood from HS shop. If anything, I came with it, and developed it later IN SPITE of HS shop.
Love of wood working and turning both came from seventh and eight show. Wonderful teacher.
Still have the first thing I ever turned. It was a salt and pepper shaker set with a holder and a handle. I gave it to mom for a gift. Found it in the back of a kitchen cabinet when we closed up her house. I tried to throw it out but my wife came by just at that moment and asked what that was in the basket. I responded it was the first thing I ever turned. " You can't throw that out," she said. Since I always listen to my wife, we still have it and it is brought out on occasion. The moral of the story is to beware of what you let your wife talk you into keeping.
Our club does demos at all of the schools here in Flathead Valley. They all have good programs though the turning aspect is somewhat limited. Mostly because none of the teachers are turners. The kids sure make some really great projects and the skill level is very good at all the schools.
I never had shop in school because I went to a private school. I did do several woodworking projects at the local Boy's Club, one of which I still have. While shop did not impact me, it did my son. Shop will soon be a thing of the past with school budgets being drastically cut and insurance premiums rising with no end in sight. If we truly want shop to be a part of the school experience, we will not only have to fight for it, we will have to find a new generation of teachers willing to teach it. Just my two cents.
HI Ellis,If you get a chance to peruse my website, you'll see I acknowledge my wood shop experience in my "artist statement". In my case, wood shop played a major role in my career decisions. I took wood shop in my junior year, and again in my senior year, thinly disquised as "metal shop". I won "Craftsman of the Year" my junior year. My shop teachers were Mr's. Ron Travis and Ed Mahler. Mr. Travis resembled Harry Morgan, and sounded just like him, while Mr. Mahler was, outwardly at least, a big gruff, no nonsense type. I was a trouble-maker, which is probably why I was sent to torment these two guys. I graduated on a Saturday, and began working in a local cabinet shop on Monday...that's all I wanted to do. I called Mr. Travis a few years back; I let him know one of my pieces had appeared in Fine Woodworking magazine, and I told him how much I appreciated all he and Mr. Mahler had done for me. At the time, Mr. Travis was in his 90's, and he told me Mr. Mahler had passed away some years ago. I am grateful for all they did for me.
The Deer Isle Stonington High School has a thriving woodwork shop where male and female students learn to use hand tools first and then shop tools for projects of their own choosing. They start with drafting.
That shop also houses a metal lathe and a forge for those inclined to metal.
It is a very well liked and attended shop.
In parallel with that shop there is a Marine Trades shop, the economy of this island revolves around fishing, so in this shop they can go in depth into things like engine maintenance and repairs, boat repairs, and things related to the fishing industry, from basic tying knots to advanced programs about seeding the fishing grounds.
At this time, there are talks about merging both programs into one, not due to lack of interest, but due to a declining student population.
I never did take a shop class. In the college-prep stream in the 1960s, and being a member of the high school band, I didn't have a class slot available. I wish I had. Ironically, my sister took shop (required for her grade level the year we were in that system). I did a small amount of woodworking with my father in the basement, but that was not a major learning experience. My major projects by the end of college were building two reflecting telescopes (including grinding two 6" mirrors), a dulcimer for my wife as a wedding present, and a scratch-built model of a Roman corn ship. I did the usual shelf building and LP storage cubes etc over the next several decades, but only in the last 10 years have I finally had a well-equipped shop. I got interested in the idea of turning 30 years ago, looking at lattice screens from medieval Cairo in the department collections while I was at the Royal Ontario Museum. It was another 20+ years before I started turning (beginning with lessons with Jamie Donaldson).
Growing up on a farm, making things instead of buying them was a way of life. But we had very few woodworking tools, a hand saw, dull jack plane, a drawknife, a brace and several dull auger bits.
In our very small high school I was exposed to drafting and then wood shop for two years. Several projects were completed, a desk, a gun cabinet, a tea cart, a solid cedar blanket chest with a waterfall front. I still have most of them.
I majored in Industrial Arts in college. A bookcase bed (does that date me?) and a double dresser both from walnut were the major wood projects. I did turn an ashtray stand and a couple of boxes, flat grain glued 3/4 material. These projects are all still in our home and used daily.
Began teaching in a slightly larger rural area school. Five great years with many projects completed by the classes. But I couldn't support my family on my salary and summer jobs so I moved to a large city.
That school district was better than most but alas it emphasized college prep. The shop boys all too often had no interest in being there or on working. They did have an interest in tearing up equipment or destroying other's work.
After two years I left teaching and was hired by a manufacturing firm with plants in 5 cities. 33 years later I retired, back to the farm and back to woodworking. I had an old Atlas school lathe, found Wood Central, eventually upgraded to a Jet 12-36 and more recently to a Jet 16-42.
Woodworking, flat and round, has been a big part of my interests since high school. It is unfortunate, in my opinion, that there is little opportunity for today's youth to be exposed to the wonderful world of wood. But I have no solutions.
I only ever took one woodworking shop class in junior high. Looking back on it, I think that the teacher was afraid of us using the tools. I remember making acrylic paperweights and stamped leather belts. The only power tool that I remember getting to use was the scroll saw. Guess he figured that we couldn't get too hurt with it. The class pretty much bored me out of any interest in taking more classes. I love woodworking now and wonder if I would have gotten an earlier start on my hobby if the class had been better.