All this discussion about the alcohol soak method and I don't think anyone even realizes the original instructions are right here on Wood Central. I still use Dave Smith's method and have had very good luck using it. I don't use it for all my bowls, just those that I am in a hurry to use.
Dave spent a long time documenting his method and it disturbs me that some are so quick to change it. Over the years I have read so many posts by turners who don't even have a remote idea of who introduced the process.
As long as I am venting, I am going to use this post to point out the lovely function provided by this forum software to allow us to post easy to use links. We don't have to copy and paste; all we need to do is click on it. Take the time to scroll down and see where a link should be put.
I had not read all the Alcohol Soak comments, just spot checked. I have grown so used to turners who didn't have a clue as to the origin of the method but act like experts after several tries, I jumped the gun.
I did read Dave Snith's article and I also read some one else's article's ( I do not remember where). I did part's of each one because I did not remember how to do it correctly. When I ruffed out the bowl it almost worked for me because I ended up with a microwave and did not wait for the alcohol soak to work.
I love the articles posted here, they are a great information for us newbies.
I learned it from Dave's article and then tried it when roughing out green box blanks. It works just fine when applied to partially hollowed box blanks.
I start by rounding up the blank, forming a tenon on each end and parting the blank in two. It is useful if you do your parting based on some preconceived design purpose for the blank.
Then it is just a matter of removing some wood from inside the lid. Again it is important to plan ahead. If you remove too much wood you may find it difficult to fit the lid to the body.
Then mount the body blank in the chuck and partially hollow it. If you rough out the body flange be careful not to make it so small that the inside diameter of the lid cannot possibly be made small enough to fit.
Mark the tenon ends somehow to identify that they belong together and throw them in the alcohol. Don't use permanent marker as it seems to be somewhat less than permanent in alcohol.
Let the blank soak at least 24 hours, take out and drain. Let the blanks dry and then tape them tenon end to tenon end. Set in a warm spot and let the wood dry for a while. Box blanks do not respond as quickly as bowl blanks because it is difficult to get them uniformly thin but the process will shorten the drying time.
You can also just rough out the blanks, tape them end to end and let them dry on their own. It takes longer and you may encounter some splitting but you cannot win them all.
I think I first heard about it in More Woodturning, Fred Holder's magazine a bunch of years ago. I got all excited, and gave it a try. For my 'turned green to final thickness' bowls, it had no effect at all. Not in drying time, warping, or cracking (several hundred bowls of all sorts of different woods, and one measured test comparing 3 sets of bowls, air dried, LDD soaked, and DNA soaked). It did make the bowls more difficult to sand out. Since others seem to have a lot of success with this method on twice turned bowls, it must do some thing. The thing I did get from it that really made a difference, particularly on Madrone, which is my favorite wood to use for bowls because it warps so much, is the wrapping the outside of the bowl, and particularly the rim. Theory: the rim is the most delicate/fragile part of the bowl. Rounding over the rim helps to keep the 'even wall thickness' idea pretty close where a sharp rim will make for a big 'change' spot. The idea of slight compression on the rim seems to make a lot of sense, and I know through error that pushing out against the rim will cause cracks. I altered the paper/tape method by using plastic stretch film to secure the rim, and by stretching it out, several times around the rim, and then got to wondering if just the plastic film would work (5 inch rolls). It did. My drying success with Madrone has gone to almost 100%, up from maybe 50% to 60%, and yes, I tried every drying method for Madrone, except for boiling it, which is the only way to twice turn Madrone (one bowl came off the lathe at 22 inch diameter, and finished moving at 25 by 17 inches).
There is one turner, not in this forum who rants that it does nothing, even though he has never tested it. I think he is wrong.
Thanks to Dave for coming up with the 'wrapping just the outside of the bowl' and leaving the inside open. Maybe some day, I will experiment with the DNA again, but I prefer warped bowls. Just a personal idiotsyncracy.
.....it would be good to remind those using denatured alcohol to minimize contact of the alcohol with your skin! (BTW - This discussion is about "methylated spirits" for you Brits and Aussies.....)
Not only does the denatured alcohol have the possibility of drying-out the skin quickly, the transdermal uptake of alcohol, and (worse) the adulterant compounds can prove to be toxic to liver, brain, and other tissues.
A private message from Mike Foydel to me this morning reminded me that there is a spectrum of different formulations of denatured alcohol - some with denaturing solvents like methanol, methyl ethyl ketone, methyl isobutyl ketone, acetone, and perhaps other liquid organic compounds. None of these compounds should be considered "safe" for skin contact.
When adding or retrieving turned pieces from my alcohol bath, I routinely use tongs to handle the submerged items, and when necessary, use nitrile gloves to protect my hands from alcohol contact. Even common household "rubber" gloves (i.e. those kinds used for cleaning) can provide adequate protection for short term handling of alcohol soaked items.
In any case, reaching-in and grabbing items out of the alcohol bath with bare hands should be avoided, since long term repeated uptake of organic solvent components through the skin has been shown to have very detrimental effects to sensitive areas (and not so sensitive areas) of the body. There's no need to expose yourself to this kind of risk when it is so easy and inexpensive to handle these things safely.
In addition to being safe at the lathe, we also need to be aware of other safety concerns presented to us by related woodturning activities we do, including chain saw safety, respiratory safety, hearing protection, and chemical safety. We all probably would like to enjoy woodturning for a very long time, so THIS STUFF IS IMPORTANT!!
All solvents have these nasty characteristics and the other thing that must be considered is that they are highly flammable. Alcohol burns like crazy.....
Not only does alcohol burn readily, but it tends to form an almost invisible fire. Spills of denatured alcohol can be a big deal. Many of us use grinders near wood shavings and get away with it. If there's been an alcohol spill, we should not even think about it -- clean up, and take a break until there's no fumes, and no odor.
To shift the topic just a little, what do you use for a container that would be open enough to accept a bowl but have a tight enough closure/lid to keep the ambient moisture from diluting the "methylated spirits" ?
Bill, I found an industrial polypropylene detergent container that is very thick and heavy which has a lid that is held on with snap ring with a compression closure. When I first started the process I found evaporation of my expensive alcohol was a bigger problem than its pickup of water from the air.
Rob: Your point is a good one. People in the US tend to talk about "DNA" as being one product. In Canada, there are about 50 different formulations for DA. (It's DA in Canada, not DNA. DNA is something completely different. The Canadian regulations that spell out how to adulterate alcohol set out DA grades.) To give an extreme example, in Canada, gasoline with 10% alcohol in it is a DA grade. So, when shopping for DA in Canada, at least, turners should look on the label to see just what denaturant has been added to the pure alcohol. Some denaturants are very toxic.
I don't use alcohol much any more, but when I did, I put shavings in a large open box, put the bowl in a heavy duty contractors trash bag and nestled the bag in the shavings and then put the alcohol in the bag to cover the bowl and squeezed most of the air out before tying off the bag. I used less alcohol and could do pretty large pieces that way. If there was danger of puncturing the bag, I would double them up.
I use a wide base, 3 gallon polypropylene container (used originally to ship lab chemicals) that has a gasketed screw-on lid. I know others have used Rubbermaid containers or even 5 gallon drywall buckets with snap-on lids; you can seal the top with plastic wrap if you suspect you are not getting a good enough seal. Dave Smith says he has successfully used ice cream containers. As long as you get a decent fit of the lid, there should not be too much moisture pick-up from the air (unless, of course, you have the container in an enclosed area with unusually high humidity).
Having a container that has study enough walls to resist cracking and leaking is important. Mike's comments about fire safety are very relevant when storing alcohol for extended periods of time.
I found a charcoal hopper at Wal-mart that works great. It is produced by Kingsford (?) the folks who make charcoal. It is designed to keep charcoal dry in outdoor environment. Pretty tight seals. Easy to open and close. Durable. Works for bowl up to about 15x6.
It seems there's a lot of "soakers" out there, so I thought I'd take the opportunity to comment that users should periodically check the concentration of their alcohol bath to see how much water it has picked up from repeated use in soaking wet turned items.
Dave Smith has explained an elaborate gravimetric way of determining the alcohol concentration to avoid the expense of having to buy a hydrometer, assuming these are very expensive instruments. While it is true that LAB GRADE hydrometers can be very expensive (especially those with traceable calibration), there are a number of inexpensive hydrometers available which can be used to get a ballpark figure on alcohol concentration, which is all we need to know. Once it gets below 70 or 60 percent, it should be discarded or fresh, high percentage alcohol added so that the alcohol bath remains effective.
I have purchased several hydrometers on eBay, some under $ 10, which are capable of determining when too much water is in the alcohol. Search eBay using "Proof and Tralle Hydrometer", or "alcohol hydrometer", and you will find several types being offered. You want hydrometers that read 'percent alcohol', often with other scales for 'proof' and 'specific gravity' - these are sold for those who produce alcoholic beverages, and the relatively few (?) who "distill their own". You may also find these hydrometers a (high alcohol concentration type - don't get a "beer" hydrometer!) at shops devoted to home wine-making and homebrewing.
I tested hydrometers purchased by 'colonelusa' and 'the-bruhaus' sellers, and compared them to a lab-grade hydrometer, and they are certainly close enough for what we need. I hve no interest in either of these eBay sellers, other than as a past customer.
I suggest getting one of these hydrometers if you are a frequent 'alcohol soaker' so you can periodically test the concentration of the alcohol you are using. It is worth the inexpensive investment to know what you are working with. I would not advise going through the time and effort of determining alcohol concentration gravimetrically when such an inexpensive and easy alternative exists.
Most wood sinks in the alcohol. When the wood floats and you need to put a brick on it to keep it submerged, it's mostly water and time to change it out.
I asked a chemist friend how to tell how much DA was left in a container. He allowed it's very easy. Leave it uncovered a few days and it will be all water!