Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Elm burl--Bowl or platter

Posts

Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#1

Roger in MO

Elm burl--Bowl or platter

Roger in MO

I started to turn a bowl from this burl. It is 11.5 dia, 4.25 "tall", hollowed to about 2" deep. There is a rather significant void near the center. The small rule in the picture sticks into the void about 3.75" from the rim. IF the void is no deeper, then the bottom would end up about 1/2"

Note the grain and colors of the hollowed portion If I continue hollowing I MAY turn away most of the grain pattern and color and possibly make a funnel.

There are two very soft bark inclusions on the perimeter that would probably be turned away in a platter.

I'm looking for suggestions.

Thanks

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#2

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter *LINK*

Doc Green

Roger, I would concentrate on making the best use of the grain/figure of the wood, which is rather dramatic.

To me it appears that a bowl with an outflowing rim may be your best bet. What I would do is, . . .

Increase the diameter of the hollow near the rim, and then form a sort of ogee curve on the inside. Creep up on the final curve with care, being careful that you don't turn away all the pretty wood. Deepen the hollow as much as you can while maintaining a good curve and avoiding turning away the pretty wood. Don't take the curve all the way to the final surface . . . yet.

Once the inside curve is established, turn the outside to match, to give a wall thickness that is more or less uniform.

Dealing with the problem areas: If it appears that the bark may fly off the rim, or if it doesn't cut cleanly, wick thin CA into the soft regions to firm it up. Take very light shearing cuts with a sharp tool.

The void at the center seems to be one for which epoxy and coffee grounds will be ideally suited. If you are unfamiliar with this method, see my website. I have an article on it:

http://www.docgreenwoodturner.com/coffee.html

After the epoxy hardens on the inside, you can make the finish cuts to establish the final surface. (Don't remove the blank from the chuck, if you can avoid it, until all the hollowing is done.)

If you wind up with jagged edges, or undesirable voids near the rim, you can often improve the situation with a bit of epoxy/coffee applied there as well.

When you reverse the bowl to finish the foot, you may need to apply more epoxy to the outside, to the bottom of the foot.

Good luck. Be sure to post a pic of the finished piece.

~Doc


Epoxy and Coffee Grounds as a Filler

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#3

Roger, JMO...

GaryG in MD

What a nice problem to have!

Plain wood is easy to find and useful for practice or augmentation.

"Figured" wood is what it's all about. And by "figured", I mean curl, worm holes, spalting, branch inclusions, bark inclusions, natural voids, lovely grain patterns, contrasts between heartwood and sapwood, etc. This you have here in abundance.

It's a great piece of wood. Don't try to turn away the hole! You won't have anything of interest left if you do. I recommend not throwing out the baby with the bathwater! So far you have roughed it enough to discover the character of the interior of the material. And that's some nice character. NOW your design challenge begins -- to discover what form you can make that will retain and highlight what you have revealed.

It's hard to recommend a lot of decisions from the photos, but, from what I can see or deduce, I would probably expand the diameter of the hollowing to create a rim of your desired width -- perhaps 1/4". If some of that rim bark flies off, glue it back on or accept the fact that the rim is irregular -- there's nothing wrong with that. Then I'd make some shallow finishing cuts to shape the inside without removing too much more material. Finally I'd reverse it onto a jam chuck and remove material from the outside of the bottom to make it a shallower vessel with the height and profile you like. I'd like to see it as shallow as you can get it while maintaining enough of the heartwood. You definitely want to leave some of the heartwood there for contrast and visual balance. The heartwood/sapwood demarcation line is going to have a significant effect on the overall appearance, so pay careful attention to that as part of the design.

I'd go for no foot -- either a round/rocking bottom or a small, subtle concave depression so it sits flat on the table. In this case, I'd go "round".

You're not going to eat off it, but it will look very nice somewhere presented as a work of turner's art. Have fun with it. You'll never have another just like it. ...Gary

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#4

Doc,

GaryG in MD

It's funny, because I was writing mine when you posted yours.

I didn't see yours till I hit 'send'.

We certainly agreed on a lot!

My only real difference is that I wouldn't use any filler. ...Gary

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#5

Good deal, Gary!

Doc Green

I'm just pleased that we came up with a similar suggestion. As for the filler, Roger will get to decide whether to use it or not, and what to use as a filler if he does. :)

Whether or not I fill a void depends on the nature of the opening. If the sides are jagged and splintery, I will fill them. Otherwise, maybe not. ~Doc

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Roger, JMO...

Lyle Jamieson

You nailed it Gary!! Make it shallower to keep the character of the wood. This is a great example of our need to make our vessel as big as possible when a smaller end product can be exceptional. The goal needs to shift from doing the biggest piece I can, to doing the best piece I can. I too would leave the voids and bark inclusions alone and let the wood/nature speak for me. If it ends up with a void in the middle of the bottom...better yet. It can make it a challenge to reverse turn, but thats part of the fun, to go where you have not gone before.

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

Brad Vietje

Hey Roger,

I'm with Doc and Gary, with one exception: I'd roll down the edge and get rid of the bark on the rim. I would probably fill the void if this was intended to sit flat on a table or shelf, or if it will be used to contain or display anything -- I think the void ends up getting full of dust or little bits of flotsam & jetsam, and the bark in the hole will crumble, etc... If you display it vertically (wall or stand), the void could be left open and jagged, and cleaned with a vacuum every now and then.

I only suggest removing the bark at the rim because you already have bark in some places, and not in others, so you could leave the bark and see how it looks (?), but leave your options open to roll the rim down under the bark to get a smooth profile all the way around. I think the contrast between the figured wood and the light colored wood will be dramatic enough without the bark on the edge, but that's just a guess. I tend to like the edge all bark, or all smooth, so I'm biased.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#8

Burl? I would call that a canker,

Keith Newton

Which is different from a burl.

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

#9

Roger in MO

Re: Elm burl--Bowl or platter

Roger in MO

Thanks for the ideas. I have turned off part of the rim reducing the bowl from 2" to about 1 1/4". Most of the bottom of the bowl has been flattened and a gentle radius has been formed.

There are areas of very soft damp fibers next to the remaining bark. There are also several small soft areas in the bowl portion. CA will surface harden these areas but I suspect I'll need to dig some of the material and fill, probably with epoxy as Doc suggested.

The final design is still open. If I fill all the voids it will take a while but I will post pics when finished.

Thanks again. Roger