The AAW looks like it's going to catch up with the 21st Century, or at least late 20th Century!
If you're an AAW member, you probably received an e-mail message from AAW board member Stan Wellborn, soliciting ideas for the use of new technologies by AAW to disseminate ideas and techniques - and making it available on multiple platforms (PCs, Macs, smartphones, tablets, etc.)
Betty Scarpino go the ball rolling as editor of American Woodturner. Now it looks like the AAW board is looking to really begin to exploit the power of the internet and devices accessing the internet.
I'm sure there are many excellent opportunities to be tapped, and that's a good thing. I'm glad they're tapping into "what's happening now" for those who live on batteries and carpal thumbs.
But I don't Facebook (I divorced them), and I don't Tweet, and I don't text, and I want my Journal on paper. Although I am a physicist and an engineer, with purpose, I do not carry a picture phone, or any cell for that matter; I do not have a Kindle or an iPod or an iPad. Don't need 'em; don't want 'em. I like real paper books. No batteries. They'll still be readable after a CME takes out the power grid. I have no need to walk around with a plug in my ear while enjoying nature and the great out of doors, be it sunny or raining.
Now if I were still working and commuting and traveling a lot, my story would be different; but I'm now privileged to do what I want, when I want. Call me a Luddite (I am), but I prefer to stay as low tech as possible.
If you want to see where this is all going, I recommend reading Rainbow's End by Vernor Vinge. (He is a multiple Hugo award winner also famous for his 1993 prediction of "The Coming Technological Singularity".) Rainbow's End is set in the "near future" -- near enough to be both prophetic and a little scary.
With the advent of free content via things like YouTube, WoodCentral, and FaceBook, there has been a fundamental shift in many aspects of woodturning away from decentralizing and to more of a self-managed, community based similar to the open standards in technology.
A simple example:
The music industry thought that digital stuff was bad because people would steal music. In fact, people are buying more music and differently via things like iTunes because it is more accessible AND they can buy it in smaller quantities (like a single song for $.99).
Is there an AAW correllation to this type of transformation available via technology? Perhaps.
What if the AAW went to an all digital magazine? Could they attract more members and lower their cost because they didn't produce a physical, US mailed medium? What if the e-magazine was completely free to anyone that wanted it- regardless of membership? Could they use the asset to drive membership for memberships other benefits? (I've heard several people refer to membership as an expensive subscription...)
My kids will almost guaranteed NEVER own a magazine subscription. We live in an age where the technology is ubiquitous and compelling. The applications are limitless. I've actually thought that the woodturning schools should also have a plan for using technology. Imagine if there was a way to show a real-time view of the facilities and students working during the sessions via a webcam? Do you think you might be able to drive someone to register next year? How about streaming the AAW National Symposiums for anyone interested? Could you drive attendance?
The use of new technology does not preclude the use of old technology, and does provide for more options. I'm for more options whether I ever use them or not. New technology is making it possible to do things that couldn't be done priorthat I wanted to do.
I have a cordless phone so I can call or get calls while I'm in the shop. Once you become a parent you remain a parent - and always answer the phone, or screen calls via an answering machine because it might be from one's "child", regardless of age, in need.
I have a $25 cell phoneand pay $60 a year for cell phone service. I use it for emergencies, like when my car was totaled on the freeway last year, while returning from a day long j. Paul Fennel demo. And when you need AAA roadside service, you need a phone, or be willing to abandon the vehicle and go hiking to the nearest phone (and try to find a pay phone these days).
I did have an iPod Mini - but the damned thing was so small I "misplaced it" - and still haven't founjd it two years later. But I've got a decent sound system at home and in my little Miata, and yes, though I have CDs, I also have vinyl LPs - and even some old 45s.
While I can drive an hour or so to be amongst Giant Sequoias, or walk to some pretty impressive sized sycamores and have a fair sized redwood tree on the side of my house, I can take a virtual hawk's eye tour of the Grand Canyon or a divers eye tour of a coral reef on my computer, or drive an hour to the Monetery Bay Aquarium - or drive up the coast and take a walk on a beautiful beach - and be the only person there.
There's a pair of doves that have made their nest and raised there young right outside my shop and each generation stops by the deck next to my computer desk to snack on the bird seed I put there for them.
ANYTHING that can be misused or over used - will be misused or over used - by some. Too much heat, or too much cold or even too much water - can kill you. But in moderation, almost nothing will kill you.
I see virtual 3D galleries that will permit me to experience turnings better than merely seeing a photo or two. I see virtual models of how to turn a multi axes piece as useful and perhaps that will give me enough info to try turning something like I've seen as a virtual 3D piece - that I might not have tried to turn before. I hope to see piece in virtual reality that I'd have never thought of, nor would likely be able to experience otherwise.
I was lucky to be able to telecommute while my son was young. That gave me time to be dad while we were together and bread winner in between naps and school later. Also saved gas and lowered my car insurance cost, to say nothing of ulcers dealing with the crazy things people do in cars while driving on the freeway.
It's all about the options new technology brings to the table. And I get to decide what I choose to use - or not.
Well I also have a foot in both worlds. Part of me says I'm not a fan of the new technology. I don't facebook or tweet or text, etc. However I do spend way too much time on these newsgroups, I obviously make videos that are viewed only on the computer and I'm one of the writers for the new AAW online Woodturning Fundamentals. so I guess I'm being dragged in a little at a time.
Many of my NYC friends gave up their land line phones years ago. If you lose your cell, you can buy another one in any store. Your land line can be VOIP if you decide you need one. Dialtone is a dying technology.
As are VCR's (dead), CD's (close), DVD's (Blueray will be the only format in 5 years) and 480p televison.
I'd love to see a tech savvy ED take the AAW to the next level. As many have pointed out, you don't need to be a great turner to be a good ED. I'd require some online marketing skills to drive growth and making the AAW website a central point for information. It's not there today.
I agree completely. Notice that in my first post here I didn't say anything about computers in general, just the mindless stuff where people can't seem to (put your own activity here) without telling somebody about it. Seriously, we don't care!! I don't want to know that I'm going to see you in five minutes at the time and place we already agreed on! I guess I'm just showing my age and lack of flexibility, but I prefer my desk computer for the many worthwhile things that have been mentioned here.
Trouble is, I spend too much time sitting here doing things like this, emails, processing photos, listening to music from around the world, looking at those pretty pictures and videos sent by others, writing articles, Googling stupid stuff, etc. So I have to try hard to limit myself.
Carrying all that battery-laden stuff with me, and keeping me constantly in contact with "the world" is what I decry. When I'm out, I'm out, and I don't want to be in contact, except, of course for emergencies, which is why that cheapo cell phone is a good idea.
What drives me wild, other than people doing these things to distraction in vehicles around me, is people walking down the street talking to "themselves". Gag me! Wake up and smell the roses! (Well, perhaps that's a bad metaphor right now because I went outside to finish turning that HF and had a huge allergy attack! Oak pollen is my nemesis, and it's early this year.) Sometimes it's hard to win.
It's clearly generational. I read that in x years people won't use desktop computers any more. Probably true. Sales are already dropping. But they'll be around as long as I need them. ...Gary
One simple reason is because the audio quality on cells is bad at best, and usually worse. And VOIP is often just as bad. I can always tell when someone is calling me (on my black, corded dial phone) from a cell because it sounds like crap.
Seriously, I think AAW can definitely move ahead digitally, and I think they will, at a measured pace, which is how it should be. ...Gary
pray tell, is going to pay for all this if it's streamed for free?
Things like the Journal and the Symposium have to pay for themselves. I'm not so sure an "advertising" model would work. ...But then it seems to work for many things online, so what do I know?
PPV? Never been a fan of that myself.
Besides, half the fun of the Symposium is being there! ...Gary
I'm sure glad you are writing all this. I'm with you about 99% and you're saving me the trouble of typing. I'm too tired tonight because I've been out doing some old fashioned work.
Gary, I thought I was the only odd man out here but I'm thrilled to find another weirdo. The only difference between your post and one that I would write is that I'm a chemist instead of physicist. Couldn't agree more with your comments. Have a great, quiet, calm, thoughtful day!
If I had a good phone with a video camera and a 4G connection, I could probably do it myself within my cell phone plan. Cost is not the question, nor is the technology. The question is would there be any value to the AAW in doing this?
Current "freemium" products like FaceBook have proven that you can give away things to your subscribers to draw in advertising. The whole advertising model is based upon the number of people in your community. If the AAW wants to draw in more advertising, the way to do it is to attract more members.
You can only expect a certain percentage of people to attend a symposium physically based on how many AAW members live in an area. Whether you charge for virtual attendance or not is unimportant, because you can grow the audience and that is the real mission.
It would also be really, really smart for the AAW to have some kind of website for the tradeshow floor that vendors could upload their "show specials" to help the vendors take orders from people who could not make it to the venue. Remember how the AAW works? More members means more advertising, but only if the members buy from the advertisers.
I don't have all of the answers, but I know that the AAW needs to have someone with a technology background promoting these ideas. In general, that would means someone under the age of 30 on staff or you end up with a dinosaur like me who never sent a text until he was 35...
First, I have never sent a tweet. I think it is sort of stupid to tell me what you are doing every five minutes too...however.
There is a completely new model of restaurant springing up because Twitter enables it: The high end food truck.
We have all seen the hotdog truck and gotten a $.50 coffee and buttered roll (ok, perhaps only in NJ...?), but there is a new generation of rolling restaurant with duck l'orange, korean barbeque, and other dishes that you used to have to go to a sit-down place to get. The chefs are highly trained, but unwilling to risk opening a restaurant in the classic sense because so many restaurants fail.
Instead, for a little bit of money, they take their kitchens on wheels to the lunch crowds and compete with fast food markets. If a company closes their doors and an area becomes unviable, they move their trucks. In fact, most of these restaurants spread their risk by not being in the same area every day. Absence makes the taste buds want ya...
How do I know when my favorite lunch truck will be parked in my area? I follow them on Twitter. They say that they will park on the corner of X and Y at 11:00, and they pull up to a line of paying customers dying to get their products. Not a bad way to work, and they SEOTT (Sell everything on the truck).
Can the AAW use bits and pieces of this somehow? I dunno...but I'd incline towards yes.
Steve You should be discussing this on the AAW Forum. I'll bet you'll get more response from the people who influence the board. As you Know Betty Scrapino is working very hard toward getting the Journal online. I see no reason why they wouldn't be interested in some of your ideas for promoting and working with the symposium.
I cannot afford to go to very many of the symposiums and would certainly try to view or possibly attend some online events during the symposium. The trade show adds would be a great way to get more people to see the products and possibly be a source of income for the AAW.
They could even pick a demo or two and either stream them or tape them for later showing. That would have to be OK with the demonstrator of course. How about a roving camera operator who simply travels around the trade show, instant gallery and some of the other shows. Of course all of this will probably need more volunteers and you know how hard that is.
Thanks for starting this. I think it's been both fun and thoughtful.
Some good ideas have been expressed here.
I agree with John that we should pass our thoughts on to AAW. Just coincidentally, Dale Larson, President of the AAW BoD is going to be attending our MCW Hosaluk demo next week, along with Stan Wellborn, the Director who wrote the letter to the AAW Membership that prompted Charlie's post. I'm going to send Stan a link to this thread and have a chat with them about it.
One thing that might help boost membership, if that is also a concern, would be to update to more electronic payment options. Paypal would be an excellent choice as would increasing the number of credit card options. In the past 5 years I've only had to physically send a check once & would not be bothered to do it on an annual basis.
A virtual symposium experience definitely wouldn't be as edifying as being there in person, but it would be a nice way to reach out to the 14,000 or so AAW members who can't afford to attend the symposium every year. As it is, their dues help to subsidize the symposium, but unless they have the time and the extra thousand bucks, they can't reap the benefit.
I'm not sure what kind of revenue model would work. People don't like paying for content, but if it were cheap and painless, they might pony up for a few demos. Not everyone has a PayPal account, but at this point I think PP is regarded as safe enough to facilitate online purchases, and it sure is quick and easy.
The actual streaming content (and/or) archived, downloadable content -- demos, a walk through the instant gallery, the Saturday night auction -- would be an ongoing revenue stream, too. People never get to see all the great demos that are taking place, so this would be a perfect way to catch up on ones you've missed or that have gotten good reviews. They would form a video history of the symposium, too.
Of course, the demonstrators would have to be on board with the video rights arrangement, whether or not it includes a royalty for them. I'm thinking that it shouldn't be too tough a sell, though, as it would enable them to reach a new audience and probably create an even greater demand for their studio offerings, teaching engagements, etc.
So, yes, I'd be on board with any and all of these technological advances. Give people the options and let them decide what to do with them.